16 ms·
On Patents
- astrodust 14y agoAn important point is that patents are not about having the idea first, but patenting the idea first. History is littered with examples of people that failed to patent their invention only to be beaten over the head by someone that did. In a patent-happy society there's no room for innovators, only lawyers.
- natermer 14y agoPatents, by function, are government granted monopolies over a idea or concept. So, basically, the person that holds the patents is guaranteed to have the ability to sue anybody that infringes on the patents. This is backed up the ability of the government to inflict violence on anybody that infringes. And what is happening is that the system is getting worse. USA was unique in that it had a first-to-invent rule governing patents. That is if you are the first inventor of something you have the right to the patent even if somebody else pays off the government first. However, soon it's going to be first-to-file. Meaning that even if you invented something first you can still infringe on a patent if somebody else is able to get to the patent office and pay them off first. This will go into effect on March 16, 2013. Now people will argue that this streamlines the system and makes it much easier to identify people that have the legal ownership of a particular patent and thus reduce fees and the expense of taking people to court.... But seeing how patents are generally terrible things then making something that is terrible better at being terrible is not really the sort of 'reform' that we should be looking forward to.
- astrodust 14y agoI'm sure people will be patenting the hell out of anything and everything at that point in time. They'll be paying interns to scour through dusty old computer science papers, publications, even textbooks for anything that hasn't been nailed down and patented. I'm sure there's people in a certain part of Texas that couldn't be happier. For the rest of us it sounds like an unending hell. It's like malaria in lawsuit form.
- natermer 14y agoYes. Theoretically 'first to file' still yields to 'first to publish'. But as I explained in my reply to my own post above this still means that it puts massive advantages into the hands of large corporate players at the expense of everybody else.
- darkestkhan 14y agoTechnically yes, in practice it strengthens prior art - you have to file it BEFORE any someone makes demos or product samples as that would invalidate patent. At least that will slightly improve patent situation in US.
- astrodust 14y agoIf by slightly, you mean that like throwing water on a blazing grease fire there's this surprisingly brief interval where it looks like it's working. Then everything in the kitchen catches on fire, including you.
- natermer 14y agoTo help put into a bit more perspective in case anybody is doubting the wrong direction of the first-to-file reform... Basically: "First to file" means that unless you are able to get your product to market and publish it before another person files on your invention then you lose your 'rights' to use your invention. In business it is very very easy to invent something. People come up with new and useful ideas all the time, and create demos and sample products, etc etc. Inventing something isn't the problem. Actually developing it and turning into a profitable product is the really difficult problem. In other words: The act of taking the idea to fruition is the issue here. Inventing new things just happens as a matter of course. Now in business the reason you will have a long time lag from invention, prototype, and then into production is lack of capital. It's extremely expensive process and you must have significant ability, credit, and resources to take something to public in a meaningful way. This means you either must sell your idea to 'big corp' or spend a huge amount of time, probably years, painfully making your case to various creditors and working a business up from scratch. Now the people that don't have this problem are obviously 'Big Corp'. They have lots of money and lots of resources so raising capital isn't a problem for them. Hiring lots of engineers and lots of lawyers to scrutinize the engineer's activity and then file patents on behalf of 'Big corp' isn't a problem either. Therefore 'first to file' as a matter of course will eliminate the competitiveness of 'individual inventors' and place pretty much all the market advantages granted by the patent system into the hands of massive corporations.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- learc83 14y agoFirst to file only comes into play if someone is filing a competing patent. You can no longer say that you had it in development 10 years ago and just hadn't released it. Additionally, proving first to invent is difficult and favors large companies already. >Now in business the reason you will have a long time lag from invention, prototype, and then into production is lack of capital. It's extremely expensive process and you must have significant ability, credit, and resources to take something to public in a meaningful way. There is no need to actually produce a full commercial product. All you need to do is publish your work to establish prior art. You can publish and file a patent at the invention and prototype stage. Plus, after you publish it you have up to a year to file for a patent. Invent something, publish, file for patent, and then develop it commercially. In practice first to file will have very little effect on the vast majority of patents.
- pbhjpbhj 14y ago>However, soon it's going to be first-to-file. Meaning that even if you invented something first you can still infringe on a patent if somebody else is able to get to the patent office and pay them off first. // This is how it is in the rest of the world. If patents are about giving information about inventions to the public domain in exchange for a limited time monopoly; which is the best form IMO. Then it is right to put pressure on inventors to either publish their inventions or patent them, their choice. If you find the invention valuable then you can patent it - submit a minimum sufficient disclosure to get a filing date and go on from there. If the invention is not so valuable or you want to merely protect from others filing then you can simply publish the invention. The whole idea is to get new inventions published as soon as possible with enough detail to enable skilled practitioners to recreate the invention. In the UK it is free to file an application; but you need to pay to get it processed, searched and examined. WRT your last argument are you saying that you'd rather that patents take up more court time and attract more legal expenses (which ultimately get paid by consumers)?
