6 ms·
To make electricity cheaper and greener, connect the world's grids
- bookofjoe 2y agohttps://archive.ph/Hb9lh https://archive.ph/Hb9lh
- yownie 2y agothe real mvp
- hunglee2 2y agoUltra High Voltage transmission lines are a key component to load balancing the grid. Currently (no pun intended...) very expensive because so few countries do it (China (of course), then I think only Brazil?) but it means that power surges from renewables can be channeled to places which need to use it, without having to try and put the energy into storage. If team humanity can find the maturity to connect grids around the globe, we can solve the load balancing problem with a very elegant and obvious solution
- stop50 2y agoEurope uses them to transfer energy in states and between states. Mostly with AC but there are some DC connections.
- Symbiote 2y agoUltra-High Voltage seems to mean over 500kV. AC lines of this voltage in Europe are only in Russia, Belarus and Ukraine. https://www.entsoe.eu/data/map/ https://www.entsoe.eu/data/map/ — there's a legend if you click the button, but navy is > 500kV AC, and magenta is DC.
- ta1243 2y agoThere's half a dozen lines over 500kV DC in operation and as many again under development and construction
- jeffreygoesto 2y agoI heard one of the problems is that since countries want to run the lines submerged, which is too expensive and/or challenging for other reasons (fields,...) for high voltage DC.
- ta1243 2y agoThe ones in europe are submarine. AC has its own challenges under the sea. This one for example at 600kV and 2.2GW https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Western_HVDC_Link https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Western_HVDC_Link There are of course issues with all undersea cables (AC or DC) in today's climate with cable cuts being so frequent. I wonder if it's easier to locate AC cables
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- alluro2 2y agoUnfortunately, there is no "team humanity", except in one losing game. If there was team humanity - and we weren't still focused on "us" vs "them" and throwing feces at each other across imaginary geographical, religious and race borders - I'm confident we could solve the climate problem completely in 5-10 years. Not to mention what else (famine, diseases...), with motivation other than short-term profit...
- rbanffy 2y ago> Unfortunately, there is no "team humanity", except in one losing game Team Humanity is frequently identified as the political left. It shouldn’t be too hard to coordinate internationally.
- lxgr 2y agoShouldn't as in you suspect it isn't, or as in it really ought to not be? In either case, while a "sociological vacuum decay" into a more efficient mode of human collaboration seems at least theoretically possible (we've had some of these in the past: The invention of money, laws, nation states, organized religions, and other practically useful human fictions), if nobody can find a way to precipitate it, it remains just as unachievable as something even theoretically impossible.
- s1artibartfast 2y agoEvery team thinks they are team humanity.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- mystified5016 2y agoFor some values of humanity
- tcfhgj 2y agoDoubt it, some just pretend
- prettyStandard 2y agoI'm not sure why you're getting downvoted. There's some educational videos on YouTube on High Voltage DC. https://youtu.be/JH9-0AbR_1U?si=l57nkFt2YG5iLl3D https://youtu.be/JH9-0AbR_1U?si=l57nkFt2YG5iLl3D North and South America could sell a lot of electricity to the east this way...
- iaaamatrumb 2y agoChina is big on UHV (1000kV) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ultra-high-voltage_electricity_transmission_in_China https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ultra-high-voltage_electricity... > In 2015, State Grid Corporation of China proposed the Global Energy Interconnection, a long-term proposal to develop globally integrated smart grids and ultra high voltage transmission networks to connect over 80 countries.[10]: 92–93 The idea is supported by President Xi Jinping and China in attempting to develop support in various internal forums, including UN bodies.[10]: 92
- markus_zhang 2y agoTeam humanity is too segmented at the moment. Unless the next Pan-whatever happens, it's just politically impossible.
- rbanffy 2y agoNationalism is often one-sided within individual countries. Their opponents have a lot in common across borders and should be more easily coordinated.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- spockz 2y agoIt seems that in our country (The Netherlands) the bigger blocker is more the interconnections between local regions as opposed to transferring between larger regions such as countries. We have varying production from solar and wind. Now that means that each local connection to the main grid needs to be almost as heavy as the main grid whereas it used to be just one direction with very predictable usage.
