6 ms·
The past, present, and future of UI at GitHub
- xnx 2y agoGlad to see some discouragement of custom design systems. I shudder at the person-hours that have been squandered on that fruitless endeavor. Pre-web, essentially zero time was spent on "design systems", and we were all better for it.
- Groxx 2y agoPre-web there are plenty of "human-computer interface" documents / guides / etc. And UX research and demos (e.g. The Mother Of All Demos). Pre-software there are plenty of "design of everyday things" books, schools of thought, movements, etc. This is nothing new, aside from our current state being driven by a recent surge.
- xnx 2y agoAbsolutely. The work of user experience research has a long history and is very important. What is new is every single "app" (website) inventing their own entire conventions and "language". This still happened with desktop apps, but it was rare typically limited to the largest players (Microsoft, Adobe). You can do a tremendous amount with basic, bog-standard, GUI widgets if you apply them well.
- anon7000 2y agoPart of the problem is that we just don’t have a std lib, or std UI framework for the web. In both Windows and Mac, the basic UI happy path involves using the pre-built libraries and UI components these companies created to make apps somewhat consistent. There is nothing like that for the web — which is part of what the article gets at.
- Aeolun 2y agoI mean, we do? There’s Tailwind now, and there was a time when 50% of the web was bootstrap or wordpress.
- Groxx 2y agoQuite a few of them, yeah. jQuery UI was a huge, massively widespread thing for a while too. People still do their own things of course. Like how tons of Windows apps build completely custom stuff (e.g. Winamp). Or very nearly every single videogame.
- nsm 2y agoI am curious to understand what bearing "lots and lots of regular people solely use their cellphone to conduct consumer transactions" has on GitHub, whose audience is significantly different than median and cannot otherwise function without a laptop/desktop.
- simonw 2y agoI frequently use GitHub on my phone, making edits to my projects using their web edit button. And I have a very decent laptop. I wish Codespaces worked better on mobile! It would be great to see them invest more work in that. Anecdotally I've heard that there are people out there who have successfully learned to program entirely on mobile devices.
- bigstrat2003 2y agoIf it works for you then great, I guess. But that sounds like the equivalent of using nail clippers to mow the lawn. You're forgoing a good tool for an absolutely terrible tool.
- lolinder 2y agoWhat exactly is your use case for doing edits on your phone? Are you making these edits while out and about without your laptop (in line?) or do you actually avoid getting your laptop out even when it's close by?
- simonw 2y agoUsually tiny things like typo fixes on web pages or in my documentation. Occasionally I'll ship feature changes to my JavaScript apps, usually copy and pasted over from Claude.
- simonw 2y agoI just shipped this change from my phone: https://github.com/simonw/simonwillisonblog/commit/a0f731ecb6150df034b93ca4b4dd22fb6b665651 https://github.com/simonw/simonwillisonblog/commit/a0f731ecb...
- simonw 2y ago> According to Pew Research https://www.pewresearch.org/internet/fact-sheet/mobile/ https://www.pewresearch.org/internet/fact-sheet/mobile/ 15 percent of U.S. adults only access the internet through a mobile device. That number seemed surprising to me - I actually expected the portion of mobile-only internet users would be significantly higher than that. Turns out the 15% number means something slightly different. From that Pew Research page: "Today, 15% of U.S. adults are “smartphone-only” internet users – meaning they own a smartphone but say they do not subscribe to a home broadband service." So the 15% is people who use the internet exclusively via LTE/5G without paying for home broadband. (I'm surprised that number isn't higher as well.)
- jwalton 2y agoThere’s no small irony that this isn’t age doesn’t render correctly on Safari on iPhone. All the text wraps off the right edge of the phone. -_-
- hawksley 2y agoNo kidding! This is my first time experimenting with converting Keynote slides into HTML, so I'm not surprised it didn't go perfectly. I just pushed a quick fix for the overflow issue but should probably figure out a longer-term solution.
