8 ms·
Important to note that the serotonin theory of depression doesn't have to be strictly true for SSRIs to be effective. People who having passing familiarity with
by Aurornis 2y ago
Important to note that the serotonin theory of depression doesn't have to be strictly true for SSRIs to be effective. People who having passing familiarity with neuroscience often assume that psychiatric medications work by correcting deficiencies, but this isn't true. It's also not accurate to say that SSRIs "give you more serotonin" or any of the other variations on that theme.
Neurotransmitters aren't simple levels in the brain that go up and down, despite how much podcasters and fitness influencers talk about them like that. Neurotransmitter dynamics are complex and the long-term adaptations after taking medications like an SSRI can't be simply described in terms of "levels" going up and down. There are changes in frequency, duration, and movement of Serotonin across synapses that are much more complex. There are also adaptations to the receptors, including auto-receptors which modulate release of neurotransmitters (side note: some newer antidepressants also directly target those autoreceptors with possibly slight improvements in side effect profile).
So keep that in mind when reading anything about the serotonin theory of depression. This is often brought up as a strawman argument to attack SSRIs, but we've known for decades that the serotonin theory of depression never fully explained the situation. We've also known that some conditions like anxiety disorders are associated with increased serotonin activity in parts of the brain, which SSRIs can normalize.
- kittikitti 2y agoYou should keep in mind that it's a serotonin hypothesis of depression, as noted in the article. Calling it a theory is unsupported by the science.
- Aurornis 2y agoThe title of the paper is "The serotonin theory of depression" and it uses the phrase throughout the paper.
- kittikitti 2y agoCan you tell me where it referenced it as a theory outside of the headline? It also concluded that there is a lack of evidence for the association so why would the authors call it a theory?
- Aurornis 2y agoUse your browser's search function. At least 4 instances throughout the article > It also concluded that there is a lack of evidence for the association so why would the authors call it a theory? Read the article. It explains this in the introduction. Click some of the citations.
- kittikitti 2y ago"The main areas of serotonin research provide no consistent evidence of there being an association between serotonin and depression, and no support for the hypothesis that depression is caused by lowered serotonin activity or concentrations." I wouldn't call it a theory especially if you're being semantic about serotonin reuptuke. Perhaps it's you who is using words you don't understand?
- wasabi991011 2y agoThe comment you are responding to makes it pretty clear that they know there is not enough evidence for it. I'm not sure it's worth commenting on the semantic difference between theory and hypothesis, especially since these words often overlap in meaning in casual conversation.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- tsimionescu 2y agoA (scientific) theory is simply a collection of many interlocked observations and logical deductions. A theory can be well established (such as Newton's theory of gravity, or the germ theory of disease), or it can still be at a hypothesis level (such as string theory) or it can be debunked (such as the humor imbalance theory of disease, or the geocentric theory of astronomy).
- aeturnum 2y agoExactly this - SSRI's efficacy was established based on improvements in reports from depressed people and we formed a theory about the mechanism based on the interactions we understood. As we try to prove that theory out it turns out our theories don't hold - but people who are depressed still improve when on SSRIs! So we're still working on the mechanism (which we always knew was incomplete at best) but this work isn't about the underlying efficacy of the drugs on the condition. It's about the nerdy explanation for why SSRIs work.
- thomassmith65 2y agobut people who are depressed still improve when on SSRIs Does that mean 'over 50%' of them improve, or is it, as is more common with pharmaceuticals, closer to a rounding error? There was a deluge of media a couple decades ago about Prozac and its dramatic effects. A few years later, I read some report that the studies testing its efficacy had ambiguous conclusions.
