13 ms·
Why are corporations cutting managers?
- apwell23 2y agoThis is all over news but is this actually true. Meta is always citied as example because Mark said and did bunch of things to appease the markets. There are no reduction in numbers at meta now. Middle managers have made a comeback at meta big time. CEOs love middle managers despite what they say to investors. Even the numbers cited in the article are not convincing > middle-manager head counts by about 6% since the peak of their pandemic hiring sprees This actually indicates the opposite that middle managment is unusually resilient to layoffs
- dyauspitr 2y agoMiddle management gets a bad rap but that political battleground makes or break companies.
- danjl 2y agoExactly. Not having political battlegrounds makes companies better. Whereas, it sounds like you're saying having people to fight in the battleground is the goal.
- georgeecollins 2y agoI think what the previous post meant was that a political battleground always exists, not that middle managers create them. If you think they don't, you're telling me your role in the organization without telling me your role.
- dyauspitr 2y agoThose battles will always exist and need to be fought.
- txextos 2y agoI just always assumed middle management purpose is to insulate upper management from any bad consequences of the actual business. Like there is a dispersion process of responsibility of the actual business as you go up the chain so if you have enough layers you can basically free roll as an upper manager with taking credit for the good outcomes while the bad was just shitty middle management. It is an investment by upper manager to free roll.
- ashoeafoot 2y agobattleground is another name for markets
- scarface_74 2y agoWhy would Mark care about appeasing the market? He has a controlling interest in Meta and can’t be fired no matter what the market thinks. You can accuse Meta of a lot of things. But being short term focused is not one.
- apwell23 2y ago> Why would Mark care about appeasing the market? you mean he doesn't care what the meta stock price is ? then I don't have a theory why mark claimed to cut middle management in 'year of efficiency' but didn't actually do it.
- scarface_74 2y agoI can’t find numbers for 2024. But as of the end of 2023, they still have more employees than they did in 2020. https://www.statista.com/statistics/273563/number-of-facebook-employees/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/273563/number-of-faceboo...
- datadrivenangel 2y agoCorporations cut managers because they're expensive. Not having enough managers is also expensive though.
- lazide 2y agoThat part usually takes a couple quarters to show up though. :(
- datadrivenangel 2y agoThe organizational / social capital starts decreasing and then a few quarters later people see the costs of not having enough organizational capital. Boom/bust.
- marcinzm 2y agoManagement monopolizing organizational / social capital is itself a sign of a fairly unhealthy organization. So you might get a couple quarters of pain but then you'll end up with a better long term organization.
- lazide 2y agoAh, optimism. Not impossible, but rarely actually works out that way.
- jmclnx 2y agoActually my manager was "demoted" back to a programmer, which I think is a good thing. He was forced onto management a few years ago, but that was a waste of talent in my opinion. I also think a lot of stress he suffered as a manager is gone. But yes, a lot of people were let go at the same time (8 months ago). And the article, no useful information from what I can see.
- 98codes 2y agoOne of the big things that keeps me where I'm working now is the org structure that keeps managers & non-managers on separate career tracks until significantly higher in the org chart than most big companies. Moving between manager & not isn't a promotion or demotion; it's a sideways shift.
- bhouston 2y agoI find this article doesn't really say much of substance nor does it have hard facts to back it its claims related to the title. It really is just an observation piece - there are cuts and here are some very general theories without evidence. I didn't really gain much reading it.
- 6510 2y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42611851 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42611851
- vonnik 2y agoNot terribly insightful. The question in the headline is not answered.
- bhouston 2y agoWas it written by an AI?
- bjt 2y agoArnold Kling is a fairly well known academic. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arnold_Kling https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arnold_Kling I read this blog post as "thinking out loud on the internet". It's something I see done quite a bit in the econ blogosphere. Sometimes a post like this will prompt responses from other econ bloggers (Greg Mankiw, Tyler Cowen, etc.). Sometimes not. It's not meant to be an essay.
- scarface_74 2y agoIt wasn’t mean to. The entire last paragraph was a bunch of questions meant to invoke discussions and theories. It has no ads, the author is already a well known economist and has nothing to prove for trying to be a “thought leader”.
- hyperpape 2y agoThis reads as if the required amount of management for different initiatives is constant, but it isn't. One thing that happens is that when money is plentiful, there is a push to find new ways to generate returns. When money is tight, new bets look bad, and companies may cut new bets and work on optimizing their existing cash-cows. Strictly, that says nothing about the number of managers needed, but I do think it's less management intensive to keep on with what you're already doing.
