8 ms·
Why Northern England is poor
- nickff 2y agoInteresting perspective, but it really seems like state capitals just tend to siphon money from far away to invest nearby, and consequently, grow. Selecting a major city as your capital seems to accelerate the process, but even countries which select minor towns as their capitals have had this happen.
- James_K 2y agoThe process is quite simple and fairly obvious. Government policy is the bedrock of all economic development. Government officials will always have the most knowledge about the capital, so all policy is tailored to it. It's no surprise that they don't make policies that benefit the North given that they don't live there.
- casenmgreen 2y agoBerlin is not like this, though. If Berlin were removed from the map, Germany as a whole would economically (loss of people, loss of income) be on average better off. If this is the mechanism, why is Berlin not doing better?
- taffer 2y agoGermany is the only Western European country with an Eastern European capital. As a result, Berlin was poorer than the rest of the country, but this is no longer the case. Since reunification, Berlin has had the fastest growing economy in Germany and is now close to Hesse in terms of GDP per capita.
- wink 2y agoBerlin is odd... for several factors. Just looking at the last 100 years, I fail to see any capital (that was not directly a war zone) be: not capital, capital, divided, part of 2 countries, an exclave...
- bryanrasmussen 2y agohow many generations from a city becoming the political center does it take for the effect to be noticeable?
- matt-p 2y agoWhat policy would benefit the north, without (even further) subsidising it? If we could invest £10Bn and get £20Bn back for the economy with our money back over time then not a single politician would turn that down, there's actually been a load of support over the past ~5+ years for "levelling up" (AKA investment in the north) but we've not invested much because the returns are abysmal. Meanwhile there's a whole stack of projects with good returns in london, but politically it's really difficult to "give more money to london" so we don't really do them. Bakerloo line extension and crossrail 2 for example. The Elizabeth line, will over time pay for itself entirely with fares alone, yet has also already added ~£2.50 to the economy for every £1 spent. This is a absolutely classic example of chicken and egg, network effects and first mover advantage. There's perhaps a case for being absolutely ruthless and just spending an obscene amount of money on Manchester/Leeds/Liverpool. What might it look like? -No third runway for heathrow, instead BHX gets 2 more runways (or MAN 1 more) and all the funding it needs to become an international hub, including an reduction in APD for 5 years or something. Central London in ~48Mins via HS2 is already committed and being built, frankly that's not that much different to what it practically takes to get from a random heathrow terminal to central. -HS2 to Manchester AND Leeds (via the branch just above BHX), that would connect BHX to those cities in <30 Mins or so and to London much quicker. -Trams for Leeds, maybe a metro for Manchester. -Liverpool>Manchester>Leeds express line (which seems committed). -Enterprise zone covering all underdeveloped commercial areas in Leeds, Liverpool, Manchester and Birmingham. Give rates, or tax relief on businesses investing, or employing in the zone, planning exemptions, easier permitting. Anything short of an absolutely insane bet like this, just isn't going to work. Chucking 1Bn to Leeds for them to buy some trams just isn't going to have a transformative effect, it might actually be a total waste because, in short, network effects. The North of England frequently runs a combined fiscal deficit in the tens of billions, with all of that subsidy coming, effectively, from London and the SE.
- James_K 2y agoThe reason for investing in the North is pretty simple: people live there. We have three options: do something productive with he area, do nothing and continue to pay for its decline, or move all the people to London and let house prices rise accordingly. What you said about first mover advantage rings true here. We can either pick the most developed city and devote resources elusively that area, or we can accept a proportionally smaller economy spread out across the whole country. I also fail to see how London is subsidising these areas. It seems to me that they'd be much better off if they were able to run themselves. This is a classic case of purposeful under-investment. You see it in business as well. If someone wants to kill off a given project, they'll deprive it of funding to he point it can't operate properly then use the lack of profit generated as an excuse to axe it. The issue we have is that we can't just axe the North. There is also the issue of measuring productivity. You say investments in London are more productive because they generate more profit, but consider that an equal investment in the North might have a much greater effect on the quality of life for the people living there. Should we measure investments by how much money they return or how much they improve people's lives? I am reminded of industrial strategy in the Soviet Union. They invested only in the most "productive" (highest ROI under capitalism) things such as heavy industry and very little in consumer technologies that make people happier. The result was rapid industrialisation which probably had the best effect in the long run. The question is how long term are we thinking? At some point, you've gotta start paying to make people happy instead of just investing in the most profitable area.
