7 ms·
Do Kwon pleads not guilty to US fraud charges in $40B crypto collapse
- ty6853 2y ago[flagged]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- proteal 2y agoWell, the US dollar is an instrument to serve the interests of the US people. Many Americans were harmed by the collapse, so the government is going to try to claw back what it can for its people. After all, doesn’t matter where you are in the world, if you’ve got USD in your hands, you’re subject to US law. Lawmakers/prosecutors do know that they are unlikely to recover a majority of lost funds. They’re going to put this man behind bars as a deterrent to others who want to (allegedly) defraud Americans.
- throwjeje 2y agoHmm same country which protects other countries criminals and gives a middle finger to other countrys laws
- numair 2y agoOh man, the irony of this response. Do Kwon very specifically did NOT have USD in this situation, and I’m pretty sure his defense will be that there was no representation that the peg would be maintained indefinitely. Whether the evidence points to the contrary is another matter altogether.
- gruez 2y ago>Do Kwon very specifically did NOT have USD in this situation The indictment lists a bunch of ways that ties his crimes to the US >KWON solicited and obtained investments from a number of investment firms in the United States and other locations [...] >DO HYEONG KWON, the defendant, nonetheless fraudulently promoted Chai to investors in the United States [...] >On or about October 12 , 2020, KWON sent an email to a representative of an investment firm based in New York containing a Terraform promotional document falsely claiming [...] >On or about October 14 , 2019, KWON made a false and misleading statement during a CNBC presentation transmitted to, among other places, the Southern District of New York, about Chai 's usage of the Tena blockchain [...]
- ty6853 2y agoDo Kwon in bars makes zero material difference or deterrence to the next Do Kwon. I understand the desire for justice, just sick of the government forcing me at gunpoint to pay to fly around these guys operating overseas stealing from people trying to operate outside the US financial system. Maybe they should take a charity donation for jailing foreign operating criminals and leave me out of it.
- llamaimperative 2y agoYou don’t think “the US federal government will come after you if you conduct crime in USD and/or against Americans regardless of where you live/operate your business” is a real deterrent, as compared to “operate abroad and you can victimize Americans at will?”
- ty6853 2y agoWhat happens in reality is the US comes after me to pay to fly and feed these criminals, makes me pay for some prosecutor to get fat on steaks and braces on his kid, meanwhile I get basically fuck all for it other than to watch the next overseas crypto scammer take his place 5 minutes later. I'm not saying you can't seek justice, i just want to be left out of it.
- llamaimperative 2y agoYou pay taxes to the US but don’t benefit from the significant deterrent effect its law enforcement creates against scamming you? How so?
- ty6853 2y agoWhat evidence do you have extradition of crypto scammers has moved the needle at all on scamming? I'm not seeing the benefit you speak of, a new one pops up 5 minutes later to replace the last.
- 2y ago
- anigbrowl 2y agoAfter all, doesn’t matter where you are in the world, if you’ve got USD in your hands, you’re subject to US law. I hope this is meant sarcastically.
- ty6853 2y agoThis is far more true than you know. Almost everyone in the west is subject to US law via our extra-territorial wire fraud or money laundering statutes that will get you as soon as anything ( read: most everything) you touch remotely touches the US banking system.
- anigbrowl 2y agoI'm aware of this, I'm trying to ascertain whether GP thinks this is great or not.
- selectodude 2y agoIt’s absolutely true. Be careful out there.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- gruez 2y ago> When you export your electrons from the US, leaving US jurisdiction why must all us taxpayers suffer to protect you? Let the victims seek whatever justice they can find in whatever shithole they did business in. "all us taxpayers" benefits from capital markets that aren't rife with fraudsters.
- ty6853 2y agoIt (extraditing crypto scammers) is ineffectual at that pursuit.
- gruez 2y agoSo what do you propose we do with scammers, crypto or otherwise? Shrug our shoulders and say "meh"?
- ty6853 2y agoThis is a preposterous premise in Kwon's case considering the US ripped away competing extradition from his home country and place of part time management of fraud, South Korea.
- gruez 2y agoBut you said last comment that "extraditing crypto scammers" was "ineffectual"? Which one is it?