- nine_zeros 2y agoThis is insightful and mirrors my understanding of corporations. New bets are too risky but existing bets need to be maintained for the sake of customers. Thus, new managers are not necessary as new teams are not necessary. Folding teams together also starts making sense. Fewer layers also starts making sense. Ultimately, management is overhead and administrative. Less important than individuals who are actually building, maintaining, advertising, and selling.
- chuckwfinley 2y ago[dead]
- asdasdsddd 2y ago> When money is tight, new bets look bad It's not optical, it's just bad. The risk adjusted returns for bets need to cross the interest rate threshold and when rates are high, the number of bets you can take must drop.
- karaterobot 2y ago> U.S. public companies have cut their middle-manager head counts by about 6% since the peak of their pandemic hiring sprees Haven't there been pretty big, well-known layoffs in other areas as well in the last couple years? Lots of engineers have gotten laid off, and the article also points out a 6% reduction in HR. Might it be that they're just laying everybody off across the board? I'd love it if this article considered management layoffs compared to the base rate of layoffs. I'm a designer, and what I tell people is that you can't avoid having a designer on your team: if you don't have a dedicated designer, design is going to get done by everybody else. Probably by people who don't want to do it, aren't good at it, or may not even know they're doing it as they make unconsidered choices that shape your product forever. I think the same is probably true with managers. You hypothesize: ahh, managers are probably dead weight, let's get rid of them to save money. But then it turns out that all the individual contributors have to split the work the managers used to do. Or, more likely, your lead IC has to do it along with their main job. And in most cases they are not good at it, and do a poor job, and when it nets out you've got a less productive team. My manager quit a year ago, they didn't backfill for his position, and it's been an utter shitshow ever since.
- Animats 2y agoDoes it take fewer managers to manage remote employees? Do the tools that help manage projects with remote employees reduce the number of managers needed?
- ergonaught 2y agoComments so far seem to fail to recognize that this post is a "response" to the WSJ article linked at the very beginning and isn't a standalone piece by itself.
- mooreds 2y agoHere's the WSJ piece for folks without a subscription: https://archive.is/SwWn6 https://archive.is/SwWn6
- rybosworld 2y agoLots of bad faith in this article. Example: "On the same WSJ front page that the story of management cutbacks appeared, there was also a story about the stock market having risen unusually fast the last two years. Perhaps these stories are connected"
- oldpersonintx 2y ago[dead]
- jawns 2y agoRemember that about 3-4 years ago, we experienced the Great Migration. The percentage of tech workers who moved to new companies was very high compared with historical migration patterns. Interests rates were still very low, companies had been buoyed by pandemic-related assistance, and inflation hadn't yet set in, so the salaries that were being offered were very attractive. In the years since, the incentives to leave one's current employer have decreased. Salaries have stagnated, there's been belt tightening and layoffs, the pool of applicants competing for the same jobs has become bigger, and a lot of folks who've gotten cushy benefits like permanent WFH arrangements would have to go back to the office if they changed jobs. But that means that a lot of tech companies are experiencing lower than normal attrition, but there's still professional growth happening, and the only way the companies have been able to reward employees is through promotions. That has led to bloat at the management layer, which this year many companies have tried to address, either by letting managers go or sending them back into IC roles. I predict that due to "tenure lock" (where a lot of people who moved in the Great Migration have the same tenure at their current company) we're likely to hit a watershed moment that leads to another Great Migration later in the decade.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- vikingerik 2y agoThe Great Migration wasn't as real as the headlines made it look, though. It was an artifact of time-shifting from the pandemic. Normal job switching didn't happen in 2020 and became pent-up demand in 2021. So the numbers looked high for a short duration, but it wasn't really any fundamental shift, just the same activity pushed into a shorter time period. Look at the total numbers from 2019-2024 and I bet it's about the same as any five-year period.
- jawns 2y agoCorrect, the pandemic led to pent-up demand, and the Great Migration was what happened when job switching became tenable again. But the effects of that pent-up demand are a larger than normal group of people who now have the same relative tenure at their new organizations, and demand is building up again, as more and more people who've been with their company for 3+ years are looking for a change, but can't find one in the current hiring climate. So I predict we'll see a similar wave of large-scale job hopping once conditions become more favorable.