- renewiltord 2y agoNeither Albany, NY not Sacramento, CA feel like the centers of their states.
- marssaxman 2y agoHaving spent my teen years in backwater Sacramento, I can confirm that it did not feel much like the center of anything. Adding a few more examples to your list, neither Olympia (WA), Salem (OR), nor Carson City (NV) are economic or social centers of their respective states.
- LexGray 2y agoThis may stumble on a solution to the problem. London combines government and financial centers. Axe parliament and 10 Downing Street and rebuild government infrastructure from scratch in some inland port where it can drag influence north. Sacramento may not be exciting, but it is self-sustaining with fairly high property costs and a huge commuter population. I think one of the things that makes California successful is the government is in a boring city with few distractions.
- gumperbumper 2y agoLike the U.S. and D.C.? NY and Albany? Canada and Ottawa? Germany and Berlin?
- nine_k 2y agoThe US somehow avoids this, likely by putting state capitals and the national capital into smaller cities. Hence NYC, SF, Chicago, Dallas, Miami, Seattle, etc are all big urban agglomerations, but are not the points that concentrate everything important in their respective areas.
- Kon-Peki 2y agoThose cities aren’t really good examples of intentionally putting a state capital in a smaller city of the state. Albany is older than NYC, and anyway the concept of NYC as a single large city is barely 125 years old. The original capital of Illinois is (strangely) west of the Mississippi River and south of St. Louis. By treaty between Great Britain and France, the current area of Illinois was off limits to European settlement, until after the revolution when the US said “that treaty doesn’t apply to us”. Chicago wasn’t a big or important city until the civil war. Los Angeles has been the wealthiest and most populous area in Alta California since like 1800 or so. But it was established as a puebla and not a mission, so it could never be a center of government under Spanish rule. Miami was fairly unlivable until air conditioning and malaria control, and its geographic location was extraordinarily inconvenient until after the interstate system. The US government established a customs house in Olympia when it and Seattle were little more than a handful of homesteads. And guessed wrong on which would grow faster.
- donavanm 2y agomore random support for your critique of a post-hoc, and historically ignorant, classification of "small cities". Offhand the CA capital contest was ongoing one and tracked from south/central CA towards the north in the mid 1800s. It's entirely unsurprising that they landed in the Sacramento courthouse; it was ~1850 and Sacramento was 1) last inland port for shipping 2) major terminus for the gold fields 3) an obvious rail hub for the connectivity in the 1850-60s, esp bay area to Sacramento and the east. Even a trivial look at the (flawed) 1850 census shows that basically all of the (mostly new) immigrant population was in Sacramento and the goldfields. eg Los Angeles was 3,500 people compared to 9,000 in Sacramento. Similar for the Washington Territory which was barely a collection of homesteads and tiny villages. IIRC Olympia was the first significant immigrant settlement in the northern Oregon Territory, the major (only?) early trade connection to shipping on the pacific, and connected to the few other settlers moving north in to the territory. Its not very surprising that it was the territorial capitol and remained so for the state. Yes, post statehood a lot of rail & shipping traffic moved north. But at least through the turn of the 20th century both Tacoma and Seattle were roughly equivalent in population and industry. Arguably the easier ship access for the Klondike is what cemented the prosperity of Seattle pre-war, and Boeing & related defence activity post war. But _at the time of territory & statehood_ Olympia was the major town in the region.
- WorkerBee28474 2y agoI think there's truth to that, it seems like every state has 1 major city. Possibly not always the capital (e.g. Toronto vs Ottawa, Albany vs NYC vs DC). I've heard that the book Cities and the Wealth of Nations [0] might talk about this more. I've been meaning to read it. [0] https://www.astralcodexten.com/p/your-book-review-cities-and-the-wealth https://www.astralcodexten.com/p/your-book-review-cities-and...
- jltsiren 2y agoIt mostly depends on stable borders and a culture of centralization. Some US states such California and Texas have multiple major cities. Germany and the surrounding areas were historically fragmented, leading to many regions having multiple mid-tier cities instead of a single dominant city.