- jballanc 14y agoNot sure if the irony here was intentional but... > But there is no way in hell you can convince me that it’s beneficial for society to not share ideas. See, this is what's broken with the patent system. Originally, patents were supposed to encourage idea sharing. The idea being that, if you couldn't protect your ideas, then you were likely to keep them a secret. Patents give you just enough protection that you can share them. You share them, and then if the idea is good, people pay you to use that idea in their own work... So, how about this: you can get patents, but licensing fees are regulated. Say, you take the average number of patents produced by a company in a field per year, divide the average expenses for those companies by that number, and divide that total by the number of companies in the field (that might be interested in licensing the patent), and that's your regulated patent fee. This would ensure that, for example, the pharmaceutical industry (where average cost per patent is something like $10 mil) would still be able to charge appropriately high fees to license patents. The software industry, on the other hand, where patents are handed out like candy, and the number of companies that could license your patent is huge, would end up with licensing fees of something like $10. I'd pay $10 for your software patent. That's probably all it's worth.
- masklinn 14y ago> That's probably all it's worth. Although probably not, unless the parent has all the code needed to implement whatever the patent covers in the language I'm using and correctly following the conventions and patterns of the language and platform. That could be worth $10.
- Swizec 14y agoWould you pay somebody $10 for a blogpost like that? There's a bunch of those around. Most don't even have ads or any revenue stream other than infamy.
- gridspy 14y agoThat is a common misconception. Actually patents were an adaptation of an existing system where royalty would give monopolies away to companies they liked. No-one did any scientific tests at the time to ensure that they were a good idea in the first place. Now those who do retroactive studies are ignored.
- losethos 14y agoGod is just. Turn the other cheek. Walk two miles. God says... eating kinds sharpsighted envy behalf tcosa11 draw millennium convert actor Commandment muttering cellars enticed remains does distances Arise admiring name behalf sees European_Union by plead telleth tempts -unlike diving unsung_hero forenoons yeah cower full encumbrances remain much Manichee
- citricsquid 14y ago> I’m not sure it’s good for society that some professions can get paid over and over long after they did the work (say, in the case of a game developer), whereas others need to perform the job over and over to get paid (say, in the case of a hairdresser or a lawyer). Not sure I agree with this point. All professions are different, some make their money long term by providing value and gaining experience, some make their money by just doing work and some make their money by providing a product over time. A (good) hairdresser for example makes their money because of reputation, if they do great work for customers they can charge more, therefore their previous work does matter, just in a different way. An actual example of people that get no long term value from the work they do are retail workers: a shelf stacker doesn't get a "better" shelf stacking job stacking "better" things if they can stack shelves well. If people support the idea that content creators don't "deserve" to make money long term then content creators will just go further down the Steam / EA route: don't provide a product, provide that product as a service. Instead of purchasing a copy of a game, you rent access to it on a service which can be revoked at any time and is 100% controlled by the issuing company. This is what Steam is...
- aaronblohowiak 14y agoThis is also an argument against capitalists or any sort of investment, really.
- powerslave12r 14y agoI feel obligated to link to my comment thread on this issue from earlier in the week: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4263790 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4263790
- shadowmint 14y agoCommon sense speaking. Patents are indefensible nonsense. That said, I think the point he raises is interesting. There are some ideas which are entirely algorithmic and are hard. Specifically complex technical standards like video compression and encoding, machine vision, wireless signal processing, etc. These are things that require a significant capital outlay to invest in research to solve the problem, but once it's solved... well, someone else can clone the logic and make a free version. So you patent the process. If you dont, you cant guarantee a return on investment in the project, and thus you dont get investment in the project, and ultimately the problem doesn't get solved. Its an interesting thought experiment, and it makes for a good argument for patents existing. ...but then, where do you draw the line between "complex and costly" and "stupid and trivial". It's an argument I've heard a lot; I think it's nonsense too, but it convinces a lot of people. It'd be interesting to see a thoughtful critique of that argument, rather than the 'stupid patents are bad' argument, which, basically everyone already agrees on.
- powerslave12r 14y agoIn such cases, you try to convince people to pay for your idea up front. Depending on how revolutionary/badly needed this idea is, it will get funded. Kickstarter and clones are the answer.
- jandrewrogers 14y agoIf you can already prove the idea isn't nonsense then there is no need to fund the R&D. If you can't prove the idea isn't nonsense, no one will fund you. Research tends to be either self-funded or backed by funding organizations that specialize in evaluating high-risk R&D projects. Even among the organizations that specialize in it, there is a problem that there are only a handful of people in the world that can even begin to evaluate the potential of a proposal. And in those cases, the people doing the vetting do not fully understand it, but they are the best outside experts capable of detecting any subtle red flags that suggests it will fail. This is the normal state of affairs for advanced research; no normal person could hope to evaluate advanced research. Kickstarter type models would be poor for funding most types of serious research. Leaving this to popularity contests like Kickstarter is a recipe for a lot of clowns and wannabes with good PR getting funded in the absence of serious (and expensive) diligence and serious research being ignored because it can't be wrapped into a shiny soundbite that everyone understands.
