7 ms·
European word translator: an interactive map
- adamsocrat 2y agoDidn't know Welsh is bit challenging. e.g. awareness in Welsh is "ymwybyddiaeth", I'm sorry what? Other than that, great implementation.
- brettermeier 2y agoSearch for Welsh road signs, on most you have Welsh and English, and the differences are night and day, I find it quite amusing => "Drive safely / Gyrrwch yn ddiogel". Or this village name: "Llanfairpwllgwyngyllgogerychwyrndrobwllllantysiliogogogoch", in it's short form just a smooth "Llanfairpwllgwyngyll" (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Llanfairpwllgwyngyll https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Llanfairpwllgwyngyll).
- enriquto 2y agoLove that the numbers in Catalan are represented as numerals, not as words. EDIT: playing with it, it's a bit sad that large numbers do not work at all (in any language); and that not all common forms of a word are shown. For example, I tried to see how "ninety six" is said in french in France, Belgium and Switzerland, but it does not work.
- BrandoElFollito 2y agoAs a French, I always found that the way Wallons or Swiss word out numbers >69 makes way more sense than ours
- watwut 2y agoAs a no French, I love French numbers you dislike. 90 being 4 20 10 is something sort of awesome and funny.
- tarkin2 2y agoI often wondered if the fact your number system forces you to multiply somehow affects your mathematical competence. France has won a lot of Fields medals.
- wongarsu 2y agoThe English number system kind of also forces you to multiply. Ninety-six is nine tens plus six, or 9*10+6. French is just special because they randomly sneak in base 20. But I doubt they really think more about saying 4 score plus sixteen then you do about saying nine tens plus six. What is more influential (in a detrimental way) is German randomly switching reading direction. They read 2196 as 2000+100+6+90 instead of the more reasonable 2000+100+90+6
- lucb1e 2y agoDutch does that too, and I've tried out what happens if you say it correctly ("negentig 'n zes", ninety and six, instead of "zes 'n negentig") It takes a second to process and then they'll ask "do you mean [reverse order variant]?" so they do kinda get it and I think transitioning to the sane version could be possible without much trouble, but people would have to want to
- blahedo 2y agoIt's because if it's out of order, your "partial interpretation so far" in your head gets messed up. A relative of mine pulls a version of this in English (that I find hilarious): in American English we usually read phone numbers one digit at a time, but sometimes group pairs of digits, and it doesn't really matter because "forty five" and "four five" present in the same order. Their phone number has a 1 in it, so to prank people that are writing down or typing the number they read it as (numbers made up, but the effect is): five six seven four -teen ... and then cracks up. I cracked up when it was done to me, although apparently not everyone finds it so funny. ;)
- BrandoElFollito 2y ago
- OptionOfT 2y agoGrowing in Belgium, we learned that our Walloon brethren use septante (70), quatre-vingts (4 * 20 or 80) and nonante (90). We never learned huitante (80), but here are apparently parts of Belgium that use is. We did learn soixante-dix and quatre-vingts-dix, and were allowed to use both. [0] The Swiss also use huitante, and Nova Scotia uses octante. [0]: Funnily enough, writing American English was a no-go. We had to write centre, colour, metre, lift (elevator), ticket (receipt).
- BrandoElFollito 2y agoHa, I only knew of octante, I dd not know there was a "huitante". I worked at CERN and it was octante.
- kozak 2y agoUkrainian and russian words often use the same letters but are pronounced very differently due to distinct phonetics. On the other hand, some Polish and Czech words sound the same or very similar to Ukrainian but look quite different because of their different alphabets. Therefore, phonetic transcription would be a valuable improvement.
- Falimonda 2y agoI've been using phonetic transcriptions in a parallel text reader application I've been putting together. It seems like they go a long way in allowing a foreign language learner to internalize a word's pronunciation.
- reader9274 2y agoYou immediately see the difference (or similarly) of languages when using words that are very old, such as "iron", or "stone", which are words that have existed from the origins of that language.
