10 ms·
Schools reviving shop class
- bookofjoe 2y agohttps://archive.ph/iGeZf https://archive.ph/iGeZf
- lowbloodsugar 2y agoSomeone’s gotta keep the old things working when the average person can’t afford to buy things from the Chinese World Hegemony.
- wombatpm 2y agoI don’t know. When you are living in a Chinese owned factory dormitory you don’t need lots.
- gorgoiler 2y agoHah, I’m currently enrolled in machinist classes and one of the big NOs is no ties! Funny to see one at the top of the article.
- SoleilAbsolu 2y ago2 of my big safety lessons from elders when I was growing up: - my Nana always wore her hair up when in the kitchen, she had worked somewhere she saw a woman get scalped by having her long hair pulled into a mixer - my Dad was wary of synthetic clothing after having seen people in fires have synthetics melt onto their skin (not sure if this was in the Army or growing up in St. Louis)
- dekhn 2y agoSee also: "degloving" (note: if you are squeamish, DO NOT SEARCH)
- deskr 2y agoIt's very interesting how many "non-trivial" things can go wrong with power tools. Kickbacks for example. They sound very trivial when you know about them. But to the layman that does a one off cut with a table saw, circular saw, chain saw, angle grinder, ... it's not so intuitive. One might say and be very careful but then a kickback shows up and causes brown pants at best, a life changing injury or death at worst.
- spicyusername 2y agoThey should also revive or create classes that teach other important, basic, life skills - budgeting, banking, getting a loan, investing, hiring a contractor, buying appliances, tiling, roofing, drywalling, etc, etc.
- millerm 2y agoCivics, ethics, and cooking too. :)
- bloodyplonker22 2y agoI found that in ethics classes, a lot of it was holier than thou and virtue signaling instructors preaching but not necessarily practicing. I am not saying all of the instructors and people who teach ethics are bad, this is what I have observed.
- gameman144 2y agoThis is interesting to me, none of the ethics classes I've ever taken even had room for a holier-than-thou instructor; they were taught as "here are various ways that people have tried to determine the right thing to do throughout time". A professor saying "And I'm great at doing the right thing" would be as out of place as them bragging about their fitness or wealth.
- protocolture 2y agoI remember my equivalent (they called it "Commerce" but it was basically law/politics/ethics) spent some significant time navel gazing at legislation that had directly influenced the private school system we were in. "here are various ways that people have tried to determine the right thing to do throughout time" would have been vastly preferable to "heres how private schools with private funding successfully managed to extort the government for even more funding" Maybe you can consider the teacher to be good because I remember the (many, many) lessons on the topic. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Goulburn_School_Strike https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Goulburn_School_Strike
- _bin_ 2y agothe cover photo wearing a tie is uhh an interesting choice for literally any kind of shop. same reason women have to keep their hair out of the way.
- yapyap 2y agohard agree, that might be the end of him if it wasn’t just for a photo op
- basisword 2y agoI remember wearing ties but tucking it into the shirt (in between the buttons) and also wearing an apron. Incredibly unsafe to just have a tie on normally around machinery so imagine that is just for the photo op.
- jdougan 2y agoMight be a clip on tie.
- metalman 2y agothis wont have much effect, as the origins of "shop class" was to introduce kids to power tools and modern equipment, who were living with all kinds of basic hand tools and work shops as the basic backgound of a world with a large percentage of hand made things. That background is gone, and with it the ability to tinker and practice, scrounge, and build stuff. Out in the country, you might still find plenty of that, but they dont need shop class, as there is any amount of tools, for free, or cheap, cheap ,cheap, building cars or anything from parts. bumper sticker says "built not bought" old timer told me that you used to have to watch your tools, and put them away, lest they go missing, now they are perfectly safe anywhere, presumably because tools have a negative conotation
- DebtDeflation 2y agoWas going to say. I graduated high school 33 years ago. Was one of the last cohorts that had wood shop and metal shop. It was fun, but even back then the tools and presses we used hadn't been relevant to industry for awhile. If you want shop to be relevant to modern industry you would need to teach robotics, CAD/CAM, CNC, 3D printing, etc.
- jcgrillo 2y ago> If you want shop to be relevant to modern industry you would need to teach robotics, CAD/CAM, CNC, 3D printing, etc. Uhh.. what? A CNC mill is, fundamentally, a mill. A CNC lathe is a lathe. You're not absolved from knowing how to use a manual lathe or a manual mill even if you use CNC machines all day long. Where do you develop an intuition for feeds, speeds, finishes, tolerances, etc if not by spending hours and hours doing it by hand?