- Daedren 2y agoThe text is still overflowing off the right side of the screen on my 13 mini
- koolba 2y ago> So the 15% is people who use the internet exclusively via LTE/5G without paying for home broadband. Does that factor in people “borrowing” their neighbors WiFi?
- lazyasciiart 2y agoOr college kids using campus internet?
- xnx 2y agoWill GitHub ever change the file list preceding the README.md content? This has always seemed a poor default, but maybe the way I use GitHub is different than their primary user?
- acedTrex 2y agoI don't know why anyone would want this. I use github to look at code, the code should be front and center immediately.
- stickfigure 2y agoGithub project URLs are the defacto landing pages for most software components, both public/opensource and private/internal. It's reasonable to lead with the documentation.
- bigstrat2003 2y agoWhy should Github change the UI just because those people are trying to jam square pegs into round holes? Github is version control first and foremost, not a web host.
- stickfigure 2y agoThen why does it display the README at all? Github is a lot of things to many people. A "web host" and a way of publishing information about software is definitely one of the things it is.
- mfro 2y agoI think this is a problem solved by github pages. If a project's primary distribution method is github, they should build a Page and link people to that, instead of the repo.
- stickfigure 2y agoExactly 0 of the hundreds of projects in my company's git organization have pages. But they have READMEs. Most software is not popular opensource with a carefully curated web footprint.
- cyberax 2y ago> Which is all to say, that mobile is the new baseline. And we’re trying to match it using a technology stack originally built for displaying documents! This is such a bullshit take. I don't think I ever used my phone to do anything on Github. Nor do I want to.
- throwaway-1231 2y agoIronically, the blog doesn't work well on mobile. The width is fixed and the end of the sentences are out of view. I have to vertically scroll right/left to read
- hawksley 2y agoYup, that's on me. As noted elsewhere this was my first attempt at converting Keynote slides into HTML (using https://github.com/mcfunley/better-keynote-export https://github.com/mcfunley/better-keynote-export). I've pushed a fix for the overflow.
- rad_gruchalski 2y agoIt still doesn’t display properly on ios safari.
- hawksley 2y agoAh, looks like it didn't update. Should be better now.
- rad_gruchalski 2y agoI used it a lot. When it was still possible to use the desktop version. Mainly triaging issues, looking at some code, search, pr review…
- ZeWaka 2y agoReally great writeup on the current industry trends, that hits all too hard as I'm sitting here implementing yet another design system...
- keyle 2y agoThat's basically the life story of the life of frontend engineer nowadays isn't it? The lower I went to the ground, e.g. backend, then native code, then C... the happier I am. It's like the ocean, the lower you go, the more stable and calm things are. On the surface, you get the crashing waves. I used to be a Web expert, from the early days, DHTML and flash, to the median years, jquery, backbone etc. to then writing my own libraries. Vue 2 was the last I really used as front-end heavy. Since then I've been secluded more towards the backend, I leave the front end to the young. I do like systems like Laravel Livewire though, it's mildly sane. When I write websites now, I do it all by hand and focus on really fast page loading times rather than a monstrosity of generated code and async over the wire. I have such a better time doing it. Today's web should be considered harmful to the health. It's a high blood pressure job.
- mystified5016 2y agoI really love firmware for this reason. Each instruction you send to the CPU means something. If you want, you can rip back all the abstraction and just run raw assembly. Sometimes the compiler can be very wrong and you get to embed the correct assembly in your C and suddenly the program is 10x faster. True story! Trying to fit my application in 1kB of flash and one hundred twenty-eight entire bytes of RAM taught me a lot as a young programmer. It really makes you confront the physicality of the machine your code represents. I don't think nearly enough programmers have that experience
- Aeolun 2y agoI’ve actually found it to be pretty nice and relaxing. Trying to customize a prebuild system where you don’t have perfect control over all the components is stressful to me, but I may be in the minority.
- zwieback 2y agoGithub is the worst of the web GUIs I use regularly. Started bad and only got worse, luckily 99% of my gitting is via PC based tools. Maybe this is the kind of app where the GUI should be modeled on client side developer tools and not modern web UIs.
