41 ms·
Laser-based device can scan almost any sample of gas and tell you what's in it
- 01100011 2y agoNow can we use this to do smog checks on cars as they drive so I can avoid the biennial chore of taking the car in to a shop?
- idontwantthis 2y agoDo they still actually analyze the gas? When I did mine they just plugged into the computer and it was done in 10 seconds.
- PaulHoule 2y agoThe point of https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/On-board_diagnostics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/On-board_diagnostics is that the engine control unit in your car is monitoring the operation of the engine and thinks it is in spec. If the computer says it is OK, it is OK, at least in most states. For years there has been talk about an OBD-III that would use the cellular network or something so your car can narc on you if it is out of spec https://www.hotrod.com/features/obd-iii-the-proposed-future-of-on-board-biagnostics-982-1639-22-1/ https://www.hotrod.com/features/obd-iii-the-proposed-future-... This has been stuck in purgatory with all the other proposals for universal telematics not least because of privacy concerns plus cell phone carriers being uninterested in anything other than "what's convenient for us" coverage.
- ziddoap 2y ago>If the computer says it is OK, it is OK, at least in most states. The downside of this method (or upside, I guess, depending on where you stand), over the sniffer method, is that this is trivially bypassed. My race car, which is by no means emissions compliant, can pass this check with the press of a button.
- Aurornis 2y agoStates are beginning to roll out systems that do deeper checks on the firmware. Those, too, can be bypassed especially on older systems. However a lot of people are getting caught at emissions time now with cars that have been passing for years.
- PaulHoule 2y agoNotably the functional test (measuring exhaust) can be gamed too, see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Volkswagen_emissions_scandal https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Volkswagen_emissions_scandal Emission control is a balance between emissions, fuel economy and performance. You can give up some fuel economy and or performance at test time and enjoy better performance at the rest of the time if the system knows it is being tested.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- PaulHoule 2y agoI remember people from Sandia National Labs using LIDAR to monitor pollution around Albuquerque circa 1990. Turns out this been a thing for a long time: https://ntrs.nasa.gov/citations/19720026861 https://ntrs.nasa.gov/citations/19720026861 and is still going on https://iopscience.iop.org/article/10.1088/1748-9326/ab9cfd https://iopscience.iop.org/article/10.1088/1748-9326/ab9cfd https://idstch.com/security/lidar-technology-revolutionizing-pollution-monitoring-gas-detection-and-biochemical-attack-prevention/ https://idstch.com/security/lidar-technology-revolutionizing... I think in those cases you know what the pollutant is that is in a gas that you know what it is and want to make a quantitative determination whereas the system described in that paper is supposed to make sense of some random gas.
- aerostable_slug 2y agoSandia and other labs have indeed been working on this type of MASINT collection for a long while. Their primary use case is remote characterization of effluents to determine if a given facility is being clandestinely used for things like chemical weapons production or nuclear materials enrichment.
- datadrivenangel 2y agoIn Virginia they do this! They have devices that they'll put near highway on/offramps and rotate them between locations every few weeks or so.
- BobaFloutist 2y agoNo, I want to add headlight lumens/angle checks and window tint checks to the smog check. It's an annoying chore but it's the one time car owners have to (semi-regularly) get their car looked at, we should take advantage of that.
- genewitch 2y agoI'm sorry, what's the issue with window tint?
- stevenwoo 2y agoSome states have annual inspections of motor vehicles and on the list of items checked is headlight aim and window translucency.
- BobaFloutist 2y agoTinted front windows cause several problems: 1. It's harder to communicate with drivers with tinted windows and to check for their attention. This especially affects pedestrians and bicyclists who have to take pains to make sure they have a driver's attention before making their move, even when they have right of way. 2. You can't prosecute someone for a moving violation if they weren't identified as driving the car (because if a car is stolen for a joyride you don't want the original owner losing their license). Overly tinted front windows make it harder to consistently ID a driver, and let people get away with reckless driving. 3. Frankly it's annoying to not be able to see through cars. It makes certain turns iffier (because you can't see through the parked cars to identify oncoming traffic) and it makes it harder to predict a slow down if you can't see through the back windshield of the huge SUV completely obstructing your line-of-site. Obviously you should be maintaining a sufficient stopping distance to safely slow down, but that doesn't make it nicer to be able to see the slowdown/stop coming a bit before it arrives.
