12 ms·
Why can't we remember our lives as babies or toddlers?
- jprd 2y agoI absolutely have memories before 3, and I've always been frustrated when told I've recreated them from stories and/or pictures.
- catmanjan 2y agoYou do realise you've just recrated those memories from stories or pictures?
- MikeTheGreat 2y agoThis being HN it was only a matter of time before someone found a way to shift the conversation to Rust. Well played, sir, well played! :)
- akagusu 2y agoI think it's time to rewrite the brain in Rust, making use of its memory safety features to prevent memory leaks
- steveklabnik 2y agoRust does not prevent memory leaks.
- akagusu 2y agoNo? Really? So what is the point? Why are people so crazy about Rust?
- steveklabnik 2y agoYes. > So what is the point? What Rust helps with is memory safety, which is stuff like dangling pointers and use-after-free. Memory leaks are not a safety issue, they're an efficiency issue. > Why are people so crazy about Rust? The whole memory safety thing isn't actually the reason so many people love Rust. In the Rust 2024 community survey, 82% of users agreed that "Rust allows us to build relatively correct and bug free software." Memory safety is part of that, but there's a lot more to it. So, for example, while Rust does not guarantee the lack of memory leaks, it does make them relatively hard to produce by accident in the first place. This is due to the intersection of a few different parts of Rust's overall design.
- didgetmaster 2y agoI have heard that rust can cause tetanus, which is not good for the brain.
- taejo 2y agoRust itself cannot cause tetanus but it can include unsafe blocks which can activate tetanus spores by FFI.
- boesboes 2y agoI'm with you. My earliest memory is from my second birthday. Not many, if any, other memories from that early though
- tzs 2y agoHow do you know that is where you got the memory? Early birthdays can be tricky because it is common for families to record them on video and if you saw such a video a few years later that could create a memory that you would think was from the birthday itself. Personally I don't trust most memories I have from before around 4 because my parents had around 20 reels of home movies from that time and I know that I saw several of those movies a few years later.
- aeonik 2y agoI fell off a countertop and got a concussion when I was 2.5, it's a very vivid and painful memory. I also moved to a different state when I was 5. I have a very clear delineation of before and after the age of 5, and I have hundreds of memories from before the move. Most are rather intense events, but I even remember the layout of my house, construction sites, my daycare, neighbors, friends houses, holidays, first bike ride, first lizard I caught, my pets, even some dreams I had, etc... I didn't have a good idea of time yet, but I can retroactively tell when things occurred based on facts I later learned, like when certain neighbors moved, even my sister was born, etc...
- boesboes 2y agoWe didnt have anything to film with & there are no pictures from that day. I remember only a specific moment: we went to pick up my grandpa and i recall the shirt he was wearing very precisely. I can’t guarantee that the memory is genuine, but it is very specific and I had to reconstruct my age from discussing the memory with my mom.
- sndinsmd 2y agoBecause — and this is true — you absolutely don’t. You can be continue to be frustrated being incorrect, or you can accept that you’re lying to yourself and move on. It’s that easy. Human memory just doesn’t work like that.
- plasma_beam 2y agoI am mid-40s and have several distinct memories from 2.
- popalchemist 2y agoOntologically, you can not say that definitively, you can only say that op's claim is highly unlikely. Only OP knows what OP knows and no amount of theory can disprove it, nor can any theory lay greater claim to ontological accuracy than he can.
- goatlover 2y agoOP only knows it if OP can verify having memories from that age. People can be wrong about their memories. Memory fabrication does happen.
- TeMPOraL 2y agoI'd go as far as saying, memory fabrication happens all the time - we recompute our memories when we reference them, and that result is affected by all the other experiences and memories we accumulated between subsequent recalls. Or, in other words, humans always confabulate (in the exact same sense as LLMs "always hallucinate", and I'm invoking this comparison on purpose) - the difference between "correct" and "false" memory is a matter of degree.
- datavirtue 2y agoThis.
- irjustin 2y ago> Only OP knows what OP knows and no amount of theory can disprove it, This isn't true either. Memories themselves are non-falsifiable. So no matter what we either side says we'll literally never know the truth.
- SubiculumCode 2y agoAround 2 tends to be the earliest limits that have been confirmed. Memory scientists don't claim that no memory persists from infancy, its just that it hasn't been confirmed, and there's lots of evidence of infants failing to remember events from months back in infant memory experimental paradigms, and highly plausible scenarios of memory reconstructions, from pictures, or from stories.
- datavirtue 2y agoAbsolutely no way to study this.
- rightbyte 2y agoLet a 6 month old play with a green or red ball. 5 year later show the same two balls and say you will give the kid an ice cream if it picks the same color. Obviously give the ice cream no matter the pick ... Look for correlation.
- anonymousiam 2y agoHeh. I've got memories from ages two and three that are pretty solid, and there were not photos or other records to prompt them. Some people really can do this. Some of my early memories were "filled in" by later experiences when I learned something that "explained" the earlier memory, and it was then reinforced, but the early memories are independent from the later ones. My earliest memory was President Kennedy's assassination, but of course I had no idea of what a president was, life, death, etc. I was 16 months old. What I do remember was a bunch of strange people in and out of the house with the TV on and everyone very concerned, but what I remember most of that day was that it was the day I learned how to shake my crib and move it around the room while I was inside. I remember my parents not liking the fact that I was able to do that. I've never discussed that memory with them, and they're both gone now, so I never will. I've got memories from when I barely knew how to talk, and didn't understand what the people around me were saying. My memory isn't good enough to decode what was said after I learned the language. I can clearly remember sitting in my high chair eating Alphabet cereal, and trying to make words with the letters I had not yet learned. I get sad when I think about how my parents would brush me off, probably thinking that I was too young to learn much. (My parents were both school teachers!)