- Angostura 14y agoUmmm, you can't patent an idea. You patent an invention. The problem with software patents is that the 'invention' is pretty close to idea level. Nonetheless you can't patent the idea of writing a long-form novel.
- astrodust 14y agoIf you've had a look through even a handful of these patents people are getting sued for millions over, they're basically the equivalent of the long-form novel. You could probably patent the idea of a "long click" meaning a particular type of action. Then you could go about suing someone that came up with the same idea independently.
- TomGullen 14y agoSo ideas aren't worthless? Patents have value, and some patents are apparently merely expressions of ideas.
- law 14y ago> If you've had a look through even a handful of these patents people are getting sued for millions over, they're basically the equivalent of the long-form novel. No. They're not. You say this because you, like everyone else, don't understand what the claims say. That's likely because they're written in legalese, and you're just trying your best to give those terms their plain English meaning. You can't do that. Many of them are terms of art, with very precise definitions crafted by the courts. As such, you have to look to various court opinions concerning claim construction (i.e., context) to understand their meaning. You may disagree with that on principle, because everyone should be able to understand the subject matter taken removed from the public domain as a matter of law, and I'm somewhat inclined to agree. However, nothing precludes you from gaining such an understanding: there are many books written on patent law, and it's not too incredibly complex.
- natermer 14y ago> I would personally prefer it to have those be government funded (like with CERN or NASA) and patent free as opposed to what’s happening with medicine <cut> I have to vehemently disagree with this. Copying ideas and making incremental improvements on existing inventions is the core of what makes technological progress possible. Even just plain 'ape-ing' ideas is vitally important to getting improvements available to the public. This works best in a decentralized environment. Fundamentally it is my contention that a 'wild west' scenario will yield faster and more meaningful human progress then a carefully regulated and regimented system. Assuming this is true: Then the patent system, as flawed as it is, is still superior to what was popular before it... which was official government academies were scientists and inventors were effectively wards of the state. This is uncomfortably close to what you are advocating. In that sort of system internal bureaucratic politics and 'administrative law' (which is a term meant to indicate rules-decided-by-committee) dictates the distribution of resources and activities of scientists rather then merit or actual need. I do not think that is a effective environment for the creation of innovation. I say that it's more freedom that is needed, not less.
- lukifer 14y agoInnovation can and does bounce back and forth between the public and private sectors. The Internet started life as a government-funded project before blossoming into the ultimate decentralized infrastructure.
- natermer 14y agopublic sector vs private sector metaphors are mostly nonsense. It's nice to say 'public sector' or 'publicly owned', but in reality the words and definitions are a creation of orwellian-style double speak. It's propaganda. Institutions like NASA or any other government institution is owned and controlled just as much as IBM or Microsoft. They are all a for-profit institution simply because the people working and running them are in it for themselves. Democracy seems like it would allow another means of control for the 'public' over the 'public institutions', but was easily nullified by the bi-partisan system. Effectively this country is controlled through two major political dynasties since just about the beginning. And these political dynasties are not driven by ideological differences, they exist for using political means to provide economic benefit for themselves. Democracy can only work on small scales; in city-states were they cannot control population movement. At the small scale governments are easily controlled by their tax base. On a large scale they cannot. That is to say nobody works for free. Everybody works for profit, otherwise there is no point in working and no point in participating in the institutions in the first place. And a organization is nothing but a body of participating individuals. The major difference is that government institutions are able to use the political means, that is violence, to get the funding and resources they desire. Where as a 'private' corporation either has to go through the government to get access to the political means or obtain what they want through economic means in the market place. Ultimately when you say 'public sector' versus 'private sector' you are saying 'people that work for profit that you are required to pay by law' versus 'people that work for profit that can only obtain funding through the market'. Unfortunately the government is intertwined very very deeply into the economic system of this country. When you get to the large corporations the distinction between government and private corporations is _very_ blurred.
- chmike 14y agoPatents are not (should not) be about ideas. Patents are about inventions you make and want to licence or exploit by your own. They define the invention so that your clients or yourself are protected from copycats. It is very close to copyright protection where trinity gets tazed for copying the novel. It make sense. The problem is patenting the concept of a novel. This is really questionnable. How much inventive is that ? This is where the line is fuzzy to set.
- zbowling 14y ago> If you own a software patent, you should feel bad. I have several (although all of them are "owned" by my former employers). We filed them not to attack, but to defend. I hate software patents but I don't feel bad for having them.
- gsb 14y agoWill you feel bad if one of your former employers goes out of business and the patents are bought up by someone else who will use them to attack, not defend?
