5 ms·
Qualcomm Claims New X85 Modem Creates 'Huge Delta' in Performance versus Apple
- isoprophlex 2y agoHave we hit Peak AI yet, or can we go even harder on the ai-washing? > It's the first modem that has so much AI, it actually increases the range of performance of the modem [...] slaps roof of modem This bad boy can fit SO MUCH AI in it
- jeroenhd 2y agoWith how much AI hype the recent Apple CPUs got because you can run their NPU with half a terabyte of RAM, I don't think we'll be over it any time soon. If it works like blockchain and NFTs, we'll be reading about AI products for at least another four or five years.
- LoganDark 2y agoThe new Mac Studio nearly made me lose my shit. I want one so bad. It's only just over a cool $14,000...
- Mistletoe 2y agoWhy do you want one? What would you do with it?
- fzzzy 2y agoRun r1 671b at a q6 quant?
- alsetmusic 2y agoPeople can want crazy-fast hardware without having a specific need. I know I want this. Doesn’t mean I’m gonna buy it.
- throw0101a 2y ago> Why do you want one? What would you do with it? For the same reason why someone wants a car with 500 HP/PS (367kW).
- MuffinFlavored 2y ago500? You mean 1,000+, right? :)
- ForTheKidz 2y agoFinally I'll be able to stretch my legs with emacs (aka "eight megabytes and constantly swapping")
- LoganDark 2y agoLLMs. Also, leaving web browser tabs open. Also, playing games without having to close/unload either of those. Although probably 128GB would be more than plenty for all that, I still drool at the prospect of having more RAM than I know what to do with.
- homebrewer 2y agoUnlike blockchain and NFTs, this curse has some real (very niche and limited) uses, so I'm afraid it will last longer than 4-5 years.
- creata 2y agoNiche and limited relative to the outlandish funding and attention they're getting, sure, but they're not that niche.
- Workaccount2 2y agoAnd here's me a non-swe using this niche and limited tool to save thousands of dollars a month because I can finally tell a computer what to do without having to crash course python again. Bumpers might be useless for pro bowlers, but they allow people like me to forgo hiring a pro to knock over pins.
- apetresc 2y agoI hate to break it to you, but you’ll be reading about AI products for the rest of your life.
- leosanchez 2y agoAt work we use a website to give appreciation to fellow collegues. Even that website has AI...
- nashashmi 2y agoMaybe it uses AI to optimize for radio settings? Maybe we should all use AI including AI chips to optimize for c.
- RicoElectrico 2y agoCognitive radio is a thing. I presume the modern modem does have some problems to solve for which we don't know the exact solution. A cursory research returned this: https://www.scribd.com/document/629742504/37817-h00 https://www.scribd.com/document/629742504/37817-h00
- wslh 2y agoAt this pace, we will soon go to the grocery store and ask for 5 kg of AI, or insert it into our language as a punctuation mark.
- dijit 2y agoThey claimed this with the last generation of chips but upon delivery were underwhelming (per core, unless you were comparing apples to oranges with core counts). Claim: https://www.macrumors.com/2023/12/18/qualcomm-snapdragon-x-elite-faster-apple/ https://www.macrumors.com/2023/12/18/qualcomm-snapdragon-x-e... Benchmark: https://youtu.be/fl7pYRfRyfw?si=1npM7NuH0CVUGj2T https://youtu.be/fl7pYRfRyfw?si=1npM7NuH0CVUGj2T Now thats a 14 core Quallcom CPU vs an 8 core apple one (counting performance cores) Compared to Intel the efficiency is amazing, but it is not touching the performance of the M-series, but it was claimed to be so: https://www.theverge.com/24191671/copilot-plus-pcs-laptops-qualcomm-intel-amd-apple https://www.theverge.com/24191671/copilot-plus-pcs-laptops-q...
- comex 2y agoThis is about modems, not general-purpose CPUs.
- taormina 2y agoThe history of overstating technological claims seems relevant.
- acdha 2y agoYes, especially with the huge gap between the underlying hardware’s maximum capabilities and what people actually get with shipping software. Qualcomm’s historic focus on hardware has left them losing ground on anything which isn’t a simple driver tweak.
- jeroenhd 2y agoWhy would you need to only look at single core performance to compare apples to apples? Qualcomm can fit more cores in the same die for a lower cost (or is willing to charge less overhead, at least), providing a faster multicore CPU. Wirh everything from games to web browsers leveraging multiple cores these days, multi core performance is quite relevant. Their performance may come at a cost of efficiency but they're beating most of the M series chips when it comes to raw CPU performance. Legacy software running only on a single core will be slower, but I haven't had a CPU core run completely idle while another is on high load for years. Furthermore, this article is on modems, an area where Qualcomm rules and Apple has a lot to gain. I'm sure Apple will catch up eventually, but they're still catching up at this point and if Qualcomm has managed to apply the lessons they've learned from catching up with Apple in the CPU area, that may take longer now that Qualcomm has reason to be competitive again.
- tw1984 2y agoqualcomm worked pretty hard to miss out on all emerging fields, now their modem business is being challenged again. I guess resting and vesting just can't keep going forever?
- daneel_w 2y agoIt didn't work out for Intel vis-à-vis AMD, at least. Maybe Qualcomm's "AI" modem can put a few hours in at their strategic initiatives department when it's not busy creating that huge payback delta against Apple.
- matwood 2y agoUnfortunately it’s not a real challenge since Apple probably won’t sell their modems for other phones, and Apple will use their own modem even if it’s lacking in some way.
- LeoPanthera 2y agoIs the iPhone 16e even out yet? Are they comparing against a product you can't (yet) buy? How do they know what the performance will be like?