- gsich 2y agoYou wouldn't know the difference.
- ryanjshaw 2y agoWhen was the last time you updated your brain OS? My rememberory format changes every couple of years.
- tomw1808 2y agoI also sometimes have memories before 3, but mostly I am sleeping. However, on rare occasion, people send me pictures where I am awake at 3, but I have no memories. Sorry folks, I see myself out, that was inappropriate, I hope nobody will remember.
- strictnein 2y agoSame. I'm always kind of shocked when people don't. My wife hardly remembers anything before she was 8. We moved a couple months before I turned three and I have a bunch of memories that predate that. I remember being potty trained and lying to my parents about it so I could get a treat. I remember my dad coming home from the family farm and having injured his hand on some machinery. I remember stealing a pack of orange gum from the grocery store and chewing it all up underneath the piano in our basement. I could keep going and going. My earliest memory was before I was two. Somewhere around 19-20 months. I know this because I had an ear infection and that's when it occurred. I'm sitting in my crib, crying due to the pain in my ear, and screaming "mom" at the door in the room. The room is mostly dark, but the door has been left open a crack to let in a little bit of light. From my vantage, looking through the slats in the crib, the door is open on the left. My mom comes in once, finally, and then leaves. I also feel like I have an earlier one, being carried in a room which may have been my nursery, looking down on a changing table. I'm pretty sure I'm being held by my father, but I can't say for certain that this is real.
- colechristensen 2y agoI had a friend who swore she had memories from before she could speak, like remembering specific events with extreme frustration about not being able to express herself.
- card_zero 2y agoSame here: she wanted to say to her mother "give me that cup back for a minute, I only wanted to look at the interesting pattern that's on it".
- xeonmc 2y agoI wonder if it has to do with the snapshot timing resolution being asymptotically high when you have not yet experienced enough passage of time. As you know we generally experience timescales logarithmically with age, i.e. your incremental experience of time is always compared in reference to dividing by the total passage of time experienced, which is why children tend to get bored much more quickly than adults, because waiting for ten minutes constitutes a much larger percentage of their current experienced life compared to that of an adult's proportion. Since a baby/toddler has only experienced a tiny amount of time passage thus far, their tiny reference "yardstick" would result in their memory being snapshotted at an untenable timining resolution thanks to division-by-almost-zero. So perhaps the brain does some form of filtering to prevent the entirety of experienced memory being dominated by the super-early ages, or perhaps there is some equivalent of an overflow in their internal counter. Keep in mind that the above are purely metaphorical as a functional description, and not to be treated as a literal hypothesis on the mechanistic operation of memory.
- roenxi 2y agoAn interesting idea; although I think somewhat unlikely. This is one of those instances where I would assume the brain is doing something carefully calibrated. But it'd be easiest to just not record as many experiences for the first few years rather than do a complete flush. My guess has always been there is some optimal approach to learning that works by developing a really basic schema (what does a person look like, which ones are mine, roughly how does this body thing work, etc) then flushing all the training data and starting again. I vaguely expect the machine learning people develop some sort of similar process where they get a lot of value lightly conditioning a model before sinking compute into doing a full train. Basically, my wild guess is there is a lot to learn in a baby's first few experiences but the risk of mis-encoding the lessons is so high that the brain uses the data to bootstrap but then throws it out as too unreliable and starts again once it orients.
- 29athrowaway 2y agoI disagree. I think the brain compresses experiences. If you had a routine of k activities every day you won't remember every instance of that routine but you may remember what the routine was.
- sema4hacker 2y agoI've always found two things interesting about memory. First, it often seems many more memories can be stored than recalled. This becomes apparent when you can't remember something to the point of being certain you've forgotten, only to later recall what you were trying to remember. (My definition of a good trivia question is one you can't answer until you're told the answer and you realize you knew all along.) And of course people who have the ability to apparently remember everything indicate memory capacity can be enormous. Second, I've often thought I can correctly remember a scene from a movie or TV show I saw decades ago, but when I see it again I realize I got a tremendous number of details wrong, indicating that particular stored memory is very general in nature and not accurate at all.
- DecentShoes 2y agoRe trivia, I often find myself thinking "I would have definitely gotten that if it was multiple choice". I agree with your second paragraph too. I often think of a certain tone of voice or pacing with which a line was delivered, and it ends up being completely different when I rewatch it. And yet there are still Mandela Effect people out there insisting their memories are 100% infallible and it's more likely there's a global time travel conspiracy to change a dot on a KitKat package than that they misremembered something small.
- choilive 2y agoSince LLMs/AI are all the rage these days - I also found a similar behavior with LLMs. If I ask a difficult recall question (usually some very niche medical knowledge) it will get it wrong or just hallucinate. But if I ask it in the form of a multiple choice question, it often gets it right. If memory works better when prompted with the information this way - I wonder how similar LLMs and humans actually encode memory?
- dboreham 2y agoBecause the apparatus for remembering is emergent, derived from accumulated training data. Only when the person's brain has gpt-2 level training data is what we call memory available. Of course actual memory as in persistent storage, is there from before birth.
- Nasrudith 2y agoI figured the reason why we cannot remember such a part of our lives is because our brains grew enough that the 'memory' neuron groups wound up converted to 'network connections', the connection and this is pretty much a result of a geometric constraints. Theoretically we could have a process of the brain relocate the memories before conversion, but it was probably selected against because it would increase calorie consumption by 5%.
