9 ms·
Microsoft CEO Admits That AI Is Generating Basically No Value - https://futurism.com/microsoft-ceo-ai-generating-no-value https://futurism.com/microsoft-ceo-ai-
by toomuchtodo 2y ago
Microsoft CEO Admits That AI Is Generating Basically No Value - https://futurism.com/microsoft-ceo-ai-generating-no-value https://futurism.com/microsoft-ceo-ai-generating-no-value
Bit of a click bait title, but it certainly seems like the realization is setting in that the hype has exceeded near term realistic expectations and some are walking back claims (for whatever reason; honesty, derisking against investor securities suits, poor capital allocation, etc).
Nadella appears to be the adult in the room, which is somewhat refreshing considering the broad over exuberance.
- bognition 2y agoTime to sort NVDA?
- toomuchtodo 2y agoA fellow degenerate gambler I see. The market can remain irrational longer than you can remain solvent, trade with caution. Being early is the same as being wrong.
- short_sells_poo 2y agoHighly regarded people unite :D More seriously though: unless you have privileged information or have done truly extensive research, do not short stocks. And if you do have privileged information, still don't short stocks because unless you have enough money to defend yourself against insider trading like Musk and it's ilk, it's not going to be worth it. It's perfectly reasonable to determine that a particular high growth stock is not going to perform as well going forward, in which case I'd shift allocation to other, better candidates. Generally, being long equities is a long term positive expected value trade. You don't have to time the market, just be persistent. On the other hand, as you correctly alluded to, shorting equities requires decently precise timing, both on entry and exit.
- bognition 2y agoA common hypothesis for why Nvidia is so hot is because they have an effective monopoly on the hardware to train AI models and it requires a crap ton of hardware. With DeepSeek it’s been demonstrated you can get pretty damn for a lot cheaper. I can only imagine that there are tons of investors thinking that it’s better to invest their dollars in undercutting the costs of new models vs investing billions in hardware. The question is, can Nvidia maintain their grip on the market in the face of these pressures. If you think they can’t, then a short position doesn’t seem like that big of a gamble.
- rangestransform 2y agoit’s effectively a software moat wrt. GPU programming, there’s nothing stopping AMD from catching up besides insufficiently deep pockets and engineering culture
- hedora 2y agoNot sure why AMD’s software side gets so much flack these days. For everything other than AI programming, their drivers range from fine to best in class. I have an AMD minipc running linux that I use for steam gaming, light development, etc. The kernel taint bit is off. There is one intel device on the pci/usb buses: wifi/bt, and it’s the only thing with a flaky driver in the system. People have been complaining about my exact issue for something like 10 years, across multiple product generations.
- rangestransform 2y agoNobody who controls the purse strings cares about the kernel taint bit if their model doesn’t train, if they’re burning developer time debugging drivers, if they have to burn even more dev time switching off of cuda, etc. If AMD really cared about making money, they would’ve sent MI300s to all of the top CS research institutions for free and supported rocm on every single product. Investing any less than nvidia, the trillion dollar behemoth, is just letting big green expand their moat even more.
- dpflan 2y agoUsing “bubble” sort? ;)
- jeyoor 2y agoThe combination of high and climbing price to earnings ratios for a smaller subset of tech firms, outsize retail investment in tech (cloaked by people buying crypto), and macro environment factors like high interest rates stimulating risky lending has me swapping this bubble toward the top of the list. See further: https://www.morningstar.com/news/marketwatch/20250123167/six-out-of-seven-conditions-are-met-for-a-stock-market-bubble-this-strategist-says https://www.morningstar.com/news/marketwatch/20250123167/six...
- HPsquared 2y agoBubble sort is very resource-hungry...
- dijit 2y agoI think its probably foolish to short nvidia until theres at least echoes of competition. AMD wants it to be them, but the reality is that the moat is wide. The closest for AI is Apple, but even then, I’m not certain its a serious competitor; especially not in the datacenter. For Gaming there’s practically no worthwhile competition. Unreal Engine barely even fixes render bugs for Intel and AMD cards, and I know this for fact. FD: I’m recently holding shares in nvidia due to the recent fluctuation, and my own belief that the moat is wider than we care to believe, as mentioned.
