7 ms·
Starlink and T-Mobile open satellite texting test to all
- bitfilped 2y ago[flagged]
- bookofjoe 2y agohttps://archive.ph/PPrgQ https://archive.ph/PPrgQ
- smrtinsert 2y ago[flagged]
- int_19h 2y agoIs Apple Messages not E2EE when used over Starlink?
- gpm 2y agoIt's text messages only, no data. So presumably not.
- wmf 2y agoThey previously said iMessage would work (no "text messages" actually use SMS any more now that iOS uses iMessage and Android uses RCS).
- JohnTHaller 2y agoThis is inaccurate. When mobile data is unavailable, you can use text but not iMessage or RCS.
- DHPersonal 2y agoT-Mobile has horrible data security, too.
- DrewRWx 2y ago[flagged]
- trothamel 2y agoA very important thing about this is going to be 911 (and other emergency number) calling. Since 911 calling bypasses network locks, we'll have a world where everyone outdoors can reach help.
- teeray 2y agoThere’s a popular tendency to overvalue connectivity in the backcountry and undervalue the ability to avoid unnecessary risk and self-rescue. Connectivity can actually cause some people to take risks where they otherwise wouldn’t, thinking a helicopter will drop out of the sky 30 minutes after dialing 911. Many stories about rescues in the White Mountains of NH, for example, begin with a call for help with known coordinates (either by cell or PLB). The trouble comes in rallying resources from Fish & Game, State Police, volunteer groups, etc. then getting into the woods to carry out the rescue. We’re talking many hours for this. Then there’s the issue of actually reaching those coordinates and hoping they are accurate—there’s been teams bounced around multiple points through grueling terrain while they, themselves, are putting their lives at risk.
- trothamel 2y agoI'm more thinking of times when I've been driving through areas with spotty cell service, rather then the actual backcountry. The sort of thing where you could drive to it, but still haven no service.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- grapesodaaaaa 2y agoI used to be a volunteer SAR member in Colorado. You are correct that it takes many, many hours in a lot of cases. Helis were almost never used, and you’d get rolled down the mountain on a “big wheel” if you couldn’t walk. This was not fun for the subject or SAR members. Not only that, but guess who mostly has time to volunteer? Retirees. I wish SAR had better funding, but that’s not going to happen anytime soon. I would urge everyone in the backcountry to do their best to be self sufficient and make good choices.
- OutOfHere 2y agoGo here to sign up for the beta: https://www.t-mobile.com/coverage/satellite-phone-service#sign-up-form https://www.t-mobile.com/coverage/satellite-phone-service#si...
- gurjeet 2y agoRegular price for the non-TMobile customers is $20/mo. From the linked page: How much will it cost? The beta is free for all. When T-Mobile Starlink launches in July, it will be included FREE on our best plan – Go5G Next – and available on other plans for $15/month. Until March 1st, T-Mobile beta testers not on Go5G Next can secure an Early Adopter Discount of $5 off per month, reducing the monthly cost to just $10/month. Verizon, AT&T and other customers can get T-Mobile Starlink without switching to T-Mobile for $20/month after the beta ends in July.
- drawkward 2y ago[flagged]
- gruez 2y agoGiven the alternative is no coverage, whatever he does is still going to be no worse than if such product never existed.
- precommunicator 2y agoWell, I don't know. As @teeray pointed in another comment: > Connectivity can actually cause some people to take risks where they otherwise wouldn’t, thinking a helicopter will drop out of the sky 30 minutes after dialing 911. (quote from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42996533 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42996533)
- SapporoChris 2y agoI don't know, I can think of worse off situations. Example: We provide a service, make the customer feel they cannot do without the service, then we exploit the customer. Real life examples: social media
- wmf 2y agoBecause that's disputed and it's the only example (from Starlink) you can come up with.
- drawkward 2y ago[flagged]
- DecentShoes 2y agoI don't understand why people keep saying this as if FSD is vaporware. It's coming along very well: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ej_BDr3wfiE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ej_BDr3wfiE Granted, nowhere near on the timeline he stated, and limited to the US, but it's very real and immensely impressive.
- WarOnPrivacy 2y agoT-Mobile silently drops every text from my personal numbers, thanks to The Campaign Registry, a T-Mobile led org. This is a wide reaching issue; the article does a disservice by not addressing it. Because if T-Mobile is gatekeeping this text-over-sat route, it'll be another network that silently drops our texts. Any evidence to the contrary would be welcome.
- Dylan16807 2y agoWhat does "thanks to The Campaign Registry" mean? Why are they involved? Are those texts automated?