- viccis 2y ago>There is debate between memory experts as to the role of language in infantile amnesia. Human researchers suggest memories may be limited by an inability to give language to early experiences. “But there must be something more fundamental that also plays a role because we see this same [infantile amnesia] effect in non-linguistic animals like rats,” says Prof Rick Richardson of the University of New South Wales. That opposition doesn't quite make sense to me. If you are examining the linguistic view of it, then what we're talking about is that memory requires symbolic understanding. Not just language (a fairly sophisticated symbolic tool), but also just the ability to schematize your various sensory impressions into conceptualized objects. My earliest memory is sitting in a high chair playing with Duplos (large Legos for young children) being frustrated that I couldn't connect two pieces. That requires a few concepts such as a high chair, the tray sitting in front of me, the pieces I was playing with, and emotions like anger. Symbolic understanding isn't necessary for any of that to happen, but it does seem necessary to store it for recall decades later. The problem with comparing this to rat memory is that I'm not convinced that rats have anywhere near the same kind of symbolic understanding, so how can they be compared to humans in this capacity? Rats can remember things, but babies can also be taught sign language starting at around 6 months, which seems much closer to rat memory (the direct linking of a perception with an emotion, unmediated by a symbolic transformation).
- jkic47 2y agocould it be that memory must require language as a predicate? Without language, how does one "record" the memory?
- forgotoldacc 2y agoThere are people without internal monologues, and most people can also visualize something and remember scenery without words. There are also animals that (likely) don't have language that apparently have memories.
- tasty_freeze 2y agoMy dog sometimes buries a bone when we give him one. Later he digs it up and chews on it some more. He forms a memory of where he buried it without the use of language (I'm pretty sure).
- drhagen 2y agoFrom experience, I am skeptical of this hypothesis. Little kids will absolutely recall memories from before they knew how to speak. Just last week, my two-year-old spied the freezer pops in storage. She pointed out back and said, "Eat on deck!" Clearly, she remembered eating freezer pops on the deck, but the last time she did that was last summer (northern hemisphere) when she didn't know how to talk at all, let alone say "deck".
- sudosteph 2y agoThat's interesting, because my earliest memory was wordplay related. Though I doubt I could have strung a sentence together at the time, there were definitely words involved. I have a few relatively early memories, but none that are totally pre-language.
- o11c 2y agoI can't counterexample the first half, but my only vivid memory from being a 2-year-old is primarily visual (though it does involve surprise at the reality contrasting with a prior description in words).
- gsich 2y ago
- mannyv 2y agoAre they remembering a memory or a memory of a memory? And in the end is there any difference? I took lots of pictures of my kids. Those pictures trigger memories, but it's unclear if they would have remembered those things without the pictures. And there's no real way to tell if those memories are real, or just narratives attached to the trigger. It's interesting to think about.
- intrasight 2y agoAll memories after the first recall is a memory of a memory. And after second recall, it's a memory of a memory of a memory. And so on. That's how the hippocampus works.
- sirsinsalot 2y agoMy mother was shocked when I recalled the bathroom tiles, layout and song she sang to me when I was a baby. There's no photos of the bathroom, it wasnt discussed as its refit was banal. The song she sang, she never mentioned to me past being a baby. As an adult I have very good visual and audio memory, as well as perfect pitch. They're not as useful as they sound. Make of that what you will.
- datavirtue 2y agoI remember a lot of my toddler years. I also remember coming out of what, looking back, feels like a dream-like state that was much simpler emotionally and cognitively but had almost a hallucinogenic feel before "waking up" as a toddler.
- dsego 2y agoI believe I remember trying to say a word and being frustrated that parents wouldn't wait and gave up just as I was about to utter the sounds, or something along those lines, it's really a vague memory of having a memory at this point.
- ipv6ipv4 2y agoMemories aren’t an objective tape recording. Memories are the brain’s model of the world. You spend your life refining your model of the world. Your earliest memories were initial rough approximations (misinterpretations, if you will) that are later superseded by better (more predictive) approximations. So you forget (they don’t activate as predictions) the old inaccurate (less predictive) memories in favor of the newer (more predictive) memories.
- prngl 2y agoIf we go a bit old-school on AI and reason in the "connectionist" framing: Let's say neural memories are encoded in some high-dimensional vector space. And so memory recall is an associative process that entails constructing a query vector and issuing it across the neural memory space. And the brain is constantly learning, and that learning entails some changes in the structure of the high-dimensional memory space. And let's say that re-encoding of a neural memory happens upon recall, and only upon recall. Then it could be that all experience is in fact stored, but because of changes due to learning, those memories become inaccessible. The machinery constructing query vectors has updated its structure enough that its encoding of those query vectors is sufficiently dissimilar from the encoding of the stored memory vectors (which use the encoding from the last recall).
- qudat 2y agoI like this while including the brain regularly does “cleanup” of connections that it deems unnecessary and removes them.
- username135 2y agoI like this one
- naderraider 2y agothis appears to be more or less what happens. (https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.ade6530 https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.ade6530)
- memhole 2y agoOn re-encoding memories as well: https://www.jneurosci.org/content/32/35/12144 https://www.jneurosci.org/content/32/35/12144 Oops, someone else posted this further down too. Great minds think alike!
- spwa4 2y agoAlso known as "catastrophic interference" or "catastrophic forgetting" ... No all that catastrophic unless it balloons, but it's a name that stuck. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Catastrophic_interference https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Catastrophic_interference
- thrill 2y agoOdd. My first memory turned out to be when I described in later years to my mother from when I was just over a year old.
- AndrewDucker 2y agoYour brain is constantly changing, and much moreso when you're young. Imagine that you're trying to load files from a previous version of a piece of software into the current version - when the format is just a binary dump and nobody has been working on backwards compatibility.