- convolvatron 2y agoI tried to learn machining on a CNC mill. it went ok, I guess. but I ruined a lot of tools, had to do a lot of polishing passes, and didn't really understand why my tolerances were so off. things like the flycutter mystified me, and using the boring head was deeply frustrating since it didn't have a tiny little servo. aligning the vice was something I dreaded, took me a good hour for some reason. 4 jaw chuck? maybe you use that if you need to drill off center or work on square stock. couple of decades later I only use manual machines (with power feeds and DROs), and I'm really a lot faster and more consistent.
- jazzyjackson 2y agoI think the return on investment is underplayed, it's not just what skills you graduate with, it's whether you find going to school at all rewarding. I was bored stiff in most of my classes, but having marching band to look forward to and the reward of traveling to different cities on the band bus kept me from completely checking out of school. Maybe another aspect missing from schools lacking shop is the sense that you're trustworthy enough to put in front of a potentially lethal machine, a little bit of self worth goes a long way.
- rckclmbr 2y agoWe had a metal lathe in our high school shop class. I still can’t believe someone didn’t kill themselves on that. I think wood lathes are fine, but honestly that should be kept out.
- mitthrowaway2 2y agoWood lathes are much more dangerous than metal lathes IMO! They run at high speeds, the workpiece is typically less secure, the material has a grain structure prone to catching the tool and digging into it, ventilation is required, and most importantly, the cutting tool is gripped in the operator's hands instead of being secured on a toolpost.
- jcgrillo 2y agoA metal lathe is the fundamental machine tool. You learn how to calculate feeds and speeds, plan depth of cut, thread cutting, parting, etc. You learn about surface finish, chatter, cutter shape... Why rob students of this? Should nobody learn basic machinist skills? It's no more or less dangerous than any other shop tool.
- artursapek 2y agowood lathes + long hair = very risky business
- WillAdams 2y agoYep. https://www.nytimes.com/2011/04/14/nyregion/yale-student-dies-in-machine-shop-accident.html https://www.nytimes.com/2011/04/14/nyregion/yale-student-die...
- cryptica 2y agoThis is an excellent subject to teach in schools. I'm a software developer and I felt like I benefited from woodwork and metalwork lessons at school. I think if the future generation is to automate systems, they will need to understand the manual processes. Another thing that's needed through is to make it easier for young people to buy land in remote areas and/or to access funding to start companies. It's insane how difficult it is to obtain funding for any venture dealing in the word of atoms. I hear stories of young people moving to China to access opportunities; in the west, it feels like entrepreneurship in the space has been regulated out of existence. It's bad enough that you have to compete with China on price and quality, but regulations make it essentially impossible.
- hi_hi 2y agoMe: Great, an article Not about about AI. clicks_link Me: Oh FFS
- rzzzt 2y agoBuilding an AI in shop class, what a prospect. I'd choose "giant mecha robot with laser attachment on each shoulder" as my assignment!
- efa 2y agoYeah, I'm not sure why it's a hedge against AI. How about a hedge against the fact that we still need to build stuff, cool spaces, plumb buildings, provide electricity and fewer people are being trained for this stuff.
- Scoundreller 2y agoRecently learned that US school students typically get ~20 minutes of outdoor time per day… is that true? I can find some legislated minimums/guidelines around that… what’s the actual practice? https://www.reddit.com/r/Infographics/comments/n75w63/recess_policy_across_the_united_states_with/#lightbox https://www.reddit.com/r/Infographics/comments/n75w63/recess... Got 60 minutes/day in Ontario Canada in elementary school, and I felt like it wasn’t enough but I guess I liked to run a lot. And that was in addition to 1-2x/week physical education “classes”.
- kjkjadksj 2y agoStructured recess in elementary school and such is usually around 30 mins a day. You'd also have gym class that might meet outdoors on the athletic facilities if the weather is good for it, that would be a full class period maybe 50 mins with some time banked in to change in an out of your gymwear in the locker rooms. In highschool your schedule might look a little more "collegiate" where you might elect to take certain classes (even local community college classes potentially that you could count for college credit in undergrad), and might end up with some free periods during your day if schedule permits. When I went to school people would use those free periods either to do homework, slack off, go home early, or smoke weed in the woods. In college on the other hand you might only have a class or two a day depending on your schedule.
- mixmastamyk 2y agoLunch, walking between classes, one P.E. period for about an hour.
- cyberax 2y agoThat's a good idea. Schools should give an "overview" of potential career paths and teach some basic skills. I don't think it makes sense to teach students how to use metalworking lathes, but giving people basic proficiency with hand tools and less dangerous power tools would be great. It can also be used to teach about power tool safety. I can't believe some of the dangerous stuff people do with angle grinders.
