6 ms·
Under new law, cops bust famous cartoonist for AI-generated CSAM
- falcor84 2y ago> "The creation of CSAM using AI is inherently harmful to children because the machine-learning models utilized by AI have been trained on datasets containing thousands of depictions of known CSAM victims," it says, "revictimizing these real children by using their likeness to generate AI CSAM images into perpetuity." The word "inherently" there seems like a big stretch to me. I see how it could be harmful to them, but I also see an argument for how such AI generated material is a substitute for the actual CSAM. Has this actually been studied, or is it a taboo topic for policy research?
- paulryanrogers 2y agoBenefiting from illegal acts is also a crime, even if indirect. Like getting a cheap stereo that happens to have been stolen. A case could also be made that the likenesses of the victims could retramatize them, especially if someone knew the connection and continued to produce similar output to taunt them.
- willis936 2y agoIt sounds like we should be asking "why is it okay that the people training the models have CSAM?" It's not like it's legal to have, let alone distribute in your for-profit tool.
- wbl 2y agoRead the sentence again. It doesn't claim the data set has CSAM but that it depicts victims. It also assumes that you need AI to see an example to draw it on demand which isn't true.
- grapesodaaaaa 2y agoYeah. I don’t like it, but I can see this getting overturned.
- wongarsu 2y agoIf you crawl any sufficiently large public collection of images you are bound to download some CSAM images by accident. Filtering out any images of beaten up naked 7 year olds is certainly something you should do. But if you go by the US legal definition of "any visual depiction of sexually explicit conduct involving a minor (someone under 18 years of age)" you are going to have a really hard time filtering all of that automatically. People don't suddenly look differently when they turn 18, and "sexually explicit" is a wide net open to interpretation.
- willis936 2y ago"It's hard" isn't a sufficient reason. Supply chain and infrastructure that makes safe food widely available is hard. We do it anyway because it's the right thing to do.
- metalcrow 2y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Relationship_between_child_pornography_and_child_sexual_abuse https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Relationship_between_child_por... is a good starting link on this. When i last checked, there were maybe 5 studies total (imagine how hard it is to get those approved by the ethics committees), all of which found different results, some totally the opposite of each other. Then again, it already seems clear that violent video games do not cause violence, and access to pornography does not increase sexual violence, so this case being the opposite would be unusual.
- harshreality 2y agoThe few studies on "video games cause violence" I've seen have been extremely limited in scope. They're too concerned with short-term frequency of playing particular games, or desire to play them. They're not concerned enough with the influence of being quite familiar with such games, or how cultural prevalence of such games normalizes thoughts of certain behaviors and shifts the Overton window. There are also selection bias problems. I'd expect media and games to more greatly affect people already psychologically unstable or on the criminal fringe... not people likely to be study participants. Studies on sexual violence and changes in that over time have even more problems, for example how difficult it is to get average people to report accurately about their private relationships. Those people likely to volunteer accurate information are not necessarily representative.
- defrost 2y agoThere's a legally challengable assertion there; "trained on CSAM images". I imagine an AI image generation model could be readily trained on images of adult soldiers at war and images of children from instagram and then be used to generate imagery of children at war. I have zero interest in defending exploitation of children, the assertion that children had to have been exploited in order to create images of children engaged in adult activities seems shaky. * * FWiW I'm sure there are AI models out there that were trained on actual real world CSAM .. it's the implied neccessity that's being questioned here.
- jsheard 2y agoIt is known that the LAION dataset underpinning foundation models like Stable Diffusion contained at least a few thousand instances of real-life CSAM at one point. I think you would be hard-pressed to prove that any model trained on internet scrapes definitively wasn't trained on any CSAM whatsoever. https://www.theverge.com/2023/12/20/24009418/generative-ai-image-laion-csam-google-stability-stanford https://www.theverge.com/2023/12/20/24009418/generative-ai-i...
- defrost 2y ago> I think you would be hard-pressed to prove that any model trained on internet scrapes definitively wasn't trained on any CSAM whatsoever. I'd be hard pressed to prove that you definitely hadn't killed anybody ever. Legally if it's asserted that these images are criminal because they are the result of being the product of an LLM trained on sources that contained CSAM then the requirement would be to prove that assertion. With text and speech you could prompt the model to exactly reproduce a Sarah Silverman monologue and assert that proves her content was used in the training set, etc. Here the defense would ask the prosecution to demonstrate how to extract a copy of original CSAM. But your point is well taken, it's likely most image generation programs of this nature have been fed at least one image that was borderline jailbait and likely at least one that was well below the line.