- sim7c00 2y agoi could never remember a lot far back until an incident caused some more recent years to disapear from memory. now i have some memories of when i was a baby but not from my teenagw years. i think its all in there, paging it in is just practically impossible to do on demand. maybe some people can do it though..
- johnohara 2y agoYour page-swap analogy is apt and razor sharp. Well done.
- biofox 2y agoI had a similar experience when deeply intoxicated, I saw a shadow that reminded me of the texture of the wallpaper in the first home I grew up in -- it unlocked a cascade of memories from my early childhood (I must have been 2) that I never would have been able to recall otherwise. But I can't remember what I had for breakfast yesterday.
- taurath 2y agoWhat you’re describing is dissociation, if you’re looking for a word! Its effects are not as well known and it’s under-appreciated how common it is. Plus having 3 different societal definitions really makes the concept difficult to talk about. I’ve done a lot of work on this myself and one can connect with one’s parts, if that model seems accurate to you.
- somenameforme 2y agoAnother fun one on this example is somebody after coming out of a coma being effectively fluent in a foreign language. Obviously the person had to have at least some familiarity with it before, but there are countless cases where somebody goes from knowing a few words of a language (presumably having forgotten everything they learned in school or whatever) to suddenly speaking it, more or less, fluently. Similar incidents can also completely change a person's accent and have other such interesting effects. There's almost certainly some way to tap into this without (what is usually/always) brain damage, which has interesting implications for the long-term future of education.
- jack_pp 2y agoCould be that we don't really replay memories as toddlers and memory sticks by spaced repetition. When I have weeks where a ton of stuff is happening I don't remember a lot of the details even now at 30 because there's too much for me to repeat
- account-5 2y agoI can't remember the vast majority of stuff before I was 2-3 but I remember seeing my younger sibling when they were bought home, there's less than a year between us. And I can remember a few other things earlier, they they are definitely fuzzier.
- dsego 2y agoI also believe I have several distinct memories from around 1 or 2, but it's not clear that they are real and not just confabulations. I probably have bigger gaps in primary school, things faded away.
- dijit 2y agoFrustratingly, a lot of what we think are memories are in fact: us remembering remembering. Human memory is increasingly fallible with time because of this. It's like playing chinese whispers with our own recollection, everything is a copy of a copy of a copy. It makes sense that you would remember distinct events, but the trouble here is that nearly all memory as you so eloquently described, is "just confabulations"- which feels wrong instinctively, until it's challenged scientifically.
- taurath 2y agoSome fact or visual memory is as that, but our memories are also made up of sensory sensations and emotional states, and combinations abound. In fact, a big part of what makes PTSD is a split off different aspects of a remembered event because it’s so difficult to process the whole experience. This takes place after a traumatic event, during attempts at memory consolidation. Also traumatic memory seems to be stored differently than day to day memory, which helps explain that triggers and flashbacks are valid and real (for traumatized ppl), while the confabulation effect can also exist. Though I’d note that confabulation can happen but that doesn’t mean it “overwrites” the old memory, or that confabulation is in any way more common than just remembering a part or a whole event.
- throwayaw2 2y agoI have some pretty intense trauma in my life that I can recall extremely vividly even though i have little memory of the weeks surrounding the event. Often when I don't even want to. Certain memories are true memories.
- lynx97 2y ago[dead]
- feverzsj 2y agoBecause the transceiver(brain) hasn't been ready to connect with the real you in another dimension.
- short28 2y ago[flagged]
- short2814 2y ago[flagged]
- short2814231231 2y ago[flagged]
- sachahjkl 2y agoI literally have memories from when I was 4. Same clarity as new memories.
- codeulike 2y agoresearchers have long puzzled over our inability to recall events before two or three years of age
- BriggyDwiggs42 2y agoMaybe the issue is that at that age we haven’t yet learned compressions for our memories. Maybe at that age our best option would be storing something closer to raw experience because we don’t know enough about the world. Eg we might remember a chair as “brown, lots of orthogonal lines, about my size” rather than using our experience of other chairs.
- randcraw 2y agoYeah, I think the first chair we observe is the template for recognizing other chairs later. Surely that 'seed' chair will undergo substantial revision in time as we become aware that it wasn't the ideal basis on which to base our modeling of all chairs to come, and we unconsciously 'normalize' the model for chair in our head (and adjust that memory too). It stands to reason that this happens to all of the baseline models for the referents we learn (nouns, verbs, adjectives, etc) that subsequent learning surely reshapes. This is likely comparable to the revision of 'concept' clusters that goes on in all unsupervised learning NN models, especially in humans, those that arise pre-linguistically (since words surely provide landmarks to memories enabling future retrieval). Perhaps we rewrite our early word2vec tables, making early memories less retrievable.
- codeulike 2y agoWhy can't HNers remember to read the article? There's actually some quite suprising stuff in that article, e.g. some cultures have earlier childhood memories than others, and there's some interesting suggestions as to why that is. Also considerations about how early events can apparently be stored but not consciously remembered.
- ben_w 2y ago> Why can't HNers remember to read the article? To quote: """NEW YORK, NY – A recent study showed that 70% of people actually never read more than the headline of a science article before commenting and sharing. Most simply see a headline they like and click share and make a comment. A recent study showed that 70% of people actually never read more than the headline of a science article before commenting and sharing. Most simply see a headline they like and click share and make a comment. Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet…""" - https://thesciencepost.com/study-70-of-facebook-commenters-only-read-the-headline/ https://thesciencepost.com/study-70-of-facebook-commenters-o...
