5 ms·
Amazon Will Spend Nearly a Year of AWS Revenue on AI Investments
- lysace 2y agoFinancially liquid companies locked into feeding AWS (with their 50%-ish profit margin) should buy Nvidia/TSMC/ASML/(AMD) stock to get some of their money back? Totally not a bubble.
- tripplyons 2y agoI've heard arguments that you should buy NVDA as a hedge for losing your job to AI. Not sure what to make of it.
- url00 2y agoIf AI actually starts replacing jobs, society is going to collapse/restructure to the point that risk management no longer applies.
- throwaway290 2y agoIt is replacing jobs
- SteveNuts 2y ago> It is replacing jobs Prematurely, in my opinion only. A lot of those will be coming back unless there's a major breakthrough soon.
- skywhopper 2y agoWhich ones? In reality, I mean, not executives’ fantasies.
- burnte 2y agoI spend 90 minutes in a meeting with our CEO and two board members and the one guy went on almost the entire time about how amazing OpenAI Operators was and how we should find a way to replace most of our people with it. All because it was able to buy a plane ticket after he give it his login credentials.
- ziddoap 2y agoPerfect example of a fantasy put forth by an executive.
- bdangubic 2y agothese kind of comments on HN show me how many people lack creativity. wherever you work(ed) I am sure you met myriad of people and thought: - they don’t do shit - I can do what they do in my sleep it is these types of jobs that are being replaced and are easily replaceable with a little bit of creativity and imagination…
- ziddoap 2y agoThe parent comment asked (very specifically!) for real examples, not C-suite fantasies. They received a reply literally describing the fantasy of a c-suite individual. I thought that was funny. How my one sentence reply pointing out the irony of the reply led you to believe that I (we? lots of HNers?) lack creativity is beyond me.
- throwaway290 2y agoIf management knows that underperformers are underperformers in order to fire them in favor of LLMs then management could do it already in favor of better workers. You can basically string replace "replace underperforming humans" with "replace humans". That is their dream
- quickslowdown 2y agoI'm dealing with this as well. CEO basically soiled himself with excitement in a group chat, some toadies joined in, most were silent. Because how else can you receive that other than "think of all the money we'd have if we could get rid of those needy workers"
- robertlagrant 2y ago> If AI actually starts replacing jobs, society is going to collapse/restructure to the point that risk management no longer applies. Once more, with feeling: automation has continued to replace jobs. That's why you aren't currently toiling in a field to eke out a meagre subsistence living. If AI starts to replace jobs (a statement made true if a single job is replaced by AI) then likely the good or service that fronts that job will become slightly cheaper, or the same.
- UltraSane 2y agoWhat if AI can replace 100% of jobs that don't require manual labor?
- robertlagrant 2y agoI imagine we'll invent new jobs that we want humans to do. Why do people pay thousands for mechanical watches when quartz ones are objectively better?
- mrbungie 2y agoWhat I can't wrap my head around is the fact NVDA almost is a representation of "AI infrastructure" in the narrative. It is weird now that everyone is saying the focus is be in inference / test time scaling compute: inference should be easier to offload to chips from other manufacturers. Maybe I'm too dense to get it, but that doesn't make sense to me.
- somanyphotons 2y agoI think there is a money to be made in making huge slow inference chips It needs, * Does the very best model fit in ram * Does it eventually produce an answer I'm completely ok with waiting a few minutes for an inference answer if I can avoid spending $250k for an 8x
- mrbungie 2y agoMe too. Just as most problems won't need "phd-level intelligence" (whatever they might want you to think, 10x devs don't require phd skills nor research abilities / test time compute for being good at their job), most problems won't need subsecond latency or response time. I'm fine waiting, not sure if others really need the best now or ever.
- morsecodist 2y agoEven if the technology of AI ends up driving a huge economic value there is no guarantee that will translate into NVIDIA stock performance. The expectation that NVIDIA will capture a lot of this value is already priced in to the stock, which is a major reason why the current price is so high.
- panarky 2y agoA better hedge might be private prison corporations and private military contractors.