- tetris11 2y agoWe also shifted largely into a service based economy, shutdown a lot of mines and mills (for better or for worse) which were primarily more north based. More than 2/3rds of my graduating physics class went straight into banking, as there was no relevant industry to pick them up... and as someone with several postdoctoral degrees, yet no house or meaningful assets... who could blame them for going into banking in this large miserable sprawl of a city utterly devoted to it?
- graemep 2y agoMost developed economies have shifted to services. Its a natural progression that results from higher productivity and higher wages. I think the big problem is too much reliance on on service sector.
- asplake 2y agoA natural progression and not necessarily a bad thing, but it makes further productivity growth more difficult.
- EarlKing 2y agoIt's a consequence of companies outsourcing to countries where they can get away with slave labor and a complete lack of environmental regulation. There's nothing natural about it.
- Cumpiler69 2y agoIt's basically a modern form of economic colonialism replacing the old style of colonialism with ships, guns and slaves in chains. The brutal hard work gets done off-shore for poor pay and the spoils(profits) get shipped to the western finance capitals of the world where people who put in little effort get the cream. It's still dependent on rich countries having historical leverage (economic, political and especially military) over the poor countries where the dirty manufacturing and hard labor happens, rather than based on any meritocracy.
- 2y ago
- okeuro49 2y ago[flagged]
- JBits 2y agoThere is less immigration to North England.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- selimthegrim 2y agoAnd Nazir Afzal their prosecutor belonged to which ethnic group again?
- thereticent 2y agoFrom a long-time HN user: please provide a high quality source when making claims connected to a people group. This place works better when we avoid culture wars and demographic-based blame.
- okeuro49 2y agohttps://www.thefp.com/p/muslim-grooming-gangs-cover-up-keir-starmer-elon-musk https://www.thefp.com/p/muslim-grooming-gangs-cover-up-keir-...
- hackandthink 2y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hit_the_North https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hit_the_North Always thought that Mark E. Smith would sing about it. I must have been wrong according to Wikipedia.
- l3w3 2y agoYou read my mind: https://youtu.be/_ViEzjcc6sE https://youtu.be/_ViEzjcc6sE
- HarHarVeryFunny 2y agoLot's of coal mining, used for steel production, used for boat building ... The high paying jobs are centered around London and the financial industry (20% of UK GDP), although post-Brexit the whole country is not doing well. Glad I left in the late 80's.
- tonyedgecombe 2y ago>Lot's of coal mining Coal mining used to employee over a million people[1] at the start of the last century. It's effectively zero now. [1] https://www.statista.com/statistics/371069/employment-in-coal-mining-industry-in-the-united-kingdom-uk/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/371069/employment-in-coa...
- HarHarVeryFunny 2y agoIt was still big up until the 70's at least - I remember the huge Miner's Galas in Durhan, attended by people like Harold Wilson, Tony Benn and Arthur Scargill. There are still lot's of former miner villages in the area that don't look like they've changed much. Maybe my comments on steel & ship building are equally dated(?), but I think it was coal driving these related industries that got the north entrenched as a poorer working class part of the country. Of course there is also the fishing industry and sheep farming due to poor quality land, again all low paying jobs. One of the best predictors of individual financial success is the wealth of your parents, and I wonder how many generations this effect lasts for ...
- skrebbel 2y ago> Limited success such as in Manchester, whose economy has nearly kept up with East German cities while the rest of North England falls behind, Woa is this a typo? I know little about England, and I hadn't realized that "keeping up with East German cities" is considered a success. I mean isn't East Germany rather well known for not keeping up all that well with the rest of Germany either?
- McDutchie 2y agoYes. I think the author's point is that the standards are that low up here in North England, and outside of Manchester it's worse than in East Germany.
- graemep 2y agoI think that means growth rates, not absolute wealth. Not all of the north is poor. Cheshire is richer than outer London or the home counties. If you adjust for the cost of living more of the north would be. North poor, south rich is very simplistic. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_regions_of_the_United_Kingdom_by_GRP_per_capita https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_regions_of_the_Unite...