- aithrowawaycomm 2y agoThe most frustrating iteration of this is when someone uses an article to make a point in an argument...and they didn't read it! A clickbait headline seems to support their claim, but the substance refutes it.
- gadders 2y agoThis looks like they listened to the BBC Crowd Science Podcast (recommended FYI) a week earlier and re-wrote it: https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/w3ct5rjf https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/w3ct5rjf
- tracker1 2y agoI don't remember everything, but I definitely have a handful of memories from when I was a toddler (2-3yo). Such as when my sister was born.
- InDubioProRubio 2y agoBut you can? You just reproduce the situation and a strange sort of deja vu returns? Take a ball- really badly, then grasp it with ever better technique and more precision, until you arrive at your grasping skills of today. Same goes with chewing on things - and the first taste of anything.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- pafry 2y agoRelated: https://supermemo.guru/wiki/Childhood_amnesia https://supermemo.guru/wiki/Childhood_amnesia
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- vanderZwan 2y agoThe cultural impact on childhood memory is interesting, but I have to say that the first paragraph was a bit off-putting, like it was written by someone who should pay a bit more attention to the actual experience of their child in order to support them through these formative years instead of projecting their own adult frustrations on them: > Life must be great as a baby: to be fed and clothed and carried places in soft pouches, to be waved and smiled at by adoring strangers, to have the temerity to scream because food hasn’t arrived quickly enough, and then to throw it on the ground when it is displeasing. It’s a shame none of us recalls exactly how good we once had it. Babies are also almost completely unable to move around by themselves and are constantly frustrated by their lack of agency. They are extremely vulnerable and utterly dependent on the kindness of their parents and other older humans in their environment. They lack language so have no other way of communicating than screaming, which is often also a cause of great distress because of an inability to communicate a basic need (and on that note, even knowing what those needs are half of the time, given that the ability to make sense of ones own senses is still being developed). All of this while life is a nonstop series of first experiences, meaning that even the most mundane thing can (and often is) surprising, confusing and overwhelming, leading to a high need for reassurance, because being scared and wanting to make sure that you're really safe is honestly a very sensible reaction to have when you add all of those things up. I'm not saying life sucks for babies and toddlers, but as a parent of a two-year old myself it's pretty obvious to me that it's no walk in the park for them either.
- KolmogorovComp 2y agoIt seemed obvious to me that part was tongue-in-cheek and not to be taken literally. It’s quite common to get readers to be ‘hooked’.
- vanderZwan 2y agoPerhaps. I've seen enough selfish parents voice this sentiment unironically to no longer give people that benefit of doubt.
- 2y ago
- jiohewrfkopwefr 2y ago> Life must be great as a baby: to be fed and clothed and carried places in soft pouches Not really. Genital mutilation is very barbaric and traumatising procedure. Most victims suppress it, and develop all sorts of mental issues. Victims have very high suicide rate! One of the reasons we can not remember our early lives. It was a horror!
- 2rsf 2y agoCan you support the claims starting from "Most victims"?
- westcoast49 2y agoWe attach our early memories to our concept of the world as it was then. Afterwards, our concept of the world changes. As a result, those old memories sort of become dangling pointers. They refer to a world model that no longer exists in our minds.
- baggy_trough 2y agoYes, it's like not being able to remember your dreams, or things when you're too drunk.
- jraph 2y ago> it's like not being able to remember your dreams That's just aggressive garbage collection happening when you wake up, arguably so you don't risk confusing dreams and reality :-) But you can somewhat partially work around it by taking notes right after waking up, before doing anything else.
- randcraw 2y agoAnd as an infant our world was incredibly smaller than our world is now. Surely the 'principal components' of that day were reshaped or subsumed by other pointers later, thereby shifting the landmarks used to retrieve memories. I would hazard a guess that the original pointers aren't revised to point nowhere, but are, if possible, moved to point into the revised reference model. (Presumably we do this now when we learn a new domain like music, and as the model for harmony becomes more concrete, our original pointers to elements within it are adjusted rather than lost.)
- ryao 2y agoI have memories dating back to the day I was born. I was incredibly bored as an infant, so I played a game I invented where I would replay all of my memories on a regular basis. It turned out that my game was essentially a spaced repetition method. The result is that I did not forget, while others did.
- osrec 2y agoWhat do you remember of the day you were born? How did you validate your memories?
- ryao 2y agoMy parents and I later discussed them. Anyway, I remember the room where they put children after they were born. Everything was white except for what was really close. A nurse that I had assumed at some point to be a relative kept putting this annoyingly warm cap on my head that I struggled to remove. I even tried pushing myself up once to look around, but I saw nothing and the effort was exhausting, so I did not try it again even though I contemplated doing it. It turns out that my grandparents were watching through the window from the hospital hallway and witnessed that, which I later heard after I recounted the story.
- osrec 2y agoWow, that's really quite something!
- pingou 2y agoIf that study is correct https://www.jneurosci.org/content/32/35/12144.abstract https://www.jneurosci.org/content/32/35/12144.abstract, considering the number of times you must have recalled them, what you remember must be significantly different than what happened, especially since you were probably missing a lot of understanding as an infant.
