7 ms·
Harvest the sun twice: Agrivoltaics promises sustainable food, energy and water
- rompic 2y agoJust read an article about one of these in the local newspaper. They currently have some challenges with bureaucracy, at least in Austria: Given that it is an industrial facility it has to be secured from unauthorized access, but as it is a field, it has to be accessable to small animals. So now it is fenced with barbed wire on the top but it's open at the bottom.
- tfourb 2y agoNot the case in Germany. Photovoltaic installations on agricultural plots are routine, in certain cases (I.e. the plot is next to a motorway) you don’t even need a planning/building permit, as long as the installation conforms to established building practices. Agrivoltaics is still a niche practice, but not because of bureaucratic concerns.
- ashoeafoot 2y agoMy brothers farm had an offer by a similar startup with different dimensions but basically the same idea. Had problems though. First was moving parts. You can not expect a system to last outside with any in them. Budget for the whole affair is tight, large repairs undo the whole endeavour . Second is crops riping at different speeds below. Finally practicality of the frame for farming machines . Meaning the dimensions need to adapt to pre-existing machines. And ideally remain upright even if one post gets hit. Finally honesty regarding erosion ..corn is one of the more erosion prone crops and then having water dumped on specific areas concentrated creates channels fast. So the idea does not work with no crops or erosion crops in rainy areas. There is a reason there is grass below most solar fields. One good aspect they didn't push is that this is ideal for electro farming. We have hyper effective electric moisture traps now and electro nitrogen fixing- combine that and this can remove one need for driving trucks through. In all other aspects i see this limited to orchards.
- otherme123 2y ago> In all other aspects i see this limited to orchards. This study is for a very specific region: East Africa (Kenia and Tanzania). Their main problems are too much evaporation, no energy sources, no other sources of food. I don't see how a solution that might work for a good share of humanity (Africa is huge: Kenya and Tanzania alone have 150 million people) gets dismissed as "limited to orchards" because it can't be used for industrial scale corn crops in my country.
- rob74 2y agoWell, unfortunately "Africa" is only mentioned in the article's title (which got cut to fit into HN's character limit) and not repeated in the article itself. But I can understand the concern: most agriculture (not only corn) is highly mechanized pretty much everywhere in the world except the poorest countries, so this would be limited to the crops that can't be mechanized.
- otherme123 2y agoOr this can be adapted to mechanized crops where it makes sense. Greenhouses where small fragile minihouses of 4x3 meters, made of wood and glass 100 years ago, used only in countries with harsh winters. Nobody in their right mind would use a tractor to work on them. Today they can be seen from the space and are mechanized... where it makes sense to do it. They turned a desert into a huge production of fresh vegetables: https://www.amusingplanet.com/2013/08/the-greenhouses-of-almeria.html https://www.amusingplanet.com/2013/08/the-greenhouses-of-alm... . Agrivoltaics could be something or nothing. But don't dismiss it because it today isn't already perfect for everything. Ten years ago the cost of the panels alone would make this projects 100% infeasible.
- rob74 2y agoThose plastic-foil greenhouses spreading like cancer across the landscape in Spain should be shown (especially up close, where you can better see the dirty tattered foil and the waste they produce) to people who think solar panels or wind turbines are eyesores. I would definitely support replacing those cheapo greenhouses with something more permanent involving solar panels!
- andy_ppp 2y agoYes you could easily combine solar panels and poly-tunnels for example. We have the potential over the next few years to make everything work so well but instead the US seems to be cutting cyber funding.
- ZeroGravitas 2y agoI've read an article with vertical bifacial panels between long hemispherical greenhouses to catch reflections.
- grumpy-de-sre 2y agoPhotovoltaic "fences" are one of those bizarre ideas that might actually make sense.
- postepowanieadm 2y agoThere's a simpler way: you may burn oats and generate heat/power without relying on problematic solar panels. It's already quite common.
- pinkmuffinere 2y agoSorry, how is this better? The whole path of [grow oats -> maintain steam power plant -> ship and burn oats] seems much harder to me than using solar cells?
- looofooo0 2y agoNo, EROEI for this is just bad if not negative. Also you do not produce any food.
- ZeroGravitas 2y agoWhat's problematic about solar panels? There's a reasonable amount of waste biomass generated by farms that can be used in various ways without growing it specifically for that use.
- pjc50 2y agoPeople just like using "problematic" as a content-free slur that's acceptable in "progressive" circles that bypasses critical thinking.
- postepowanieadm 2y agoMainly recycling.
- ZeroGravitas 2y agoEven if you couldn't recycle them, they'd be a much better solution than what they replace. The fact that you can recycle them just makes them even better.
- dukeyukey 2y agoAnd the problem with that? Seems we can reasonably easily recycle the vast majority of solar panels, no differently to any other electronic good.
- metalman 2y agoso called agrivoltaics will have certain very limited applications, and putting pv panels on the many very large agricultural buildings roofs, is much easier to integrate. A big risk with "agrivoltaics" is that they will in fact destroy the agricultural potential of land and then become the only source of income for the "farmers" , therby converting protected agricultural land, into purely industrial uses. Putting solar pv over canals is a better option, it reduces evaporation, while providing a cooler operating enviroment for the panels, in places that have no real constraints with developing them further.Also resevoirs can benifit/help in the same way with floating solar pv.