- zoklet-enjoyer 2y agoNothing stressed me out more than working with a band saw hoping I didn't cut my fingers off
- operator-name 2y agoTangentially related, Jony Ive of Apple fame recently did an interview on BBC's desart island disks where he discussed his father's involvement in bringing Design Technology to UK schools: https://www.bbc.co.uk/sounds/play/m00289vf https://www.bbc.co.uk/sounds/play/m00289vf https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Design_and_Technology https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Design_and_Technology
- trentnix 2y agoIt’s not just about acquiring “basic skills” or “marketable skills”. Shop enables practical, skill-appreciating minds to use geometry, physics, and science in concert to solve problems. You learn about symmetry and measurement, force and torque, and materials and chemistry simultaneously. Many learn better at a workbench than at a chalkboard. And even those that don’t often appreciate the chalkboard more when they can relate what they’re learning to what they are doing.
- ljsocal 2y agoI was very fortunate to be in middle school (ages 11 - 13) in the late 60s when shop classes were still going strong. Here's what I recall of our curriculum: 6th grade: industrial drawing, hand tools, shop safety, home maintenance: replacing windows, wiring bulbs, switches and outlets, faucet installations. Basic fabrication with plastic, hammered metal forming and band sawing wood. 7th & 8th grade: Metal: forge, lathe, welding (electric arc & acetylene), sheet metal (cutting, bending, punching, riveting, soldering) Wood: turning on lathe, table sawing, planing, routing, laminating, veneering, clamping, etc In high school, all of the above plus architectural drawing, project management, metal machining, and fiberglass (mold design, making and part-making). Student projects included dune buggy car bodies, boats, water skis, furniture and all the usual (cutting boards, knife blocks, spice racks, etc.) In today's world, parents (and lawyers) might find it unsafe for boys (very few girls elected to take these classes) but in seven years of shop, I only recall one serious accident involving the loss of a finger tip. I went on to college major in Industrial Design and business then spent a career designing and producing projects for major consumer product company clients.
- WillAdams 2y agoThe best advice I ever got (after my Kindergarten teacher telling me, "Now young man, you should _never_ pass up the chance to go to the bathroom.") was my shop teacher advising: >Before hitting the switch on a power tool, slowly count to 10 under your breath to yourself on your fingers, visualizing all the forces involved and planning out the entirety of your movement and how you will be moving the stock/tool, and considering what might go wrong and the results thereof and what will protect you (all guards should be in place and all suitable PPE worn) or where you should be positioned so as to avoid any potential projectile, reminding yourself that you want to be able to repeat that count in the same way when the tool is switched off. Sawstop wouldn't have a business model if all tablesaw accidents were tried by a jury of shop teachers.
- Xfx7028 2y agoI don't get that advice from the kindergarten teacher. Can you explain please?
- dekhn 2y agoI had a shop class in middle school (mid-to-late 80s) and I learned a ton of useful skills even though i went on to software engineering. Got experience welding, etching, knew what a "tap and die" was, did drafting (and got exposed to AutoCAD). I also had "home ec" which taught how to cook, clean, and sew. A few others that I would have liked to see: basic plumbing repairs,working with hand tools (plane, chisel, etc), building structures from framing lumber. It really seems like having a good non-academic curriculum for life skills is broadly useful beyond folks who are going into the trades.
- jcgrillo 2y agoI think there's another really important set of lessons available from basic tool use which translates directly to the software industry--intuitive understanding of what makes a tool good. Tools (as opposed to appliances) scale with the user's ability. A good lathe in good condition does better and better work as you learn its behavior and capabilities. You could spend 5 decades with one hammer incrementally improving your forging technique day by day and week by week. Your dishwasher, however, just always does the same thing. Knowing the difference between a dishwasher and a hammer is something it seems like many of the engineers, designers, and product managers in the software business are completely incapable of.