- xKarl 14y agoFair point. But somehow, if you're employed, you don't own your inventions: your company does. Your company's policy is sadly not taking your beliefs in account… and if they sue people using your invention, you can't complain. So basically, you'd have to make the difference between personally owning a patent (in which case you do whatever you want with it) and inventing something for your company (in which case you can't control it).
- CamperBob2 14y agoCongratulations. That means you basically worked for a company that manufactured land mines.
- xKarl 14y agoExplain yourself. I don't see any reason to not own patents in order to protect your work from being patent trolled. Let's say you invent the novel. Right? You don't patent it because you think patents kill babies. Then I act fast enough and quickly patent the novel, because no one did so before. I did it quickly enough to make it unclear who was first. Then I sue your company for copyright infringment. Yeah, that means I'm an asshole. Doesn't matter, I'm rich now. That's why you should patent you ideas, even if you don't mind other people using them.
- 14y ago
- MysticFear 14y agoWow, so the plaintiffs have a patent on checking with a server to determine if your software is licensed. "devices that require communication with a server to perform a license check to prevent the unauthorized use of said application, including, but not limited to, Mindcraft."
- DanBC 14y agoThe patent is a little bit more complex than that. But yes, it appears to be a "thing that exists, but with online stuff added". This form of tweaking, taking an existing idea and adding a trivial modification and being able to get a patent is harmful.
- gsb 14y agoRegardless of how one feels about the ideal of software patents, the implementation leaves huge amounts to be desired with vague and obvious patents granted every day. Imagine if every time a patent was invalidated by the defence at trial, the patent office itself was ordered to pay defence costs. As one of the few government profit centers, I think you would suddenly find a big improvement in the standard of patents granted.
- taligent 14y agoThat's nice in theory. In the "real world" it would never work. The patent office would be too scared to actually award patents and even if they did the due diligence they would do would take ages. During which time copycats could come in and copy the invention. You may as well abolish patents altogether. A better solution is to punish those companies who are defeated at trial and then strip them of the patents to prevent future lawsuits.
- gsb 14y agoYou may be right about the patent office, and that would be OK by me. But for those who say that only some patents are a problem, it leaves open a nice incentive to make that distinction real. All it means is that the USPTO suffer for their own errors of judgement rather that foisting that suffering onto others. If instead you punish those defeated at trial, there are many who say that this is unfair to small players who cannot afford to make as strong a case as the really rich companies. I personally don't see this as such a great problem as they should be doing something more constructive than filing lawsuits, but I think holding the patent office accountable does not favour large players to the same degree.
- reitzensteinm 14y agoIf your patent were granted, you'd still retroactively be covered from the date of filing. Go back and sue the copycats. Your "real world" solution does nothing. Patent trolls are rapidly becoming the worst part of the current system. They have no assets, and a handful of patents. What penalties, exactly, can you impose on a shell company with no assets? gsb's proposed solution may not be perfect, but it's clearly superior to the mess we have now.
- crazyduckling 14y agoThis show called "This American Life" did a wonderful show on patents. http://www.thisamericanlife.org/radio-archives/episode/441/when-patents-attack/ http://www.thisamericanlife.org/radio-archives/episode/441/w...
- aayush 14y agoI can't remember a single case of patenting improving consumer experience in the modern era. The way I see it, patents are designed to improve capitalist behaviour, once where your ideas are protected: the march towards innovation is strictly optional. It's time instead to consider how dependent our world is on iterative practices. Everything we build on and upon is no longer unique: it's all inspired, and improved. Jim Jarmusch said this once: >Nothing is original. Steal from anywhere that resonates with inspiration or fuels your imagination. Devour old films, new films, music, books, paintings, photographs, poems, dreams, random conversations, architecture, bridges, street signs, trees, clouds, bodies of water, light and shadows. To embrace iteration, we need to get rid of patents. That much is certain.
- taligent 14y agoDyson Vacuum Cleaners. One sole inventor who developed 5,127+ prototype designs and clearly brought something unique to the marketplace. Gave his whole life and money to the product. Almost immediately after it came out Hoover copied the design and basically would have put him out of business. The patents were the ONLY thing that protected him from a huge multinational who didn't invent anything. Now Dyson went on to invent a whole range of very cool gadgets which never would have existed without patents.
- radio4fan 14y agoInterestingly, the Dyson design was based on an existing cyclone system widely used to separate out dust and particles in industrial settings. The innovation was using the process in a domestic vacuum cleaner. So it's not too far removed from the "thing-that-already-exists but on the internet" patents which are a large part of the problem, or the "thing-that-already-exists but on a mobile" patent which is biting Notch's ass at the moment. Not that I'm saying Dyson's patents are invalid, nor that his designs haven't improved the state of the art in several fields, but he didn't invent the cyclone technology in a... vacuum.