- jsheard 2y agoFraming it in that way is essentially a get out of jail free card - anyone caught with CSAM can claim it was AI generated by a "clean" model, and how would the prosecution ever be able to prove that it wasn't? I get where you are coming from but it doesn't seem actionable in any way that doesn't effectively legalize CSAM possession, so I think courts will have no choice but to put the burden of proof on the accused. If you play with fire then you'd better have the receipts.
- ilaksh 2y agoYou probably have a point and I am not sure that these people know how image generation actually works. But regardless of a likely erroneous legal definition, it seems obvious that there needs to be a law in order to protect children. Because you can't tell. Just like there should be a law against abusing robots that look like extremely lifelike children in the future when that is possible. Or any kind of abuse of adult lifelike robots either. Because the behavior is too similar and it's too hard to tell the difference between real and imagined. So allowing the imaginary will lead to more of the real, sometimes without the person even knowing.
- Hizonner 2y agoThe word "revictimizing" seems like an even bigger stretch. Assuming the output images don't actually look like them personally (and they won't), how exactly are they more victimized than anybody else in the training data? Those other people's likenesses are also "being used to generate AI CSAM images into perpetuity"... in a sort of attenuated way that's hard to even find if you're not desperately trying to come up with something. The cold fact is that people want to outlaw this stuff because they find it icky. Since they know it's not socially acceptable (quite yet) to say that, they tend to cast about wildly until they find something to say that sort of sounds like somebody is actually harmed. They don't think critically about it once they land on a "justification". You're not supposed to think critically about it either.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- ashleyn 2y agoI always found these arguments to be contrived especially when it's already well-known that in the tradition of every Western government, there is no actual imperative for every crime to be linked directly to a victim. It's a far better argument to me, to suggest that the societal utility in using the material to identify and remove paedophiles before they have an actual victim far exceeds the utility of any sort of "freedom" to such material.
- error_logic 2y agoIf only the same logic had applied to Trump.
- yellowapple 2y ago> It's a far better argument to me, to suggest that the societal utility in using the material to identify and remove paedophiles before they have an actual victim far exceeds the utility of any sort of "freedom" to such material. Or at the very least: flag pedophiles for further investigation, including one's social network. Even if a given pedophile hasn't actually harmed any children, one probably is acquainted with other pedophiles, possibly ones who have harmed children. Softening the punishment for CSAM possession in and of itself could actually help with investigating the creation of (non-simulated) CSAM by this logic, since people tend to be more cooperative to investigators when they think they have done nothing wrong and have nothing to hide.
- adrr 2y agoBe interesting to see how this pans out in terms of the 1st amendment. Without a victim, it would be interesting to see how the courts rule. They could say its inherently unconstitutional but for sake of the general public, it is fine. This would be similar to the supreme court ruling on DUI checkpoints.
- PessimalDecimal 2y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Legal_status_of_fictional_pornography_depicting_minors#United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Legal_status_of_fictional_porn... comments a little on this and suggests that some of the existing laws have been tested in court already. Still, it's probably better not to be involve in a case like United States vs. $YOU and then have your name appear in this Wikipedia article.
- jrockway 2y agoI think the victim is "the state". The law seems to say that by creating a model using CSAM, certain outputs are CSAM, and the law can say whatever it wants to some extent; you just have to convince the Supreme Court that you're right.
- olliej 2y agoThe Supreme Court ruled already that there does not need to be a victim, or even any real people at all in its justification to permit refusal of service to lgbt people. So I’m unsure why even if there were no victims that would be relevant. To me the problem here is they might identify someone with a problem, but then send them to jail with essentially the same label as an actual pedofile or rapist, and prisons in the US exist as a source of slave labor and future criminals rather than any kind of rehab. So person goes in who is already clearly fucked up (not necessarily this case, assume some case where it’s clearly be demonstrated guilt or whatever) and then comes out with a pile of trauma and no employment prospects and it seems like a sure fire way to create an actual dangerous pedo/abuser. I think a better equivalence would be the treatment of alcohol - alcoholics don’t go to jail immediately, not even when driving, it requires them failing to get the alcoholism treated, or actually harming people for them to end up in jail.
