8 ms·
Macron to open debate on extending French nuclear protection to European allies
- zzzeek 2y agoyeah, they're going to have to build a new NATO-like alliance and go it alone. Seems like it would be a good thing if the EU had some military teeth of their own to give them more leverage in all the Bad Things going on now.
- mrweasel 2y agoSome countries have already started. JEF can operate as part of NATO, or separately. The organisation is also nuclear armed, thanks to the UK.
- hagbard_c 2y ago...and before you know it the old rivalries flare up again on who is to be the leader of this fourth iteration of a European empire. Germany versus France, France versus the UK, Germany versus Poland, Italy versus France, a combination of some of these versus one of the others. A 'European army' would be under the control of... the EU? Some new organisation to be specifically created for this purpose? Some committee-designed scheme of rotating leadership between the main powers in Europe? These are not spurious questions. Europe is a large and diverse place, far more diverse than e.g. the USA. Would such an army serve to protect Hungary as well as Spain, Sweden as well as the Czech republic, Poland as well as Germany? Even if some of those countries do not care to fall in line with the agenda set by the Eurocrats in Brussels?
- _fizz_buzz_ 2y agoNot as long as there is an adversary I.e. the new US-Russia alliance.
- watwut 2y agoHungary and Slovakia are pro-russia currently, so not really. But nothing unites people as much as common threat and both US and Russia are currently providing that.
- robwwilliams 2y agoNot much more diverse than the US. Yes, a melting pot, but Europe is now a big melting pot too. The most important axes is City versus rural communities which boils down to rich vs poor. And the USA and Europe are very similar in this way.
- Earw0rm 2y agoI can't speak for the US, but in Europe it's less rich/poor (though some country folk would like you to think so), and more rural conservative values vs city progressive values (which weirdly harbour some very religious-conservative people from immigrant/minority communities).
- bad_user 2y agoYou can ask these questions about NATO as well, and while USA has been the greatest contributor, in a confrontation with China, it wouldn't stand a chance without its NATO allies. I know that many like to complain of Europe's bureaucracy, but we're talking about half a billion educated people, with enough resources and with an existential crisis, which we're surely facing, the EU+UK, joined by allies, can be a force to be reckoned with. The problems EU is facing come from within. We have far right movements as well, aided by propaganda, the pandemic and the immigration waves. The far right are more contained than in the US apparently (due to US having just 2 parties), but it can lead to government paralysis. Seeing the US administration ally itself with Russia to dismember the EU wasn't in my cards. So, it's going to be an interesting year.
- Exoristos 2y agoI think it's realistically only Germany v. France, with U.K. meddling (powerfully) from the sidelines. And I don't think either Germany or France has the fortitude to establish any real hegemony. So I predict that, with or without expressed U.S. support, Europe will continue to be satellites in the U.S. orbit.
- dtech 2y agoThe EU already also has a mutual defense clause extremely similar to NATO though
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> EU already also has a mutual defense clause extremely similar to NATO Is it explicitly nuclear?
- palata 2y agoWell, there is still NATO. Because the US are unreliable doesn't mean that the other members of NATO are? Genuinely asking.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> there is still NATO For conventional war, probably. For nuclear, will Paris risk its homeland for Latvia?
- palata 2y agoRight. So the question is: given that NATO is now a lot weaker because of the US, it's not clear whether the promises of mutual defence still hold. Do I understand that correctly?
- Aloisius 2y agoWe saw the EU's commitment to Article 42(7) when France invoked it in response to the Bataclan attacks. To say it was underwhelming would be an understatement.
- jlaporte 2y agoMacron has been advocating for a European Army for around a decade. With the recent EU defence spending announcements the idea of a unified command structure in Europe is becoming likely. The French offer to extend their nuclear umbrella seems to me to have two purposes: 1. Deal with the immediate vulnerability opened by questions over U.S. Article 5 commitments to NATO 2. Try to get ahead of potential nuclear weapons proliferation among other EU states
- forty 2y agoAlso selling weapons. What this idiot of Trump seems to have missed is that countries have been purchasing weapons to the US to actually purchase US protection (like Australia did when they cancelled the submarine purchase they did to France to purchase US ones instead). Now that the US has announced being an unreliable protector, there is probably good business opportunities for all the countries that are nuclear powers and big arm dealers (such as France).