- kenjackson 14y agoYou don't know what may have never existed with no patents. Maybe Jobs doesn't even consider the iPhone. This sort of thing is just speculative without a control.
- flexie 14y agoDebating whether patents are good without differentiating on industries seems wrong to me. I've been involved in investments in pharmaceutical companies and investments in IT companies. Those are two completely different worlds. In the pharmaceutical world founders and employees more often have large opportunity costs by starting or joining a new venture. They are usually in their 30s or 40s with huge student loans, mortgage and kids. They forgo high incomes if they join a start-up. The road to the market is much longer (often more than 10 years). Investment in machinery is also at a completely different level. Drug development usually entails million dollar investment in specialized equipment. Perhaps the most costly aspect of drug development is the regulatory obstacles, such as getting approvals. In contrast, IT companies are cheap. Founders often have little formal education (Microsoft, Facebook, Skype) and the road to market is much shorter. IT start-ups expect customers (or at least users) in a matter of weeks or months. Many IT companies can get to proof of concept with almost no investment in equipment. The founders simply bring their laptops on board). Regulatory concerns, if any, can usually be dealt with by one lawyer in a few days. I cannot imagine anyone investing hundreds of millions of dollars in drug development over the course of 10 years without some assurance that competitors can't "steal" their idea. Usually that assurance is a patent or a trade secret. But keeping secrets over 10 years with employees coming and going - that's difficult. tl;dr: Once you have an idea about, say a shopping cart in a web store, it can be implemented in a few man-weeks. Turning an idea about a new drug into a product often takes thousands of man-years. Whereas the institution of patents seems harmful in the world of software development, it may be necessary in the world drug development.
- dasil003 14y agoOf course the flip side is that if a drug is not patentable then research stops. More effective drugs are replaced with slightly modified, possibly less effective or more dangerous, and definitely shorter track record drugs just to preserve profit margins. If natural compounds are more effective in treating some condition, today's pharmaceutical industry will do all they can to avoid discovering that. Sure drugs are expensive to development, but I'm not sure that the twisted system of incentives is beneficial overall. Of course the industry will claim that none of this research would happen without patents, but of course they are set up that way and can't imagine it any other way. I doubt that humanity as a whole would simply stop advanced medical research because the economics changed.
- noonespecial 14y ago"If you own a software patent, you should feel bad." You might think its "just for defense" and have the best of intentions, but like landmines and toxic waste, the patent will almost certainly outlive your use for it and wind up in hands other than your own. So there it is: Patents are like the toxic waste of innovation. You promise yourself to keep them safely contained, but its hard to do in the real world and once they spill, they contaminate everything around them, making the ground uninhabitable for 20 odd years. Feel bad.
- Heinleinian 14y agoPresumably there's some kind of legal construct that could act as a poison pill. i.e. some kind of contract that says "if this patent is used for [insert evil purposes here], it is immediately converted to GPL." Also, I refuse to lump defensive patent holders in with organizations like shell-corporation patent trolls or Intellectual Ventures. From what I can tell, IV isn't even bothering to try and execute on ideas they come up with. They simply brainstorm, apply for the patent based on the idea vapors, and then go after anyone who is putting in the blood and sweat to try and actually build it.
- Produce 14y agoI think that a better analogy is thinking of patents as nuclear weapons. What we need at this point is a disarmament treaty.
- Kronopath 14y agoWhat about a patent under something like Twitter's Innovator's Patent Agreement? http://blog.twitter.com/2012/04/introducing-innovators-patent-agreement.html http://blog.twitter.com/2012/04/introducing-innovators-paten...
- huhtenberg 14y ago> If you own a software patent, you should feel bad. You should feel bad if you enforce it. Practically speaking, if I hadn't had a patent granted while I was doing my first startup, I would've never gotten the acquisition valuation I got. It's a part of the game, you just have to have an "IP." Do I think this is retarded? Sure. Do I feel bad that I got a patent? No.
- cgs1019 14y agoI agree wholeheartedly with your sentiment but call foul your pejorative use of the word "retarded". It's just too easy not to compare bad things to "other" groups. English is a great and vast language; show some respect.
- huhtenberg 14y agoDo suggest alternatives. I am not a native speaker.
- cgs1019 14y agoSorry for incorrectly presuming you used it knowingly. The word "retarded" as it is commonly used in modern colloquial English originates with its use to describe people with mental disabilities of one form or another: they were at one time classified broadly as "mentally retarded". That was gradually abbreviated as "retarded", which has gradually been used as an insulting term for all manner of things (including but by no means limited to humans).
- huhtenberg 14y agoI know what the word means. I also know its slang meaning, which you appear to be ignoring. Now, please do suggest an alternative that carries the same expressive load in a similarly succulent manner, but without being "offensive to other groups".
