4 ms·
After Moss Landing Power Plant reignites, officials brace for more flare-ups
- tahoeskibum 2y ago[flagged]
- notwhereyouare 2y agomusk turned anti-CA. but also, if you read the article, the plant is owned by a company in texas. >Vistra Corp, the Texas-based company that owns and operates the facility,
- MrMcCall 2y ago[flagged]
- BurningFrog 2y agoCA Assemblywoman Lorena Gonzales turned Musk anti-CA: https://www.sfgate.com/tech/article/Tesla-move-Lorena-Gonzalez-tweeted-f-Elon-Musk-16519812.php https://www.sfgate.com/tech/article/Tesla-move-Lorena-Gonzal...
- s1artibartfast 2y agoThat's fairly reductive. CA and Musk had a long falling out throughout COVID cemented by the acquisition of Twitter, firing of the staff, and advertising boycott
- BurningFrog 2y agoYou're right that there were many straws, and that tweet was only the final one.
- yardie 2y agoHere we are 4 years later, and I would say a lot of people would agree with her. LOL.
- dragonwriter 2y agoI'm pretty sure CA enforcement of its anti-discrimination laws had a much bigger impact than any tweet.
- floatrock 2y agoThe battery packs are Tesla Megapacks, as was celebrated when the facility opened in 2022 https://investor.pgecorp.com/news-events/press-releases/press-release-details/2022/Creating-Our-Clean-Energy-Future-PGE-Commissions-its-Moss-Landing-Elkhorn-Battery/default.aspx https://investor.pgecorp.com/news-events/press-releases/pres... If politics played a role, it's the convenient omission of this in the linked article while the owner/operator company was named. [edit]: Nope, I'm wrong per reply below. There is a 2022 Tesla array at Moss Landing, but apparently the one that caught fire was an older 2020 array with LG batteries. Read the article below instead, the chemistry and designs for large battery arrays changed a lot in those years, and looks like we're seeing "safety standards are written in blood" play out live here.
- martinpw 2y agoUnless the fire spread to them, it seems the batteries that burned were not from Tesla but from a different provider at the same site https://www.canarymedia.com/articles/energy-storage/moss-landing-fire-reveals-flaws-in-the-battery-industrys-early-designs https://www.canarymedia.com/articles/energy-storage/moss-lan... Vistra used batteries manufactured by Korea's LG (not Tesla batteries, as some news reports incorrectly claimed; a separate Tesla battery array sits next door).
- MrMcCall 2y agoSeeing as lithium is a powerful "mood stabilizer and antidepressant" (per wikipedia), I am curious how awful inhaling its smoke is for human beings? I'm sure it existing in combination with other elements changes its bioavailability (as opposed its practically non-existent elemental form), but for better or worse?
- voidUpdate 2y agoThe bipolar treatment is generally Lithium Carbonate. The product of burning lithium is Lithium Oxide. I doubt it has the same effects on a person when inhaled
- gus_massa 2y agoLithium Oxide reacts with water and you get two Lithium Hydroxide, so when it reach a mucous membrane it will split intermediately into Li+ and HO- and nobody will remember they were together. Lithium Carbonate is very soluble, so once it reach a mucous membrane it will dissolve, split in two Li+ and one CO3= and nobody will remember they were together. So in both cases you get intermediately Li+ so I expect no differences in the bioavailability. (IANAMD. Don't try this at home) But there is an important difference: Lithium Oxide one is too alkaline and so I guess that inhaling it is like inhaling quicklime power and you may get a huge irritation. If there are firefighter, rain or other sources of water you will get Lithium Hidroxide that is like hydrated lime that is not as bad. Lithium Carbonate is only slightly alkaline (like anti acid pills) so I guess that inhaling it is like inhaling limestone power that is not a good idea but is no terrible.
- matkoniecz 2y agoIt seems unlikely that it is inhaled, especially its burned form, when used as "mood stabilizer and antidepressant"
- phyzome 2y agoBear in mind that lithium has some unpleasant side effects. So if you don't need it, it's... not great.