- robomartin 2y agoI've been a mentor for the FRC robotics competition team at our local high school for a number of years. This is as close as any of the schools in the area get to shop class these days. And by that I mean that the schools do not teach any of it. They simply provide a space for the team to conduct their activities and we, the mentors, take-in any kid who might want to join and teach them how to design and build competition robots as well as other areas (business, marketing, graphic design, etc.). It has been very difficult over the years, including a time when we thought about pulling the team out of the schools and running a smaller team out of our home. The bureaucracy and ebbs and flows of support made is painful at times, almost terminal. Thankfully the team survived. Many of our team members went on to nice careers in science and engineering. I've also had the experience of trying to start an RC model airplane club at our local schools. I was going to fully fund it myself, donate all tools and equipment and teach the course once a week. I was also going to have other engineers and acquaintances join in from time to time, including people who worked at SpaceX, designed the F117 stealth fighter, built cameras for space and the moon, designed a lunar lander, etc. I met with the principals from five of our schools. They all said they were enthusiastic about it and wanted to do it. So, I got going with planning and got a curriculum and some demonstrations ready for the next meeting. Long story short, they all ghosted me. And, on top of that, Los Angeles County demanded a $2 million dollar bond (or whatever it was) as a precondition. Just f-ing crazy. I walked away and never spoke to anyone at the school district about this or any other STEM ideas again. My kids are out of the system and I have zero interest in enduring that kind of torture again. So, yeah, our system of education is broken beyond recognition at many levels. Not sure what it will take to fix it.
- thenextbastion 2y ago[dead]
- somenameforme 2y agoDecentralization will solve it. The current heavily centralized scheme has just created a system where everybody's optimizing for the lowest common denominator's test scores. Anything that doesn't improve that is heavily deprioritized, especially if it could entail any sort of liability or risk. Infantilization follows naturally.
- varelse 2y ago[dead]
- OJFord 2y ago[US schools] (Never went anywhere afaik over here.)
- kragen 2y agoOver where? I see you're working at an agtech company. Are you perchance in Uttar Pradesh? Brazil?
- OJFord 2y agoYes, I could be anywhere, exactly.
- kragen 2y agoI'm not sure why you would comment that somewhere in the world there is a place that continues to have shop class in high school. Did anyone doubt that? We don't live under a world dictatorship; I'm sure anyone could have guessed that somewhere it still exists.
- riahi 2y agoI had no shop class in my middle school years 99-2002 but technical theater is the closest thing that may still sneakily exist in many schools. I learned basic carpentry and electrical, including lighting design and sound, all in the service of making sets for the yearly plays.
- stego-tech 2y agoLong overdue, in my opinion. I grew up desperately looking forward to wood, metal, and automotive shop classes to compliment my computer electives; by the time I reached High School, all but wood shop had been replaced by more weight rooms for the football team to use. Primary education should always include basic skills in craftsmanship, inclusive of at least shop class and cooking/home economics. Hopefully this marks a more general rebound of these long-neglected skillsets.
- throwaway422432 2y agoI still use a steel toolbox I made at school. Did the lot: cutting, folding, welding, painting and got an A+ which is fair because it's now almost 40 years old. My kids didn't get to do any of that which is a shame. There are obvious downsides like having the tools to make throwing stars from the metal off-cuts.
- SoftTalker 2y agoAll the kids had knives and throwing stars when I was that age. The boys anyway. I carried a pocketknife all through middle and high school.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- Duanemclemore 2y agoEven in the rural midwest in the early nineties you didn't get a big shop education in middle school, and I was on the academic track in high school. But we did a lot of woodworking in Scouts. Pretty much everyone grew up in families that worked with their hands. Some of us came factory work, the farm kids all learned how to use tools. And even the "rich" kids families owned small companies who worked in these areas. Fast forward to the beginning of architecture school and we all had to draft by hand (which I had been doing in some capacity since 7th grade) and learn to and use the shop. We didn't learn to draft because it was a necessary skill anymore, but to learn 1. spatial thinking and in turn 2. how to turn ideas into real things you could communicate. Same with the making of physical models (even if you didn't use the shop). These require the attention to detail and understanding of process necessary to break a sophisticated design idea down into individual actions (single lines, cuts, etc), and are of immense value even if you never touch a wood shop after undergraduate. Even today, 25 years later and a time when we don't even necessarily teach 2d -CAD- drafting anymore we still require shop work, physical modeling, and hand drafting of ALL our students. So much that in a lot of places the first year of a 5 year professional Bachelor of Architecture doesn't even touch digital modeling of any sort. If you want a foundational read that touches on deeper meanings around workmanship let me recommend David Pye's The Nature and Art of Workmanship[0]. [0] https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/319901.The_Nature_and_Art_of_Workmanship https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/319901.The_Nature_and_Ar...
- 0dayz 2y agoI know in Sweden it's required to do both sewing and woodwork in school upwards to secondary high school. I think that's a wonderful because both genders are forced to learn skills that can be helpful in life.
- linsomniac 2y agoI moved schools in the middle of 7th grade, and my new school made a big deal about "grandfathering" me in to letting me take both Home Ec and Shop the semester I moved, because ordinarily they wouldn't let someone take both. They were both easily the most valuable classes I ended up taking, as far as my daily life goes.
