2 ms·
At this point someone please explain to me how finance doesn't exist to extract wealth from the rest of us.
by amelius 2y ago
At this point someone please explain to me how finance doesn't exist to extract wealth from the rest of us.
- fxtentacle 2y agoIt's called capitalism because we use capital to allocate value creation. So obviously finance extracts wealth, that's their job in a capitalist system.
- DrScientist 2y agoWe only allocate to value creation if there is a functioning free market. The banks profit margins would suggest that they are not really facing the fierce winds of competition.
- amelius 2y agoBut in the case of OP the value creation does not happen because they are working in finance instead of in a job creating value. I want to see some decent analysis of the situation, not stories about how the system is supposed to work.
- mewpmewp2 2y agoDecision of where to allocate money creates value. Imagine you have 500k to allocate. You can choose to invest in A or B, after analysis you realize A is a failing business, but B with 500k invested will create enormous value by producing product C. If you didn't allocate in B this company wouldn't have had enough money to produce C and succeed.
- amelius 2y agoYes, but this can still be true if the system works in a perverted way. In your example, you should include how many $ go to the entity doing the allocation. If this is an insane amount of money, then maybe we are better off without finance and just figure out the optimal allocation in some other way.
- mewpmewp2 2y agoBut who will do that other way of optimally allocating? To take a simple extreme edge case, let's imagine that there's a business that requires 500k to truly flourish, but if it gets that 500k, it will become $10B company within 5 years. If it doesn't get the 500k it will likely fail. Only 1 person has noticed and believes that this business would have that potential. And let's say they either have 500k or they manage to convince others to get the 500k, how much of that $10B would they deserve?
- skirge 2y agoif money come from printer and not from factory you need a "printer operator", not a worker or engineer
- mjburgess 2y agoThe job of secondary financial markets is to redirect areas of surplus unproductive wealth (that makes no return), to productive areas. By the magic of markets, sustained profitability = productive use of resources. The problem with labourers who work in these secondary markets however, is the same as the guards who watch the gate: they can extract large tolls for being in the right place at the right time. People in finance are rich because they're well-placed to skim highly productive traffic. However, it is -- in the vast majority of cases -- only skimming. The system functions very well to take unproductive surplus and allocate it effectively. Though admittedly today, the larger beneficiaries are increasingly monpolies, and so on. But this isnt a side effect of the finance industry, but of the state.
- lordnacho 2y ago> The system functions very well to take unproductive surplus and allocate it effectively. How do you quantify this?
- mjburgess 2y agofeels^2 But also, profit margins of major industries; amount of wealth held liquid; and so on. You might have a moral idea of 'effective' in mind, which may not be realised. I mean only that one does not find cash lying around the vautls of the ritch -- as in pre-modern times. People do not bury gold as jesus advised. Rather they dont keep gold, it is a line item held by a business doing something with it.
- amelius 2y agoI've heard this many times, but where is the proof? How would you apply it to the story of OP?
- bell-cot 2y agoThis...but a twisted, bloated, incompetent, and malevolently self-serving version of it. Actual efficiency would dictate that there be only a relative handful of finance jobs, let alone very well-paid finance jobs. And that the vast majority of the money go to actually productive industries. And that the financial markets understand the principles and timescales of other industries, so they don't screw everything up with decisions equivalent to "Fiscal quarter ends in June, and Farmer Jones says he can harvest zero corn by then. Shut him down."
- hoppp 2y agoThe modern monetary system is a big pyramid scheme so...
- Dalewyn 2y agoIt's actually Pretty Bloody Hard(tm) to store or move money/wealth safely and properly, not the least because most of us are all highwaymen when given the opportunity. Banks exist to try and bring some civility to that madness, with the cost being (ideally) a pittance skimmed from the top to keep their highwaymen tendencies at bay. If you want to call them a protection racket akin to the mafia... you're probably right. Of course, banks these days are much more than that and there's plenty to rightfully crucify them for. But even still, there's a reason being called a third-rate bank clerk is an insult among the highest order.
- pja 2y agoFinance jobs in London / New York (partially) can afford those pay rates because they extract wealth from the rest of the world. Whether they do so in return for services rendered or are extracting rents by acting as gatekeepers is a question that never quite gets resolved. A little of each I suspect, depending on the context.