- aerostable_slug 2y agoDepends on the weapons. Certainly France is competitive when it comes to ships and many expendable munitions, but they aren't selling F-35s and the US is, and so far it seems that the juice is worth the substantial squeeze when it comes to that jet. The race is largely for second, because first place (the Lightning) is so far in front of the pack.
- woodpanel 2y agoEvery now and then, a French president floats the idea of Euronukes: https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/09662839.2020.1855147#abstract https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/09662839.2020.1...
- Yeul 2y agoPower comes from the barrel of a gun. Once again the Chinese were right but we didn't listen...
- throw0101d 2y agoSome folks are arguing even further, "Japan, South Korea, and Poland need nuclear weapons immediately": > The modern world is a place where nuclear-armed great powers, led by authoritarian leaders, often feel the impulse to bully smaller nations. If those smaller nations lack nuclear weapons, they lie prostrate and vulnerable at the feet of the bullies. But if they have nukes, they are much harder to push around. This doesn’t mean they’re impervious to attack — Israel has been struck by Iran and its proxies — but having nukes dramatically improves a small country’s security. * https://www.noahpinion.blog/p/japan-south-korea-and-poland-need https://www.noahpinion.blog/p/japan-south-korea-and-poland-n...
- hn_throwaway_99 2y agoI think the collapse of the US as "The World's Policeman", will result in the most nuclear proliferation since the 50s. That alone will make the world a much, much more dangerous place.
- deactivatedexp 2y ago[flagged]
- ryanisnan 2y agoWhat does this mean? Is this super racist or am I just interpreting it that way?
- rat9988 2y agoNo, it's the opposit of racist actually.
- potato3732842 2y agoHe's asking if the first world will allow non-rich non-european countries that don't already have nukes to develop nukes while insinuating that there's a racial element (there definitely was historically) to such decisions.
- onepremise 2y agoGiven that the Trump administration aligns itself with Russia and North Korea, the EU will need it. The US convinced Ukraine to scrap their nukes as they promised they would come to Ukraine's aid if needed. Trump is basically exploiting the situation to gain access to their natural resources. He's also telling them to let Russia keep the territory they stole when they Invaded Ukraine. Yes imagine that, Russia starting a war. Our country is so gaslit, our own citizens don't know right from wrong; fact from fiction. Protect your networks ppl. It's only going to get worse.
- clivestaples 2y agoThe war has been going on for three years with no end in sight. What's the next move? What are your ideas to defeat Russia and take back the areas they've gained since 2014?
- watwut 2y agoThe thoughts are to NOT allow them to have time to rearm, get ready for another invasion, get another territory. And then again and again. That is all the peace right now would be - strategic pause so that Russia can get stronger for the next attack. Also, Trump is supporting Russia while attacking Europe, Canada, Mexico, Greenland ... . Trump talks about annexing parts of Europe (Greenland) and annexing Canada.
- robwwilliams 2y agoMore than a maniac.
- clivestaples 2y agoSo by continuing to send more cash and weapons, it will eventually force Russia to retreat? I'm trying to understand what would secure victory.
- watwut 2y agoPrevent further expansion and besides, yes, they are attritioning. Or were before they found new supporter and ally in the form of America. Like common, Trump is not just stoping to send arms. He is doing everything he can to weaken west and empowers Russia.
- LAC-Tech 2y agoThe speed at which EU defense integration precedes is dizzying. In only: - one month after the US openly said it won't be the primary security guarantor of Europe - a month and a half after the second inauguration of a NATO sceptical president - three years after the start of a major european land war bordering the EU - 14 years after another US administration formally announced it's "Pivot to Asia" ... a European country has announced it's "open to discussion" about extending its nuclear umbrella. Not that it's offering the umbrella. Not that it has discussed offering the umbrella. But that it's open to start those discussions.
- Ancalagon 2y agoTbf, nuclear proliferation really sucks for a number of reasons, and shifting priorities in democratically elected non-authoritarian regimes with checks and balances typically means pushing such an unpopular policy forward is going to take a while.
- erentz 2y agoI really think too many people inside America do not properly understand how much the world now thinks it’s at risk from the US. The world sees what has happened as us turning into an autocracy that is now adversarial to democratic countries. Words are actions in politics. They aren’t jokes or memes. We are threatening our neighbors. And for actions we have flipped on Ukraine and now withdrawn all aid, including intelligence, and just reported turned off their ability to target with GMLRS. We have even turned off our cybersecurity activities as it relates to Russia. Writing is very clear to people outside the US.