- ryao 2y agoIt is not that significantly different, although my poor understanding certainly left people with that impression. I thought the nurse in the hospital on the day I was born was an aunt. As a young child, I would later describe my baptism at 9 months of age as being dunked. It was not that I meant that I was literally dunked into the water. I simply thought the sensation of water dripping to the back of my head was being dunked. I also had been terrified during my baptism since I thought the deacon was trying to drown me. My parents were so thrilled that I was not crying like the other children while in reality, the reason I was silent was because I terrified about actually being immersed into water and drowned. That said, at the time, I did not really understand how to disambiguate what I had regarded to be dunking from immersion, even though I had the faint concept that the air supply could be severed by being immersed in water, which is why I had been terrified. I recall one time when I was around 2 years old and my parents took me to Pizza Hut. When asked about toppings and hearing that we could have three, I said I wanted extra extra extra cheese. They thought I was being cute. However, I had no concept of cuteness or how to be it. I simply wanted all 3 toppings to be extra cheese and to my disappointment, 2 of the toppings were not. At the time, I had not known how to say 3 toppings of extra cheese and I thought repeating extra three times would communicate what I wanted. That said, I stopped playing my memory recall game around age 5 when I began to be bullied and did not want to remember the past anymore. That left me with far fewer memories from early grade school than I had from prior years. It also let many of my early memories fade, although not enough for me to forget them entirely.
- 47282847 2y agoFor something incredible, read about the methods developed by some Hungarian child psychologists to strengthen the bond to children even before they are born: https://www.taylorfrancis.com/books/mono/10.4324/9781003331865/prenatal-bonding-analysis-gy%C3%B6rgy-hidas-jen%C5%91-raffai-judit-vollner https://www.taylorfrancis.com/books/mono/10.4324/97810033318...
- scotty79 2y agoSynaptic pruning?
- scotty79 2y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Synaptic_pruning https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Synaptic_pruning
- tomatocracy 2y agoOne of my earliest memories is not of an actual event/place but of a nightmare I had. Given the tendency to forget dreams very quickly I've always wondered how common retaining memories of dreams from early childhood is - eg I've never heard anyone else mention this when talking about early memories.
- mattmcknight 2y agoI do have memories of a nightmare from age 4-5, but it was a recurring nightmare.
- ambarp2 2y agoI have memories of my first dream or an early dream. Everything was white and bright, and I was just there, naked, with my younger sister. I’m guessing I was 2 or 3 yrs old. I woke up and was very scared by what I had experienced.
- fjfaase 2y agoI once hear the story of a colleague who when going to college met with someone who he felt that he knew although they were unable to establish were they knew each other from as they came from different cities. When he returned home and told the story to his mother, she smiled and told him that they as toddlers had met.
- 0xEF 2y agoI had a psych professor with a similar story that she liked to share. Her prevailing hypothesis on why we don't remember our infancy was that there's typically little to no reason to recall it, so the memories either fade or morph into general feelings and emotions that often help form the bases of our early personalities. I may be getting some of that wrong, too. I was not particularly engaged with that class since I was still a rather immature student, back then. I'm not saying I subscribe to her idea, but it's certainly interesting to think about.
- Clubber 2y agoI've read a hypothesis that it's because when you learn to speak, you remember things in a new way. You don't know how to access the memories you stored before you knew how to speak.
- mediumsmart 2y agoAbsolutely - "Tree" is so much easier to file than the magic thing standing there before you.
- smogcutter 2y agoIn other words, you’ve forgotten the class for the same reasons you’ve forgotten being an infant.
- barrenko 2y agoOnce in college I had a girl stare at me for a while on a long distance bus (we were almost the only passengers in there). When I got home my mom told me her mom called her to ask if I was also on that bus - apparently we have spent a lot of time together as toddlers.
- miftassirri 2y agoi remember i was crawling as a child
- Raztuf 2y agoIt's crazy that people here have memories from when they were toddlers while I'm 29 and have a hard time remembering stuff from my early teens.
- nelblu 2y agoI am with you. That said, I feel like looking at a photo when I was very young say around 4 or 5 does seem to invoke memories about the house I grew up in. I wonder if the brain is just making up the memory or the photo is actually helping the brain access some dormant region in the brain. Further, I have also noticed that when I meditate sometimes my mind wanders and brings me some memories from the childhood - totally random, unrelated to current events memories.
- busterarm 2y agoI drank heavily from my early teens to my late-twenties. Like full-blown alcoholism. I can't remember many things from that decade+, but more significantly my sense of when things happened that I do remember is usually off by years.
- helboi4 2y agoI have memories from my whole life but only smatterings of them. When I say I have memories from being as toddler it's like a few here and there.
- wat10000 2y agoI have a decent memory for places, so-so for people, very little for events. I could draw a reasonable floor plan of my childhood home and tell you about friends and family who were there. But I could only tell you about a handful of things that happened in that place. It's not much better in more recent times. I could say much the same about everywhere I've lived as an adult.
- kittikitti 2y agoOur culture is predicated on the inability of infants to remember. The overwhelming majority of newborn infant boys have their genitals mutilated and the medical community claims that they will have no knowledge. When stakes are this high, we don't want them to remember.
- Levitz 2y agoMy earliest memory is about awareness of conscience and memory. I remember laying in bed, my diapers being changed, I don't know who was doing it or what the room looked like at the time, but I remember that there was nothing before that, and that on following days I thought back to that moment with the conviction that it was important for me to remember that specific moment, since it was the first for me.
- apwell23 2y agoyou prbly just made an educated guess
- thornewolf 2y agoI have a similar experience. "A conviction to remember". I was a bit older though and playing with my toys.
- darkhorn 2y agoSame awakening moment happened to me. I was in the edge of a big bed and I was not able to move. And there were (our) wardrops on the other side of the room (later they were moved out). I remember that there was notning much to remember before that and I realized that I was small and new in this world.
