6 ms·
James Thomson on the Origins of the macOS Dock
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- sillywalk 2y agoLinks to https://tla.systems/blog/2025/01/04/i-live-my-life-a-quarter-century-at-a-time/ https://tla.systems/blog/2025/01/04/i-live-my-life-a-quarter... Which was discussed a few days ago: 300 points by CharlesW 4 days ago | flag | hide | past | favorite | 178 comments https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42616699 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42616699
- myrandomcomment 2y agoI want the NextStep style menus and shelf back. The dock sucks. :)
- whatever1 2y agoI don’t even know what it does today I a multi monitor world. Not a good launcher, not a window switcher.
- dagw 2y agoI genuinely never understood why nobody else implemented a version of the shelf from NextStep. It was such a fantastic UI innovation. In many ways NextStep was the pinnacle of desktop UI/UX design.
- anthk 2y agoGNU/Linux and BSD had and still have WindowMaker and the whole Cocoa/OpenStep implementation with GNUStep.
- dagw 2y agoI used WindowMaker for years and while it was pretty good, it was never as good as NextStep. GNUStep I could never really get to work consistently, it always felt more like an interesting proof of concept than a stable desktop environment.
- helf 2y ago[dead]
- efortis 2y agoBTW, similar to DragThing, you can add a folder next to the trash can on the Dock. And to move a file to that folder, drop it there while holding CMD.
- forgotoldacc 2y agoYou don't need to hold command.
- efortis 2y agonice. Thanks
- hulitu 2y ago> James Thomson on the Origins of the macOS Dock Looks like a polished copy from CDE. (The site is horrible. White on light gray. I didn't expected this from a Mac developer).
- dcrazy 2y agoI can only surmise you’re referring to Daring Fireball, not James’s blog. You might want to check your monitor’s color calibration (specifically its white point) or brightness setting. DF is and always has been white/light gray on dark gray. Specifically, it’s #fff (body text) or #ddd (blockquotes) on #4a525a.
- eviks 2y agoWhy do you need any calibration to see that this is an awful color scheme?
- msk-lywenn 2y agoEven black on white can be awful with disastrous calibration... white on #4A525A is almost white on black. It looks good on any of my screens and I don't even have that good calibration.
- eviks 2y agothere is nothing "almost" about it, #4A525A is ~35 on a 100 lightness scale away from black, "almost" would be 5% or something
- dcrazy 2y agoIt’s still within contrast accessibility guidelines. I find it much more pleasing on the eyes than full black on white, which causes a lot of eyestrain on an emissive display like a monitor.
- 2y ago
- eviks 2y agoWho was the genius that invented the perma-jumping attention stealer dock effect?
- nobleach 2y ago"Jumping up and down like a Jack-Russel Terrier" as one commedian put it.
- dsiner 2y ago[dead]
- reader9274 2y agoWe all know the correct dock location is LEFT, because there's fewer mouse movements to reach the dock apps and the close/minimize buttons of a window when using a mouse. No further arguments will be heard on this topic (:
- barnabee 2y agoLeft, hidden, as small as possible, with active app indicators turned off and nothing pinned to it. I'd get rid of it entirely if I could. (Alfred, cmd+tab, cmd+` (and occasionally Exposé) are all I use to open and switch apps outside of the terminal.)
- c-fe 2y agoI used a command to make it always hidden, and I just reach it via Mission Control, been liking this setup a lot especially since i use Mission control extensivley via the trackpad
- pandemic_region 2y agoThe correct dock location is hidden. What is this 'mouse' device that you refer to multiple times ? ;)
- walthamstow 2y agoI like RIGHT, but we can all agree that BOTTOM is the worst, because it shortens your screen by about 15%!
- ktpsns 2y agoAs a decade long windows and linux desktop user, the mac OS X dock was one thing I was really envy. There are tons of bad copies of it for various linux desktops (KDE, Gnome, XFCE, you name it), they all don't get it. The software quality of the dock and window manager was something where OS X was, for a long time, years apart other GUIs. My feeling is the default setting made the dock less exciting in the last years.
- conradfr 2y agoWhy? It's restricted to one display, but will insist on moving from one to another if you make some moves with your cursor. You can't decouple multiple windows of the same app. IIRC it insists on disappearing if you are in fullscreen on another display. It also wastes more space than other taskbars to be usefull and look decent. (disclaimer: I dislike MacOS globally)
- weberer 2y agoSorry, but the Mac DE sucks compared to modern ones like KDE. Why does my left-aligned dock change width every time I open a new program? Now every window I maximize has a slightly different width depending on how many programs were opened when I maximized it. Why can't I disable this feature? Why can't I get the dock to fill the height of the screen? Why are programs still "open" when they have no open windows? Why am I able to cmd-tab to applications with no open windows and have nothing happen?
- memsom 2y agoThis is a MacOS thing - an app is not just windows, it is also a menu. The windows can all be closed and the menu is still there. Apps that don't behave like that feel like they are not proper Mac apps. As a seasoned Mac user, cmd+Q is your friend.
- NaOH 2y ago>The windows can all be closed and the menu is still there. I'm a few macOS versions behind what's current, so it's possible things have changed, but historically in OS X/macOS your description applied to apps that could have multiple windows. Any app that could only have one window—for example, System Preferences—would quit when the one window was closed.
- oneeyedpigeon 2y agoI almost never use the Dock. Cmd+Tab for app switching, Launchpad for launching. The Dock sure looks nice, and that animation was magical 20 years ago, but I hate how it interrupts the cleanliness of the desktop.
- cwales95 2y agoI'm similar but I tend to use spotlight for launching. I do sometimes use the dock but all animations are disabled and it's hidden by default.
- ahartmetz 2y agoIt's a severe case of form over function and the worst launcher-task manager of any current desktop GUI. The only worse one that I've personally experienced is Windows 3.1. (Early 2000s twm or fvwm or whatever don't count, right? They weren't even trying.)
- I_am_tiberius 2y agoI'm using Mac OS for 3 years now but still find KDE/Windows to be way better.
- tomaskafka 2y agoBecause many people still don't know: Set dock delay (when it's hidden and you move the mouse to the side of the screen) to instant: > defaults write com.apple.Dock autohide-delay -float 0.0001; killall Dock Undo: > defaults delete com.apple.Dock autohide-delay; killall Dock