- throwaway290 2y agoin order to > Hedge Against the AI Future So robots are not going to do it?:) This is a game of whackamole, there is no real hedge aside from demanding a policy change.
- WalterBright 2y agoI took every shop class. Drafting, wood shop, metal shop, auto shop. I still have the desk I made. I tried to build a steam engine in metal shop, but failed. I was able to build a working one in the metal shop in college.
- kragen 2y agoImpressive. What kind of valves? Including the boiler?
- WalterBright 2y agoIt had a sliding double-action (push-pull) piston and a push-pull valve operated by a linkage attached to the flywheel. I didn't make a boiler - just ran it on compressed air. It vibrated ferociously, though, as I had paid no attention to balancing it.
- kragen 2y agoImpressive. A wobbler would be doing the valve on easy mode.
- danans 2y agoThe confidence I gained from my middle school wood and metal shop classes in the late 80s came in handy 30ish years later when I remodeled significant portions of my own house in the 2020s, from the building fabric in to the floors and finishings. My white collar peers were surprised I could do such a thing, to say nothing of my South Asian professional immigrant family. I feel like I got the best what those classes were meant for: teaching people how to build many of the things they need in their lives rather than be dependent on the consumerist systems. Self reliance taught through a socialist public education system in the Rust Belt. Go figure. I'm so lucky I had it because most such classes were cut in the following years as public school funding was cut back. I still have one of the industrial art pieces I made back in 8th grade shop class - a cast aluminum Great Seal of America, mounted on a wooden plaque.
- icsa 2y agoIn my suburban middle school in Northern NJ, everyone (boys & girls) was required to take: * Wood shop * Metal shop * Cooking * Sewing * Typing I never saw an injury. Learning to work with our hands safely was quite valuable.
- tbossanova 2y agoFirst day of metalwork I managed to catch my hand on a sharp edge and got a cut that was bleeding juuuust enough to warrant a bandaid. I went to the teacher to ask for one. The look of confusion on his face is emblazoned on my memory. After a few minutes of scratching his head and thinking about the situation, he found some packing tape and covered the cut with that. And that was the last injury in that class!
- INTPenis 2y agoJust recently my mind went back to shop class actually. In the middle of southern sweden in the 90s we had annual theme days and one of them was candle making. Probably went there because of all the "stearin" that is thrown out with modern disposable candles.
- hinkley 2y agoWoodworking was terrifying. But there are so many other things one could make or fix in a shop class.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- brador 2y agoReal reason shop was ended: cost and safety. Materials are expensive, tools are expensive. $0 for a math class, $100 for a shop class. PER CLASS. The danger of kids with tools getting stabby (and cutty). Those remain unsolved. Shop will not be revived until they are.
- cdot2 2y agoWhat changed between when shop class was common and now to cause those issues?
- ThinkBeat 2y agoI have not been paying attention. I had no idea they were gone. It is not one of my favorite classes when I took it, but what I learned, has been useful in a lot of situations, and still is. So please bring it back.
- abc123abc123 2y agoI hated shop class. It was an enormous waste of time I could have invested in learning more about computers, or to reduce hours in school. It should be completely abolished and people with an intense desire for carpentry and similar activities can learn about it after school without tormenting all children with this nonsense.
- idiotsecant 2y agoWhat a remarkably incurious take for a HN enthusiast. I thought shop class was great, and I also love computers, for many of the same reasons.
- drakonka 2y agoI never knew it as "shop class", but my high school in Austraia had a "metalworking" elective and it was _so cool_. I made a mirror frame and a sword.
- tristor 2y agoShop, Home Economics, and Media were the only classes I liked in middle school. I took Shop 3 times and Home Economics twice, because you could retake it voluntarily since they were elective classes. While I don't use this knowledge every day, some of what I learned in Shop class laid the foundational knowledge I needed for a number of my hobbies, including the work that went into building my first race car. Home Economics taught me how to sew and embroider, which came in handy many times for small repairs like sewing a button on, but more importantly it helped teach me to cook, and as an adult I am a relatively accomplished home chef. I was never going to make a career out of either, but it definitely helped round me out in a way that has helped me to become over time something of a Renaissance man.
- jjkaczor 2y agoHeh - it's even more helpful when your shop class teacher is missing a finger/part-of-finger or several, and holds up his hands during introduction to safety when operating machines. He never did say what occurred, but thinking back, I am hopeful that it was from trying to save some students from their own carelessness...
- aenopix 2y agoPreparing them for the war machine. This is what they want.