- nashashmi 2y agoI have been able to recall memories from the time I was one years old. I even recalled a dream I had at the age of 3. These memories were long forgotten and probably the last time I recalled them was at the age of 7. I am now 40. Recently, I unlocked a memory at the age of 2 months. It is difficult to believe except to me. After unlocking it, the memory felt like it was yesterday. And I have recalled this memory multiple times in my childhood phase. I guess I am now recalling my childhood in greater detail which is causing me to remember what memories I was recalling at the time. So why can't we remember our baby memories? Because of shock. The present day gives us so much stress. So we focus on now. We focus on what helps us now. We recall memories that help us in the NOW. If you want to recall a memory from before, imagine a stress that likely would have also occurred from before. Like being hungry and being unable to communicate. And reaching for a bottle of milk. Being unable to walk or crawl. Lying on your back. For me, hunger does not evoke too much stress. Other things do like headaches.
- stef25 2y agoSo it's like a built-in protection to prevent us from recalling traumatic experiences ? Could make sense. But then why also block the overwhelmingly good memories like getting xmas presents ?
- asdff 2y agoI don’t think you can put logic on what you do and don’t remember from an event. Biology would have to mate that with some contextual reasoning somehow which seems a bit to complex for something so inherently subconscious. For example when I think of some family vacations from childhood I can remember deep details about staring out the car window at some place, but as for the fun things we actually did there I am at a loss and have to be reminded by family. I guess all that is to say you can’t seem to be in control of when the tape player starts recording and you can’t reliably find your old tapes.
- Supermancho 2y agoMy earliest memory is age 2, which was a traumatic one. Being wheeled through the double doors into the surgery areas, while my mom had to wait outside and was assuring me we would get Taco Bell after. Age 3. My father assembling a solid plastic child riding horse with springs. Age 4. A residential home converted to child day care, where I first encountered Cosmic Encounter on a table (probably left out from the night before). I had no idea what that was until my teens. Age 4-6, a rather large number of memories like beginning to formally write with my left hand, almost choking on a sea shell I had been sucking on, Jimmy Carter was president, my first memorable Halloween, etc. All at a Kindercare facility, which is a national pre-school chain.
- resters 2y agoI remember back to age 2, fwiw.
- kingofheroes 2y agoThe earliest memory I have, that I actually consider a memory and not just a weird dream, is a sensation of feeling very warm and comfortable and then suddenly feeling very cold and upset and wanting to go back to the warm place. I'd like to say this was a memory from when I was born, but I honestly have no clue when this happened as I couldn't see anything. I think the reason this memory stuck with me was just the stark contrast between "this is nice" to "this sucks, put me back".
- yu3zhou4 2y agoSame here! My wife did some research recently and it seems like some people really have a memory of this sensation
- BoiledCabbage 2y agoI'm curious - could you describe one of the weird dreams your had from earlier then this? It'd be interesting to know.
- Seb-C 2y agoI have a 10 days old baby, and this comment resonates a lot with the experience of bathing him. He is very calm and seems to appreciate the experience, until it's time to get out of it. We do our best to keep him warm and heat the room, but it does not seem to ever be enough to ease the ending.
- rtkwe 2y agoSo many of my early memories feel almost 3rd person because I mostly remember them as the stories told. Mostly around injuries I had as a kid though I know the memories are at least a little warped because the way I "remember" laying while I was getting stitches in my hand would mean it was on my left hand but I have the scar on my right hand. (Most likely I wasn't looking at the doctor/surgeon like I remember but facing the other way or something.)
- Bayart 2y agoI have snapshot memories from before the age of 1 that I can certifiably say aren't false (no photographic evidence, no external testimony, being able to recollect them regularly since infancy) and that can be pinpointed to that time due to specific details. They become a continuous stream around age 2 and everything around age 3 starts being as clear as anything else. In any case I've always found it interesting to have such a big delta with the people around me but not particularly significant until I seriously structured my introspection and got into cognitive behavioural therapy. With the aid of psychedelics I've managed to re-experience with extreme clarity events that I remembered but didn't register as meaningful and gleaned a new understanding about that period. For example I've come to realize that as a toddler I was very aware of my surroundings, of myself, I had an overwhelming feeling of boredom and probably needed far more stimulation than kids that age ; hence behavioural patterns during adulthood that I previously couldn't explain.
- pmontra 2y agoYour experience is more or less my experience. I even know a person that remembers from well before being 1 year old. That person started speaking very early, maybe that's related to having early memories. Different people develop at different times. The ages in the articles are averages of their respective populations so these data points are offset, for example, by the daughters of a friend of mine that told me that they don't remember anything before being 5 or 6 years old.
- thenthenthen 2y agoBefore 1 is kinda absent, but from 2 I can remember factual stuff pretty clearly (dramatic events, fun and less).
- helboi4 2y agoYeah I'm always shocked that there's a general assumption that people don't remember things before the age of 5. I remember some things from 2 years old and everything is pretty clear from 3 onwards. I do assume this is a sign of advanced development.
- BurningFrog 2y agoMuch of human evolution is about the tension between our big brains making us smarter, but also killing our mothers more often during birth. The hack evolution landed on is that we're born 1-2 years premature compared to most mammals. From that perspective, this isn't especially weird.
- darkhorn 2y agoIt is interesting that many people do not remember events when they were two years old. But much more interesting that some people do not believe that there are people who can remember events from age two.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- r0ze-at-hn 2y agoThis is my educated guess on the topic having spent time investigating the intersection of poor memory, human growth patterns etc where this topic intersects: Norepinephrine is a key regulatory of memory. Before a certain age the body is much more in parasympathetic activation v.s. sympathetic activation, very low Norepinephrine, lower cortisol response needs, etc. Once growth slows down and this can flip over then mammals will start to form memories. Human curves for the curious: https://obgynkey.com/growth-and-puberty-3/ https://obgynkey.com/growth-and-puberty-3/ Some fun notable mentions such as many earliest memories are "super scary" and those with poor ability to produce Norepinephrine and slower growth velocity will have later "first memories" than everyone else.