- Flockster 2y agoYes, I can pick it up today in my Apple Store it says on the website.
- Almondsetat 2y agoThe iPhone 16e has been out for roughly 10 days for consumers, and even more for reviewers and publications. This information is a 1-second google search away
- Philpax 2y agoApple usually have iPhones available to purchase within two weeks of announcement or less; it's due to their famous logistics pipeline.
- scarface_74 2y agoThe C1 Modem is pretty bad https://www.macworld.com/article/2626940/apple-c1-modem-real-world-tests-iphone-16e-download-upload-speeds-performance.html https://www.macworld.com/article/2626940/apple-c1-modem-real...
- userbinator 2y agoFunny name, considering that Apple has used an Intel modem (with an x86 CPU core!) in its iPhones in the past: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17988756 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17988756
- kalleboo 2y agoApple bought Intels cellular modem division, so their new modem is a derivative of the Intel ones... x86 may be back...
- grandinj 2y agoDoes that matter? Most of the time you will be limited by the network tower and the number of people around you using phones. Energy efficiency is more important to most heavy mobile data users, I would guess
- croes 2y ago> largely thanks to its AI-powered features. So it hallucinated bandwidth?
- inkyoto 2y agoIt gets better than that: clients are guaranteed to receive a response even before they send a request.
- mrweasel 2y agoIf feels a little suspicious that Apple comes out with the C1, shows that it's fairly good, even if it's lacking in some areas, and then Qualcomm announces their new modem? Seems a little unnecessary. Apple isn't going to switch back to Qualcomm, nor are Android makers going to be able to get a C1 into their phones. It's not really a competition.
- janderson215 2y agoSometimes big co’s have to play the market and do things for appearances. QCOM shareholders and potential shareholders are probably the ones who appreciate this news the most. Losing Apple as a customer is a very big deal for vendors.
- kotaKat 2y agoOkay, but does my mobile device NEED to be able to pull 12Gbps speeds? I’ll take a solid reliable 20-50Mbps of LTE on a power-sipping SOC over Qualcomm trying to beat their chests with another space heater of a chip for network applications that just don’t exist yet.
- daneel_w 2y agoIt's almost like the smartphone camera "megapixel" race all over again...
- jsheard 2y ago5G is already dangerously fast on cheaper plans, I've accidentally burned through my entire monthly data allowance by running a single speed test.
- zinekeller 2y agoNot necessarily, but if the improvements that lead to 12Gbps includes refinement over signal processing, such that certain previously-garbled signal are being successfully decoded now, this will allow for better real-life speeds and latency. Obviously, this will not equate to 12Gbps but serving a thousand people with guaranteed speeds of 12Mbps and practically receiving (assuming not everyone is downloading) 100Mbps with minimal latency and packet loss would be great improvements. This is also the thing with Wi-Fi, you would unlikely to get ~6Gbps unless you're the sole user, but the improvements allow for faster and lower-latency real-life speeds.
- 2y ago
- ksec 2y agoI think I will wait to see more real world C1 Data.
- llm_nerd 2y agoThis is way beyond the point of diminishing returns. There are some edge situations that people will cite, but for the vast, vast majority of users, none of the cellular data improvements over the past half decade have made an iota of difference.
- bfrog 2y agoQualcomm can say whatever they want, it seems unlikely Apple goes back to the hassles of working with them.
- wslh 2y agoRight, it seems like Apple is obsessively replacing the non-commodity hardware in their devices. It is embedded in the company’s vision.
- inkyoto 2y agoIn the case of 5G modems, I, for one, welcome and fully support Apple's obsession with replacing the 5G modems with their own for two reasons: Qualcomm 5G modems are power-hungry and run hot to very hot. Ever feel that burning sensation from your smartphone tucked away in a pocket of your jeans? That is right, that is Qualcomm sending you invisible rays of love. A 4G MiFi device I used to have could easily run on a single battery charge for 8 hours, and sometimes it would still have some battery charge left. The battery in my current 5G MiFi device can barely sustain 4 hours of operation, and sometimes even less – because of the power hungry Qualcomm 5G modem. Every single 5G device (smartphones, tablets, and MiFi devices) I have owned came with a Qualcomm 5G modem, which has always had a detrimental impact on the battery life of the device, and especially so as the data transfers increase. Given the engineering and financial resources at Qualcomm's disposal, it is bewildering that they have not even attempted to address the power consumption of their flagship product that also happens to be a cash cow. It is regrettable that Ericsson is not in the business of making consumer-grade 5G modems/chipsets, focusing on the core network equipment exclusively. The downside of Apple eventually achieving the feature parity with Qualcomm in the future is, of course, that their 5G modem availability will be constrained to the Apple ecosystem in the embedded form unless they also decide to make their MiFi device, which is not very likely.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- chmorgan_ 2y agoGlad we've got some competition in this space. Qualcomm was the only manufacturer with top tier performance for several years. I'm a bit skeptical of how much "AI" is going on here but given the number of parameters in RF systems its not a surprise that ML could be trained on them to reduce the necessity to perform things algorithmically and outperform what a human could describe and code.
- crazygringo 2y agoSerious question: what can AI actually do with modem operation? I'm struggling to see where in the signal processing chain you can inject any AI benefits, but I'm only familiar with the basic principles. Where can pattern recognition/classification help? Since I really doubt it's anything LLM-based... Or is this just pure marketing fluff?
- GeekyBear 2y agoGoogle's Pixel phones abandoned Qualcomm modems for Samsung modems several years ago, and it doesn't seem to have cost them market share. If Samsung and Google can both abandon Qualcomm modems without losing market share, I'm sure Apple can do the same.