7 ms·
Backdooring Your Backdoors – Another $20 Domain, More Governments
- Lammy 2y agoTo avoid my comment being entirely a terminology nitpick I will say this is very cool work that I would be too afraid of CFAA to ever attempt. Especially funny to see four parasites on one government domain. Do skiddies not excise other skiddies' backdoors when pwning systems so they can have them all to themselves? > We then hooked that up to the AWS Route53 API, and just bought them en-masse. Honestly, it’s $20, and we’ve done worse with more. > We’re incredibly grateful for the support of The Shadowserver Foundation, who have agreed yet again to save us from our own adventures and to take ownership of the domains implicated in this research and sinkhole them. I wish we could collectively stop using the terms “buy” and “own” with regard to domains. Try “leased” or “rented”. If they could be bought then they wouldn't have been available again for this exercise.
- awwaiid 2y agoAll property, physical and digital, is rented if you squint just right.
- noduerme 2y agoI'm curious if this is a socialist lament about landlords or a libertarian complaint about governments.
- sgjohnson 2y agoI read it as a libertarian complaint about governments. i.e. own real estate? Try not paying the property tax on it, and see who really owns it. :)
- lazyasciiart 2y agoMaybe it's an existential comment about the fleeting existence of life.
- noduerme 2y agoThat was actually the first way I squinted at it, and it doesn't have to be existential - the lack of ownership in the fourth dimension is stated well in most religions. But for some reason I doubt they meant it that way.
- foobarbecue 2y agoProperty is theft from the state
- noduerme 2y agoA curious assertion, considering that the protection of private property and enforcement of contracts is one of the foundational reasons for the existence of most modern states. Stop me if I missed the sarcasm.
- foobarbecue 2y agoThis was intended to be a wry comment referencing a communist idea that has always tickled my brain. Somehow I had it in my head that Marx said this (probably because of another joke-- "why did Karl Marx only drink herbal tea? Because proper tea is theft"). Checking my facts now, I see it was actually Proudhon, not Marx (although Marx did discuss the idea here: https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1865/letters/65_01_24.htm https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1865/letters/65_..., but seems to say it has a self-reference problem, and seems to delight in insulting Proudhon). I think the "from the state" part is an accidental addition either of my own or from whoever explained the "proper tea" joke to me the first time. I just thought it always referenced the extreme philosophy that all property should be communal and therefore private property was theft from everyone, or equivalently from "the state".
- robertlagrant 2y agoDrinking tea is in itself an act of theft - he drank that tea and now no-one else can drink it.
- noduerme 2y agoHah! I love the proper tea joke. Hadn't heard that one. Extreme philosophy or not, I reject the idea that "everyone"=="the state". Most (all?) states which confiscate property in the name of "everyone" don't distribute it fairly anyway, so it's all a bit of a sham. Even if it wasn't, I still don't fancy having the 7 or 8 drunks I know at the local bar showing up to sleep on my floor, shower in my toilet and claiming it in the name of everyone, or the state, or whatever. Screw those people.
- nightpool 2y agoI think it's just acknowledging the reality that property is a social construct, one that's created by the social contract.
- mathieuh 2y agoWell, Rousseau himself would say property is theft in not exactly those words From his discourse on inequality > The first man who, having enclosed a piece of land, thought of saying "this is mine" and found people simple enough to believe him, was the true founder of civil society. How many crimes, wars, murders; how much misery and horror the human race would have been spared if someone had pulled up the stakes and filled in the ditch and cried out to his fellow men: "beware of listening to this imposter. You are lost if you forget that the fruits of the earth belong to everyone and that the earth itself belongs to no one!"
- short_sells_poo 2y agoUltimately it comes down to force. The person with the pointiest sticks will likely be able to enforce their view about ownership over others. Taken quite literally, property is armed theft from the commons I guess. Unfortunately, it's tricky to do otherwise in a loosely organized swarm of barely tribal actors, because any peaceful society based on shared ownership will be prone to exploitation by malicious actors. It's basically a very large prisoner's dilemma: the global optimum would be to abolish private property, but as long as there are (enough) people around to exploit the situation for their own benefit (and to the massive detriment of everyone else), we have to stick to a sub-optimal system where everyone is worse off than the optimum.
- robertlagrant 2y ago> the global optimum would be to abolish private property The Soviet Union had this I believe, at least with buildings, and it didn't necessarily work out optimally.