- dambi0 2y agoI think it's a bit more subtle than that. For one the author tells us they think this is an example of success story. Although I guess it depends on when you are measuring from, and they may be being somewhat tongue in cheek with their choice of East Germany I think the point is that we would expect East German cities to have reasonable relative growth post-unification because we are taking a relatively structurally deprived area within a wider more successful economy. That Manchester has kept up with areas where you'd expect to see reasonable growth, is positive. I suppose there's also the hint that this suggests that this has been allowed to happen by central government, but I could be making that up.
- thomasforth 2y agoNot a typo I'm afraid. East Germany's economy overtook North England's economy in 2010. Excluding Berlin, East Germany's economy overtook North England's economy in 2013. Every East German large city (Berlin, Dresden, Leipzig, Halle, Chemnitz) is today a stronger economy than every North English large city except Manchester. Manchester is still a weaker economy than Berlin, Dresden, and Leipzig. All the data is from the OECD using comparable definitions of the cities and collecting at https://tomforth.co.uk/humancapital/ https://tomforth.co.uk/humancapital/
- vixen99 2y agoAlthough not quite in the sense intended by the author, point 9 as of January 2025, is only too true. "Why Britain can't afford to carry on as it is."
- dboreham 2y agoSaw the headline and thought "well, it won't give the real reason: because London". But refreshingly, it does.
- tonyedgecombe 2y agoDutch disease sums it up. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dutch_disease https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dutch_disease
- lispforlife 2y ago[dead]
- guerrilla 2y agoI'm sure Wales, Ireland and Scotland could have told you much the same just speculating off the top of their heads. England has always been a colonial project in one form or another, from day one. In fact a lot of it is common knowledge at least among the online left. One difference though: I think he under-emphasizes the shutting down of the coal mines; or at least others have historically emphasizes that more.
- sjclemmy 2y agoI have never heard it referred to as North England. Northern England or the North of England yes. As a reluctant “northerner” it dunt sarnd reet.
- shellac 2y agoYes, a minor thing but concur that it is definitely peculiar.
- dang 2y agoOk, we've erned it in the title above. Thanks!
- AnimalMuppet 2y ago"Erned it". Dang, you don't usually make me LOL, but you got me there.
- thomasforth 2y agoI agree it sounds odd. It's a phrase I've moved to using after fifteen years of being shouted at for using other phrases. North England, while sounding a bit odd, generates much fewer rage replies than other formulations. There's also a slight preference on my part for shorter phrases because of social media.
- jdietrich 2y agoI think there's a fundamental gap in this analysis, which is how hyper-local many of the inequalities are. Manchester has a GDP per capita of £59,000. Tameside, the poorest area in Greater Manchester, has a GDP per capita of £19,000. Leeds has a GDP per capita of £42k; ten miles away, Bradford has a GDP per capita of £23.6k. Those disparities are really difficult to explain in terms of infrastructure or commercial investment. Similar disparities exist within London, although for plausibly different reasons; compare Lewisham with the neighbouring Southwark, Camden with Haringey, or that one bit of Tower Hamlets with the rest of Tower Hamlets. I think we need to be looking much more granularly at the gaps between neighbouring areas, schools and families - the human capital factors that trap people in lives of poverty. Building a university or innovation hub in Knowsley probably won't do much for the huge numbers of kids there who leave school unable to read and write. https://www.ons.gov.uk/economy/grossdomesticproductgdp/bulletins/regionaleconomicactivitybygrossdomesticproductuk/latest https://www.ons.gov.uk/economy/grossdomesticproductgdp/bulle...
- matt-p 2y agoTo a certain extent, would making the productive parts of manchester, even just 2X more productive not fix this over time in the same way that it has in London? If you look back even say 30 years ago in London, you'd of said the same thing about places like Hackney, as you do now about Tameside. Today it houses some of the most desired and valuable real estate not only in London, and by extension the UK, but in the world.
- Retric 2y agoSimply displacing a population can make an area more wealthy but it does little for the overall population. So, I don’t think we care about land here but rather people.
- threatofrain 2y ago> but it does little for the overall population. Not sure about that.
- tomcam 2y ago[flagged]
- matt-p 2y agoPlenty of criticisms of mass immigration, but it can hardly be blamed for this, that's insane.
- butterknife 2y agoWhistling here or do you actually mean the overwhelmingly higher proportion of immigrants in South East compared to North?
