3 ms·
You don't think "Examine the data" and "Which other conclusions can you draw from the data?" are open-ended? And even when explicitly prompted to look at the p
by Dylan16807 2y ago
You don't think "Examine the data" and "Which other conclusions can you draw from the data?" are open-ended?
And even when explicitly prompted to look at the plot, they only brush up against the data anomalies rather than properly analyzing the plot.
- brookst 2y agoWhat’s the point though? That LLMs tend to be constraint by constraints in their prompting? That seems unsurprising. Humans are visual animals. We can spot a chicken in a graph, but we’re unlikely to be able to tell that a different graph is using XY coordinates to encode a message against a one-time pad. But so what?
- taberiand 2y agoI tried it on gpt4o with an upload of the image and "What do you see?" as prompt and it said "monkey". So ymmv, these tools can't be evaluated with just a bunch of gotcha prompts and ignorance of how to use them effectively
- Dylan16807 2y agoIt's not a gotcha to give it the data points and ask it to analyze. Uploading this data in image form is effectively a leading question tuned to the specific data, and an analysis tool that needs that kind of leading question is not good at its job.
- taberiand 2y agoI don't know why you would expect it to see a gorilla without an image to look at. Humans can't.
- Dylan16807 2y agoWithout an image? No, not at all. It's supposed to make its own image. And it did make its own image. But it didn't properly analyze the image it made.
- taberiand 2y agoThat's a feature that would need to be implemented. There's no reason to think it could look at the image of the plot it generated automatically, but feeding it the image it generated back to it is no different to if it did view it automatically
- Dylan16807 2y agoThe point of telling it to explore the data is so I don't have to think of every angle myself. Humans can get an understanding from visuals that LLMs can't match, apparently, even without gimmicks.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- taberiand 2y agoThe llm is able to see the gorilla when shown the image in the same way you would show a human an image. Imagine if you gave someone the raw data and told them to write code to graph the output but on to a screen they couldn't see. They would not be able to tell you it's a gorilla until you turn the monitor around and show them. Humans are still better at seeing the image, sure (for now), but the llm is a tool with certain features and abilities. You can't make up a scenario that is misusing the tool and then pretend that it doesn't work - especially when it seems you want it to use it without applying your own brain power to the process And to be clear, I'm open to criticism of llms and exploration of their limitations - but I'm tired of hearing complaints that amount to PEBKAC.
- Dylan16807 2y agoWhen I tell a human to analyze the data, I sure don't expect them to interpret it as "write code to graph it to a screen you can't see". You found the problem but glossed right over it. > misusing the tool and then pretend that it doesn't work It was told to analyze and then it did a bad job of analyzing. I don't care if an LLM expert expects this already, it's worth pointing out to everyone else. It's not PEBKAC.