- bureaucratsux 2y ago[flagged]
- nixass 2y agoHow do you do fellow citizens?
- flyinglizard 2y agoEU has grown fat to the point it can't get out of bed any longer. Time for the majors to create their own alliance - maybe not instead of the EU, but alongside, with a common military, nuclear umbrella and foreign policy.
- bureaucratsux 2y ago[flagged]
- kindeyooweee 2y ago[dead]
- deactivatedexp 2y agoAnatoliy Golitsyn may have been right is the craziest thing i never expected to see in 2020 plus fun to see divide and conquer get used elsewhere and on HN
- jxjnskkzxxhx 2y agoThe people decide for themselves. I'm happy with this particular bureaucracy, it's doing ok in protecting Europeans.
- McDutchie 2y ago> created: 8 minutes ago Transparent bot
- bureaucratsux 2y ago
- rKarpinski 2y ago> France and Britain are Europe's only two nuclear powers. What about the European power with the worlds largest nuclear arsenal?
- tromp 2y agoAs https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russia https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russia says: > Russia is the most populous country in Europe but it's only partly in Europe: > is a country spanning Eastern Europe and North Asia.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> What about the European power with the world’s largest nuclear arsenal? If we’re being pedantic to the point of silliness, we could argue that a significant fraction of Russia’s nuclear assets are outside European Russia [1][2]. And that Muscovite Russia retains significant elements of its Mongol roots relative to the Kievan Rus [3]. [1] https://npolicy.org/interactive-nuclear-atlas/russias-nuclear-weapons-complex/ https://npolicy.org/interactive-nuclear-atlas/russias-nuclea... [2] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/European_Russia https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/European_Russia [3] https://geohistory.today/mongol-empire-effects-russia/ https://geohistory.today/mongol-empire-effects-russia/
- rKarpinski 2y agoIt's not pedantic, Russia is part of Europe and according to your link has 80% of its population in Europe [1]. The exclusion from the list of European Nuclear powers is incorrect and politically motivated. [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/European_Russia https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/European_Russia
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> Russia is part of Europe…politically motivated The Europe-Asia boundary is a political boundary [1]. [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_tectonic_plates https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_tectonic_plates
- cjbenedikt 2y agoJust wondering what Australia might think now after having rejected the French nuclear sub deal for a US one. Perhaps DJT might consider "buying" Australia soon? Lots more minerals than Ukraine.
- morkalork 2y agoSitting between an antagonistic USA and China must be uncomfortable.
- cjbenedikt 2y ago...to say the least...
- madspindel 2y agoI was listening to an interview with the Swedish Prime Minister Ulf Kristersson about this. He said it's good that Europe has nuclear weapons capacity. Then he says something like "it's not relevant to us right now but could be in the future". https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Swedish_nuclear_weapons_program https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Swedish_nuclear_weapons_progra...
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- TheAlchemist 2y agoFor several reasons, France is uniquely positioned to be the leader of Europe. Nuclear arms, a lot of nuclear energy, defense industry, food independence. All of this thanks to Charles De Gaulle, who insisted that France must be autonomous in most important domains. With hindsight, this was extremely important. Without France's nuclear energy and arms, Europe would be in a very very bad position right now.
- euroderf 2y agoAin't it the truth.
- t_mann 2y agoThe UK also has a nuclear arsenal [0]. A bit smaller than France's, but the reality is both pale in comparison to the US and Russia. Europe has no natural leader, it's an ensemble of what some would now call random countries that only have relevance when considered together. But that doesn't need to be an issue imho. Decentralized systems are generally messier but also more resilient than centralized ones. If this situation leads to an arms race of individual countries, the outcome may well be that the combined total force is the strongest on the planet. The question is whether they're willing to go there. They would have the engineering and industrial footprint, but they would completely need to change their political DNA. Avoiding armament of European nations is literally the EU's original raison d'être. On a more practical level, they would need to ditch the Maastricht rules on fiscal discipline, something that is also deeply enshrined in the EU's institutional mindset, as well as its laws. Or they would need to issue collective debt, but that runs against the political DNA of some member states. Everything is doable, the question is whether the sense of urgency is strong enough. Given how keen European leaders currently are to let everyone who wasn't asking know that they're helpless without the US, it seems that there's still a long way to go. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_states_with_nuclear_weapons https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_states_with_nuclear_we...