- walthamstow 2y agoThe brain drain from northern England to London is massive. There are four high income tech/finance/media households on my culdesac in east London, thankfully including my own. Of the eight adults, I am from London but the other seven are from the midlands or north of England.
- drunkensailors 2y agoOT: but it seem that something in time'd change: (reads) https://www.thevintagenews.com/2020/07/01/london-beer-flood/ https://www.thevintagenews.com/2020/07/01/london-beer-flood/ ...and now a "barrel" has more than a thousand hectolitres...? hint: read //en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bloomsbury
- spacebanana7 2y agoThe very success of Northern England in the nineteenth century may have also precipitated a great deal of its subsequent failures. The rail, coal and manufacturing industries crowded out other forms of enterprise economically. The related union / capitalist disputes crowded out other political activity. Similarly the great agricultural “successes” of the Scottish Highlands in the 17th & 18th century crowded out everything else, leaving it something of a backwater ever since. Perhaps something similar will happen to London when the time of finance comes to an end? Then finally the South West will take its turn being the heart of the British economy.
- devnullbrain 2y agoWe'll have the same thing for the whole country when the time of housing investment comes to an end. Why start a business when you could just buy another house?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- retrac98 2y agoSort of an aside from the article, but I never feel like these geographic averages translate well to densely populated countries like England. The North, like all parts of the country, has pockets of extreme affluence near areas of relative poverty, with a lot of middle income households scattered about the place too. Talking to some southerners you’d think the whole of the North was a dump, and I worry people write off a truly beautiful part of the UK because of this misconception.
- CapeTheory 2y agoAny article which seeks to explore the problems of northern England and doesn't mention the weather is fundamentally incomplete. I've lived in every part of England, but being in the north west for the last decade has highlighted how much our mental health can be damaged by constant grey skies and rain. A population predisposed to feeling hopeless naturally leads to a less vibrant economy.
- tom_ 2y agoThe diagram of the northern "urban" centre also fails to point out the Peak District, though you can detect it by noticing what looks like an obvious gap in the middle of the circle. In the middle of the London circle is, of course, the centre of London, world-famous capital city of the United Kingdom, seat of power of its government and monarchy. In the middle of the Northern circle? Some mountains and the occasional picturesque little village... (The weather might also be a factor here too. The elevated regions are much colder, snowier and windier, causing problems with transport. Getting between Sheffield and Manchester at this time of year can be a painful business.)
- thomasforth 2y agoIn my comparisons with the Netherlands I explore this in detail. The centre of the Netherlands' main urban region is a six metre below sea level swamp that the Dutch never have and never will build on and which is just as much of an obstacle to agglomeration as the Pennines. So I really don't think this matters. As for the weather, Ireland, Scotland, Belgium, The Netherlands, and Denmark are hardly renowned for their fantastic weather and they're all doing much better than North England. Meanwhile Southern Spain, Southern Italy, and Greece are lovely places but not doing well economically. I don't think the weather is a good excuse for Northern underperformance.
- CapeTheory 2y agoThe bad weather places you mention have largely uniform bad weather, which is not true of England - the south east is noticeably warmer and drier than the north west. Weather is of course only a contributing factor, just like the historical influences.
- intalentive 2y agoThe author says that the region is poor because, after the decline of industry, it didn’t have universities to drive tech, finance and services. But it sounds like the problem is simply deindustrialization in the first place, same as the US Rust Belt. Material wealth means having stuff. You can only get stuff by making it or taking it from the earth. Meanwhile Chinese cities are sparkling and new, and their workers enjoy a high standard of living at low cost, not unlike Northern England or Cleveland, Ohio 100 years ago. Because they make a lot of stuff. It’s that simple.
- Neonlicht 2y agoDeindustrialization happened all across Europe. Some countries got over it and found new ways to make money. Besides you can make money with trading stuff... Anything that is sold in central Europe has to pass through the port of Rotterdam.
- snowwrestler 2y agoIndustrialization worked for China recently for the same reason it worked for western nations more than a century ago: you can drive local economic growth even if the population has low education. Once you have a strong local economy based on manufacturing, you have to drive innovation to sustain it. So you use the economic output to fund education and research, to create new categories of products and services, which create durable competitive advantage. The U.S. has succeeded wildly with this playbook. China is currently following this playbook. The author is saying that the playbook in Northern England was interrupted by the South.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- fmajid 2y agoIt's interesting that in India, which inherited some of the worst aspects of British governance from the Raj (like perfecting red tape), there is also strong centralization in Delhi, but the richest and best educated parts of the country are the Dravidian South.