- 2y ago
- simonw 2y agoIf you haven't heard of Moss Landing before it's one of the most underrated spots in all of California: it has California's largest population of sea otters living in in https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elkhorn_Slough https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elkhorn_Slough and you can rent kayaks and head out to visit them. We use https://kayakconnection.com/ https://kayakconnection.com/ (The rules are that you can't paddle within 60 feet of an otter, and if one comes closer than that you need to stay still until they leave. The otters will quite happily pop up from nowhere right next to your boat.) I'm deeply worried about the impact of the fires on the wildlife there. My favorite restaurant in Moss Landing is currently closed: https://www.hauteenchilada.com/ https://www.hauteenchilada.com/ "It is with profound sadness that we announce the immediate closure of The Haute Enchilada Café & Gallery. The fire incidents and thermal runaway caused by an explosion at the nearby Moss Landing battery storage facility on January 16 and February 18 of this year have introduced safety and environmental concerns that are insurmountable for us as the fires continue to burn."
- bradgessler 2y agoThere’s a small Marina there where you can hire boats to go whale watching in Monterey Bay. Highly recommend doing that if you live in the area.
- hedora 2y agoI was going to recommend the Whole Enchilada (same owners, down the street), but it closed recently. It was always packed. I wonder what happened. Hopefully the business makes it through this crisis.
- JKCalhoun 2y ago> My favorite restaurant in Moss Landing is currently closed As long as Phil's Fish Market is still there.
- BashiBazouk 2y agoWhen I got certified for diving through the Moss Landing Marine Laboratories in college, there was nothing more curative after a long morning of diving than a Phil's chowder in a bread bowl...
- perihelions 2y ago- "EPA onsite coordinator Eric Sandusky said officials have been conducting real-time air monitoring, tracking air quality and hydrogen fluoride levels." Hydrogen fluoride? That's incredibly toxic stuff. Surprised it's allowed to build something this hazardous, in California of all places. Why would they choose a fluorine battery chemistry for a power plant when there are many alternatives?
- s1artibartfast 2y agoFluorine is in every lithium ion battery.
- 0_____0 2y agoMore info: https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-017-09784-z https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-017-09784-z Edit to add: > The electrolyte in a lithium-ion battery is flammable and generally contains lithium hexafluorophosphate (LiPF6) or other Li-salts containing fluorine.
- russdill 2y agoIt is toxic, but fortunately has a rather short half life compared to many other environmental toxins. Other than burning lithium ion battery plants, the other major source is burning coal.
- WD-42 2y agoI’m all for alternative energy but Vistra really needs to take their R&D back to Texas.
- rsynnott 2y ago> The Moss Landing Power Plant is a natural gas powered electricity generation plant as well as a battery energy storage facility I feel like it's at least mildly weird to actually _colocate_ these. Like, it makes sense that they would be _close_, but probably not right beside each other.
- renewiltord 2y agoCould you pass environmental review on a new site? Besides, putting it anywhere else would ruin that place’s community and cause gentrification.
- itishappy 2y agoHow do batteries cause gentrification?
- renewiltord 2y agoIt’s a very complex and nuanced issue. The literature is replete with examples. And there is even a famous adage that references them: power corrupts.
- itishappy 2y agoCan you share some that you had in mind? My cursory search turned up little.
- renewiltord 2y agoSure. My rate is in my profile. Is there an email I can invoice?
- itishappy 2y agoYou'd need to demonstrate competence first, but it's clear you're making stuff up. Have a nice day!
- krupan 2y agoThe problem with energy is that it's, well, energetic. It doesn't matter if it's green clean solar or nasty fossil fuels or highly debated nuclear energy, there are big risks of the energy production and storage getting out of our control and causing big problems. It's incredibly unfortunate that energy has become such an emotional and political topic. I think we could do a lot better at being innovative and safe (both short-term and long-term) if we could be more cold and calculated about energy production and storage.