- lqet 2y agoAlso "cow". And "sun", "mama" and "papa" seem to transcended most European languages.
- svilen_dobrev 2y agosalt, tea, .. one can follow migrations.. and criss-crosses.. btw, "orange" as color in Bulgarian is still "orange" (оранжев/а/о/и), but "orange" as fruit is портокал ("portokal") - so that's tricky.. "oranges" seems more correct, vs "orange color" maybe
- adrian_b 2y agoSalt and tea are good examples for the 2 reasons that can be the cause for finding the same word in many languages. Salt is an ancient Indo-European word that was already in use several millennia ago, so it has been inherited in most Indo-European languages. Tea is a relatively recent borrowing in the European languages, which has spread from one language to another, with a few pronunciation variants, across all Europe, regardless of the genetic relationships between languages.
- wongarsu 2y agoPoland took issue with the story that worldwide there are only two words for tee, and which one you use depends on whether you got introduced to tea via sea or via land
- adrian_b 2y agoFor some words, their identity is not obvious when you do not know the rules for the changes of sounds between the Indo-European language subfamilies. For instance "cow" and "Kuh" come from the same word as "boeuf" and "buey" (also despite the gender difference).
- nedt 2y agoI can mostly speak for German. It seems to mix them all into one general language. But there are a lot of local differences between north and south of Germany, Switzerland and Austria. And it’s not just dialect, but really different words that might not be understood everywhere. If you look at the english part it has at least three different words. Similar in Spanish.
- lqet 2y ago> And it’s not just dialect, but really different words that might not be understood everywhere. If you look at the english part it has at least three different words. Similar in Spanish. I think you cannot really compare the minuscule differences between "Standard German", "Austrian Standard German", and "Swiss Standard German" to the differences between English, Irish and Welsh, which are not even from the same language family. Also, the tool is based on Google Translate, and AFAIK Google Translate doesn't differentiate between them. Comparing the tool to this map [0], it seems to do a pretty good job in capturing all major languages in Europe, while ignoring their dialects. But I agree that I would be great if you could zoom into the map and also show differences in local dialects. ChatGPT seems to be pretty good at translating to different variants of standard German, or German dialects [1] [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Languages_of_Europe#/media/File:Languages_of_Europe.svg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Languages_of_Europe#/media/Fil... [1] https://chatgpt.com/share/67bba4db-9458-800c-b5f8-fd3fa196d40b https://chatgpt.com/share/67bba4db-9458-800c-b5f8-fd3fa196d4...
- wongarsu 2y agoMy best guess: - Swiss German and Austrian German didn't make the cut because Switzerland and Austria are on good terms with Germany and don't mind if we call their languages a dialect of German. Not only is that justification to exclude them, they are also not in Google translate for this reason (which this map uses) - Luxembourg did mind and went to great lengths to get their German dialect recognized as a separate language, is in Google translate, but Wikipedia lists them as only 300k speakers - Frisian is seen as a distinct language because of how different it is, is in Google translate, but has about 200k speakers - Similarly, Scottish Garlic is in Google translate has only 70k-200k speakers The map is consistent if you set the goal of only considering languages that are in Google translate and have at least 500k speakers. I do think these rules detract from the map. Frisian and Luxembourgish are interesting as "in-between" languages (Luxemburgish has a lot of French influence, Frisian is closer related to English). And Swiss German has many distinct words that are very different from their German counterparts, so for the purposes of this map it really should be a language.
- DonaldFisk 2y agoThere are examples from five language families shown here: Indo-European, Basque, Uralic, Turkic, and Afro-Asiatic. The words for bridge split neatly into language subfamilies. The only exception appears to be Welsh.
- riffraff 2y agoUgro-finnic too.