- jazzyjackson 2y agoFor prisons see GEO (up 100% since the election [0]) and CXW (Up 50% [1]) gov't contractors are in a bit of a bind given the treasury chaos (consider the current agenda to cut waste and inefficiencies) Looking around for private security I don't see anything publicly traded but I did learn there is an ETF named GUNZ [2] and one might check out the companies they invest in. [0] https://finance.yahoo.com/quote/GEO/ https://finance.yahoo.com/quote/GEO/ [1] https://finance.yahoo.com/quote/CXW/ https://finance.yahoo.com/quote/CXW/ [2] https://finance.yahoo.com/quote/GUNZ/ https://finance.yahoo.com/quote/GUNZ/
- UltraSane 2y agoAWS has a lot lower margins that most enterprise IT companies.
- lysace 2y agoNo.
- Drunkfoowl 2y ago[dead]
- lesuorac 2y agoThis seems like a fine decision by Amazon? If there is a ton of demand for shovels it seems fine to make more shovel factories?
- notyourwork 2y agoAgreed, investing in platform facilities and AWS capability seems like it cannot be a terrible idea.
- belter 2y agoThere is a redflag here. Their CapEx is growing faster than revenue. And there is no apparent direct correlation between AWS growth, percentage wise, and CapEx surge...Using CapEx makes profits look higher today...
- scarface_74 2y agoWhat’s the alternative? Not have the capacity when needed?
- UltraSane 2y agoIf this is a good decision or not all depends on what the ROI ends up being.
- dekhn 2y agoThey are paying an opportunity cost to have access to future growth.
- lesuorac 2y agoDid we read a different article? It seems like the claim is that it pays for itself in under 2 years. > For AI servers and the datacenters that wrap around them, as we have shown here, for every $1 you spend for an AI cluster and its datacenter (including its power and cooling), you get 87.8 cents back every year that you rent that AI cluster out to customers, assuming a reasonable mix of on-demand and reserved instance hours and a $9.40 per GPU-hour rate. In 410 days, you get your bait back on the entire AI datacenter investment if you rent all the GPUs out. The model we created (riffing on an Nvidia model) shows that for the three years after that, the 87.8 cents per year goes right into your pocket.
- eichi 2y agoIt's OK. The revenue is from incompetencies of engineers and enterprises that can not switch into siginificantly cheaper cloud vendors.
- scarface_74 2y agoWhere are these significant cheaper cloud vendors?
- eichi 2y agoOracle. I like bare-bone ARM VM and bare-bone volumes.
- lysace 2y agoGoing from the embrace of a semi-domesticated mostly aloof wolf to that of an understimulated psychotic tiger. Uh... Good luck?
- teitoklien 2y ago… Everywhere ? OVH, Hetzner, Cloudflare, Vultr, Linode, Scaleway, Equinix (ok Equinix this can be pricey at lower levels) A million other regional VPS providers, Colocation Hosts, etc ?
- scarface_74 2y agoYou really think that all people do with AWS is host a bunch of VMs and they manage all of the services (databases, storage, big data services, messaging apps) themselves? Drill down in each category https://docs.aws.amazon.com/whitepapers/latest/aws-overview/amazon-web-services-cloud-platform.html https://docs.aws.amazon.com/whitepapers/latest/aws-overview/...
- teitoklien 2y agoI’ve used most of those services and know well that outside of DynamoDB, EC2/Lightsail, S3, DataLakes (s3+athena) and AWS Lambda. Most of aws services have sub-par performance for insane prices, for components that can easily be replaced at scale with open source more mature components. Programmers have just lost all of their sysadmin skills these days and will use everything to justify the need for these insane , low performance abstraction abomination that Netifly, AWS RDS, AWS RedisCache, AWS TimeseriesDB, etc are. Whatsapp used to process billions of users and exited for a billion dollar+ valuation and exit, with just a few FreeBSD running VPSes running their code, and a 20 person employee team… Most people will never touch stuff in scale of whatsapp, stack overflow, instagram. and they did it all just fine. Programmers should be mandated to learn Linux and Sysadmin skills again instead of re-inventing entire bullshit services for what is essentially often systemd replacement or a crontab/fcron replacement.
