8 ms·
Microsoft comes under fire for five-figure Xbox 360 “patch fee”
- briandear 14y agoWhy would anyone pay someone for the right to only release on their platform? That seems backwards. The other bit of nonsense is $40,000 -- really? That's crazy talk. Apple does some boneheaded things but at least you don't have to pay them for updating and releasing, aside from the nominal yearly $99 fee for the dev program. I admit, I don't fully get it. Perhaps someone here can clarify the situation.
- weaksauce 14y agoIn another thread about this issue the fee to microsoft gives them a competitive edge in that ecosystem; stuff like marketing and highlighting inside the xbox live store. 40k for a patch is absurd though.
- justin66 14y agoI haven't seen the $40k figure confirmed by anyone from Microsoft. It's just being uncritically passed around by bloggers.
- msbarnett 14y agoThe $40K figure comes from Tim Schafer, who has a history of being a reputable voice in the game dev community. There's no real reason to believe he made it up.
- justin66 14y agoIt's not clear to me that the figure would be the same for every developer and every circumstance. In any case, I'm sure Tim is a great guy but it would be nice if someone (anyone who is writing on this) would research it a little for confirmation.
- the_mitsuhiko 14y agoYou won't see it confirmed by people because there are NDAs around it. And people that are happy with their Microsoft account managers have no reason to complain on twitter or any other tech blog and get into potential legal trouble :-)
- 1337biz 14y agoThe game industry has had "traditionally" certain kickback mechanism towards the gaming platform developers. For example I remember playing around with MIT/Sloans Platformwars, which even included variables for the game developer kickback in form of licenses[1]. I suspect these were argued by the mutual benefits in the development, branding and licensing. But of cause the democratization process initiated by the low entrance barriers in the App market are putting these in question. Nevertheless one could still see the fees taken by Apple from each App sale as a form of license to get access to their platform. [1] https://mitsloan.mit.edu/MSTIR/system-dynamics/platform-wars/Pages/default.aspx https://mitsloan.mit.edu/MSTIR/system-dynamics/platform-wars...
- 89a 14y agoCan't Polytron use some of their IGF winnings to fund the patch to patch the bugs they introduced when rushing out their first patch
- ROFISH 14y agoAs much as I don't like this particular flair of drama, I'm siding with Fish. If a patch cost five figures just to go through certification, then Microsoft needs to rethink their XBLA strategy for independent games. Let this be another flag for teams to avoid XBLA at all costs. Plus Microsoft's XBLA terms are horrible. For example, you must sign a contract that puts your XBLA release as a pure-Xbox-exclusive release, or at least a timed-exclusive if you have the clout to fight back. (Only the majors can swing a "same-day multi platform release" via XBLA) The percentages XBLA offers are unfavorable, they make you pay for advertising on the games page, and I've heard that you make more money via PC release on Steam (or your favorite DRM-free service). In short: if you're seriously working on XBLA, demand a better contract or dump it. It's just unfortunate that Fez's original contract is probably so old, the Apple App Store with it's free patches was a new concept then. If you're working on something that will take forever to do, get a PC prototype working first then dumb down to consoles if you must.
- wreckimnaked 14y agoI frankly never understood the real reason why Fez was released exclusively for xbox. From the outsider perspective it seems like a very bad decision when it comes to a game as hyped as this one was.
- Steko 14y agoMS probably heavily promotes exclusives to their users so free advertising on what was becoming the dominant console anyway.
- rbanffy 14y ago> what was becoming the dominant console anyway Do you have any numbers to back you up? I couldn't find any. All I got pointed the Wii as worldwide sales leader and 360 and PS3 more or less tied in second place. The 360 seems to have a small lead over the PS3 in the US (with Wii coming in third), but that's all.
- 14y ago
- zdw 14y agoThey knew what the policies were (one free patch, future ones are $$$) when they signed up with the platform. What it comes down to is the developers thinking: "Who will gamers hate more? MS for the policy, or us for not releasing a patch?" Especially if they say: "We have fixed the problem… MS just wants their ransom for us to give it to you." MS is then in the bind of making an exception, thus creating the expectation for future developers that the platform agreement is flexible and/or a joke. There's no way to win this one. Both parties have somewhat dumb policies and because of the contract are deciding to play russian roulette with user's data.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- Rhino55 14y agoThat's ridiculous. MSFT made some decisions without really A) thinking about or B) caring about the consequences. Their MO from day 1 is to screw everyone else and become fabulously wealthy in the process.
- klodolph 14y agoOkay, they knew what the policies were when they signed up. Big deal. It's not like the devs predicted that they'd botch a patch for some 1% or so of their users. The developer is just saying, "Look, the cost-benefit analysis just doesn't support making a new patch." That's honest. It doesn't sound like a policy to me (you'd have to so something more than once before I'd call it "policy"). The devs don't owe it to the affected users to pony up the cash to Microsoft. Devs don't have unlimited liability for lost save files. Microsoft's policy makes sense from a "Look, it costs money to make sure that your games don't crash on users' systems." So maybe Microsoft will change the policy so that a small enough patch goes through a less thorough review process. That's what happens when your policy has unintended consequences: you reevaluate it.
- 89a 14y agoMaybe test their patch properly before deploying it… Judging from their previous behaviour it's a horrendously sloppy "company".
- duncan_bayne 14y agoTL;DR: developer builds software for walled garden ecosystem and is surprised when he's hurt by the owner of said ecosystem. http://xkcd.com/743/ http://xkcd.com/743/ When will people get sick of variations on this story?
- Steko 14y agoWhen there's not a 1000 bigger success stories that drown this out.