- alberto_ol 2y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Finno-Ugric_languages https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Finno-Ugric_languages
- dvh 2y agoYou are coloring it by 4 colors like map but you should color countries phonetically (speex, levenshtein or something similar)
- overflowcat 2y agoWiktionary has dialect maps for common Chinese vocabulary that showcases the differences in terminology across various regions of Chinese, rather than their similarities. Example: sleep -> https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/Template:zh-dial-map/%E7%9D%A1%E8%A6%BA https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/Template:zh-dial-map/%E7%9D%A... , hide-and-seek -> https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/Template:zh-dial-map/%E6%8D%89%E8%BF%B7%E8%97%8F https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/Template:zh-dial-map/%E6%8D%8... p.s. I'm saying this because most of these terms that has a dial-map are common in daily conversation. The differences in written Chinese vocabulary aren't as significant; how scientific and technical terms are expressed is largely determined by your administrative region.
- jhanschoo 2y agoNote that a very significant amount of this data on Wiktionary comes from the tireless work of a handful of contributors, and especially https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/User:Justinrleung https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/User:Justinrleung
- consumer451 2y agoHuh, the example "she runs" is not correct in Polish. Currently translates to "ona działa" = "she functions." She runs, as in the form of locomotion, is "ona biega/biegnie."
- lucb1e 2y agoThe site says that in a blue bubble below the input field (I agree it's not very noticeable at all): > This example demonstrates that the map should be interpreted with care; some translations have the meaning "she lasts" or "it works". Another mistake for this example, although subtler, is the Dutch version, which is translated to the meaning of "she walks"
- consumer451 2y agoThanks, didn't notice that. Not very thorough of me. It's interesting that the site says it uses Google Translate, because using it via the web UI, it does give the correct answer. https://translate.google.com/?sl=iw&tl=pl&text=she%20runs&op=translate https://translate.google.com/?sl=iw&tl=pl&text=she%20runs&op...
- Muskwalker 2y agoThe site also says (at the bottom) that it grabbed the translations from Google Translate back in 2014 and hasn't updated them since.
- lucb1e 2y agoPerhaps of interest, the translation guesses things like age relations and genders. This is accurate when the word has that same meaning in English, like nun and monk have a gender, but e.g. the word hairdresser in English is translated to a specific gender in German and Dutch even though the original didn't have one. Similarly for diminutives: "brother" (broer) usually means "big brother" in Dutch because for a younger brother you'd add a diminutive suffix. It's hard to define, but maybe: words that are not synonyms, yet all translate back to your input. (The reverse also exists, of course: insulation and isolation isn't differentiated in Dutch) The map would be more complete with this information because it may be very similar or completely different and can be interesting to compare, for example: - EN: receptionist for both, NL: receptionist and receptioniste, DE: rezeptionist and empfangsdame. The map currently just shows the female version for German, without indication that they also use a transliteration of the English. - EN: little brother, NL: broertje (the submission shows a doubled up version of kleine broertje), DE: kleiner Bruder. Although German has the diminutive suffix to make Brüderchen, they don't use it the way that we do, which I find interesting to see. Google Translate's API can output multiple options, <https://cloud.google.com/translate/docs/reference/rest/v3beta1/TranslateTextResponse https://cloud.google.com/translate/docs/reference/rest/v3bet...>, and Google's own website seems to indeed provide these different variants, but there is no label to say what the different array entries mean the way that Google's own website shows I got curious which gender it guesses that you might mean. It seems to assume a male unless it's also very heavily female-connotated in English. In Dutch and German, it outputs male for hairdresser and doctor, female for nurse and receptionist (German translations mean "sick-sister" and "reception lady", respectively), and mixed for secretary (female in Dutch, male in German) because Dutch doesn't have a male word for it anymore (only workarounds)
- benregenspan 2y agoThis is very cool. Also, it seems like Romanian is the only language where the word for turtle translates literally to "shelled frog".
- cantaloupe 2y agoGerman’s Schildkröte, “shield-toad”, is quite similar.