- short_sells_poo 2y ago
- short_sells_poo 2y agoI tend to think is neither of those, but meant very literally. For that reason I like it and I think it's an interesting subject. What is ownership after all? The universe does not seem to have any form of ownership embedded in it's fundamental laws. If ownership is a human construct, then it is only meaningful insofar as a group of humans agrees on it. I can stroll up to the White House and declare that I own it, but I'll struggle to convince a sufficient number of other people that this is true. If I can't assert my ownership, then I don't really own it, do I? It doesn't matter whether it is just, or fair (again - purely human constructs), ownership only matters if it can be enforced. Being a human construct, it is also by definition temporary. It is only valid as long as humans are around to enforce it, and humans are fleeting. Humanity might endure, but there's no reason to think we are going to be around for eternity. So it looks like ownership is not only temporary, but it is also fickle. People routinely disagree on ownership and are willing to kill- or be-killed for asserting their claims. It looks like neither the communists, nor the liberatarians are in the right. Things will be owned by whoever has more pointy sticks :D
- robertlagrant 2y ago> Things will be owned by whoever has more pointy sticks :D That sounds like the feudal or socialist systems. Isn't one of the points of modern democracies that we have the pointy sticks for outside invaders, and a legal system that replaces the system of internal-facing pointy sticks with an economic system and a justice system?
- krapp 2y agoNo. All systems of law, regardless of their "democratic" nature, are based on the principle of the state's monopoly on violence, and that violence is always directed towards the citizenry. No matter how civil your society may seem, resistance to the state will eventually mean you get shot or beaten with truncheons.
- short_sells_poo 2y agoExactly. Democratic and highly civilized countries still enforce property rights with pointy sticks. They maintain their claim on their territory against outside invaders with the army, and internally they enforce the laws of ownership using the police.
- SkyBelow 2y agoMaybe a deeper truth that is harder to put into words but which feeds into both of them. Something captured in much higher dimensional concept space that, when forced into our 3D world (and our <whatever>D political discussion space), looks like a sphere in one projection and a cube in the other, but which is neither.
- hhh 2y agowhat's the difference?
- judge2020 2y agoWhat would buying even mean in this sense? Even countries don't "own" their ccTLDs, but ICANN has made considerable efforts to outline policies that go "we really need to treat ccTLDs like the countries own them to avoid tensions over internet namespaces". That's why most gTLD rules don't apply to ccTLDs. Countries "own" their ccTLD in the sense that they (or most) have the military prowess to defend their usage of their ccTLD if ICANN, or the servers at root-servers.net, were to stop resolving TLDs appropriately.
- BobbyTables2 2y agoDNS is then a weapon of mass destruction
- NewJazz 2y agoThe root servers hold the real power, and IIRC over 50% are operated in the US, with many of them being operated by the US military and others educational institutions. I can only assume that the US has tolerated varied use of ccTLDs for the sole purpose of avoiding a competing alternate DNS root zone becoming more prominent.
- croemer 2y agoBut root servers aren't a democracy, are they? If US root servers went bonkers, people would just use different root servers. Doesn't matter whether it's 50% or 90% that are in US if they can be ignored?
- NewJazz 2y agoYeah that's the point. If US acted up, and pressured other operators to follow suit, the root zone could split up. They don't want that to happen.
- preciousoo 2y agoI’m sure the NSA does their best to make sure the US doesn’t politically fuck that up
- TacticalCoder 2y ago[dead]
- bell-cot 2y ago> I wish we could collectively stop... That's a "feature" of human nature and English. People say "my car" and "my phone number" when those are leased. "My house" when they have a new zero-down mortgage. And all sorts of other conceptual contractions - with the messier reality assumed to be common knowledge. Or just irrelevant to the point at hand.
- numberless 2y agoTechnically this is a dupe as this has been submitted twice before in the last week https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42658405 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42658405 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42633273 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42633273
- blendergeek 2y agoIt only counts as a dupe if it received discussion/upvotes last time.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- catoc 2y agoThe first link is also watchtwr, but a different post
- Thorrez 2y agoI wonder what would happen if they exploited these webshells' backdoors to delete the webshells...