- Aurornis 2y ago> Does that mean 'over 50%' of them improve, or is it, as is more common with pharmaceuticals, closer to a rounding error? This question is more complicated than it appears. One of the biggest challenges with depression studies is that the placebo group always improves dramatically, too. Using your terms, "over 50%" of the placebo group would likely show improvements in their depression inventories. This makes it very complicated to interpret the studies, because now you have to look for how much more the active treatment group improves relative to the placebo group. This is a huge detail that gets abused a lot by anti-pharma people, who write headlines about how SSRIs are "barely better than placebo" and then ignore the actual statistics. Another common tactic is to try to reframe the thresholds in different terms like "effect size" and then pool studies together to try to show that the "effect size" is below some arbitrary threshold. Another challenge is that placebo response has been getting stronger over the years and nobody really knows why. Some antidepressant studies have even been halted because, ironically, the placebo group improved so much that there numerically wasn't much room left for the active group to be statistically better given the sample size. This is less of a problem with very large scale studies where smaller margins can be shown to be more statistically significant, but those are expensive and rare. There isn't really a question about whether or not they are effective for many patients in the world of empirical treatment. However, if you go digging through the internet you can find plenty of commentary trying to convince you they don't work. Sadly, I've had some close friends and family members delay SSRI treatment for years because they read too many of these studies, but when they finally gave in and did a trial it turned their life around. The drugs aren't perfect and don't work for every situation, but they do work for a lot of people.
- dondraper36 2y agoA fairly surprising fact revealing how little we understand the efficiency of SSRIs is that the serotonin level rises pretty quickly once you have started taking an SSRI. Still, there is an unexplained cascade of reactions that takes weeks before patients notice any improvement. As much as I respect proof-based medicine, the very fact that scientists can't explain how all this works made me want to stop my treatment and just do more weightlifting and running.
- TZubiri 2y ago>how little we understand the efficiency of SSRIs A drug that is taken by millions of people, if your take is that we understand it too little, either you are deep enough in the subject to make some interest questions, or you are missing the forest for the trees. I'm not sure how useful it is to keep investigating exactly how it works on a chemical level, yeah for sure some people should look into it, but in the same way that some one should do 1600m in the regional competition of Minnesotta, as a niche. You can observe the effects of the medication on people, done. I remember seeing a video on a cannabis researcher explaining that they didn't find any difference between the indica and sativa strains for example, and she talked about chemical properties. Just get 10 people to smoke one or the other and you are done. There is such a thing as overintellectualizing, and FUTON bias isn't a particularly impressive way to do it.
- swores 2y ago> "I'm not sure how useful it is to keep investigating exactly how it works on a chemical level" It has the potential to be incredibly useful. Not because there's a benefit to being able to tell patients "this is the technical explanation of how the SSRI we're giving you will help", but because we currently don't have a perfect treatment for depression, and understanding how existing imperfect (but useful) treatments actually work might lead to either creating better SSRIs that are more effective, or to creating non-SSRI treatments that we haven't yet thought of.
- TZubiri 2y ago>treatment for depression That reads like a treatment for death, or a solution to poverty. Will you find the answer by doing 100 metastudies and taking advanced chemistry. Or will you find the wisdom by meditating and talking with your dad and priest. So I'm either an anti-intellectual, or you are a super-lectual.
- TZubiri 2y agoIt sounds like a very naïve explanation of depression. I'm cynical enough to believe that's why it's popular: "You are sad because you are missing happy chemicals" Reality is more complex, hitchen's razor tells us we don't need to spend more time down that road. That said, I'm open to the idea that ssri's (while certainly tangential to the theory) are more complex. If only because they may be prescribed early on either due to a physician desire for a simple theory or due to the patient's desire for it. But once you have gone down that road you can't change course easily. I believe whatever issue existed prior to SSRI onset becomes secondary (whether for better or worse) to the symptomps caused by SSRIs themselves, the patient becomes fungible and the disease a categorizable syndrome with clear treatment and support systems (and low suicide rates, which is usually the concern of family). On that note, the medication is not only taken for the patient, but some properties are designed/selected for the physician (low suicide/malpractice rates) and family (less outwardly symptons). In this way it's a milder version of lobotomies to my judgement. End rant
- amanaplanacanal 2y agoSeems like less suicide would be better for the patient too.
- throwaway94048 2y ago[dead]
- 42772827 2y ago> People who having passing familiarity with neuroscience often assume that psychiatric medications work by correcting deficiencies, but this isn't true. They think this because that’s literally what the commercial for Zoloft said. [0] [0] https://youtu.be/twhvtzd6gXA https://youtu.be/twhvtzd6gXA
- agumonkey 2y agoWhat I'm trying to figure out is the interplay between the transmitters, and "semantic" (sorry, making this term up, not a neurologist, basically your representation of the world) layers in the brain. What interpretation mechanism are affected by brain state to distort your perception of so many things.