- dv_dt 2y agoIt would be great to sample plastic and get composition sufficient to determine a recycling category
- bluGill 2y agoWe already do that. However not all plastics and be determined that way. Black plastic in particular often cannot be figured out (since the laser as absorbed) and so even if the plastic is easy to recycle it is often land filled. There are open questions on if recycling plastic is worth bothering with at all, but that is a different debate.
- whatshisface 2y agoIf you zapped it you'd have vapor to analyze.
- aj7 2y agoOne time at the laser show, the booth across from us had a methane analyzer. You could tell when people farted.
- throwup238 2y agoSimple hand held methane detectors have been around for a few decades. This was used to great effect in the Kenny VS Spenny episode, Who Can Blow the Biggest Fart: https://youtu.be/ash2NzL1IHo https://youtu.be/ash2NzL1IHo (It’s a Canadian show)
- colechristensen 2y agoI prefer the trash to electricity route. If you think about it, the oil just took a detour into being a water bottle or whatever for a little while on it's way to the power plant. I really can't imagine we'll be at 0 hydrocarbon electricity grid any decade soon and burning garbage (and instead of "recycling" plastic) seems to be a perfectly reasonable thing to do if you can do it cleanly in a power plant.
- aantix 2y agoIf you wanted to identify the components of a liquid, could you heat it and analyze the steam?
- Keyframe 2y agoif it can survive phase transition untouched. otherwise, if there'd be a chemical change, you'd be looking at something new.
- zdragnar 2y agoI apparently have watched too much explosions & fire / extractions & ire, because my immediate thought on seeing the parent comment was that "yeah, it's gonna decompose before it vaporizes, and if it's hypergolic with itself that'll be fun" Apparently, watching an Aussie with a backyard shed full of mysterious chemicals and reagents has me assuming that any mysterious, unmarked liquid that needs to be identified is probably explosive.
- rtkwe 2y agoAFAIU most methods of spectroscopy work by measuring the atomic composition of the materials anyways not the exact structure and bonds so a chemical change shouldn't matter much.
- Keyframe 2y agothat'd make sense
- 2y ago
- xeonmc 2y agoSimilar concept to FTIR in terms of de-convolving a known agitation pattern to enable more robust signal collection.
- rz2k 2y agoI wonder how the mirrors are cleaned or kept clean. Maybe that isn’t an issue when detecting concentrations that would take a mile of light to measure, and existing NDIR detectors are sufficient for things like detecting different gasses in pollution. It would be nice if there were general purpose gas measurement sensors that could identify more gasses rather than being specialized to a specific gas. Could this be done by replacing the circuitry of a typical evaluation board with an interface to something like an NVidia Jetson Orin Nano?
- condensedcrab 2y agoUsually cavity mirrors would be somewhat sealed to prevent dust/junk build up. Problem with general purpose spectroscopic measurements is that you need a broadband source and detector. This adds complexity compared to a targeted wavelength range.
- jmusall 2y agoYou usually mount mirrors vertically so dust does not settle on them that much (also it is safer to keep laser light propagating horizontally at only one height). Additionally, overhead ventilation is often installed which provides a vertical Laminar flow of dust-free air. If you have to clean the mirrors eventually, you'd use compressed (clean) air or special mirror cleaning wipes. Thorlabs (lab supply company) has a detailed guide on optics cleaning[1] [1] https://www.thorlabs.com/newgrouppage9.cfm?objectgroup_id=9025 https://www.thorlabs.com/newgrouppage9.cfm?objectgroup_id=90...
- aj7 2y agoPeople can’t even tell how much cheap oil is in olive oil, let alone “extra virgin olive oil” vs. el cheapo olive oil. Take it from this old laser spectrocopist. When there’s 75 mirror mounts on a 4 foot by 8 foot table, with a Chinese graduate student handcuffed to the table to adjust them, it’s at least a decade away. When you can buy a frequency comb laser on Aliexpress, now we’re talking.
- j45 2y agoAvailable on Aliexpress really is a solid indicator.
- kylehotchkiss 2y agoWhy did you handcuff a grad student to the table?
- generalizations 2y agoPresumably they require constant high-precision adjustment and a lot of domain knowledge. I'd read it that the only way to do it now is with a high-maintenance setup and a lot of technicians.
- khazhoux 2y agoYea, buy why handcuffs? Is it to limit range of motion when taking precision measurements?
- nartho 2y agoI believe this was a figure of speech to illustrate that the student has to stay right by the table, not that the student is actually being handcuffed
- AlecSchueler 2y agoWhy does the student need to be Chinese? And is that Chinese as in from China or Chinese as in having Chinese heritage?