- cgs1019 14y ago
- antjohnst 14y agoI think that whilst notch has raised some valid points, he has really written an argument based on half the picture. I believe that maybe notch should read up more on criteria of patentability, other patent areas, and the feasibility of having everything 'funded by government' and perhaps share some of that too. I agree that something like a software patent may be a bad idea, but you have to realise that a lot of people read your stuff and get influenced by this 'half of the patent picture' and then leave with the wrong idea and start criticising legitimate patent areas. For example: Company A spends $200M of investors money finding a new anti-depressant. Ok so they invested all of this money, now they need to spend 8 years proving to the FDA that it is safe to use, there goes another $300M. 'Generic pharmacies inc' says hey, thanks for doing all that work, now we can manufacture that drug in our factory for 1c/pill and make a little bit of money, good luck recouping your research money because we just got all the cheap sales. Company A goes bankrupt, the investors lose their money. Company B and C notice this industry is poor for research, and decide never to spend that money finding an anti brain-tumor agent. However, if company A had patented their idea, then they will have around 10-15 years of patent-protected time (because they have to patent before divulging it, and by the time you get through trials and approval you can often have just a few years left) to sell their drug at a price where they can recoup their $500M, and invest in more bigger and better research. Meanwhile, whilst patented, other companies can see that research and build upon it with their own research - they just cant rip them off with the money they are owed in that time by selling it without permission. If they really want to sell it, they can ask the company to license it to them, and pay royalties. Later, the patent expires, as all of them do, and then generic company is free to manufacture it without paying the inventor a cent. Is this not a valid reason for patents? I'm sorry notch but you cant copyright a pill, even though that copyright law may protect your own interests (minecraft)
- TomGullen 14y agoIdeas are worthless, that's what everyone likes to repeat. I've raised the example before that ideas aren't worthless, for example patents have value but was criticised because "patents are not ideas, they are execution". Notch seems to think patents are ideas. I don't know enough about patents to really draw a conclusion as to if they are expressions of ideas or executions of ideas. Also, the example of writing your own similar book is quite a clumsy one for patent infringement.
- antjohnst 14y agoI agree the example is clumsy because people will find it hard in that example to imagine why a novel is patentable (because it is obviously not in our world, ironically lacking the criteria of being "novel"!) I felt like notch matured a while ago but this is a surprisingly childish rant from him, i honestly felt it was a bit below him. He has a point, a valid point, but he has not conveyed it very well, and has caused collatoral damage to other valid fields for patents in the process of criticizing software patents.
- TomGullen 14y agoI totally agree, I really like Notch usually. His posts are concise, to the point and honest. This one isn't very well thought out and is adding more confusion into the pot.
- billswift 14y agoBefore you get too wrapped up in the idea of "other valid fields for patents", you might check out some of those other fields. There is actually quite a bit of evidence against patents in many other fields as well, though the only link I have handy is to Derek Lowe's discussions related to pharma - http://pipeline.corante.com/archives/patents_and_ip/ http://pipeline.corante.com/archives/patents_and_ip/
- antjohnst 14y agoHave a read of my other comment on the page (search antjohnst to speed up finding it) giving an example in the pharma industry.
- joseph4521 14y agoEach time I see a patent related article on Hacker News, I'm thankful that software patents don't exist in Europe. That's at least one thing we got right.
- stoodder 14y agoHonest question, if I have a software idea and am thinking about patenting it, but then don't (although I've developed the idea), what happens if someone else re-creates the idea and then patents it themselves. Would I now be infringing on their patent?
- redsymbol 14y ago(Am not a lawyer, but am a tech entrepreneur whose job is to somewhat understand patent law:) Yes, you would, in the USA. If you are not ever sued for infringing, nor asked to pay licensing fees by an agent of the patent holder, nothing happens and it's effectively moot. This is the most likely outcome. If you are sued/asked to pay, you could try to invalidate the patent (or threaten that) because there is prior art... i.e. your implementation. You can only do that if you can prove that you implemented it, at a specific date sometime before the patent filing. This may not be easy. In fact - and ideally, there is a USPTO officer reading this who can comment - it may be the case that something can only be considered prior art if it's been published in a textbook, tech industry journal article, etc. (Or if there another existing patent for it). Ideally your evidence is so strong, the patent holder will look at it and decide it's not worth taking you to court (i.e. they believe they will lose, or even risk getting their patent invalidated). Then they back away slowly from you, going after easier prey. If you go to court for any reason, it's likely to be a long, hard drain on your energy, time and money.
- stoodder 14y agoAwesome, thanks for the reply. I'll take a look a bit deeper, but this really helps a lot.
- Natsu 14y agoIf you publish it openly somewhere that a date can be clearly established, you can create prior art that might prevent someone else from getting a patent on it. Be sure to cover as many of the minor, obvious generalizations or adaptations as you can.