- EA-3167 2y agoWithout in any way indulging in the delusion of a united Europe, in which Germany is willing to subordinate itself to France, one thing is worth saying: The UK does have a nuclear arsenal, but it's essentially leased from the US.
- ph4evers 2y agoFull speech with transcript and translations https://app.fluentsubs.com/stream?v=cm7wc02s201x3zgxl5v85c6be https://app.fluentsubs.com/stream?v=cm7wc02s201x3zgxl5v85c6b...
- aerostable_slug 2y agoI think it's interesting that the Trump administration hasn't breathed a word about the nuclear-sharing arrangements currently in place. It's low-hanging fruit, sends an extremely clear message, and relatively straightforward to accomplish, yet he hasn't made a move towards emptying the WS3 vaults in places like Kleine Brogel and Aviano. I suspect right now we're seeing a lot of public noise designed largely to get Europe to spend more on both internal defense and their NATO commitments, while privately the attaches continue to conduct business as usual, at least when it comes to the American-supplied nuclear deterrent.
- ssssvd 2y agoAh, the formation of German-lead coalition to oppose Russia AND US, how fresh. Surely third time will be the charm.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> German-lead coalition to oppose Russia AND US Macron isn’t German.
- ssssvd 2y agoHe hasn’t managed to lead much of anything so far. The British will happily switch sides the moment they can play those Continental fools against each other again — it’s practically a national sport, and it always works. When the real trouble starts, it’ll come down to the Germans and the Poles, as it usually does. On the bright side, all that capital fleeing France and Germany will go a long way toward reindustrializing the US and giving Britain’s economy a much-needed shot in the arm — so, it’s not all bad.
- lostmsu 2y agoViva la France
- elzbardico 2y agoHave one comment for that: LOL
- lostmsu 2y agoCan someone clarify if this applies to Ukraine as well?
- cladopa 2y agoIt is obvious that Sweden, Denmark and Norway and Germany, Poland and of course Ukraine need nuclear weapons now. They had been threatened by Russia with nuclear weapons and it looks like when push comes to shove the US is not going to defend them(go to ww3) using nuclear weapons. Trump's actions about WW3 means that countries that have nukes are first class, and the rest are third class. It looks like a Molotov-Ribbentrop Pact in which nuclear countries divide the non nuclear's territories. When Russia invaded Ukraine it had almost nobody defending the border, that was the reason of Kursk offensive success. The official story was that "Russia had to defend itself from NATO invasion". In reality they knew nobody was going to invade a nuclear power not having nukes, while they could invade freely.
- Palmik 2y agoWhy these specifically? Why Poland and not Slovakia, Romania or Moldova that also neighbor Ukraine? These countries have much weaker conventional defenses than Poland, further increasing the importance of something like nuclear weapons. I would go even further. All countries that used to be part of the USSR and got violated by USSR for decades without any external help would be wise to develop at least the capability. In secret if need be.
- adrr 2y agoRussia's invasion of Ukraine is the main cause. Countries can't count on agreements or treaties to keep them safe. Russia would have never invaded if Ukraine had its ICBMs and hundreds of nuclear warheads.
- m4rtink 2y agoYes, under the Budpest memorandum Ukraine should have been protected by the USA from Russian aggression in exchnage for giving up its nuclear arsenal: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Budapest_Memorandum https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Budapest_Memorandum Given how that played out, not one will ever get ridd of nuclear weapons they have & many more will logically now need to have them as well to assure basic security for their country.
- cm2187 2y agoNo country will risk its own annihilation to defend the borders of another country. That's why de Gaulle left NATO in the first place, he didn't want anyone else's finger on the french nuclear button than his own, he didn't trust the US would go nuclear with the USSR over France. Third party nuclear protections are little more than warm reassurances, but will amount to nothing when the day comes. And to be honest I am not even sure first party nuclear protection is worth that much. French president Giscard d'Estaing famously said he would probably not have used nukes if France had been invaded under his presidency. What a moronic thing to say (it massively undermines French nuclear deterrence).
- dragonwriter 2y ago> That's why de Gaulle left NATO in the first place, De Gaulle did not leave NATO, the alliance; France has been a member of NATO since its founding without interruption. France left NATO’s integrated military command from 1966 to 2009, and also did not join the NATO nuclear planning group when it rejoined to integrated military command.