- blackeyeblitzar 2y agoA number of corporations are going to learn hard lessons from indiscriminate cutting of middle management, like when Google thought they were being innovative in not having much management a long time ago.
- mschild 2y agoI think as with everything, it depends on what end of the spectrum your company is at. There are a lot companies, Volkswagen to name a prominent example, that have over time built up massive management layers that don't ultimately serve the company goals. Getting rid of excess is something that is necessary because they have ballooned to expensive and unhealthy proportions. Having none at all or too little obviously also has downsides.
- _DeadFred_ 2y agoManufacturing is all about management though, isn't it? Management is the make or break in that industry. Sure you can coast with your current setup, but that isn't enough for an auto company long term. You need to manage your PLM (product life cycle CAD/design software) integrated to your EBOM (engineering bill of materials) to your MBOM (manufacturing bill of materials) to support your ERP (enterprise resource planning) in support of your MRP (manufacturing resource planning). All of that requires people at higher levels that understand the systems at the conceptual level and the company specific level, working together to make sure that 40,000 parts manufactured in house and purchased externally, all with varying lead times, come together at the exact right time to build the correct model/configuration for the market right now. I've seen plenty of companies making bank today but that were doomed because they no longer did any of the above, they fired management, they outsourced design, they outsourced IT, they coasted on prior managers work in setting/configuring everything and it all became fixed in place as is. Best they could hope for was to bring in consultants to heavy lift changes as part of 'major' efforts going forward, allowing what managers would have been continually adapting to pill up until it became such a big issue money was freed up for the consultants.
- 2y ago
- pjdemers 2y agoThe same reason sports teams fire their head coach (or manager) when the owners want a change - because it is easy to replace one manager than an entire team.
- riku_iki 2y agonew manager then can slowly fire and hire according to new goals.
- xoneill 2y agoPart of the problem: https://47cleanupcrew.com/ https://47cleanupcrew.com/ "Of course they want to bring in Indians and Artificial Intelligence. Why would they want to pay a US citizen $100,000 a year or whatever the commensurate salary is for your job."
- 9rx 2y agoIs head count the right metric anymore? For all the talk of the LLM impact on programming, LLMs are even better at doing managerial tasks. The managers may no longer have heads.
- acjohnson55 2y agoTo begin with, the people who make and influence strategic decisions at companies--executives, boards, and major investors--are just as susceptible to fads as anybody else. The difference is that the fads they get into have massive impacts on people's lives. You rarely get fired for making a bad decisions everyone else is making at the same time. We see this in professional sports where playcallers will make decisions that are conventional but demonstrably suboptimal. There are a lot of managers who are force multipliers for their teams. There are a lot that do crucial glue work but aren't gamechangers. There are a lot who are mediocre. There are some that are counterproductive. It is very difficult to tell the difference between these. Even if you have lots of time, it is hard to isolate the work of the manager from the circumstances they're in. One way to find out is to get rid of the managers and see which initiatives suffer. I'm guessing we'll see the number of managers gradually converge to whatever the long-term average, unless the nature of white collar work has changed. On case-by-case bases, teams that are hamstrung by insufficient management will demand more management. They'll get it, especially if they are doing critical work. Other teams will regain management due to the desire for consistency.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- mobilejdral 2y agoBecause there was general layoffs of the workers in the previous year or two? There is a fairly formulaic way that companies tighten belts. First you do layoffs, get rid of projects that will never make money, reduce headcount for orgs that grew fat, etc. At the same time you explore offshoring (especially as it keeps the same number of headcount under a vp for less cost). Then there is a round of cleaning up the management layer, making sure everyone has a minimum number of reports, moving some managers back to being leads/IC etc. This was all formulaic and the more experienced directors and VP's back in 2022 knew this and immediately started playing the new corporate game to win in the long run.
- floppiplopp 2y agoBecause middle management is a self-perpetuation and completely useless caste at best, maliciously incompetent is usually what I observe in their ranks. Cutting the vapid, self-important, ignorant and lazy middle management is probably the best idea any company could have. Fire everyone who does not do any real work, then hire qualified personnel where organizational prowess is really needed.
- purplezooey 2y ago"Perhaps what happened in recent years is that senior executives could not see how to boost revenues quickly enough to satisfy shareholders." And there we have it.