- bjornsing 14y agoTo quote robomartin (http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4275361 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4275361): "I am not against patents. I am against the granting of patents for non-inventions." The main problem IMHO is the cultural definition of "obviousness" among patent examiners. They seem to think a) that (in practice) all meaningful prior art is patented so all they have to do to find it is search their patent databases and b) the slightest difference between prior art and a new "invention" makes the "invention" non-obvious. IMHO prior art should be whatever you can find in library and (more importantly) on the Internet. The test should be that the difference is non-obvious "to a person skilled in the art", i.e. the inventive step itself has to be non-obvious.
- patrickmay 14y agoExactly. If it can be proven that an alleged infringer actually came up with the same idea independently, that should demonstrate that the idea is not non-obvious and therefore the patent is invalid.
- stcredzero 14y agoFrom the patent examiner AMA on reddit, and from comments that patent law professionals have made here, it seems that those involved with patents are a bit out of touch with the reality for software professionals. The patent database is a tool, it's not reality. The way that patents are written and treated is also out of touch with reality.
- hbharadwaj 14y agoI keep thinking that they should not allow companies to sue on patents unless the patent has been implemented in one of the company's products, currently in market. Exception of course being algorithmic patents - compression techniques etc., - These could be made FRAND. My comment is vaguely generic and there may be lots of exceptions but the first part would eliminate a lot of the patent trolls I keep hearing about.
- grellas 14y agoIf you own a software patent, you should feel bad. Even as someone who feels we should be rid of software patents, I cannot for the life of me understand this statement. I can believe, philosophically, that relatively high tax rates will benefit a society. That doesn't mean that, even in so believing, I wouldn't do my utmost to minimize the tax that I pay within the rules provided by the law. The question before me when I make such decisions is what makes sense for me as an economic actor, not what the broader policy for society should be. And there is no reason I should "feel bad" for acting in my own self-interest in that case even if I believe the rules should be otherwise. So too, if I am a founder, I can abhor the idea of software patents while still using the full range of IP protections afforded by the law to enhance the value of my startup. If getting a software patent for my company's early-stage innovations enhances funding valuation, acquisition pricing, and competitive edge in the marketplace - and if the law says this is a perfectly legal way not only to protect but also to gain monopoly protection over intangible assets that my company has and others don't - my decision here will turn on weighing the costs of getting such protection (money costs, disclosure risks, etc.) versus the benefits, the likelihood of qualifying for it, and similar considerations having nothing whatever to do with the abstract policy debate concerning whether the law should afford such protection in the first place. What is more, if I don't avail myself of such protections and if a competitor later does so in a way that hurts my venture's prospects because I now have to surmount legal barriers that wouldn't even have been there had I acted to protect my company's legal interests in the first place, then I have done affirmative harm to the people who trusted me to run my company to its best advantage - whether they be my investors, my co-founders, my employees, or just my own family members who might suffer if that venture should fail. This does not mean I need to blindly pursue some form of artificial legal protections for my company's innovations. It means that I need to make intelligent judgments about availing myself of such protections as opposed simply to categorically rejecting the idea of using them. In short, I need to be smart about protecting my venture using the tools afforded by the law and not forego those tools out of some philosophical preconceptions I have about what the law should be. The "should-be" part of the law is basically irrelevant in this context for most entrepreneurial decisions of this type. And there is certainly no reason to "feel bad" owning software patents if they turn out to be helpful for one's venture in this context. Maybe this will be seen as narrow, unenlightened, lawyer-driven thinking. It is, however, my universal experience in having dealt with countless founders over many years. Without exception, they have all acted consistently with the pattern I describe and there is no reason they shouldn't have. It makes perfect sense for a rational economic actor. Startups have enough risks as they are. There is no reason to add to them artificially owing to social pressures telling you to "feel bad" for doing what is right for your company. I know the sentiments against software patents are strong here on HN but there is a big difference between a policy debate seeking to influence Congress and actions that make sense for individual actors having to deal with the realities of the law as it exists today. One can condemn the idea of software patents generally without necessarily passing censorious judgments about the actors who need to deal with the law as they find it.
- Craiggybear 14y agoI think the best way to associate your involvement in the development of software is not to take out patents but to publish your work -- and in that way your name is firmly associated with the work ... patents for software are just plain stupid. What matters, and carries more kudos, is having a published record with peer review.
- robomartin 14y agoLet's stop for a moment boys and girls to fix one recurring theme in some of these blog posts and discussions: You are not supposed to be able to patent ideas. There's a reduction to practice requirement. Sadly, I must say that there are tons of patents out there that are nothing more than ideas or concepts turned into patents. I've run into lots of them in the hundreds of patents I must have read over the years. They fact that they are or were mere ideas becomes a glaring reality when you look into actually implementing the patent and discover that nothing works as advertised. This is another sad failing of the USPTO: While the rules of the game say that ideas are not patentable, in reality, they are. So, yes, I contradict my first statement. I still prefer to speak with more precision when it comes to patents and not say things like "patent you idea" or "people like to file patents to protect their ideas". You are not supposed to be able to do that.