- marcosdumay 2y agoYes, Brazil has some UHV lines. AFAIK, the US has one, Europe has a few, not only inside the EU. Long distance power grids are only useful if you have huge generators localized away from the power consumers. So, mostly places with hydroelectric generators have them. It was never a matter of "maturity" or politics.
- arthurofbabylon 2y agoTime and time again, from one industry to another, the bottleneck in progress remains human, or political, or social organization (whatever you wish to call it). No matter our technological progress since the Industrial Revolution this failure point appears to persist. As my gardening instructor would tell our class: it’s not the features themselves that matter, but the relationships between features that define the system. It’s been in vogue to hype up technical solutions (“more compute,” “yeah but when it gets better…” “we just need a few more years on this”) to all of these problems that deserve to be solved in the socio-political sphere. It’s often more effective to restructure a given systems’ relationships than to hope for magical boosts here and there.
- ip26 2y agoThat feels like a tilted assessment. The technical solutions can break down enormous walls, and very quickly. There are just some walls they can't - political, social, etc - and once the other walls have been leveled, we tend to get focused on those & lament.
- rbanffy 2y agoTechnology has been used to change the political landscape quite effectively. So far, I’ve seen it used to favor short term interests of small groups, but a sufficiently motivated organisation can do a lot toward a favourable outcome for the whole planet.
- hansonkd 2y agoCould be a bottleneck some ways. In other ways its an accelerant (think space race). Like most things in nature you probably get the most out of "progress" (kind of a slippery word in itself) through some type of equilibrium rather than an absolute everyone must work together.
- agumonkey 2y agoIt can be even worse. When people are too deep into a particular technique they lose track of what the system needs. I've seen 500M intranet applications who were slower that handwriting on preprinted paper templates (which means network failures would increase productivity overall).
- wcoenen 2y agoAnother article from 2022 by the WSJ on that topic, titled "Building a Power Grid to Span the World": https://www.wsj.com/articles/building-a-power-grid-to-span-the-world-11646660908 https://www.wsj.com/articles/building-a-power-grid-to-span-t... archive.ph link: https://archive.ph/dM2oM https://archive.ph/dM2oM
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- euroderf 2y agoExtend the European synchronised grid to Northern Africa. Then you can think about deploying solar on a massive scale to parts of the Sahara.
- hkt 2y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Xlinks_Morocco%E2%80%93UK_Power_Project https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Xlinks_Morocco%E2%80%93UK_Powe... tl;dr this is already proposed
- 1over137 2y agoIt's risky to connect your grid to another country's. ex: Canada's grid is connected to the USA, but now the USA is being hostile to Canada.
- twodave 2y agoI mean, logistically speaking everybody is already depending on the US pretty much. So you could say this about every country in the world from one perspective or another.
- Hamuko 2y agoMoldova (+ Transnistria), Russia and Ukraine are also in a fight over gas deliveries that make up a significant chunk of Moldova's electricity.
- _njyk 2y agoThree countries, Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania are disconnecting from Russia literally in 2 weeks for that specific reason, so it's an horrible idea to interconnect everything in the current world.
- guax 2y agoThat seems like a problem of a single large provider and not a connectivity problem. It's a monopoly issue that would be less of a problem if a single or even a minority of players were not the largest producer. At least electricity can be produced more broadly than gas where you had to win the lottery of location or game of Thrones of imperialism.
- 1over137 2y ago>That seems like a problem of a single large provider and not a connectivity problem. No, it sounds like a problem of a belligerent super power next door.
- danny_codes 2y ago
- davidw 2y agoConnecting the world sounds pretty utopian when the broader interconnectivity, like trade, that we do have is fraying at the edges and starting to crumble.
- jonhohle 2y agoThe main issue with everyone agreeing is the one who disagrees often gains the advantage, especially if the control something they perceived more valuable then they are getting from being agreeable.
- guax 2y agoNext people will want a interconnected communications channel between countries. Utter pipe dream.
- horrible-hilde 2y agothe checks and balances will eventually be deregulated and forgotten.
