10 ms·
How corn syrup took over America
- rezmason 2y agoI was raised with an allergy to this stuff. Now I eat it for breakfast and observe its birefringence between two polarizers.
- jjtheblunt 2y agoAllergy with what symptoms? that's wild
- rezmason 2y agoBreaking out in hives, mostly. Throwing up a couple times. I forget how we determined it was maltodextrin, but for the first year I was also off wheat and milk while they worked it out.
- johnsonjo 2y agoMy sister went to an allergist and found out she is allergic to corn/HFCS as well with similar symptoms as you (hives, vomit inducing). Corn and HFCS are in almost literally everything, so it's a really hard allergy for her to have. You say now you eat it for breakfast? What do you mean by that? Are you over your allergy and what has worked for you if so? If you could give someone going through something similar advice what would you say?
- rezmason 2y agoDisclaimer: I'm not an allergist or nutritionist, I only know my personal experience. I would consider myself over my allergy. I'd say it lasted seven years, gradually diminishing in severity over time. For the first couple years following the diagnosis my parents had me eating spelt, kamut, quinoa and all that. Alternative recipe books, bag lunch, Martin's potato bread, health food store, no vending machines, no trick or treat candy, and we checked the ingredients on every box. But like you said, HFCS is practically unavoidable. My parents made some judgment calls— they checked my reaction to corn starch and plain old corn, and I had none. The alternative grains went away, we were just ingredient checking and keeping my corn intake relatively low. Five years in, I was eating the same stuff other kids ate as long as it wasn't sugary like pancake syrup or a cinnamon bun. Then after puberty corn syrup was the bad grade scapegoat and nothing more. Nowadays I will demolish a bowl of Honey Comb cereal— basically corn flour hexagons. I read the nutrition facts and ignore the ingredients list; my childhood allergy doesn't even enter my mind. Arrowhead Mills spelt flakes are delicious, though. Your sister's a completely different jumble of molecules, and my experience might not apply, but I would recommend a similar approach my family took: switch to boring food for a year or two, even in the tricky social situations surrounding food. Then, talk to the allergist (or don't) about safely testing subcategories of corn product. The worst offenders are probably the sweeteners. I hope corn flour makes it back on her menu, but if not, I imagine now is a great time to be allergic and on the Internet.
- jjtheblunt 2y agothat's terrible, and it's also very interesting. i had various allergies as a kid, but nothing so severe. mostly ragweed pollen turning my nose into a 2 month running faucet, and itchy eyes...classic stuff.
- fortran77 2y agoI think the biggest mistake the Corn Syrup people made was naming! Instead of "High Fructose Corn Syrup" they should have called it "Low Sucrose Corn Sugar"
- cyberax 2y agoYeah, right next to the "Evaporated Cane Juice".
- Maxion 2y agoRefined beets sound quite sophisticated.
- hombre_fatal 2y agoDon't forget monk fruit, quite ascetic.
- drewcoo 2y agoHere in the upper midwest, beet sugar is as normal as winter wheat. And "bowing to your partner" is not sophisticated. It's just the custom. Promenade!
- xnx 2y agoConcentrated grain essence
- drewcoo 2y agoThat's Everclear! `Everclear is also used as a household "food-grade" cleaner, disinfectant, or stove fuel alcohol` https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Everclear https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Everclear It's not very palatable orally, but butt-chugging is really not advised. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alcohol_enema https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alcohol_enema
- dekhn 2y ago
- somat 2y agoI recently watched an interesting video on the subject of corn syrup. Which led me into the fascinating rabbit hole of sugar chemistry. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NY66qpMFOYo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NY66qpMFOYo If I might summarize. Your body can absorb three types of sugar into the blood, glucose, fructose and galactose. glucose is directly used by cells, the other two have to take a trip through the liver to turn them into glucose. Table sugar is sucrose. a complex sugar. which can be best thought of as a fructose and a glucose linked together. Corn syrup is a mixture of ~ 45% glucose 55% fructose Sucrose is quickly broken apart into glucose and fructose in several environments, high heat will do it, but also acidic environments. like your stomach, or a soda. a soda will be slightly acidic due to the carbon dioxide dissolved in it(carbonic acid). And some formulations(like coke) add additional phosphoric acid. And to spoil the video. Even if you put sucrose into a soda, that is not what you are going to be drinking. I was unable to figure out why it tastes different, are the ratios off? additional trace chemicals in one source?
- gorkish 2y ago> I was unable to figure out why it tastes different, are the ratios off? additional trace chemicals in one source? Turns out the trick is super super simple: It's not the sugar; it's the salt. It's on the label. The soda brands that have been differentiating their cane sugar products, such as the various "throwback" promotional drinks or "Mexican Coke" all have measurably more salt in the cane sugar versions which tends to enhance the flavors for all the same reasons that salt does that in every other food. If you want your corn syrup american coke to have that south of the border $8 imported flair, put about half a pinch of salt in it. It will taste the same, except you won't get to drink it out of the tall glass bottle.