- neontomo 2y agoSköldpadda - Swedish too
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- joshdavham 2y agoI love when languages have funny words like that. Like how in Japanese, "mushroom" can roughly be translates as "tree child".
- nakedneuron 2y agoHedgehog is literally "needle-mouse" (hari-nezumi).
- dreijs 2y agoIn Dutch, a porcupine is called a "spike-pig" (stekelvarken) Edit: and a turtle is also a "shield-toad" (schildpad)
- riffraff 2y agoPorcupine is actually the same meaning, porcus (pork) spina (thorn/spike). It's just a bit obfuscated in modern English compared to e.g. Italian (porcospino)
- 2y ago
- weddpros 2y agoFrench is the only language where Company and Society are the same word: société. It's fun to watch
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- psychoslave 2y agoNo, in French you can use both "une compagnie" or "une société", as well as "une entreprise", "une firm", "une corporation" and "un business" or even "le biz" are all pretty common. But of course, none of them are fully interchangeable in all contexts. You will typically not expect to hear "salut la compagnie" in a formal meeting with "les gens de la bonne société." If you like synonyms, CRISPO gives 77 for société and 33 for compagnie. https://crisco4.unicaen.fr/des/synonymes/soci%C3%A9t%C3%A9 https://crisco4.unicaen.fr/des/synonymes/soci%C3%A9t%C3%A9 https://crisco4.unicaen.fr/des/synonymes/compagnie https://crisco4.unicaen.fr/des/synonymes/compagnie
- weddpros 2y agoÉtant français, je n’ignore pas les différents synonymes disponibles. Mais le mot société a les deux sens, et est TRÈS utilisé dans les deux sens. Au point que cette app montrait société comme étant la traduction de society et de company. Je voulais voir si d’autres langues européennes étaient similaires.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- joshdavham 2y agoI highly recommend people go and translate "pineapple".
- kgeist 2y agoFor Portuguese, it gives the Brazilian variant, although the translation is placed over Portugal.
- wozniacki 2y agoSuch a neat little tool! I shall use it and share it. Clever idea using the map to simultaneously display words. Small feature but hugely piques the interest of the user.
- usr1106 2y agoThe Finnish example translation is wrong: "an example" should be "esimerkki". (There are no articles in Finnish.) The map shows "esimerkiksi" which means "for example". (Prepositions are relatively rare in Finnish.) Edit: Ah, it says the data is from Google translator. So no suprise here, Google translator produces poor results. It's said that Deepl is much better. I can't really tell because I don't need machine translation Finnish English. Both are roughly equally strong foreign languages for me.
- kgeist 2y agoFor Slavic languages, it sometimes produces arbitrary case forms, too.
- fjivnfyu 2y agoWhen translating between two languages with gendered nouns, it will also lose the correct gender in translation, since it goes through the intermediate step of English. It’s hilarious how inadequate it is.
- hulium 2y agoThe fine-print at the bottom of the page says "The translations were retrieved around 2014". Machine translation has come a long way since then.
- Tainnor 2y agoMachine translation has come a long way since then, but Google Translate continues to be so far behind it's quite ridiculous.
- encom 2y agoI've had very mixed luck with all online translation services when translating between danish and english. Google was bad to the point of being unusable, but none were great. ChatGPT however is excellent at this. It's a shame its output is so extremely slow, or it would have been perfect.
- riffraff 2y agoThe Hungarian translation of "en example" is incorrect, the translation there would be "as an example" or "for example". "Egy példa" would be more literal.
- irrational 2y agoIt seems like it would be more useful if the Russian and Greek words were transliterated into the Latin alphabet.
- tdiff 2y agoIt mixes different word meanings on the same screen: Input: cross Russian: пересекать (as in verb "to cross") Polish: Krzyż (noun, as a christian symbol).
- unwind 2y agoThe notes clearly say that it only shows one meaning, and I it would be more difficult (five years ago before LLMs I would have just said impossible) to discern between different meanings of a word and pick the proper one. Edit: "translation" -> "meaning".