- Lerc 2y agoI think if it like a snow globe, occasionally the snow falls into patterns you don't like, there is an abundant body of science that covers principles of physics that dictate how the snow moves. You might be able to come up with some broad patterns that show what lead to outcomes that you don't want. Nevertheless the best option for fixing the undesirable pattern of snow is to give the globe a quick shake. Solutions do not necessarily require a complete understanding of the problem, or even directly target the problem. Now if you only wanted to move a few problematic flakes without shifting any others, that's a different, much harder problem.
- TwoPhonesOneKid 2y agoAll of this fine, but surely in your context the efficacy of SSRIs should not imply the accuracy of a serotonin theory of depression. At best we know that the medication works, at worst we know that it's actively encouraging people to kill themselves, although the latter seems a little unlikely atp. Having been on an SSRI myself I gave up on the hope of SSRIs forming the basis of real treatment decades ago. Bupropion seems less harmful but also seems to have similarly small impact.
- H8crilA 2y agoPsychiatric benefits of SSRIs show around 2 to 4 weeks after the therapy starts, but the serotonin levels increase on the first day. It is obvious that depression is not just some "nutritional" problem in the synapses. It does look like it can be cured by systematic "overeating", though, at least in some/many cases.
- spondylosaurus 2y agoIt's interesting (1) how many drugs have effects on serotonin, even if they're not SSRIs and (2) how different SSRIs and SSRI-adjacent drugs can have notably different effects, like how buspirone affects serotonin but is an anti-anxiety drug rather than an antidepressant. There's clearly a lot going on with just that one neurotransmitter! The former can have some unfortunate consequences though, and to make matters worse, it's not always obvious which drugs you need to watch out for. Those "may increase risk of serotonin syndrome" warnings are no joke!
- mtlmtlmtlmtl 2y agoYep, all very good points. Neuropsychopharmacology is extremely and recursively complicated. It's turtles all the way down. Just take one component in all this, the receptor. One might want to think of a receptor as just a switch triggered by a chemical. But autoreceptors are a thing, as you mention. Receptors do different things in different areas of the brain. Receptors form complexes with eachother(e.g 5-HT-2a and D2), and we have essentially no idea why? Receptors have all sorts of different modes of interaction both with ligands and cell internals. Agonism, partial agonism, antagonism, inverse agonist, positive/negative allosteric modulation. The GABA-A receptor is not really one receptor, it's more like a family of receptors made up of a varying constellation of subunit proteins. Different constellations appear in different parts of the brain, and have different allosteric binding sites, which is why benzos vary widely in qualitative effects despite all being "GABA-A PAMs". NMDA receptors don't just bind to glutamate, but also glycine, and magnesium needs to be around? And NMDA triggers an intracellular cascade that regulates membrane expression of AMPA receptors. This is thought to be involved in memory. Cannabinoid receptors are expressed presynaptically carry signals in reverse, so that's weird. And there are 5 identified cannabinoid receptors. We only sort of understand what 2 of them even do. The other 3 are still quite mysterious(last time I checked). Most of the well studied neurotransmitters have not one, but many different receptors they interact with. 5-6 dopamine receptors, I can't even remember all the serotonin receptors, etc. Many of them are still poorly understood. And of course, neurotransmitter systems talk to eachother. Serotonin so much so that it's also been called a neuromodulator. Because it very often regulates release of other neurotransmitters(including itself). It's a field that, the more I dig into it, the more confused I get, honestly. So when I see someone say herp derp, serotonin hypothesis is false, therefore SSRIs are ineffective, the only conclusion I can make is they haven't even tried to dig into it.
- Centigonal 2y agoThe analogy I've used with friends is that neurotransmitters are to brain communication as letters are to language. If something gives you "more E" or "less L" in your writing, the change in letter frequencies is probably not the thing that's directly making your sentences better, but the change shows it's clearly making a difference. There is an effect that is occurring on a level of complexity that we just can't fully decipher yet.
- caycep 2y agoAt some point, neuroscience HAS to replace "serotonin" and other monoamine hypotheses by what they're really getting at: serotonin/dopamine/glutamine etc are all data packets for a neural network, and a better way of describing the network-level changes for depression etc is sorely needed.