- Trasmatta 2y agoHistorically I've thought the GitHub web UI was great - clean, usable, simple. Over the past couple of years it's started to get more and more feature bloat, to the point where it's becoming less usable.
- zwieback 2y agoI've only used Github desktop briefly so I can't say much about it, was commenting on the web UI. I suppose if I was using a lot of GitHub functionality vs. just using github.com as a repo things might be different and I'd give Github desktop another try.
- Trasmatta 2y agoSorry, that's what I meant actually, the web UI. I said desktop to differentiate it from the mobile web UI, but I realize that was the wrong way to say it because they also have a desktop app.
- Aeolun 2y agoI feel like file browsing and pull requests actually got better? That’s what I use 99% of the time. Projects is a mixed bag, but not terrible. I feel like Github is generally good at making things as complex as they need to be, and no more.
- inferiorhuman 2y agoThinking back on it I've used Github nearly since the early 10s. Today I find myself wondering how the fuck I get a list of all issues for a project. For fifteen odd years I've been able to clear the search box of the "is:open" and "is:whateverfuckingelse" bits and just get a list. Now? Whatever UI update they've just pushed isn't reflected in the documentation. I can't think of anything that's been improved since GH decided to reinvent text rendering (and poorly at that) and then double down on it. Upon further inspection it sort of works if I log in. It behaves differently at least. Ugh.
- mhh__ 2y agoTwo requests: 1) A UI that _cleanly_ shows me things assigned to me and opened by me 2) Filter PRs by directory. Phabricator did both of these quite well.
- hawksley 2y agoFor 1), have you tried https://github.com/pulls https://github.com/pulls and https://github.com/pulls/assigned https://github.com/pulls/assigned?
- mhh__ 2y agoI have. They're better than nothing but not by much.
- rad_gruchalski 2y agoThe correct place for those requests is here: https://github.com/community/community https://github.com/community/community.
- airstrike 2y agoStats about general internet usage should mean very little to GitHub since it is used by a specific subset of the population which I'd wager is way more heavily skewed towards laptop/desktop Also shouldn't they be able to just know this based on traffic? Why the need to use third-party general research as a source rather than "Our traffic patterns suggest X"?
- hawksley 2y agoThe mention of general internet usage stats was in the context of broader industry trends influencing overall consumer expectations.
- airstrike 2y agoSure but GitHub users are developers, not "consumers" in the general sense, so that mention doesn't really apply.
- aragilar 2y agoSlide ?42? (https://hawksley.org/img/posts/2025-01-08-past-present-future-of-ui-at-github/slides.042.jpeg https://hawksley.org/img/posts/2025-01-08-past-present-futur...) also hints at some level of disconnect, what's the number of users accessing GitHub via Linux?
- TheRealSteel 2y agoYeah. Looking at stats without context of their audience is what caused the Xbox One disaster. They saw a huge number of hours on Xbox 360 being used for watching streaming shows, so they thought that was all anybody cared about, ignoring the fact that their audience still bought the device as a game console and that alot of those hours were relatives and housemates.
- hedora 2y agoThe 360 was a better streaming box than the one. The one was a crap console all around, but Microsoft’s auth BS is what finally got both of them stuck in our attic. More recently, this happened with minecraft. GitHub recently forced me to turn on 2FA over SMS. Now they’re running a banner telling me that it has all the problems that were the reasons I didn’t want to turn it on, and telling me to turn on some other 2FA instead.
- BoingBoomTschak 2y agoRelated: https://github.com/orgs/community/discussions/62372 https://github.com/orgs/community/discussions/62372 (GH increasingly not displaying anything without JS)
- internetter 2y ago> Which is all to say, that mobile is the new baseline. > 15 percent of U.S. adults only access the internet through a mobile device. Absolutely nobody is using GitHub exclusively from their phone. As an aside, this site doesn’t work on mobile. > But there is a bigger problem. Why are there so many design systems in the first place? Because homogeneity is boring. I read the article linked about the global design system: > Many — or even most! — web developers shouldn’t need to understand many close-to-the-metal HTML concepts in order to make web applications function Next they’re gonna say that web developers shouldn’t need to know how to code. HTML isn’t low level. > For the love of God, why is there more than one way for me to provide my shipping address on the internet? For fun? The screenshot shows 3 perfectly good looking forms. I have never ONCE struggled to input my address into a form.