- tdiff 2y agoIts great they acknowledge this in their notes, but it does not make the service more useful/reliable or accurate. At least they could have tried picking translations for matching parts of speech (nouns, verbs etc), and it would have been a great improvement, even if they ignored homonyms. Doing so does not require LLM.
- sschueller 2y agoHere is an interactive card of how Swiss people (Only the German speaking part) call the left over piece of an Apple: https://www.kleinersprachatlas.ch/interaktive_karten/F15_Apfelueberrest/apfelueberrest.html https://www.kleinersprachatlas.ch/interaktive_karten/F15_Apf... Here some other words as well: https://www.kleinersprachatlas.ch/karte-1-butter https://www.kleinersprachatlas.ch/karte-1-butter
- jhoechtl 2y agoIn lower Austria we would call this a "Burzen" -> Apfelburzen. But this is colloquial and somewhat outdated. It's from https://de.wiktionary.org/wiki/Apfelbutzen https://de.wiktionary.org/wiki/Apfelbutzen
- lakomen 2y ago[dead]
- alberto_ol 2y agoThere is something wrong or that I don't understand. I put "the example", the Italian translatione is "nell'esempio" which is wrong, but in google translate the translation is correct "l'esempio"
- psychoslave 2y agoExcellent, nice work. Here are a few feedback for improvement, - looking up for "user" gives some results, but starting from a term in other languages doesn’t work; also it doesn’t display multiple nouns that can apply as a translation (ex: ulisatrice/utilisateur in French) - if the target user is English speaking user centered (at least for now), probably providing transliterations (along there Cyrillic/Greek correspondence) would probably make more sense
- layer8 2y agoOne-to-one word translation doesn’t make too much sense, because words tend to have more than one meaning, and they don’t map 1:1 between languages, both in meaning and usage. For example, “nice” is translated here into words that would (depending on language and context) more commonly translate back to “beautiful”, “pleasant”, “good”, or “fun”. They aren’t necessarily wrong as translations, but the website’s premise of “word A in language X is equivalent to word B in language Y” is.
- imhoguy 2y agoYou can put phrase, e.g. https://ukdataexplorer.com/european-translator/?word=glass+of+water https://ukdataexplorer.com/european-translator/?word=glass+o...
- vincnetas 2y agoMissed opportunity to colour countries by the similarity (phonetical) of the translations. Now as i understand all country colours are hardcoded.
- oboes 2y agoI tried with month names and it doesn't work, it only show the English word. Too bad because month names in other languages are sometimes interesting.
- 3D30497420 2y agoIt appears to be using a downloaded/pre-cached sub-set of words from Google Translate rather than a live Google Translate query. I assume it doesn't include any proper nouns. I tried putting in country names because I always find it interesting what different countries are called in different places, but it didn't return those either.
- tgv 2y agoSo I tried "folk", and it comes up with the translation for "people" in Dutch and German, "folkoric" in French, "popular" in Italian, "folk music" in Danish, and fails for a whole bunch of languages. And it's these kind of words for which its use is most interesting. Words like "linguistics" have a much greater similarity across languages than common, old words (although surprisingly called glossologia in Greek).
- shawabawa3 2y agoi wonder how long until google translate just swaps out for gemini LLMs are so much better at this (chatgpt 4o gave these answers: English: folk French: peuple German: Volk Dutch: volk Italian: popolo Danish: folk )
- darkwater 2y ago> LLMs are so much better at this Yeah, IME as well LLMs really shine at translation of sentences and getting the right meaning depending on the context for words. Way, way better than Google Translate via web UI or app. I guess that right now there might be some high level IC/manager trying to get a promotion by switching Google Translate to use Gemini in a cheap and effective way :)
- hnbad 2y agoNeither of them is right or wrong, really. "Volk" can have very specific connotations in German (e.g. "völkisch" nationalism is similar to ethno-nationalism but the concepts of "Volk" and ethnic group are not entirely identical which is why a separate term exists for the concept and why the English term uses it as a loanword). "Folk" can mean many different things in English. There is no exact overlap between words across languages most of the time so it depends on the context. For example, while "Leute" in German also translates to "people", in "power from the people" that word would be correctly translated as "Volk" not "Leute" as it refers to the people as an abstract political force from which a state's power is derived.