- bluedino 2y ago> you won't get to drink it out of the tall glass bottle. Arguably the most important part. Plastic bottle soda tastes terrible.
- function_seven 2y ago
- gorkish 2y agoCorn Syrup and Sucrose are chemically identical from the standpoint of human metabolism, especially in solution where sucrose will have already disassociated. The only difference is that the ratio of fructose:sucrose is slightly (~5%) higher in corn syrup. I've always been dismayed at the misdirected fury around corn syrup as if it is somehow worse than any other sugar. If you want to go down the rabbit hole, try to find an actual proper double blind academic study that demonstrates a taste difference between sucrose and high fructose corn syrup. I'll be here waiting.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- jandrewrogers 2y ago> The only difference is that the ratio of fructose:sucrose is slightly (~5%) higher in corn syrup. HFCS used in soda is 55% fructose. HFCS used in e.g. baked goods is usually 42% fructose, so it can have lower fructose levels than sugar.
- gorkish 2y agoHFCS is made by enzymatically converting glucose in corn syrup to fructose, so it stands to reason that the product can have any glucose:fructose ratio needed. Since humans categorically taste fructose as sweeter than glucose, it makes sense that HFCS is tuned differently for different applications and in situations where the ratio is very far away from 1:1 I do contend that HFCS could taste different than sucrose. Perhaps it was unwise for me to assume that most HFCS used is close to the 1:1 ratio of sucrose.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- tptacek 2y ago"High fructose" corn syrup is "high" in fructose relative to normal corn syrup. Table sugar is naturally high in fructose already. The corn syrup you're suggesting is used in baked goods has less fructose than table sugar does.
- aucisson_masque 2y agoAmericans are paying their food higher than they should because industrials are paying more for sugar because lobbyist paid money to politicians to get them to put tariff on sugar import. So, basically American's money is going in the pocket of big corporation thanks to corrupt politicians. And it's still going on to these days, no government has yet removed these tariffs. Isn't tariff what started the American revolution ? Things changed.
- rad_gruchalski 2y agoTariffs are going to MAGA. That’s what the orange man on fox news says.
- Jalad 2y ago> industrials are paying more for sugar I'm not sure that more cheap sugar is a good thing
- ben7799 2y agoIf the US didn't have tariffs on sugar we would not have HFCS in all of our food because it would be less expensive to go back to using cane sugar. The price of HFCS is cheaper than US-produced sugar, but is more expensive than the international market for sugar. The US puts the tariff on international sugar and subsidizes corn so that both the US sugar farmers, the corn farmers, and the giant industrial food manufacturers all win. The consumer loses due to all the subsidized corn syrup going into the food.
- aucisson_masque 2y agoPeople in america are free to eat all the fat and all the sugar they want, both at the same time. Having to pay extra so industrial and subsidized corn farmer can get rich, on the other hand it is not normal. Beside it promotes this political environment where politicians are expected to receive kickback in exchange for service.
- justin66 2y agoNot much mention of the USDA or the relevant committees in the House and the Senate. They're awfully relevant. The department and committees who control agricultural subsidies and how much corn syrup gets spooged into American food also control the funding of SNAP (food stamps). Politicians in the states where corn doesn't rule everything are nevertheless limited in what they can do to combat these trends, since their political opponents are happy to use hunger as a weapon if they can. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22656777 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22656777 https://www.essence.com/news/new-trump-administration-proposal-750000-food-stamp-recipients-lose-out/ https://www.essence.com/news/new-trump-administration-propos...
- qwerty456127 2y agoI'd rather check why do most people get so addicted to sugar/whatever in their childhoods (the very archetype the first picture in the article illustrates) and why some don't.
- beala 2y agoThe title says "corn syrup" but the article is entirely about high fructose corn syrup, which is different. Corn syrup is mostly glucose. HFCS is when you use enzymes to convert a lot of that glucose into fructose.
- floppiplopp 2y agoIt's capitalism again, isn't it, with it's corporate handouts and disregard for the people?
- SpaceL10n 2y agoWhen I was in school, I was taught that the push for corn was to help the central states. We don't really grow that much sugar cane in the US and the belief that we should spend that money internally, I think, is not misguided. So as I read your comment, I can't help but remember that. Maybe it was American propaganda filtering its way into the school system to brainwash me. Or maybe it was true. either way, one has to admit that Americans love sugar. We are going to consume a lot of it regardless. Doesn't seem like a bad thing to find a sugar alternative that grows well in the continental US.
- hank808 2y agoWasn't there also an anticommunist angle? Much of the sugarcane was being grown in places that were at risk of communist revolution and the US didn't want to be sending them money, I thought...
- ben7799 2y agoThis is really interesting to read the comments here and they are so pro-HFCS that you'd think the corn lobby was here in force. And yet if you regularly read HN you get the impression the mean BMI of commenters is in the obese range and many HNers are on GLP-1s.