- tetrisgm 2y agoI’m simple on that notion: Russia is our adversary. They have assassinated people in the EU and UK. Sabotaged our pipelines. Paid anti EU politicians. Threatened EU powers. Shot down civilian flights. Made plans to invade the Baltics. They are an adversary. We have weapons and an army. We should neutralize that adversary. Russia has currently lost momentum in Ukraine. So they are seeking a temporary peace, to rebuild. Logic dictates that we start behaving as their adversary. To not give them any benefit, and build on that momentum to keep them diminished.
- Vilian 2y agoThe argument to rebuild don't work because Ukraine can rebuild too, and russia is advancing at snail speed but still, and a Ukraine rebuild would complete derail that advance with better defenses
- tetrisgm 2y agoThe argument to rebuild absolutely works. It allows Russia to recover their frozen assets, partner with China and Iran, and work with the US leadership. Understand that NATO will be diminished if Russia claims they are peaceful.
- akvadrako 2y agoThat's only if Ukraine continues to get massive outside investments. Otherwise Russia has a bigger revenue stream and weapon factories.
- bluehornet 2y agoA two front war is tough. Trump has also said the he'll get Greenland, "one way or the other": https://www.politico.eu/article/us-will-take-greenland-one-way-or-the-other-donald-trump-says/ https://www.politico.eu/article/us-will-take-greenland-one-w... The last time a US president has used that phrase Nord Stream was blown up. There is a high chance that all of this is political theater designed to get the EU to spend more on its military and take over the Ukraine war so the EU will be the culprit while the US can trade with Russia and China. Playing off continental powers against each other has historically been the hallmark of Britain and now the US, both of whom live in splendid isolation. The EU should hedge against this scenario and seek better relations with Russia. If Trump is serious and none of this is theater, the EU should also seek better relations with Russia, otherwise it will have a two front war against the two superpowers.
- s1artibartfast 2y agoIt would be nice to have a substantive discussion of the topic without falling into the well worn rhetorical traps. In that sprit, I'm curious what advantages Euro-nukes offer relative to the existing French arsenal. What is the current status and limitation of French nuclear protection through NATO and European Union security guarantees, and how do these limitations compare to what nuclear protections the USA has historically provided?
- nojvek 2y agohttps://www.noahpinion.blog/p/japan-south-korea-and-poland-need https://www.noahpinion.blog/p/japan-south-korea-and-poland-n... Related read that we need more nuclear proliferation as a deterrent. If Ukraine had nukes, Russia wouldn’t touch it.
- glimshe 2y agoI see we've had hours of the European echo chamber here. I'm an American but I obviously don't represent my country. I just want to say one thing... You Europeans don't need to worry. We will not abandon you in case Russia shows up in NATO territory because we have too long of a history together and strong commercial relations. We are a large country and you can bet we have shared values. It's in our strongest interest to ensure that you don't become part of a Russian Empire. We'd go there again as we've done multiple times in the past. Even Trump would do it. Don't take our renewed relationship with Russia as indication that we trust Putin. We just decided it's not worth pushing them against a corner. Disrespecting Russia is a mistake and leads to bad and dangerous outcomes. But one thing we will no longer do is bail you out on every little crisis in your continent. We are not your private security. YES, let France be your nuclear shield. YES, have the UK and its ships protecting you. German tanks. Italian airplanes. Polish artillery. Make sure you are armed to the teeth and Russian dictators won't dare to invade you.
- iteratethis 2y ago"You Europeans don't need to worry. We will not abandon you in case Russia shows up in NATO territory because we have too long of a history together and strong commercial relations." This history has been wiped out in a month's time. Trump has threatened to annex EU territory, plays with economic destruction on the daily, constantly lies about Europe and mocks and humiliates us. America is now a threat and an enemy. "Don't worry" will not cut it. Your mind must be truly warped when you think supporting a sovereign country that is ruthlessly destroyed by Russia is "disrespecting Russia". We do not have shared values. Yesterday Trump decided to cut sharing intelligence so that Russian missiles and drones can go through without Ukraine being able to prepare for them. Trading human lives for a better mineral deal, like picking a corpse. Demonic "values".
- glimshe 2y agoIf you are right and Europe has so many enemies, the solution is to buy more weapons to defend against Russia and the "demonic" country that "mocks and humiliates" yours. Deal?
- deleted 2y ago