- KaiserPro 2y ago> putting pv panels on the many very large agricultural buildings roofs, is much easier to integrate for industrial farming yes. This study is aimed at subsistence farmers in africa. ones that don't have much mechanisation. > will in fact destroy the agricultural potential of land Given that this study highlights the water conservation features of agrivoltaics, I'd say it has a greater chance of stopping salinisation of agricultural land from over irrigation. > Also resevoirs can benifit/help in the same way with floating solar pv. again, this is aimed at african farmers with limited infrastructure. this would be the stepping stone to getting cheap electricity
- grumpy-de-sre 2y agoI really don't get the hype around Agrivoltaics at all. It all kind of pivots of the idea that land for Photovoltaics is scarce. Maybe it is in the UK but in the vast majority of the world this is a non sequitur. Cover the crop in shade cloth, and mount the panels on the ground / roof structures nearby. No need to over complicate things.
- aa-jv 2y agoDo you have your own personal garden? I'm excited about it because its a combination of many things I truly enjoy doing and get a lot of pleasure from - harvesting energy, growing food, seeing life in equilibrium. The integrated growth-stands with full-spectrum solar -> plant -> fish -> soil process is really, really appealing. Healthier food, energy harvested in neat ways. If I can get carrots and radishes and salads from the same device that charges my cell phone in the next year or so, I'll be a happier human for sure.
- grumpy-de-sre 2y ago> Do you have your own personal garden? Yes, every season I grow ~20kg of vegetables on a 15m^2 balcony (tomatoes, cucumbers, peppers, celery, various herbs). They are grown vertically on a trellis system, using 11 liter hydroponic "bato" buckets and recycled/reused perlite (sterilized). Nothing fancy. The main energy input is the chemical fertilizer. Electricity to run pumps/valves etc is very minimal and probably amounts to 5-6 KWh over the season. I use synthetic fertilizers but avoid insecticides/fungicides, instead opting to use biocontrols (shout out to Koppert! https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AFPkAQUfYvo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AFPkAQUfYvo). The future of agriculture (excluding cereal crops, which I dream might be replaced by synthetic starches one day) probably looks something similar to: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a_pR_HihCVo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a_pR_HihCVo
- barrenko 2y agoNow this is solarpunk.
- 2y ago
- phr4ts 2y agoIf this is target at developing nations, theft of the solar panels will be a major hindrance.
- thinkindie 2y agosomething similar came out a couple of years ago for growing lemons in the south of italy with solar panels providing shades from an ever increasing temperatures https://www.bbc.com/future/article/20230424-how-agrivoltaics-helped-save-italys-citron-and-lemon-trees https://www.bbc.com/future/article/20230424-how-agrivoltaics...
- leemelone 2y agoThis is a pretty dumb idea. This article is from researchers at a University. Has anyone done this for real without a grant subsidy? I understand the interest in maximizing space utilization, but this just doesn’t make any sense. Some replies indicate field setups for solar should take priority and tractor/equipment systems should adapt to these new systems. Crazy stuff.
- hannob 2y agoAgriphotovoltaics is largely a solution for a non-existing problem. It is always brought forward as an argument when the perceived landuse issue of solar is brought forward. But if you do any serious analysis, the landuse impact of even utility scale solar is so neglegible that it's not an issue to worry about. If you want to talk about landuse impacts of renewable energy, there's really only one issue to focus on: bioenergy crops. It can be as bad as 30 times less space efficient than generating the same energy with solar photovoltaics. Talk about using the same space to make food and bioenergy. Use agricultural land for food, and utilize the residuals as good as possible. Stop making biofuels out of food. And treat the space needed for utility-scale solar as what it is: tiny. (P.S.: If people can make agriphotovoltaics work, I have no issue with that. Great. Even tiny impacts should be reduced if possible. But I have an issue with the way this is discussed, because it makes up a problem with photovoltaics that largely doesn't exist.)
- daveguy 2y agoI think this implementation and purpose is slightly different. The climate they are testing in is East Africa. One harvesting is the photovoltaics for energy. But the second harvesting is for food crops. The partial shade provided by the PV panels allows the plants to lose less water from evaporation and protect against overexposure to sun so that food crops like beans and corn can provide higher yield in a normally difficult climate zone. I agree harvesting the sun as PV + biofuels is a step down, but PV + food crops in a difficult climate zone is a step up.
- 0_____0 2y agoGreat points Some (very rough) numbers to give scale here: Corn in the US covered ~90 million acres in 2024. Something like 40% of that gets turned into ethanol IIRC. Based on solar capacity figures around ~200GW, the surface area of the PV panels themselves (not the installation) are about 250-300k acres. Both solar and bio-ethanol render an energy output on the order of 250-350TWh/year. Broadly similar levels of energy, but using a tiny fraction of the land area and chemicals and industrial pollution for the former.
- shawn-butler 2y ago