- WarOnPrivacy 2y ago> What does "thanks to The Campaign Registry" mean? It means The Campaign Registry is the full reason why my texts are silently dropped. ref:https://old.reddit.com/r/VOIP/comments/107omsg/lets_talk_about_telecoms_clear_racket_tcr/ https://old.reddit.com/r/VOIP/comments/107omsg/lets_talk_abo... > Why are they involved? Because they can be. Ostensibly, it's a T-Mobile-led effort to reduce levels of SMS spam. It does this by forcing commercial entities to register or else their SMS are silently dropped. In reality TCR is a system that blocks SMS traffic inappropriately and broadly. This last bit includes traffic from telecom providers like mine (that compete with wireless carriers). TCR does this (astoundingly) by lumping smaller telecoms with mass marketers. It's the sort of anti-competitive behavior that an ethical and capable FCC would look into - eventually. Past that, TCR is onerous, expensive and unpredictable. It puts small-biz thru big-corp-sized hoops and will endlessly reject legit applications with little recourse. Small local shops have to pay-to-play & traverse the onboarding ordeal - or else they're fully blocked from texting their customers. Period. > Are those texts automated? No. They're routine texts I manually send from my personal numbers. Except to T-Mobile lines.
- mlindner 2y agoHow is your personal issue on an unrelated topic relevant to the article? I understand you're having personal difficulties but I've never even heard of this issue and more sounds like a simple mistake that can be addressed by talking to T-Mobile.
- doodlebugging 2y agoWith T-Mobile's history of recurring data breaches one needs to wonder whether they have an internal plan to sell all their user data periodically and then claim that they were pwned by some new vulnerability. I'm sure I wouldn't touch any service that associated with or shared data with them. Y'all do your own thing though.
- WarOnPrivacy 2y agoI sometimes wonder what their data collection on me would look like. I get a new starter SIM and number each month. I don't store anything in the SIM.
- IshKebab 2y agoYou get a new phone number every month? This is peak HN lol.
- throawayonthe 2y ago[dead]
- WarOnPrivacy 2y agoI do! I started because it was $17/mo for 10GB. I pay $23/mo now but I really like calling from a disposable number. I have a 2nd SIM in my phone ($30/yr) for incoming calls + backup carrier.
- EgregiousCube 2y agoThis seems like an unfair conspiracy theory. It’s more likely that they are just a big target with historically not enough defense.
- doodlebugging 2y agoI think their history of breaches indicates that they are slow to learn from thier mistakes made in securing their customer's PII and as a result I am obtaining my cellular service from a competitor. Though that competitor has also suffered data breaches, moving to another service makes no logical sense to me since it seems that none of them have a deep commitment to data security since the cost of noncompliance is too low. If meaningful penalties were mandated, something that is unlikely to happen in the current anti-consumer, deregulatory environment, then it would make sense to switch to a provider that has a strong commitment. Otherwise you might as well stay with your current provider. T-Mobile did get hit annually between 2017-2020 making it appear to a casual observer that perhaps they were just selling the data with their low prices serving as a loss leader and making up the difference by selling everything that they could scrape from customer services annually. It's a cynical take, I know. It keeps me from switching though.
- glzone1 2y agoIt's interesting to see all the criticism of things like this on a place like hacker news. Starlink has repeatedly been pooh-poohed. It's impossible, it'll never work, no one will want to use it. If you have ever travelled internationally the potential game changing nature of Starlink would be immediately apparent. This is a test. If nothing else, spacex is known to iterate. Starlink satellites have intentionally low lifetimes in space, they are all going to be replaced relatively soon with later generations. Yes, Biden and the FCC successfully fought Starlink, they got the awards for rural connectivity revoked, and the appeal of the revocation also kept the award revoked because starlink supposedly couldn't provide rural connectivity. So at least on paper starlink has "failed" to meet the needs of rural folks. The FCC "concluded that Starlink had not shown that it was reasonably capable of fulfilling Rural Digital Opportunity Fund requirements to deploy a network of the scope, scale, and size required to serve the 642,925 model locations in 35 states for which it was the winning bidder." You'd sort of expect hacker news folks to be interested in the science of potential benefits of this sort of thing (even if they doubt it'll ever happen). T-Mobile is betting pretty clearly that starlink WILL be able to deliver messaging via a space based backhaul. And rumor has it that starlink is bringing in some real money even if the govt has determined its not technically feasible so there is some market validation of their ideas.
- WarOnPrivacy 2y ago> It's impossible, it'll never work, no one will want to use it. Of the issues I've heard tied to Starlink, none are these three.
- ipaddr 2y agoThe issues usually are: Expensive, slow, weather related connection issues, blocking sky, space junk and/or falling debri.
- senordevnyc 2y agoI'd include ethics of giving money to Musk.
- 2y ago
- therealpygon 2y agoHand over control of nearly all my communication methods to someone as trustworthy as Musk, who has shown a willingness to ban/blacklist people from other services based on his personal feelings and ego, among his other less savory behaviors? Nah, no thanks.
- aeternum 2y agoGood thing we live in a capitalistic society where this is an n+1 option rather than a socialist society where it is decreed that everyone must use starlink.
- insane_dreamer 2y agoso far
- gjsman-1000 2y agoHa, have you seen YouTube censorship of anything worthy of importance? That's just part of life. I much prefer a well known public personality with lots of problems; than an opaque council of censors at Google or Facebook.
- gs17 2y agoI don't see the difference from an average user's perspective. Either will ban you arbitrarily on a whim and then ignore you. Knowing who's to blame by name isn't that big an improvement if there's no chance they unban you.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- zelon88 2y ago"If you've got a nazi sitting at a table and 10 people sitting around talking to him, then you've got a table with 11 nazis."