- Iaks 14y agoSeveral years ago I was a programmer for a small gaming firm. I spent 3 weeks working closely with the producer at our publisher and one of the tricks he told me about in their QA process was they they would hedge their costs by submitting their games to MS before they had finished internal QA. This would essentially allow them to obtain free QA time from a very large external group. (console QA is usually better than PC, so a multi-platform release would push the xbox version first to maximize the effect.) I think it came up because the certification fees for releasing on the 360 were just being raised to free first check, $40,000 each time there-after.
- kalleboo 14y agoAt least when patches cost $40k, you have an incentive to make a really, really solid first release. I wonder if it leads to less buggy software in general? (obviously this is kind of a counterexample to that...)
- landr0id 14y ago> At least when patches cost $40k, you have an incentive to make a really, really solid first release. The rule applies to all titles (not just XBLA -- I remember looking at the official MS documents stating how much it is), and you'd think that it would be pretty good incentive, but for some games it's really not. I believe Call of Duty Black Ops is on its eighth title update. Other games such as Forza and Halo (which are/were both MS studios) actually have had very, very few updates. Halo 3 had two total, while Reach I believe had none -- both of which are very well-coded games. I think you can generalize and say that it does lead to less buggy software in general, but it really depends on the studio.
- slavak 14y agoRemember back when consoles weren't connected to the internet and there was no way for developers to push patches to users? Remember how people used to complain their console games work fine, while their PC games require installing 3 patches right after installation in order to be able to play the game? I'm not saying I approve of what Microsoft is doing here, but surely there must be a solution other than making all gaming systems equally fucked-up?
- derefr 14y agoThere have always been patches; it just used to be that they were unequally distributed, and those that didn't get them, just lived with the bugs (mostly because that was "just the way things were.") Super Nintendo cartridges, for example, have a version metadata field as part of their ROM headers. Many games, a few months after their original release, would release 1.1, and even 1.2 versions of the cartridge. This would occur with no change to the product packaging or labeling, or even a different distributor-catalogue SKU number. Simply, if you bought the game after a certain point in time, you got a version with less bugs than someone who bought it before that point. This didn't help anyone bit by the original bug, of course--unless they went out and repurchased the game!
- corysama 14y agoWhat everyone is missing over the dim of disapproval is that THE PATCH FEE IS NOT A PROFIT for Microsoft. They are going to spend on the order of $40K testing your game. They are that serious about making sure your patch doesn't screw up the user experience.
- ryanhuff 14y agoHow much work (number of hours) goes into testing this type of game? Using $150/hour as a basis, that would cover 266 hours of testing time. As somebody with no experience in game testing, this sounds more like government pricing in aerospace.
- wccrawford 14y ago
- mtgx 14y agoThis is why something like OUYA is needed to disrupt the market, and be more open for developers.
- pjmlp 14y agoI wish this was true, but sadly the games developer community is all about protecting IP and using proprietary tools as much as possible. Big studios only care about platforms and their support, not if they are open.
- mtgx 14y agoWell OUYA is meant more for indie developers than big studios, so that might help.
- bonch 14y agoOUYA is extremely unlikely to be successful, if it even comes out at all.
- unsigner 14y agoWe've been in the position of Fez's creator, and it pains me to say, we made the same choice as him (except for the drama) but... the $40k figure is way, way off. I have no idea how Tim Schafer came to it, or rather, how he was misinterpreted (because the man is obviously NOT an idiot).
- brohee 14y agoWay off is kinda unhelpful, is it way more expensive or way cheaper?
- dt7 14y agoAs a guess, I'd say it varies depending on a few factors such as the scale of the game, the changes introduced, etc.
- unsigner 14y agoFor us it was way cheeper. Still a shocking amount for a small studio. I'm not aware of any "pricing structure", or if there is any; I heard the number we were supposed to pay.
- christoph 14y agoEverything I've seen of Polytron irritates me. I watched the Indie game documentary a few weeks ago and had a bitter taste in my mouth from them then. If you read the press release on their website it certainly doesn't paint a great picture either. We believe the save file corruption issue mostly happened to players who had completed, or almost completed the game So Phil Fish harps on about how its a game that should be enjoyed on Saturdays on the couch, but is happy for paying users to have their entire experience destroyed at the end. As a gamer that would be my worst nightmare and I would never buy anything you sold again. I would probably put the controller through the screen as well. The patch fixes almost everything that’s been wrong with the game since launch. The framerate issues, the loading, the skips, the death loops, everything! All that stuff is fixed! Wow. Version 1 obviously wasn't ready at all. Why was it shipped in the first place? I guess a good question is why did MS let it ship? What annoys me more, is in the documentary, the demo build they had at Penny Arcade had all those seem issues. Phil stood their straight faced telling people it was because they made last minute changes. This is game that was in development for FIVE YEARS! From what I could tell, Phil wasn't even a programmer at all. Just art director/concept guy. He had some French guy doing all the coding. People often mistakenly believe that we got paid by Microsoft for being exclusive to their platform. Nothing could be further from the truth. WE pay THEM Then you suck at business. Get out of the game and find something else to do with your life. I wanted to like Fez, but Polytron clearly have no idea what they are doing - how to build a loyal customer base, ship working code, etc. They are happy to blame the big bad wolf, when quite frankly the only people they have to blame are themselves.
- michaelt 14y ago> Wow. Version 1 obviously wasn't ready at all. Why was it shipped in the first place? I guess a good question is why did MS let it ship? Perhaps the one-free-patch policy should change into a no-free-patches policy, to encourage companies not to ship unfinished games.
- dt7 14y agoDid they have a deadline to release though? Release then patch seems to be the way to do things now- the last (big) game I remember noticing being delayed was Halo 2. It seems that since then the priority has been on shipping, then patching (which creates a whole lot of problems for the future, when MS shut down the XBL servers and we can't get patches for our older games any more).