- abound 2y agoIf you're the FBI (and maybe also have a court order), you can do this [1]. If you're a grey hat hacker in Russia, you can maybe do this [2]. If you're a random person in the US, you're likely exposing yourself to a lot of (CFAA) risk. As the authors of this post note, they were careful to only receive + log traffic and not otherwise send interesting responses/engage with the webshells. [1] https://www.malwarebytes.com/blog/news/2024/02/fbi-removes-malware-from-hundreds-of-routers-across-the-us https://www.malwarebytes.com/blog/news/2024/02/fbi-removes-m... [2] https://www.zdnet.com/article/a-mysterious-grey-hat-is-patching-peoples-outdated-mikrotik-routers/ https://www.zdnet.com/article/a-mysterious-grey-hat-is-patch...
- busymom0 2y agoSlightly off topic but what's going on with the font for the "y" character in this article? It sticks out like a sore thumb.
- sosborn 2y agoIt's the font design: https://abcdinamo.com/typefaces/favorit https://abcdinamo.com/typefaces/favorit
- busymom0 2y agoLooks like the font provides an "alternative y" which looks normal. But the default one has that ugly broken look.
- roygbiv2 2y agoWow what is going on with that website.
- lioeters 2y agoI guess it's "Brutalism" or something, but I had a physical revulsion to the entire site design and all their fonts. It's so ugly it's almost charming.
- yencabulator 2y agoBrutalism is a form of unapologetic minimalism, specifically the kind that does not spend effort covering up structural components. Adding visual crap and animation isn't minimalism at all.
- alt227 2y agoThat website had me in tears of laughter. From the amazing picture at the top, to the hand offering cookies, to the over the top shaking and spinning of everything on hover. This is one funny website.
- npteljes 2y ago
- fn-mote 2y agoI loved this write up. Light-hearted. Conscious of the impact of any disclosure. Everything substantiated, but not taking themselves too seriously. Enjoying read, and at the same time talking about a serious issue.
- taspeotis 2y agoI also loved the appearance of WordArt, shame they did not do the rainbow one.
- ipdashc 2y agoThank you for putting it in words. I felt the same way, both about this and the writeup for their previous .mobi thing. Well explained with plenty of context, no buzzwords, light hearted and cool (while not trying too hard to make themselves sound cool), and plenty of substance with no fluff. A lot of blog posts or security write-ups violate some of these; this is a breath of fresh air.
- pea 2y agoBlast from the past seeing h0no mentioned.. Brings me back to days of darpanet/m00/#darknet/dikline
- croemer 2y agoI'm not sure I understand this correctly: > This is a line of CSS, specifying that the ‘menu’ style should fetch a background image from the given URL. On loading the page, the web browser will attempt to fetch the specified .gif file from the w2img.com server. > Note: Disclosing just the domain in referrers is a relatively recent browser change, and indeed attackers using older browsers were sending us full shell URLs. In particular re "attackers using older browsers": haven't the (original) attackers taken over the _server_ that's serving the CSS and the browser belongs to unsuspecting _users_ of the pwned server? Isn't it wrong to say the attackers use the browsers then, as the browser is used by a victim? Under which circumstances would _attackers_ be using a browser? I can't make sense of this.
- TazeTSchnitzel 2y agoA webshell is a page (typically a .php file) uploaded to a site by an attacker after a compromise (e.g. an RCE), which is then used by an attacker through their browser to perform further actions on the compromised webserver. These premade webshell files however have been made by other attackers and come pre-compromised with a backdoor. In this case the CSS in the webshell makes the attacker's browser snitch the webshell's location to a domain controlled by the author of the webshell.
- croemer 2y agoThanks that makes sense, not sure how I could miss that.
- croemer 2y ago> with the hopes of painting a paint a clear picture. Typo: "a paint" is superfluous > Taking a look through the results for high-value domains within our referrers, we the following stood out like a shining beacon: Typo: superfluous "we" in "we the following" > Atleast there will be memes on the record, and an awkward explanation of a raccoon. Typo: "Atleast"
- croemer 2y agoI wonder why they redacted almost all domains but the Federal High Court of Nigeria's? It's not mentioned explicitly, so I hope they did responsible disclosure.
- m3kw9 2y agoShould be called front dooring your backdoor
- 1oooqooq 2y agoso, it was 99% based on dns hijack, but he says nothing about how it was done?
- aneutron 2y agoHave you actually read the article ? He explains everything in sufficient detail. He didn't "hijack" the DNS records, he bought the ones that were expired and available. The only thing he doesn't explain (for obvious reasons) is the how he found the shells online (because as he puts it, they fell off the back of a truck).