- suraci 2y agoit's very dangerous, shorting in a market where a gamma squeeze can occur is extremely dangerous other markets s like Taiwan are preferable
- unsupp0rted 2y agoNadella is looking for the world to grow at 10% due to AI enhancement, like it did during the industrial revolution. That seems like a low bar because it already is- it's just not equally distributed yet. My own productivity has grown far more than 10% thanks to AI, and I don't just mean in terms of dev. It reads my bloodwork results, speeds up my ability to repair a leak in my toilet tank, writes a concise "no I won't lend you money; I barely know you" message... you name it. Normally all of those things would take much longer and I'd get worse results on my own. If that's what I can do at the personal level, then surely 10% is an easily-achievable improvement at the enterprise level.
- toomuchtodo 2y agoYou should be curious why Nadella is looking for the world to grow at that rate. That’s because he wants Microsoft to grow into $500B/year in revenue by 2030, and it will be challenging without that economic growth to grow into that target. You can grow into a TAM, try to grow or broaden the TAM, or some combination of both. Without AI, it is unlikely the growth target can be met. https://www.cnbc.com/2023/06/26/microsoft-ceo-nadella-said-revenue-would-reach-500-billion-by-2030.html https://www.cnbc.com/2023/06/26/microsoft-ceo-nadella-said-r...
- thagsF 2y agoAnd Henry Ford would reply: "Who is going to buy the cars?" We have been living in a fake economy for quite some time where money is printed and distributed to the "tech" sector. Which isn't really "tech", but mostly entertainment (YouTube, Netflix, Facebook, ...). Growth of the economy means nothing. The money that has been printed goes to shareholders. What the common man gets is inflation and job losses. If you want to grow the real economy, build houses and reduce the cost of living.
- szundi 2y ago[dead]
- coliveira 2y ago> If you want to grow the real economy, build houses and reduce the cost of living. Yes, I wonder why it is so hard for Western countries to understand that there's no future in a place where housing is more expensive than your average salary. If may look cool for a few years until most people have left or are living on the streets.
- bsenftner 2y agoThe "elephant in the room" is that AI is good enough, it's revolutionary in fact, but the issue now is the user needs more education to actually realize AI's value. No amount of uber-duper AI can help an immature user population lacking in critical thinking, which in their short shortsightedness seek self destructive pastimes.
- geuis 2y agoIt's not "good enough", it's mostly overhyped marketing garbage. LLM models are mostly as good as they're going to get. It's a limitation of the technology. It's impressive at what has been done, but that's it. It doesn't take billions of dollars and all human knowledge to make a single human level intelligence. Just some hormones and timing. So LLMs are mostly a dead end. AGI is going to come from differenst machine learning paradigms. This is all mostly hype by and for investors right now.
- literalAardvark 2y agoLLM direct response models are quite mature, yes (4o) LLM based MoE architectures with some kind of reasoning process ( Claude 3+, o series, R1, grok 3 with thinking ), are the equivalent of v0.2 atm, and they're showing a lot of promise.
- infecto 2y agoIt's pretty good for a whole class of problems that humans currently do.
- rsynnott 2y ago"You're holding it wrong" only goes so far.
- petee 2y agoI spent more time yesterday trying to get "AI" to output runnable code, and retyping, than if I had just buckled down and done it myself. But I don't think you can blame users if they're given an immature tool, when it really is on companies to give us a product that is obvious to use correctly. Its not an exact analogy, but I always like to think of how doors are designed - if you have to put a sign on it, its a bad design. A well designed door requires zero thought, and as such, if "AI" usage is not obvious to 99% of the population, its probably a bad design.
- mrtksn 2y agoIMHO anyone who started using AI seriously: 1) Wouldn't want to go back 2) Wouldn't believe that it's about to replace human intellectual work In other words AI got advanced enough to do amazing things but not 500B or T level of amazing and people with the money are not convinced that it will be anytime soon.
- righthand 2y agoWhat is using AI seriously? I’ve tried to use it as a web search replacement and often the information is generic or tells me what I already know or wrong. I’ve used a code suggestions variant long before OpenAI hype started and while sometimes useful, rarely is it correct or helpful on getting over the next hurdle. Any code from my coworkers is now just AI slop they glanced over once. Then I spend a long time reviewing and fixing their code. I really don’t find spending time writing long form questions so a bot can pretend to be human all that time saving, especially if I have to clarify or reword it to a specific “prompt-engineer” quality sentence. I can usually find the results faster typing in a few keywords and glancing at a list of articles. My built in human speed reading can determine if what I need is probably in an article. LLM seriousness has made my job more difficult. I would prefer if people did go back.
