4 ms·
Notes on Argentina
- blackeyeblitzar 2y ago> The structural changes are painful but necessary. One thing that is amazing, is how quickly Milei was able to make these changes. I’m guessing Argentinian law allows the president a lot of power to make changes quickly. By comparison, efforts to make the government more efficient in America will probably fail because they will be bogged down in lawsuits and obstruction.
- andsoitis 2y ago> how quickly Milei was able to make these changes. Milei's speech at Davos 2025: https://www.weforum.org/stories/2025/01/davos-2025-special-address-javier-milei-president-argentina/ https://www.weforum.org/stories/2025/01/davos-2025-special-a...
- g8oz 2y agoInteresting speech. He certainly seems to worked up over various culture war topics.
- EA-3167 2y agoThe same powers that allow Milei to make rapid changes are the ones that allowed decades of his predecessors to run the country into the ground.
- igsomething 2y agoSurprisingly, no. Milei's party does not have majority in the Congress, he does not have much power, and the best example is his omnibus bill [1]. Initially Milei's party attempted to pass a massive 300-page reform, consisting primarily of deregulations and paving the road for a more free-market government model. The reform was debated for almost 6 months, and the accepted version was about a 3rd of the original one. The president has power to make only small changes in Argentina, but the previous system was so flawled that any minor change resulted in noticeable changes to the general economy. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Law_of_Bases_and_Starting_Points_for_the_Freedom_of_Argentines https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Law_of_Bases_and_Starting_Poin...
- darthrupert 2y agoAmazing news. This is bound to cause painful cognitive dissonance on those who hate to see free market capitalism working.
- codechicago277 2y agoThat’s oversimplifying a complex issue, some of his policies will work and some will fail, and that fact says nothing about underlying ideologies that drive his behavior.
- slothtrop 2y agoAll of the improvements are being hand-waved away by those desperate to see Milei fail, because success would jeopardize their worldview. It's not to see it's smooth sailing, but I'm optimistic based varied sources.
- wslh 2y agoThere's a saying in Argentina: “Nothing changes in years, but everything changes in a day” It’s still too early to make definitive statements about Milei’s government. However, for those unfamiliar with Argentina, it’s worth noting some key realities under this so-called "libertarian" administration: the USD/ARS exchange rate remains controlled, a nominee presented by Milei to the Supreme Court is widely regarded as a highly corrupt judge (in the Gotham City way), and similar contradictions abound [0]. Milei is undoubtedly a skilled influencer. On a more practical note, consider this: if your software company needed a few laptops or notebooks to operate, you were previously limited to importing them by courier with a cap of USD 1,000, which was only recently increased to USD 3,000 a few months ago. This is one Apple powerful notebook, including taxes. When it comes to managing inflation, certain strategies or "tricks" are often employed: inducing a recession, withholding increases in retirement benefits, and encouraging carry-trade practices [1]. In this binary world it is important to highlight that the previous governments were terrible. [0] https://www.cato.org/blog/mileis-key-pending-task-ending-argentinas-currency-controls-part-ii https://www.cato.org/blog/mileis-key-pending-task-ending-arg... [1] https://www.investopedia.com/terms/c/currencycarrytrade.asp https://www.investopedia.com/terms/c/currencycarrytrade.asp
- augusto-moura 2y agoInteresting that we have the same saying in Brazil. Latin America countries are very similar indeed
- wslh 2y agoYes, there are similarities among Latin American countries. However, beyond the shared saying, Argentina's trajectory has been notably different, especially when compared to Brazil [1]. It’s important to emphasize that Brazil has developed robust industries, while Argentina has not achieved that level. Argentine industries have historically been prebendaries, relying heavily on state support, subsidies, and protectionist policies (e.g. corruption) rather than fostering competitiveness or innovation. This dependency created a system where industries benefited from privileges granted by the government, often at the expense of broader economic efficiency and sustainability. [1] https://datacommons.org/tools/visualization#visType%3Dtimeline%26place%3Dcountry%2FARG___country%2FBRA%26placeType%3DAdministrativeArea1%26sv%3D%7B%22dcid%22%3A%22Amount_EconomicActivity_GrossDomesticProduction_Nominal%22%7D https://datacommons.org/tools/visualization#visType%3Dtimeli...