- ZeWaka 2y ago> Absolutely nobody is using GitHub exclusively from their phone. As an OSS maintainer, I do quite a lot of issue triage and simple PR review via the GitHub mobile app, which has gotten better by leaps and bounds in the past 3 years. > I have never ONCE struggled to input my address into a form. The different ways forms treat secondary addresses can be a real pain, if you have one of those.
- cobertos 2y agoUsing availability as a metric for UI bugs is great. After all, UI is just an API for humans, and it breaking breaks workflows. > These unique kinds of UIs have less convention and unique accessibility characteristics that are expensive to solve. But a lot of the time, our budget should be zero. To build it with what we have already. To copy-paste. If you build UIs like this, you end up with the sort of one-size-fits-all UIs no one likes. Like when Twitter (and others) consolidated their desktop and mobile UIs into one mobile-first one that works worse on. You waste a bunch of space and information density, lose eye scanning ability, for the benefit of higher developer velocity. It must be carefully applied. Things like shipping address forms (example from article) or yes/no modals are a great place for standardization but trying to assemble those pieces on a single page, or show something slightly different and you're back to square one. --- Didn't we try to standardize some of this already? Isnt this why <input>s are derived from the OS and why alert() and prompt() exist? And default style sheets? And no one wanted this! Browsers have opened up _everything_ to be customized, capitulating to designers. And even with all that customization, some things like HTML5 validation still feel like theyre missing pieces.
- madeofpalk 2y agoFor building as a part of an overall product, I agree that the budget should trend towards zero, not away from it. It should be easy to make things “look like GitHub”, but still possible to build new outside-the-box experiences where relevant.
- binary_slinger 2y agoI would like to see renewed focus on supporting the user to be able to customize the UI to their liking. This is sorely missed in design systems and web apps. Everything is GitHub at the whims of a UX designer that did some “research”.
- jdxcode 2y agowhat the heck is "four-dimensional drag-and-drop"?
- ZeWaka 2y ago"Where you drag and drop something onto something else, hold it, and then it performs an action"
- samatman 2y agoIs your Markdown renderer ever going to figure out how to reflow paragraphs with hard newlines in them? Will there ever be a way to dispose of the enormous header blocking me from reading source code? Those are what I want from the future of UI at GitHub.
- aetherspawn 2y ago> MS want to move users off AZDO to GH Do they really want to move users off Azure DevOps to GitHub? Asking as someone about to invest in AZDO.
- mattmanser 2y agoI looked myself about 6 months ago and it's not clear whether that's true or not. Which probably doesn't bode well for AZDO as it's not a definite no, but on the other hand it's not clearcut that they are actually pushing that. The general consensus among the great unwashed is that AZDO is turning into an undead project that won't improve. But the reality is there's a lot of present enterprise investment in AZDO and no clear migration path, as well as a lot of internal MS use of AZDO, so it's doubtful it's true but more a loud PM in GitHub over egging his own product. But it's sort of turning into a self-fullfilling prophecy as people are getting skittish about investing in AZDO. The reality is that unless you have crazy builds switching is a few days work and more a pain in the ass than a real project.
- aetherspawn 2y agoThe whole design of AZDO is Enterprise-focused, and for example you have the capability to customise every little thing. It has a plugins API so you can add renderers for custom file formats. The design is such that even if you have 100 active repositories, it is easy to use. GitHub has no such vision. The interface is clean and easy to use, but the depth of customisation is nearly nonexistent. And the interface keeps bringing you back to the public area of GitHub. Would be very disappointing if they killed off AZDO. I don’t think GH is an alternative, at all.
- hawksley 2y agoI've updated the slides to fix this typo- it should have said "MS wants enable AZDO customers to migrate to GitHub."