- OutOfHere 2y agoAmazon requires employees to work five days a week from the office without paying them extra for it. Even if paid extra for it, it is not healthy considering the number of contagiously sick people at the office, risking a persistent inflammatory load on the body. I don't see good workers wanting to work for Amazon, and I don't see good outcomes ahead for Amazon. It will remain a non-innovating laggard that is trivially outcompeted. The only reason AWS even profits is because of its outrageous egress cost.
- scarface_74 2y agoAll of the BigTech companies are forcing RTO. Hybrid work is just as bad RTO. Either way I can’t make an above local market wage and live in a low cost of living area. Anytime any company reaches out to me and if I ask is it fully remote and they say “no” the conversation ends. I almost ended my initial conversation with AWS in 2020 when they reached out to me about an SDE position that would require an eventual relocation until they suggested I interview a ProServe (no longer there), I’ve since stopped conversations for a similar position at GCP once they said it would be hybrid. Not that I would ever work for a large company again unless I didn’t have a choice.
- OutOfHere 2y agoHybrid work is just as bad if you live well outside of a commuting distance. If you live within a commuting distance, it is somewhat acceptable if it's about two days a week with a decent salary. Good remote jobs are very difficult to get as they are very competitive, so hybrid jobs fill that void for those who can commute. 5x/wk RTO is nothing but a means of growth control and cheap layoffs.
- scarface_74 2y agoThat’s very true. When I was looking for my jobs in 2023 and again last year, it’s a shit show out there trying to find remote software development jobs if even all you are looking for are regularly old enterprise CRUD jobs. That was my “Plan B” both times. I was lucky that even before COVID around 2017 my goal was to work in strategic cloud consulting focusing on app development (ie not staff aug) because that was the only way I could see making above local market wages without having to commute and even back then most of those jobs were remote with travel. But then again, if you don’t have to worry about moving somewhere with a “good school system” because you have kids, why not move somewhere closer to the job?
- eichi 2y agoSpoil from incompetents is the good strategy and all too much nerd engineers should follow the strategy.
- scarface_74 2y agoI left AWS Professional Services in 2023. Being in ProServe, I interacted with a lot of different service teams (teams that work on various AWS services) and I got a first hand view of their messaging and strategy. Internally, Amazon/AWS has always been a shitty company for employees. But they always were somewhat innovative and long term focused. I saw things going down hill by the end of 2022. They are definitely a “Day 2” company now and not out in front of trends As if the original RTO policies weren’t bad enough for instance, now they are forcing their “field by design” workers to be in the office 5 days a week when they aren’t at a customers site. These are the consultants (full time employees), sales, SAs etc who spend most of their time interacting with the customer and where you rarely have your internal teammates in your same office. Before anyone asked why I worked there if I knew it was shitty. I worked remotely the entire time, it looked great on my resume and I like money. It definitely opened some doors
- late2part 2y agoWere you one of the many overemployed people that also worked at AWS?
- scarface_74 2y agoI am 50. I have always had a strict policy of never doing two jobs or a “side hustle”. Whatever we can’t do from my working one job, we don’t do. That means no open source work worrying about my GitHub profile, no BS “thought leadership” posts on LinkedIn. Nothing. When I get off of work, I shut my computer down and live my life - exercising, travel, spending time with friends and family, etc.
- Temporary_31337 2y agoImagine if Amazon acted the same way- oh we already have 1 customer, we won’t bother with the next 6 billion because we have one shittty one already.
- scarface_74 2y ago
- mparnisari 2y agoDoes this mean that I will be able to use my Echo Dot for something other than asking what the weather is?
- rbanffy 2y agoMy daughter routinely asks hers to tell jokes.
- DanielHB 2y agoReally looking forward what all that GPU compute is going to do for non AI stuff once it quiets down a little.
- rbanffy 2y agoWith that much power, we’ll be able to reliably predict a hundred thousand years into the future of our societies and shorten the period of barbarism after the fall of the galactic empire.
- DanielHB 2y agoI was wondering all the crappy simulation software used in engineering that is still CPU-bound.
- kirubakaran 2y agoTo everyone going for the shovel metaphor: Samuel Brannan cornered the entire shovel supply of San Francisco before running down the street shouting "Gold! Gold on the American River!". He'd have gone broke if he had just done a big capex to offer Shovels as a Service. He still died without enough money to pay for his own funeral. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Samuel_Brannan https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Samuel_Brannan