- klawed 14y ago>The problem with this argument is that patents apply even if the infringer came up with the idea independently. While I agree that our broken patent system is in dire need of reform, I'm not in favor of complete abolishment. That said, if an accused infringer claimed that she had come up with the idea independently I can't imagine a fair method of proving or disproving that. Hence, I don't see how one could make exceptions for independently developed ideas that aren't prior art.
- gfodor 14y agoThis is a mind-bogglingly simplistic and broken argument against patents. The main argument is by analogy and argument is patents suck because they prevent the sharing of ideas. These are both horrible ways to argue against the patent system. I guess it's garnered a large number of upvotes because of the author?
- magicalist 14y agoThose aren't analogies, they're examples, and software patents are almost exactly patents on ideas, not inventions. "Although the invention has been described by way of examples of preferred embodiments, it is to be understood that various other adaptations and modifications can be made within the spirit and scope of the invention." Good luck with that when the only invention actually described is a "system" that embodies the ideas described in the claims.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- JVIDEL 14y agoIs funny how things work out: patents which are meant to stave off copycats from profiting off someone else's work end up being snatched by patent trolls who sue anyone who does something even remotely similar even if they had no idea there was a patent on it. Meanwhile copycats always find a loophole, they much like patent trolls hire the best lawyers to protect themselves and keep blatantly stealing from others, sometimes going as far as copying the logo and other minor details, showing they don't want to compete but to deceive consumers of the original to use the copy. Either way the innovator gets shafted, specially when the patent troll or copycat is an even bigger company.
- jliptzin 14y agoTo kill software patents, don't abstain from patenting software. Do the opposite. Flood the patent office with so many ridiculous and obvious software patents and clog up their system so bad, they'll be forced to deny all of them or just let applications sit pending for decades.
- tysont 14y agoPlease, please, please do not hand the development of new drugs over to the government. Also, if you're going to make an odd blanket statement that ends up being a lynchpin of your argument like "patents in software are trivial" at least try to unpack it or back it up somehow. Microsoft (for example, via MSR) dumps a sh ton of $ into research to come up with some ideas that end up being software, so how is that different than the biotech scenario?
- scott_meade 14y ago"But there is no way in hell you can convince me that it’s beneficial for society to not share ideas." Sorry, but Notch has it backwards. Patents are designed to for sharing - not for preventing sharing. (Patent holder shares information on how they implemented something in exchange for being granted temporary rights to deliver on the method implementation.) I know I'm being naively simplistic in that statement. Yet so is Notch in his analogy. I've found no one who claims that "it's beneficial for society to not share ideas". Setting up a straw man makes for juicy debate, but not great argument.
- gavanwoolery 14y agoYes, patents suck. But talking will do nothing. We need to literally put our collective money where our mouthes are. I am only half joking, but somebody please run a Kickstarter campaign with the goal of reforming the patent system, I will gladly donate. We need to lobby the sh_t out of our government. Start stuffing money in their pockets - this is the only thing the beast understands. Get them to phase out the patent system - that is, issue no new patents, wait for current patents to expire. We also need to create an alliance of companies that agree to never sue each other over existing patents. We need to publicly shame companies (namely, patent trolls) that use patents solely for exploitation. Yes, maybe these ideas are dumb or naive, but they would still be more effective than just talking about it...
- pbhjpbhj 14y ago>you want to profit from all novels that are ever written // Patents are time limited so that's out. If Trinity, nor anyone else had seen your novel (as described in full in the patent application he fails to mention that he submits - this is key as copyright is an automatic right but patents are not) would they have come up with the idea? If they would then why hadn't they? How long would it have taken them to come up with the idea? More than 20 years? Suppose the idea of a novel was so revolutionary that it never would have been created by anyone else ... is it worth a monopoly on the idea for 20 years to ensure that you open up that idea and share it with society for the rest of time? Trinity of course can research your idea freely. She can use your idea. Indeed when she does use it privately she has an idea, based on yours, of a trilogy. Now, you're kicking yourself, Neo, wondering why you didn't think of that. Of course if Neo hadn't submitted his patent application in the first place then she never would have had the details on which to build her idea ...
- Greendogo 14y agoI don't think patents OR copyrights are moral. You shouldn't have the ability to stop people from using ideas in their mind (which belongs to them) even if you were the one who came up with the idea originally and put it into their mind. Other people's brains don't belong to you, neither does their equipment for making books, games, movies, music, medicine or anything else. If they can make it, why the hell should you be able to stop them from using their hands and their property to turn out exact duplicates of your own creations? By the way Notch, I disagree with you on the government research thing. Government is terrible at just about everything. Instead, vital research should be done by the free market, but without the protection of patents or copyrights, as anyone who owns either is automatically a troll. In a decade or three we'll be able to ask a computer to invent medicines and technology on the spot, so why should we let one person dominate something that is going to be so easy to discover and produce in such a short amount of time?