- empressplay 2y agoIn British Columbia both text-based accounts (real and fictional, such as stories) and drawings of underage sexual activity are illegal (basically any sort of depiction, even if it just comes out of your mouth.) So California is just starting to catch up.
- userbinator 2y agoWrong country (at least for now...!)
- skissane 2y agoNot wrong country. In 2021, a Texas man was sentenced to 40 years in federal prison over CSAM text and drawings - https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/texas-man-sentenced-40-years-prison-running-child-obscenity-website https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/texas-man-sentenced-40-years-...
- metalcrow 2y agoSpecifically, this ruling does not make that kind of content illegal. This person was convicted under federal obscenity statues, which are....fuzzy to say the least. As Supreme Court justice Potter Stewart said, it's a "i know it when i see it" thing. Which in effect is basically a "you can go to jail if we think you're too gross" law.
- drinpt 2y ago[flagged]
- skissane 2y ago> Specifically, this ruling does not make that kind of content illegal. I don't know exactly what you mean by that, but if you can get a 40 year prison sentence for "that kind of content", then it is illegal. > This person was convicted under federal obscenity statues, which are....fuzzy to say the least. So are child pornography statutes. Canada's [0] has lots of subjective clauses open to judicial interpretation, such as whether the content "has a legitimate purpose related to.. science, medicine, education or art". How do you draw that line? Potter Stewart’s famous quip applies here too [0] https://laws-lois.justice.gc.ca/eng/acts/c-46/section-163.1.html https://laws-lois.justice.gc.ca/eng/acts/c-46/section-163.1....
- grapesodaaaaa 2y agoQuestion for anyone that knows, but what happens if a 16 year old draws a naked picture of their 16 year old partner?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- alwa 2y agoLast I heard, depending on local attitudes, potentially jail. For that matter, minors can be charged for producing images of themselves. The CSAM laws in the US tend not to draw distinctions between first- and third-party production: https://www.ojp.gov/ncjrs/virtual-library/abstracts/blurring-line-between-victim-and-offender-self-produced-child https://www.ojp.gov/ncjrs/virtual-library/abstracts/blurring... https://www.innocentlivesfoundation.org/threat-of-sg-csam/ https://www.innocentlivesfoundation.org/threat-of-sg-csam/ https://www.findlaw.com/criminal/criminal-charges/child-pornography-and-selfies--what-you-need-to-know.html https://www.findlaw.com/criminal/criminal-charges/child-porn...
- Hizonner 2y agoDepends on where you are. In some places in the world, into the gulag with them. In fact, they can get gulaged if they draw a picture of a totally imaginary 16 year old, let alone a real person. It's kind of in dispute in the US, but that'd be the way to bet. 'Course, in a lot of US states, they're also in trouble for having a "partner" at all. In practice, they'd probably have to distribute the picture somehow to draw the attention to get them arrested, and anyway they'd be a low priority compared to people producing, distributing, or even consuming, you know, real child porn... but if the right official decided to make an example of them, they'd be hosed.
- olliej 2y agoI mean there have already been people reported to police or having all accounts cancelled for the kind of images most families have of their children growing up. This entirely ignores what happens when you have states classifying telling a child “it’s ok to be gay/trans” as child abuse, or even just being gay/trans as a sex crime - which plenty of states in the US have said that they want to do. Typically the same states and people that actively support child abuse by banning actual sex ed, and normalizing child molestation.
- tetrisgm 2y agoBetween the 3D printed weapons and the AI CSAM, this year is already shaping up to be wild in terms of misuses of technology. I suppose that’s one downside of adoption.
- Hizonner 2y agoThe main "3D printed weapons" scare was years ago. The current thing is just a blip.
- NotYourLawyer 2y agoHow are 3D printed weapons a misuse?
- tlack 2y agoI believe the parent poster was referring to recent efforts in New York State to require licensure and background checks to purchase a 3D printer [1] [1] https://www.nysenate.gov/legislation/bills/2025/A2228 https://www.nysenate.gov/legislation/bills/2025/A2228
- danaris 2y agoIf it's AI-generated, it is fundamentally not CSAM. The reason we shifted to the terminology "CSAM", away from "child pornography", is specifically to indicate that it is Child Sexual Abuse Material: that is, an actual child was sexually abused to make it. You can call it child porn if you really want, but do not call something that never involved the abuse of a real, living, flesh-and-blood child "CSAM". (Or "CSEM"—"Exploitation" rather than "Abuse"—which is used in some circles.) This includes drawings, CG animations, written descriptions, videos where such acts are simulated with a consenting (or, tbh, non consenting—it can be horrific, illegal, and unquestionably sexual assault without being CSAM) adult, as well as anything AI-generated. These kinds of distinctions in terminology are important, and yes I will die on this hill.