- TaurenHunter 2y agoAn idea that looks good on paper but can be disastrous in reality. Interconnected systems increase exposure to cyber threats.
- yownie 2y agoand small systems with no decentralized redundancy can fail catastrophically, what's your point? We have have far more recent examples of the former rather than your hypothetical musings.
- TaurenHunter 2y agoDon't be a IYI, learn something: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Northeast_blackout_of_2003 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Northeast_blackout_of_2003
- the__alchemist 2y agoDon't put your infrastructure on the internet.
- Hamuko 2y agoNot just cyber threats. Just ask Estonia how much electricity they are currently importing from Finland.
- mike-the-mikado 2y agoWe already have hundreds of millions of people on connected electricity grids. Loss of a few interconnections would not lead to catastrophic failure of the whole system.
- ben_w 2y agoCyber security is a huge concern irregardless of if the grids are national or international. IMO the novel challenges are: (1) too many borders with too many opportunities for corruption (2) Coronal mass ejections become an even bigger issue than already (impact goes from regional to global) (3) Literally only China is making enough aluminium for this, and nobody's making enough copper or superconductor
- ndsipa_pomu 2y agoHuh - looks like Buckminster Fuller's idea might be relevant. Unfortunately, I can't seem to access http://geni.org http://geni.org for more details, but here's the Wikipedia link: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Global_Energy_Network_Institute https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Global_Energy_Network_Institut...
- metalman 2y agoThere is no way to make this idea work, or for that matter describe any plausible way to impliment it. Its physicaly impossible to span the pacific and atlantic oceans. Other north south bottlenecks occur and then many of the ereas that could host grid scale solar, are poor, and therefore exporting there light,which is only going to bring 11 fully temporary part time jobs per 100000 inhabitents, who go home to huts, with no electricity, is not a good look anymore. The real nitty gritty is rights of way for transmission lines. India, Pakistan, Afganistan, Iran, all in a nice neat row, you have my personal permission to build anything you want! and as an as an added bonus I will put in a word with China ,Russia, and Khazakistan, then quick climb up the pole, twist a few wires together and gzzzzzzzzitz* and zam London to Bieging at the speed of light. VS, distributed solar, wind, water, geothermal, power that serves local grids, just fine. Battery storage will get much cheaper, and the generating equipment is only getting more efficient and cheaper. The world grid will have to wait until we have some kind of fusion power and a super conducting grid, where power is in fact too cheap to meter and has demonstrably less impact than any other source.
- michaelmior 2y ago> Its physicaly impossible to span the pacific and atlantic oceans There are already plans to connect North America and Europe with an undersea power cable. https://www.offshore-energy.biz/worlds-most-ambitious-subsea-interconnector-igniting-zest-for-clean-power-superhubs-embracing-nato-l-to-reinforce-energy-security-bonds-between-america-and-europe/ https://www.offshore-energy.biz/worlds-most-ambitious-subsea...
- Zanfa 2y agoThis is never going to be viable. Even existing short undersea cables are difficult (impossible?) to protect from sabotage, let alone one that would span an ocean.
- ben_w 2y agoLonger cables need to be thicker if you want resistance to be fixed. If you want 1Ω then by coincidence a 40,000 km cable has a cross section of almost exactly one square meter. If you're putting a significant fraction of global power through that at any sane voltage, you can't use most cutting tools (or indeed electrical motors) near it because the magnetic field is too strong. China is making enough aluminium that this is a plausible thing they may do as a "belt and road" type project.
- BJones12 2y agoDoes anyone remember the 2003 blackout [0] that left 55 million people in 2 countries without power for up to 3 days? With a worldwide grid we could make one a hundred times larger. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Northeast_blackout_of_2003 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Northeast_blackout_of_2003
- michaelmior 2y agoThis not a necessary outcome of connected grids though. Technology has advanced a lot in the past two decades.
- ryao 2y agoHas it? https://arstechnica.com/security/2025/01/could-hackers-use-new-attack-to-take-down-european-power-grid/ https://arstechnica.com/security/2025/01/could-hackers-use-n...