- fipar 2y ago> Babies are also almost completely unable to move around by themselves and are constantly frustrated by their lack of agency. They are extremely vulnerable and utterly dependent on the kindness of their parents and other older humans in their environment. They lack language so have no other way of communicating than screaming, which is often also a cause of great distress because of an inability to communicate a basic need (and on that note, even knowing what those needs are half of the time, given that the ability to make sense of ones own senses is still being developed). While mine did certainly scream when they were hungry (or annoyed, or bored, or I picked the wrong red crayon, etc.), they also had non-screaming verbal communication. Both my kids started "talking" very early (I wanna say within the first or, at most, second month of being born, but "and we'll remember this when we are old and ancient though the specifics might be vague". In any case, definitely while babies), it's just that we (obviously?) didn't understand them. But they had a very definite "language" of different sounds, which was also different between them if we compare it. Screaming is a good way for babies to get attention, but it's certainly not the only one!
- throwaway314155 2y ago> Both my kids started "talking" very early (I wanna say within the first or, at most, second month of being born... Well sure if you just redefine what talking is...
- fipar 2y agoThat's why it's quoted, but you knew that already :)
- throwaway314155 2y agoSorry about that. Was in a rotten mood. No excuse though.
- spcebar 2y agoThe technical term is babbling! It's a step on the road to acquiring language and it occurs in different phases at different ages for different infants. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Babbling https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Babbling
- royaltjames 2y agoMy brain/memory turned on full lucid at age 2ish. I remember dreams in vivid detail, can draw you pictures of houses ive been in, all sorts of conversations my parents had. I'm writing a memoir right now, since I dont know what else to do to shed this since it's pretty horrible stuff I remember.
- i_love_retros 2y agoI think it's because babies and toddlers aren't conscious. Sentient, yes, but like a dog.
- Razengan 2y agoAs others have said, I remember "snapshots" too, but I also remember "feelings": the scent of my favorite family members, my aunts and uncles, their voices, how they used to behave, their common catchphrases, the feeling of happiness when meeting them or fear when they got angry, and so on.
- amatecha 2y agoI remember a few things from when I was a baby/toddler. The strongest memory is the confusion around why I was "me", since I was experiencing reality from my totally-subjective experience and I didn't understand why I wasn't someone else. Did all the other people around me have this similar sense of being themselves? Why am "I" trapped in myself? These concepts were scary to me and really distressing, and I didn't know how to talk yet, nor could I really understand anything yet, so it was extra scary and just super difficult to make sense of. To give a sense of what my age would have been, I remember experiencing this while being in a crib. Later in life these same sensations evolved into pretty much nightly existential dread, and it's taken me decades of "I'm not thinking about this" to not have panic attacks about inexistence and the extreme temporariness of my self. Due to my early life experiences I never really dismiss a baby crying as something inconsequential like "awww he's [hungry/tired/whatever]!" because for me I was often experiencing some really primal variation of existential terror before I could even speak.
- ObiWanFrijoles 2y agoI don't think I've ever heard anybody put my exact feelings into words before. Although I don't feel distressed by the subjectivity of the experience as much as a feeling I can only describe as "odd". Why am I me? Not in a bad way, just, why am I seeing things from this specific point of view?
- phantompeace 2y agoWe’re all a different POV for the same experience/entity
- linuxftw 2y agoI have a few memories prior to being able to talk, they are visual memories that I confirmed with an older sibling (7 years older). He couldn't believe I could remember those things. I also was thinking, perhaps all memories aren't visual or auditory, and I then I read your post. It's quite possible we all have memories of that time in our lives, but they are emotional in composition rather than comprised of physical senses. Is the ability to recall something specifically a 'memory,' or could emotional feelings with seemingly no connection to the present also be considered memory? Like a lifetime of emotional deja vu. When you recall something stressful, and you feel stress in the present, is that stress you are experiencing from the present as your brain processes a stressful scenario in your mind, or is that stress part of the memory, and your brain is re-experiencing that stress in the same way you can visualize a memory?
- graycat 2y agoDo remember some from when we were in Florida; since we moved to Tennessee when I was 5, those memories were from <= 5! Memories: (1) In a few seconds older brother taught me to ride a bicycle: He put me on his bicycle and held me up as I turned the pedals. He kept saying he was holding me up as I kept pedaling and he was > 10 feet back of me! (2) Mom made eggnog! Last I ever had! (3) Brother and I got 'twin' beds, with headboards, foot boards, and posts! (4) Dad took a lantern, some dough balls, a net, and a big wash tub to the coast and returned with the tub full of shrimp! (5) One baby sitter was really nice -- still remember her smile! (6) Shela next door was my age, and we played. When her family moved to Milwaukee, I said "When I grow up I'm going to 'Wilwaukee' and marry Shela!"
- smeeger 2y agoim fascinated by the idea that good memory is a sign of low intelligence. it started when i saw that video of apes being made to play memory games in a lab. they have insane, super-human photographic memory. when they are exposed to a pattern on a screen for a fraction of a second they are able to recreate the pattern… large complicated patterns that look like noise to a human. so i think of forgetfulness as a feature not a bug. the more intellect you have, the more your brain tries to focus your mental resources onto a smaller and smaller area.
- kvakerok 2y agoI remember everything. Eidetic memory. Things before vision developed are obviously blurry or fully dark from before birth. What do you want to know?