- mikhailfranco 2y agoThe boundary between his North and South roughly follows the Roman Fosse Way from Lincoln to Exeter. The 'ditch' (fosse) and road marked the border of the initial phase of the Roman invasion after 43 AD. It was a military road for rapid deployment of forces from the legionary bases to defend border incursions. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fosse_Way https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fosse_Way Apart from the Fosse Way, almost all other major Roman roads fanned out from London. This structure is still visible in the numbering scheme of roads today: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Britain_road_numbering_scheme https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Britain_road_numbering_s... The natural routes for roads also influenced railways, so the boundaries of the original private railway companies (GWR, LNER, LMS, SR), and the regions of the current unified rail system, follow the same structure: https://www.railwaygazette.com/network-rail-regions-take-over-project-delivery/55098.article https://www.railwaygazette.com/network-rail-regions-take-ove...
- desas 2y ago> the boundaries of the original private railway companies (GWR, LNER, LMS, SR) Minor point, though maybe less minor in context of the original post. They are not the original private railway companies. They are the companies created in the 1920s by the London government as it forced railway companies together after it had took them under state control during ww1. The original private railway companies were originally primarily northern companies, some of who eventually developed mainlines to the rich south eastern markets.
- mikhailfranco 2y agoA useful measure of the centralization of a state is the ratio of the size (population, economy) of the capital to the rest of the country. A large capital usually means workers and companies cluster around the government to get work and contracts, but also lobby and bribe to win such favors. Highly centralized countries include UK, France and Thailand. Centralized countries that have a strong geographical excuse might include Egypt and Chile.
- Cold_Miserable 2y agoThe UK is a poor country with a money laundering capital tacked-on.
- sensanabae 2y ago[dead]
- arpinum 2y agoI'd put less blame on London and more on secondary cities than the author does because he misses an important point: London is the only UK city that tolerates growth. The UK system heavily centralised in tax-and-spend powers, but heavily decentralised in veto powers. Secondary cities have used their veto powers to either stop development or make it so expensive that very little gets developed. City centres are not being built up to concentrate talent, and I wouldn't blame London or lack of public money. Housing and rents are high enough to justify private spending on concentrated development if not for the regulatory burdens and delays. The author points out Leeds and Manchester having no metro system that exists in other similarly sized cities. But how much of a useful metro system could Leeds build given the same money spent by Toulouse or Lyon? My guess is none, the money would be consumed by lawsuits and addressing local veto owner concerns. HS2 is cut short because of money that people outside of London demand be spent on making it so expensive on a per-mile basis. If the line were developed similar to other lines in Europe there would be money available for the full length. I'm somewhat bullish on Manchester in the long run, they may emerge as a second city that tolerates growth. If they develop enough to become an affordable and large city then they will attract a lot of businesses who would otherwise be in London. In my city we have a "housing crisis" while the city council owns large empty lots in the city centre from torn down or empty buildings. They have been waiting 8 years on handouts from London to afford to develop it themselves, spending £15m so far without a single unit built. It could be sold to developers and fixed council finances, but there is such a strong aversion to allowing a private company make a profit. The council actually has assets to develop the sites, but has preferred to pursue handouts instead of spending their own money.
- desas 2y ago> I'd put less blame on London and more on secondary cities > HS2 is cut short because of money that people outside of London demand be spent on making it so expensive on a per-mile basis. I'm not sure that's accurate. Cost overruns have also come from inability to find efficiencies, high inflation in the construction sector, low contingency estimate (half cross rails) and a misunderstanding of ground conditions. The expense increases due to consultation / public demand have come from demands made on the route between London and Birmingham. For example the Chiltern tunnel extension. There aren't many cities in that gap, and most of that area is London facing rather than Birmingham or north facing. HS2 between London and Birmingham has the worse cost:benefit ratio of the whole initial plan, and yet it's the only bit being built.
- sireat 2y agoBrings back to mind KLF - It's Grim Up North : https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=20XLWEjN9eI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=20XLWEjN9eI