- adrian_b 2y agoThis is not surprising, because many English words are ambiguous, being used not only as nouns, but also as adjectives or even as verbs. All such uses must be translated into different words in other languages. When the word to be translated has no context, a random translation choice is possible. "Folk" as in "folk music" or "folk dances" may be translated correctly as "folkloric" or "popular".
- zkid18 2y agomy favorite example of trade routes influenced the spread of a word is "tea". the word for “tea” comes from either a variation of “cha” or a variation of “te,” reflecting distinct dialect pronunciations in China. countries receiving tea overland (e.g., via the Silk Road) adopted forms of “cha,” while those trading by sea through Fujian ports adopted forms of “te.” The project visualise perfectly this distinction.
- darkwater 2y agoNot doubting about this but then, how come that Portuguese uses the "chai" version, being on the extreme west of Europe, and with all the other countries in between Portugal and the end of the Silk Road using "te"? Not to mention the fact that Portuguese were a naval power for many years, with colonies in Asia as well.
- zkid18 2y agoGood question, Portuguese traded not through Fujian but Macao, where chá is used. The term cha (茶) is “Sinitic,” meaning it is common to many varieties of Chinese dialects. Meanwhile, the word tea comes from the Min Nan variety of Chinese, spoken in the coastal Fujian province, where the character 茶 is pronounced te.
- fjivnfyu 2y agoRussia got it from Mongolia, so it uses the “chai” variation. Move just a tiny bit West though and Poland got it from France, which got it via sea routes, therefore Poland uses the “te” variation, even though a lot of the culture of drinking tea in Poland has been influenced by Russia, with boiled tea being a thing in more eastern parts, and variations on that with citruses and honey being very popular (even becoming more popular today). Curiously, contrary to the word for tea, Polish word for kettle borrows from Russian influence – “czajnik”, where the first syllable comes obviously from “chai”.
- alkonaut 2y agoWhy translate 1-2 words? That makes no sense. Words don't map 1-1 or 1-2 or 2-1. It would make sense to enter a sentence, select 1-3 words as important, then highlight the same 1-3 words in the translated sentence. But translating the english words "current", "right", "bark", "date", etc. are good examples of why 1-1 word translations don't make sense.
- alentred 2y agoNice idea, quite a novel to represent a dictionary. Somehow it breaks on words "Monday", "January" and "Italy", for example - doesn't show any of the translations.
- Aardwolf 2y agoThe random words had "lead", I tried it and some translations are e.g. "plumb" which is about the chemical element, while others are e.g. "conduire" which is about the verb "to lead" So it seems to not interpret the English word as the same one for all languages in case of words with different meanings!
- HNDen21 2y agoShe runs is translated as she walks in several languages....should be ona trči in Croatian and ze rent in Dutch (German is also translated as she walks)
- venusenvy47 2y agoI was excited to try this, but it seems to have a very tiny dictionary built in. It came up with nothing for any combination of "small {noun}", or some other common words. I sometimes struggled to find two words that would work.
- kreyenborgi 2y agoWhat is the most "diverse" word? Fewest seemingly etymologically related translations? "girl" is my best so far
- asveikau 2y agoOff topic, but I recently learned that "girl" in Middle or Old English originally referred to a child of either gender, and I believe only acquired its gender specific meaning in the late middle English or early modern period.
- yitchelle 2y agoI typed in "nazi". Only UK has the word appear over it.
- aadhavans 2y ago> The translations were retrieved around 2014 How does that work? Are they cached somewhere? Devtools doesn't indicate a call to google translate.