- ck2 2y agoShame this won't work lightyears away very hard to detect oxygen around exoplanets apparently but they came up with a new method recently https://news.ucr.edu/articles/2020/01/06/scientists-develop-new-method-detect-oxygen-exoplanets https://news.ucr.edu/articles/2020/01/06/scientists-develop-...
- zerealshadowban 2y agoIt seems that the frequency comb laser is easy to diy! "NIST Shows How to Make a Compact Frequency Comb in Minutes" (2013) [0]. I can think of many applications apart from the medical diagnosis they talk about. The varying mirror cavity is today's innovative step, plus the computation to identify atoms and molecules from the observation of color absorption. [0] https://www.nist.gov/news-events/news/2013/07/nist-shows-how-make-compact-frequency-comb-minutes https://www.nist.gov/news-events/news/2013/07/nist-shows-how...
- aj7 2y agoYes. And a surgeon can remove your appendix in minutes too. A 777 can be landed in a crosswind, in minutes. Why a pass can be intercepted and run back for a touchdown in seconds! All of this easy. I’ve seen it on TV, even.
- cududa 2y agoOh. Don't bring up surgeons/ doctors in general on here. A shockingly large contingent of people believe the field is "gate kept by exams being too hard" -- which I'm pretty sure just means their parents wanted them to be doctors
- pjs_ 2y agoIt has been possible to buy pretty nice handheld Raman spectrometers for a while now: https://www.bruker.com/en/products-and-solutions/infrared-and-raman/raman-spectrometers/bravo-handheld-raman-spectrometer.html https://www.bruker.com/en/products-and-solutions/infrared-an... This paper is obviously trying to go much further. But if you just want to buy a tricorder, you can
- multimoon 2y agoI was unable to find a specific price for the model you linked in my few seconds of looking but these devices generally run in the $10,000 USD range, so I don’t think it’s achieved the “if you just want to buy it” territory yet.
- pjs_ 2y agoGood point. You have to ask yourself — would you rather have a '97 Camry or a raman spectrometer and a pushbike ;) That said this is getting into Christmas present territory: https://www.ebay.com/itm/167319991806?_skw=handheld+raman+spectrometer&itmmeta=01JNRXQZS1PV1H21AA6Y9JC9BP&hash=item26f50c75fe:g:UdMAAeSwzzxnsgoI&itmprp=enc%3AAQAKAAAA4FkggFvd1GGDu0w3yXCmi1c0S2r6vWQekNUve29kO0Hym%2F31TP8hIMHMu2UoRpudsb03ZrgSbf4jz2d2k67HxvUyk2TvoWfWKbJcd14lGSSo2eoZ1gcxMJQgnEe%2FjL7DTN2uuB2dVVU9VYl6M6Tki25FZgJhzs42xGvaSf4U0ZDNOF0aztlRRVOa6B6WJ8yyOQd5J8kt%2BEPH%2FAe48dKdNbcMBSc5lEer9l1oeyqYb4K%2Ftf27%2F2AZURCkB3ed%2BkKjdMam5NQzebnReLAt5Iw51V1Xmn5X3opDuMy3kB7Z1Bjz%7Ctkp%3ABk9SR9j8352uZQ https://www.ebay.com/itm/167319991806?_skw=handheld+raman+sp...
- throwup238 2y agoI love the juxtaposition of thinking a ‘97 Camry is anywhere close to $10k while at the same time a $3k piece of lab equipment is “Christmas present territory” :) It’s one banana, Michael. What could it cost? Ten dollars?
- Loughla 2y agoIt is genuinely disheartening when people in this board start talking about things they buy when they're WILDLY out of my price range. It's almost like living in a flyover state and working in education isn't optimal for income. Weird.
- reaperducer 2y agoLaser-based device can scan almost any sample of gas Oh, sure, it can tell you who smelt it. But the real money is in figuring out who dealt it.
- Vox_Leone 2y ago[flagged]
- mannyv 2y agoContamination?
- akomtu 2y agoCan it detect the amount of PFAS in tap water?
- Beijinger 2y agoSounds trivial. Without opening the link, let me guess: QCL?
- amelius 2y agoCan it detect medical disorders, similar to how (according to popular belief) dogs can smell cancer?
- preezer 2y agoSo you build the tester from plankton? 99 % evil 1% hot air or the other way around ^^