- mistrial9 2y agoask the armed guards with bullet-proof vests arriving in PG&E trucks? (seen yesterday at a nearby construction site)
- AJ007 2y agoImagine if that area had to be strip mined, factories set up, and coal power plants built. There's nothing clean or green about renewable energy. Californians and Westerners in general should be thankful they just have to deal with things like battery fires and not the raw material extraction and solar panel production, because that's what is happening in other countries instead. And no I'm not trolling, this sort of whitewashing out the ugly parts have contributed a lot of damage and waste from things like "recyclable plastic" which weren't actually recyclable, but everyone felt good it in a green bin next to grease soaked pizza boxes that weren't recyclable either.
- skyyler 2y ago>and not the raw material extraction and solar panel production I see stuff like this often and it always leaves me wondering. Does equipment for coal power generation fall from the sky? Raw materials need to be extracted for coal power plants too, right?
- WD-42 2y agoNo but the good 'ol boys from back east were the ones that used to make it so it's fine.
- MostlyStable 2y agoThe article is short on details, but I'm curious if this is a direct result of the first fire (something got damaged that led to this one maybe?) or a situation where the same faulty engineering/bad equipment led to another fire? I assume that the battery plant hadn't restarted operation after the first fire yet since I can't imagine that repairs had completed.
- rtkwe 2y agoWe really need to figure out a way to reliably extinguish Lithium fires or at least have a way and a place to transport them to so they can be contained until we can be sure they're not going to spontaneously reignite like these did. It's kind of wild to me that they seem to have just left the burnt batteries in place.
- SoftTalker 2y agoIsn't the big problem with extinguishing them that they supply their own oxygen? We need a different battery chemistry.
- rtkwe 2y agoOr a method of cooling them down reliably. They have to get hot enough to liberate the oxygen from the salts and to ignite the electrolytes. Maybe something that could aggressively bind to the electrolyte that makes it more difficult to burn could also work? Chemistry was never my best subject though.
- Syonyk 2y agoThey're an absolute pain in the rear to deal with, because they're self igniting, and it propagates between cells. Your typical lithium 18650 - vape cell, old laptop cell, whatever you know it as (18mm diameter, 65mm length, cylindrical), has a high end capacity of around 3500mAh - so 3.5Ah (amp-hours - so will take an hour to drain at 3.5 amps, 3.5 hours to drain at 1 amp, handwave goes here). At 3.7V nominal, that's around 13 Wh (watt-hours, a measure of energy capacity). As a first order handwave, when a cell runs away and burns off all the materials in it (electrolyte, plastic separators, etc), you'll get about twice the energy out of the cell as the electrical capacity - so, ballpark, 25Wh for a fully charged 18650 running away. Except, it doesn't run away in an hour. It runs away in about 30 seconds, so doing the math on that, you end up with about 3000 watts for those 30 seconds. That, meanwhile, can heat nearby cells up enough to cause them to enter thermal runaway, and the whole pack will just go, until cooled sufficiently. "Dumping a lot of water on the pack" will, generally, cool it down enough to stop this. Assuming you can get the water where it needs to be, and in something like a shipping container battery, that's far from given. At this point, you've got a damaged battery, in unknown condition, with none of the existing current paths able to be relied on, and probably new current paths that may or may not exist yet (water, metal, corrosion, and those paths are often high resistance and slow to form, which creates a lot of heat). It's not really safe to disassemble it or work on it until things have been discharged, because if the pack has energy left in it, it's prone to do exactly what this article talks about - reignite, later, inconveniently. As far as disassembling it, would you go work in a few megawatt-hours of energy, in unknown configuration, with the state of the safety systems unknown, in a charred environment of unknown toxins (what you get out of a runaway is far from predictable, beyond "generally unfriendly to humans")? It sounds silly, but if the pack is confined and the fire isn't going to spread to other packs nearby (which is why they tend to be quite spread out), the safest thing to do really is to let it burn to completion. At that point, if it's actually burned out, there's no energy left in the cells to do anything terribly nasty, and you've burned off most of the electrolyte and such. Anyway, the right answer is lithium iron phosphate for grid scale energy storage, but even those can catch fire if water gets in the wrong places, and they will, with enough prodding, burn.
- BashiBazouk 2y agoI got to take a tour of the plant when I was in high school. This was long before it had lithium batteries. A very interesting experience and very loud.