- michaelmior 2y agoA hack was not the cause of the 2003 blackout.
- ryao 2y agoIt did not need to be. My pint was that upgrades being done by everyone did not eliminate all points of fragility.
- lxgr 2y ago“Connect” doesn’t have to mean “operate as a closely coupled synchronized grid”. Using HVDC (which is more efficient over long distances anyway), adjacent grids basically appear as just another power plant to yours (and some early HVDC connections literally consisted of a motor coupled to a generator!), and grids ought to be able to stomach the sudden outage of one.
- itishappy 2y agoWas a great time for stargazing, at least!
- k0stas 2y agoBeware of talk about benefits without mention of drawbacks. Connecting grids could significantly increase the fragility of the system resulting in higher risk of large-scale power outages. Some of you might have experienced the 2003 blackout in northeast North American (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Northeast_blackout_of_2003 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Northeast_blackout_of_2003), which luckily happened in the summer. Tail risks should not be swept under the rug. Even a single widespread event could completely wipe out the benefit gained from connecting grids.
- api 2y agoThis is a general principle: making things bigger and/or more centralized tends to increase efficiency and decrease the frequency of failures but greatly increase the cost and severity of failures. In computing think about, for example, centralizing identity management in the hands of a few large companies. These companies have large security teams and mature well built infrastructures, but a huge failure or a huge security compromise of, say, Google’s OIDC system, could be utterly catastrophic, paralyzing and destroying vast swaths of our digital infrastructure. Entire companies, services, or even sectors would be paralyzed or worse. Small, decentralized, and diverse is overall more costly and experiences many smaller failures but is more robust for the long haul. This is probably why life, having evolved over a billion years, is mostly this way. Giant super organisms and super-optimized monocultures are possible but fragile. Our economies, having only existed for hundreds of years and being incentivized to only care about next quarter, tend to go all in on anything that makes numbers superficially better.
- lizknope 2y agoI remember we were at work and the power flickered and all the UPS's started beeping for about 10 seconds. Then it went back to normal. Then about 30 minutes later people looked at the news and saw a massive blackout. We were hundreds of miles away and that's all we felt but I had a relative tell me about walking a few miles home because the subways were down and the traffic lights not working made it even crazier.
- Havoc 2y agoBlackouts & instability can happen on isolated grids too - if not easier given less options. See the texas grid drama. It does seem sensible to beef up resilience on large interconnects though agreed to mitigate cascading risk.
- vinni2 2y agoForget connecting world’s grids first the governments should connect national grids. Like in Germany and Norway north and south grids are disconnected contributing to fluctuating prices.
- johnea 2y agoWith an intercontinental power grid, the sun is always shining. Of course, The Economist isn't worried about that, they really only care about how they can make money from it. But for a technologist, there's always that messy real world to deal with. And for solar power, that reality is night. A world wide power grid could be constantly transmitting power to the dark side.
- ryao 2y agoThe following seems relevant to any discussion of interconnecting the world's grids: https://arstechnica.com/security/2025/01/could-hackers-use-new-attack-to-take-down-european-power-grid/ https://arstechnica.com/security/2025/01/could-hackers-use-n...
- p0w3n3d 2y agoWhat about the cost on transmission of the power?
- ryao 2y agoI cannot help but wonder what the answers are to these points: > Norwegians are forgetting that domestically produced power is not always cheaper. Whenever the current in the cables flows towards them, it helps reduce high prices. Norway could add some diodes to the cables so that it only imports and does not export. > And even though Norway exports more power than it imports, that is fantastic for domestic energy producers. Norway’s state-owned power firms have been raking it in, which is one of the reasons the government can afford to subsidise household prices. Wholesale prices would plummet if this energy had nowhere to go. Getting wholesale prices down seems to be the goal here, so why not keep the energy trapped and let the wholesale prices drop? If they wholesale prices drop, you would expect that to help pay for lower household prices. These are not my actual views. I just feel that the articles' author did not address these points, so I decided to raise them here.
- grayhatter 2y ago> Norway could add some diodes to the cables so that it only imports and does not export. Does norway really transfer power via DC? that can't be true can it?