- thrance 2y agoInflation is down and the economy is doing better, but what's the point when poverty rates just skyrocketed to over 50% of the population [1]? Will it "trickle down", like it never did anywhere? Moreover, cutting public services as aggressively as Milei did is bound to hurt the economy in the long term, with less access to education, healthcare, worsening public transit... All things companies rely on the state to provide their employees. If you need proof of the dangers of austerity, take a look at the UK. They reduced spending, but are they really better off? [1] https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/ceqn751x19no https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/ceqn751x19no
- Empact 2y agoSeveral sources report more recent data showing a drop to 37-39%. The picture in Argentina was not rosy before Milei took office, it was a country on the verge of hyperinflationary collapse. Given that starting position, IMO it’s remarkable how quickly things have turned around. https://www.batimes.com.ar/news/argentina/expert-reports-say-argentinas-poverty-rate-has-fallen-to-368.phtml https://www.batimes.com.ar/news/argentina/expert-reports-say... https://x.com/marionawfal/status/1870100943418630363?s=46 https://x.com/marionawfal/status/1870100943418630363?s=46
- thrance 2y agoMy numbers are from December, did we really see a drop of 15% in a month? One of us has to be wrong, and I don't see many sources claiming your numbers, the X one you gave is clearly partisan, opening with "MILEI DELIVERS".
- Empact 2y agoThe article you cite is from September 2024. Where are you getting December?
- marcosdumay 2y agoThe poverty rate above 50% of the population is something that happens when a country goes over several corrupt governments that steal everything the people have and put it in the hands of a handful of people that are always prepared to flee. All those people failing to notice Argentina was poor before Milei got the presidency either have no idea what they are talking about or are malicious. Now, yes, about worsening public services; Milei did the basic thing so the country can actually do something, the real test for his government is how he fixes those problems. (From the shit he talks, I would be in he not fixing anything, but if he actually acted like he talks he wouldn't have got inflation under control and would probably be already out of the presidency by now.)
- quijoteuniv 2y agoI really really struggle to understand how anyone can have a rational justification of that guy.
- boxed 2y agoIt's all about what the alternative is. And the alternative is very bad. I'm not saying this is a good rationalization, but it is a fairly rational one, as those things go.
- quijoteuniv 2y agoTell me about the alternatives
- selectodude 2y ago75 years of Peronism?
- quijoteuniv 2y agoOk. What was bad with Peron himself? and what was the alternative there? Then, Are you saying that the various military dictatorships, Alfonsin, Menem, De la Rua and Macri were Peronist? What is your evaluation of their economic results?
- selectodude 2y agoArgentina was one of the wealthiest countries in the world with a massive amount of fertile land and natural resources yet somehow is now poorer than Chile and Uruguay.
- rbanffy 2y agoI would love to understand what effect the military dictatorships had in the economy.
- tptacek 2y agoAm I crazy, or does this read like a litany of ways in which residents are worse-off after Milei's victory, concluding with "it looks like they're on a strong path to recovery"?
- slekker 2y agoHe did say it would get worse before it got better
- antics 2y agoI’d love to hear what people are reading to actually understand this. At this point I will openly admit that I do not know if what’s happening in Argentina is good or even on purpose. I sense that everything I read is at best motivated reasoning and at worst propaganda, and I’m not skilled enough to determine what is correct and what is not.
- Empact 2y agoYou have to consider why Milei was elected in the first place - a dramatic break from typical Peronist politics with a historic 55% of the vote. The picture in Argentina was not rosy before Milei took office, it was a country on the verge of hyperinflationary collapse, with a population declining through emigration, a largely informal economy in decline, and people struggling to keep up with dramatic inflation. I don’t know of another case where hyperinflation was arrested without introducing a new currency. Milei has apparently done it by simply cutting spending, which naturally comes with some pain as the subsidies and government employment are curtailed, but a sound currency sets the stage for distributed investment, lending, entrepreneurship and growth. More recent policy changes have focused on opening up the country to exports and imports, which will be key to bringing about prosperity through growth in industry, and bringing prices into line with international norms. https://www.msn.com/en-us/politics/government/javier-milei-deregulates-food-imports-and-exports/ar-AA1xAZA5 https://www.msn.com/en-us/politics/government/javier-milei-d...
- Geee 2y agoI was just reading about the Chinese economic reform[0], which started in 1978. That was basically the end of communism in China, and the start of market liberalization. The point here is that when economic policies are reformed, it obviously doesn't turn the country wealthy instantly, which is what some of Milei's critics tend to assume. Due to these reforms Chinese economy had an impressive growth rate of 9.5% from 1978 to 2013, but they didn't solve poverty instantly. China's poverty rate fell from 88 percent in 1981 to 0.7 percent in 2015 [1]. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chinese_economic_reform https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chinese_economic_reform [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poverty_in_China https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poverty_in_China
- magicfractal 2y agoYeah, seems like everything is much worse off but somehow a higher dose of neoliberalism will definitely fix things, just give it more time
- Jotalea 2y agoI love Argentina.