6 ms·
> USA is a place where you can go from $100k to $100m vesting if you are lucky. That very few do achieve this isn't the point: you cannot do it, in almost any o
by amelius 2y ago
> USA is a place where you can go from $100k to $100m vesting if you are lucky. That very few do achieve this isn't the point: you cannot do it, in almost any other economy.
That's a kind of lottery-mentality that Europe doesn't want to attract anyway.
- qwe----3 2y agoYeah, in Germany the rich stay rich.
- tremon 2y agoWhereas in the US the rich get richer? Or the poor stay poor? What's your point?
- fsckboy 2y ago>That's a kind of lottery-mentality that Europe doesn't want to attract anyway. the problem with the European thinking you describe is not lottery vs sure-thing, it's the idea that everybody within a geography should should think the same way and not all mentalities "belong".
- Juliate 2y agoNot at all. It’s that we experienced several times, first-hand, that some mentalities and mindsets systematically drive our societies to discord, war and death. And to those mentalities… yes we ought to remind they’re not welcome.
- fsckboy 2y ago>And to those mentalities… yes we ought to remind they’re not welcome. gee, no matter how many times Europe has told the Jews that they are not welcome, they've kept coming back, bringing ses penchants for assessing capital risk in middleman trade, and hedging financial risks!
- Juliate 2y agoYour comment, and you for it, is despicable.
- ggm 2y agoI tend to agree, but having met some of the people who pursued this dream, they are very very inventive. They're smart. If that energy chasing a dream could be redirected, they'd be doing amazing things. Mostly, they wind up realizing that the goal is illusive, and re-pivot to a saner outcome but by that time they are fully vested in "america" as a plan. The bounty here, is the people on the cusp of realizing its not going to pan out but who are both very smart, and smart enough to realize they need to pivot. It would be almost a given they are consciously walking away from IPO manna. I guess if you include it in the pre-sort on applicants, you get to winnow out the people still glued to money-is-the-prize. BTW the EU would welcome more IPR inside the EU. Some amount of bonus may have to lie in the packaging, to get to where the EU wants to be on IPR. Novo Nordisk style.
- scarab92 2y ago> That's a kind of lottery-mentality that Europe doesn't want to attract anyway. Except that it’s the opposite of a lottery. It’s almost entirely based on your skills and the decisions you make. There are right-place right-time effects, but it’s still your decision to be in the right place for the current time. Europe’s economy is badly lagging the US economy, and it’s because culturally they hold these types of incorrect, fatalistic, zero-sum views towards success and innovation.
- TheOtherHobbes 2y agoIt's almost entirely based on your skills, the decisions you make, and your privileged background. You're just not going to get past the first few rounds of the entrepreneur game if you're not a certain kind of person. The US has terrible social mobility. Objectively, by any measure. This isn't up for debate. Guess which state is #1 for social mobility? Wrong. It's Utah, which is a low bar because it's 28th by GDP. How about CA? 38th for mobility. TX? 45th. It's a mythology of meritocracy excusing inherited privilege. https://www.archbridgeinstitute.org/social-mobility-in-the-50-states/ https://www.archbridgeinstitute.org/social-mobility-in-the-5...
- scarab92 2y agoThis is nonsense. The US is full of billionaires who came from underprivileged positions. Infact, your advice is worse than wrong, it is actively harmful, because you're discouraging people from trying by (falsely) telling them that their efforts don't matter and they were destined to fail from birth.
- robocat 2y agoAnd need to compare with countries outside the US. It's misleading to try and talk about differences between states.
- zdragnar 2y agoYou don't even need to look for the count of billionaires. My grandparents were poor-as-dirt farmers. My dad's education stopped at high school. He even went to a one-room schoolhouse until he was 14. My brother and I are both college educated and, while not "rich", have a lifestyle and income my grandparents could have only dreamed about. It is truly painful to watch people preach learned helplessness through failure and destitution as the only possible outcome.
- kortilla 2y agoThat’s not lottery mentality and thinking that it’s equivalent is why Europe isn’t innovating. If someone wins the lottery and gets rich, society isn’t better off. If someone starts a new company that made a cure for some disease and gets rich, society is much better off. You absolutely want to attract people that want to make huge breakthroughs with unlikely odds of success.
- 77pt77 2y ago> If someone starts a new company that made a cure for some disease and gets rich, society is much better off. The reality is that you get crap like Facebook, Instagram, Xwitter.
- baq 2y agoYou get both, Facebook’s job is to be known about, so you know about it. There’s a ton of companies doing drug research basically silently… in the US. Most fail, it doesn’t matter as long as a few succeed.
- cycomanic 2y agoIt's worth pointing out that the biggest innovations (both scientifically, but likely also monetary) in the biomedical field in the last years happened in Europe not the US. So that seems to disprove the point that innovation happens in the US because of the chance of going from 100k to 100M.
- 77pt77 2y agoPlease tell me what those pharmaceutical companies with a similar maker cap to Facebook Are.
- BrenBarn 2y ago> You absolutely want to attract people that want to make huge breakthroughs with unlikely odds of success. It's fine to want that and to attract those kind of people. What you don't want is to attract people who want to do that in order to make a lot of money.
- robocat 2y ago> That's a kind of lottery-mentality You're the one incorrectly using the concept of gambling replying talking to someone taking about risk versus reward (investing). It is hard for somebody who believes in gambling to win at investing. The US has both monetary and social incentives to create new businesses. I live in NZ where founders are discouraged by financial incentives and by social incentives.
- garte 2y agoThat's an interesting distinction you're making. Gambling and investing are very close together. You're only able to make rational decisions on perfect information which is not available. So investing seems to be a sort of gambling to me, it's just part of a different societal institution.
- matwood 2y ago> That's a kind of lottery-mentality that Europe doesn't want to attract anyway. It’s not lottery mentality, it’s risk taking. And it’s something that the EU should be fostering. The US encourages risk taking where failing isn’t even seen as a bad thing.
- jampekka 2y agoEnding up homeless for failing is probably not the risk taking encouragement Europeans want. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31524645 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31524645
- ykonstant 2y agoThat is the thing though: with the increased safety nets of the richer European countries, you would think that taking risks would both be more encouraged and naturally less dangerous than the US. And I am a big proponent of said safety nets. But we don't see this "moderate-risk-taking" mentality in the EU... ...or don't we? I am not sure. We are definitely not seeing the runaway successes of US big tech, but is it because people are not taking measured risks, or do operations fumble at a later point in their development? I don't know. What I do know is that revenue sources in the EU come with extremely onerous strings attached, are orders of magnitude below US levels, or are only available to big corporations of the old guard.
- jampekka 2y agoI'm not so sure there even is so much less risk-taking in Europe than in US. There are many structural reasons why Europe doesn't produce gigagrowth oligopolies like the US. EU has a highly fractured internal market that is more difficult to dominate, EU is not bathing in reserve currency windfalls to be thrown all around and EU doesn't have as ruthless foreign/trading policies. Also there's a difference how "risk taking" is portrayed in the public discourse. In US success of companies are seen more as result of risk-taking of individuals, whereas in Europe success its seen more as resulting from collective effort, and founders/CEOs of successful companies are not lauded as heros, or are even usually especially famous.