- ryao 2y agoThe map on Wikipedia shows several HVDC links exiting Norway: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High-voltage_direct_current https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High-voltage_direct_current HVDC for long distance power sharing makes sense since it is generally more efficient than HVAC. On land, HVDC is more efficient beyond ~500km, but underwater, HVDC is more efficient beyond ~50km: https://www.electricaldeck.com/2021/08/comparison-between-hvdc-and-hvac-transmission-system.html https://www.electricaldeck.com/2021/08/comparison-between-hv... Beyond the efficiency benefit, HVDC easily handles transfer of power between grids operating at different frequencies. There are also several other benefits documented at that second link.
- ZeroGravitas 2y agoThe Economist did address these, their basic argument is that trade is a win-win. Usually when these win-wins go wrong they have the gains filtered off by a middleman or monopolist but in this case it seems the government uses the money earned to subsidize household bills which means they do get the benefit of trade. Stopping the trade therefore means higher prices for domestic consumers. This is the basic point the article makes repeatedly.
- grizzles 2y agoThe sun is always shining somewhere on earth. One day solar energy will be shifted from Portugal to Shanghai & Moscow then across the Bering Strait to Alaska & New York.
- toast0 2y agoThe Pacific ocean is quite large. There's several hours a day where it's the only place getting sun.
- waltercool 2y agoThat's a shtty take, centralization is almost always the most inefficient way to do things, and leads to multiple problems by implementation, specially around different cultures What country A wants to do is totally different that country B wants. Some western countries are freezing as they are investing hard in solar/wind plants, while China makes ton of carbon plants.
- worthless-trash 2y agoI like in the image in the article, PNG is expanded to kinda represent Australia and new Zealand is forgotten entirely.
- Havoc 2y agoEurope and large parts of ASEAN already are pretty connected. Aside from connecting the three US grids next step would surely need to be connecting continents? Quick google says it should be feasible. London to DC is about 5k km. Longest UHV DC seems to be just over 3k built in 2018 (over land) so maybe?
- xkbarkar 2y agoHeh, author of this should try living in south Sweden that allows Germany to suck them dry when the wind turbines stand still over there. Quote: Summary of Thursday’s Electricity Prices: Electricity areas 3 & 4 (Southern Sweden): SEK 2.5-3.6 average price per kWh, peak at SEK 8. Electricity areas 1 & 2 (Northern Sweden): 17 öre and 9 öre per kWh, respectively. [source| https://www.timber.exchange/news/details/in-depth/electricity-price-in-sweden-high#:~:text=Electricity%20prices%20soared%20to%20new,an%20increased%20demand%20for%20electricity https://www.timber.exchange/news/details/in-depth/electricit....] Denmark is trying to do to Norway what Germany has done do the Swedish in that respect. I fully understand that the Norwegians want to cut the cable to the south.
- thecopy 2y agoSounds like Germany and its people are getting greener and cheaper electricity
- xkbarkar 2y agoI call German and Danish windmills bordering on greenwashing. For any energy to be truly green, it must also be pragmatic. It's not green energy if it's so expensive ordinary households cannot afford to use it. Id like to see you rejoice if your electricity bill went from 0.4kr to 8kr per kwH because your neightbour countries' "awesome green energy supply" fails to support its citizens needs. This is not a constant occurrence fortunately but happens enough to anger the Swedish and Norwegian authorities. They are already quadrupling the electricity cost with a myriad of taxes ( green, state, maintenance, municipality, what have you ) so this price hike due to failed windmills and lack of daylight at the neighbours' makes them look incompetent. Sweden and Norway does not want to lower the taxes to leverage energy bills for the average tax payer because Germany and Denmark cannot get ther sh!t together, that's for sure.
- Projectiboga 2y agoWhat about some of the world being 60 HZ and the rest being 50 HZ? Is syncing the interconnection hard or is that a major limiter?
- NullPrefix 2y agoDC coupling or maybe the whole long transmission line is high voltage DC
- NullPrefix 2y agoShould we interconnect with Russia, China and North Korea? You know, for the greener energy future