- ashleyn 2y agoThis is where my technical knowledge of genAI breaks down, but wouldn't an image generator be unable to produce such imagery unless honest-to-god CSAM were used in the training of it?
- 6ix8igth 2y agoIt's possible for the model to take disparate concepts and put them together. E.g. you can train a LORA to teach stable diffusion what a cowboy hat it is, then ask for Dracula in a cowboy hat.that probably doesn't exist in it's training data, but it will give it to you just fine. I'm not about to try, but I would assume the same would apply for child pornography.
- gs17 2y agoIt's like the early demo for DALL-E where you could get "an armchair in the shape of an avocado", which presumably wasn't in the training set, but enough was in it to generalize the "armchair" and "avocado" concepts and combine them.
- danaris 2y agoNot at all. If it's trained with images of children, and images of pornography, it should be pretty easy for it to combine the two.
- NotYourLawyer 2y agoSeems fine.
- loeg 2y agoRight? Hard to be mad about the outcome.
- 6ix8igth 2y agoLaws like this impede everyone while providing little tangible benefit for actual children. It's silly to imply that generating an image with a model hurts anyone. In general I don't like legislation that tries to criminalize abstract depictions of something that would otherwise be a crime. It's too intangible, and opens the opportunity for abusing the legal system to persecute undesirables. We have to be really careful about what spiders we swallow to catch small (or sometimes imaginary) flies.
- loeg 2y agoI don’t feel remotely impeded by this and neither do most other people. No one needs to generate CSAM.
- 6ix8igth 2y agoYou don't feel impeded right now, but let enough stupid stuff like this through and you'll slowly drip feed your rights away. I explained in my post above why this is bad - if you make it a crime to do a simple thing, it becomes very easy to falsely accuse a person of a crime, and act in other authoritarian ways. I already have personal experience facing strong arm measures under the pretext of "protecting the kids". Last time I returned to my home country of Australia, the policy forcibly did a digital search of my phone, on the pretext of looking for child porn. I have my banks details and pics of my girlfriend on that thing. In no first world country should I have to surrender it to authorities without a warrant. No one would tolerate this bullshit for any other reason then the moral panic around children. I'm anti-pedophilia, but the legislation the article is talking about is incredibly stupid. We don't accept invasive police-state tactics to combat any other crime, we shouldn't accept them here.
- darquomiahw 2y agoAI-generated "CSAM" is the perfect form of kompromat. Any computer with a GPU can generate images that an American judge can find unpalatable. Once tarred by the sex offender brush and cooled by 20+ years in prison for possession, any individual will be effectively destroyed. Of course, no real children are being abused, which makes it all the more ludicrous.
- ALittleLight 2y agoYou could say the same thing about real CSAM. Authorities claim you have it, present a hard drive they "recovered" from your property to court and you get convicted. At some level we just have to hope, and be skeptical of etc, that the government is basically staffed by mostly trustworthy people.
- WarOnPrivacy 2y ago>> Of course, no real children are being abused, > You could say the same thing about real CSAM. Maybe this is trying to make a technical point. But abuse is a brutally heavy topic, mere technicalities aren't ever going to be strong enough to support the weight put upon them. That said: I do believe there are counter arguments to be made. I question the ethics and actions of people who leverage the pain of injured children to expand gov reach and power. Having been a child who can check all the abuse boxes, it gets old watching the endless parade of interests try to mine that pain for their own ends.
- ALittleLight 2y agoIn the scenario I laid out, no additional real children are being abused either - because the government is simply framing you and you never consumed or produced any CSAM. That's what I meant by it being similar - if your concern with punishing people for AI generated CSAM is that law enforcement could lie about it and frame innocent people, then what I'm trying to point out is, that same risk exists with the real thing, they could lie about that too - if you want the government to enforce any laws you need to trust they're mostly trustworthy.
- yellowapple 2y agoAn important thing omitted from the article is that only some of the alleged child pornography was computer/AI-generated: https://www.nbcbayarea.com/news/california/cartoonist-arrested-child-porn/3762634/ https://www.nbcbayarea.com/news/california/cartoonist-arrest...
- drinpt 2y ago[flagged]