- esprehn 2y agoI believe this is misinterpreting the app usage trends. While the number of minutes on mobile is heavily skewed to apps (ex. 90%) the time is also spent in a very small number of apps (ex. Instagram or YouTube). It's not clear how that trend applies to something like GitHub or developer tooling in general.
- andygocke 2y agoI guess people have different experiences as I don’t see the React changes as improving the mobile experience: just the opposite. I often interact with GitHub by browsing through the file tree and various links. But the new react renderer breaks the back button. So often when I’m browsing and hit back, I leave GitHub entirely instead of going back to the parent directory.
- meixger 2y agoSame. The broken back navigation needs more attention. Upvote here https://github.com/orgs/community/discussions/75889 https://github.com/orgs/community/discussions/75889
- cjk 2y agoBetween the back button issues and the horrible sluggishness on many repo and pull request pages, the React switchover has seriously degraded what used to be a great experience. Not just on mobile, but on desktop as well.
- justinclift 2y agoUgh. GitHub's UX has been getting so much worse over time. :( :( :( They even completely break super basic things that used to work fine. For example, if you want the direct download url of (say) an image file in your repo you used to be able to hover over the "Download raw file" button and the status bar would show you the url. But no, no any more. It's now some kind of javascript button bullshit and there's no way to get it to show the actual download url. Clicking it at least downloads the file, but the history entry is messed up "blob:..." and also doesn't show the download url (using Firefox). Because at GitHub they clearly can't leave alone the things that actually work, and need to change things just for the sake of change. Seriously not impressed. :( :( :(
- MarkyC4 2y agoIsn't this to combat abuse? People using github as a file storage site?
- justinclift 2y agoNo idea. Whatever their reasoning is, they've utterly broken yet another basic UX element that people used.
- butz 2y agoI think issue search field became more slow. Sure, it has more features, but feels sluggish.
- m3047 2y agoA discussion thread which won't die: https://github.com/orgs/community/discussions/135572 I don't regret posting my comment (on Sept 4, not shown by default) because it truly was a shit change, but finding a viable alternative to GitHib has definitely elevated in my "get around to it" pile as the preferable alternative to ever giving feedback again. It just exposes how much else interferes with getting things done. How do I make the comments stop? It's noise at this point. My comment isn't in my own account page under "contribution activity". There's no way to search for the comment in the actual discussion thread and trying to search page source for e.g. the username doesn't do any good because not all comments are shown by default; changing the sort to "top" doesn't work because, even though I only got 2 upvotes (and 1 emoji), the initial display still hides the majority (221 out of 251) of items to display lower priority stuff at the bottom... and besides it's broken and threads aren't sorted strictly according to any interpretation of "top" I can muster.
- hulitu 2y ago> Various reports estimate the around 90% of internet usage on mobile devices is [in apps](https://www.emarketer.com/content/the-majority-of-americans-mobile-time-spent-takes-place-in-apps https://www.emarketer.com/content/the-majority-of-americans-...). If you use apps all day, websites are a step back. This website is a step back. One cannot say if there are some slides (presentation) with handouts (??) or something else. > Which is all to say, that mobile is the new baseline. I'm sure a lot of mobile users browse github. Phones and tablets are a wonderful development environment. Notice the diversity of code editors and debug tools running on the phones and tablets. /s
- vwvw 2y agoGenerating slide 19 aka code survability, was generated with https://github.com/erikbern/git-of-theseus https://github.com/erikbern/git-of-theseus Thanks to Joel for pointing it out!
- IYasha 2y ago> But our HTML, CSS, and JavaScript runs on several major versions of each major browser How freaking bold this mofo is! I stopped using GitSht because after being bought by MS it went downhill progressively rendering every crucial feature unusable! Like on purpose, simplest things like buttons and menus went more and more broken. Month by month SOMETHING new went wrong. How f* sinister can devs be to enjoy torturing users so much? Oh, right: this is a corporate policy. I have 3 browsers that are possible to run on my system and NONE of them fully works with GitHub. When even on PaleMoon issue comments started glitching I gave up on GH. F*k it. I'd rather run my own.