- mrtksn 2y agoIn my case its coding real world apps that people use and pay money for. I no longer personally type most of my code, Instead I describe stuff or write pseudo code that LLMs end up converting into the real thing. It's very good at handling the BS part of coding but also its very good at knowing things that I don't know. I recently used it to hack a small bluetooth printer which requires its own iOS app to print, using DeepSeek and ChatGPT I was able to reverse engineer the printer communication and then create an app that will print whatever I want from my macOS laptop. Before AI I would have to study how Bluetooth works now I don't have to. Instead, I use my general knowledge of protocols and communications and describe it to the machine and I'm asking for ideas. Then I try things and ask the stuff that I noticed but I don't understand, then I figure out how this particular device works and then describe it to the machine and ask it to generate me code that will do the thing that I discovered. LLMs are amazing at filling the gaps in a patchy knowledge, like my knowledge of Bluetooth. Because I don't know much about Bluetooth, I ended up creating a CRUD for Bluetooth because that's what I needed when trying to communicate and control my bluetooth devices(it's also what I'm used to from Web tech). I'm bit embarrassed about it but I think I will release it commercially anyway. If I have a good LLM under my hand, I don't have to know specialised knowledge on frameworks or tools. General understanding of how things works and building up from there is all I need. It's like a CNC machine but for coding.
- rsynnott 2y agoLining up for whatever the next thing is. "Look, we know we said AR/VR was the next big thing in the late tens and LLMs were the next big thing in the early 20s, but quantum is the next big thing now. For real, this time!" (Not entirely sure what the next fad will be, but some sort of quantum computing thing doesn't feel unlikely. Lot of noise in that direction lately.)
- sigmoid10 2y agoCuriously, all of these three (VR/AI/QC) are limited by hardware. But AI is the only one that has seen meaningful progress by just throwing more contemporary hardware at it. Sure, future hardware might bring advancements to all of them. But if you're making an investment plan for the next quarter, the choice is pretty obvious. This is why AI rules the venture capitalist sector instead of fusion or other long term stuff.
- zamalek 2y agoOf the three, QC is different in that it's not a solution looking for a problem. If we ever scale QC to the point where it can do meaningful work (the "if" is doing a lot of work there - per your point about hardware), then I don't see it fumbling like the other two have. We have immediate and pressing needs that we know how to solve with QC. The other two are very much research coming up with cool toys, and product fucking around so that they can find out what to use them for.
- sigmoid10 2y agoWhen considering scientists perhaps, but when you look at the general population the other two have way bigger ramifications on daily life than QC.
- akomtu 2y agoQuantum AI will be the next buzzword, once AGI loses steam.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- dfxm12 2y agoDid they tell the M365 sales/marketing teams about this? My users get bombarded with sales pitches, new free trials and other commms about how wonderful copilot is. It's almost a full time job to manage people's expectations around this...
- fny 2y agoNadella is just saying we haven't yet seen a revolution yet measurable by 10% economic growth--he makes no statement about the future. Most people have no clue how to use AI or where to use it in their lives. There was a guy at work who was submitting command-like queries (give meeting summary) and complained about how it left out XYZ. Then I told him to ask "Give me the meeting summary with X, Y, Z" or "what did so and so say about Y." His mind was blown. We are in the first inning. We haven't figured out how to integrate this into everything yet.
- otabdeveloper4 2y ago> We haven't figured out how to integrate this into everything yet. Maybe we don't need to. The world is fine without a sci-fi chatbot.
- apsec112 2y agoHe doesn't actually say that, the (very biased and polemical) article writer seems to have made that up. The actual quote is: "Us self-claiming some [artificial general intelligence] milestone, that's just nonsensical benchmark hacking to me. So, the first thing that we all have to do is, when we say this is like the Industrial Revolution, let's have that Industrial Revolution type of growth. The real benchmark is: the world growing at 10 percent. Suddenly productivity goes up and the economy is growing at a faster rate. When that happens, we'll be fine as an industry." That's a completely different statement from "AI is generating no value"!
- MichaelMoser123 2y agoWhat kind of growth? who is going to buy all that stuff, if a third of the workforce has suddenly been made redundant? (I always thought that this 'evil microsoft' trope is a sign of stupidity, now i am having second thoughts...)
- ipsum2 2y agoThere's a wikipedia page addressing your exact concern: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lump_of_labour_fallacy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lump_of_labour_fallacy