- ty6853 2y agoI didn't say Koreas punishment would be effectual at securing our markets either. My answer implied it is not equal to shrugging of shoulders. Your false dichotomy here is totally illogical.
- gruez 2y agoSo US putting scammer in jail... "ineffectual", but South Korea doing the same is effectual? Are US prisons that much cushier that South Korean prisons?
- sbuttgereit 2y agoIt is wholly appropriate for a government act to protect it's citizens' rights including their property rights. Fraud and theft violate those rights. Your arguments are essentially shifting blame from the fraudster to the victim... not unlike the kind of arguments that suggest certain rapes or murders are also the victim's fault for either dressing suggestively or travelling through the wrong part of town at the wrong time. While those things may actually be unwise, that the victim didn't act with wisdom or prescience doesn't relieve the perpetrator of culpability nor make the victim deserving of such violation. Wisdom merely dictates that it might be better for you to avoid the risk of becoming a victim if you can. I personally don't engage in these kinds of financial instruments because I feel the risks are pretty high.... but I absolutely applaud the government pursuing a fraudster where ever they can... without regard to the wisdom, or foolishness, of the victim.
- ty6853 2y agoYes and the government is defrauding me claiming this is effective governance and stealing from me to lock these guys up. They are violating my property rights in extraditing kwon. You are victim blaming me for being unhappy with this.
- Rodeoclash 2y agoThis is an astounding level of "logical" jumps. As for why the government is doing this, it's very beneficial for the US to demonstrate its long arm of the law as a lesson to other criminals.
- ty6853 2y agoIs it? There is a Korean poster bragging here about how happy they are to have offloaded kwon to the US for a free ride on us since they are too lazy to mete out full punishment of people operating on their turf. We are a laughing stock. Dump your criminals on the US taxpayers to play world police.
- 2y ago
- teractiveodular 2y agoThe figure "$40B" is bandied about uncritically in the press, but I gather this is the highest notional market cap of Terra/Luna, not a reflection of actual money (fiat) put in? By contrast, SBF of FTX fame was convicted of stealing $8.7B and ordered to restitute the amount to investors in USD.
- Hilift 2y agoI still remember Do running away from FTX right after meeting with SBF, a few days before it fell apart. That was before the "a $4.55 billion settlement that he and Terraform reached with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission.". The $40 billys is the losses due to fluctuation in value. It's possible they are pressuring him to release information on crypto holdings that were transacted with Iran and other sanctioned entities.
- tw04 2y agoOk? And? If you rob a bank and walk out with $10k you’re facing 15+ years in prison. If the number is “Only” $1b he should spend the rest of his life in prison.
- mrayycombi 2y agoHow about the death sentence if it exceeds a certain number of victims or dollar amount? Executing these fools might act as a deterrent.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- artdigital 2y agoAs someone who lost around 50,000 in the terra/luna collapse, I do believe a lot of it is on Do Kwon. He was the one that kept the Anchor flywheel at unsustainably high APR, moved more UST to refill the reserves and so on. He also ignored warnings of a death spiral and continued with advertising unrealistic expectations. When the depeg happened, Do Kwon was front and center on making it sound like everything was under control, instead of damage control. And his creation of LUNA2 is even more of a joke for the people that lost money on this. Is it his fault that it collapsed? Maybe not directly, but he steered the boat.
- jiggawatts 2y agoIt doesn’t matter how hard you tug at your bootstraps or how fast, you’re not going to avoid the splat once you’ve stepped off a bridge over a chasm. The Terra/Luna implosion was inevitable. Actions by Do Kwon may have hastened or delayed the end, but could not have prevented it. Believing otherwise is a pure fantasy… … but that’s the whole point, isn’t it? For a short time people really wanted to believe that one fantasy can prop up another fantasy and the construct of the two can somehow become real. I watched the Neverending Story too when I was a kid. It ended.
- nurettin 2y agoI wonder if there are people who made it their business to short hype coins.
- tibbydudeza 2y agoYes - see the shady character behind the Hawk Tuah meme coin - son of some famous actor who was a judge on The Voice.
- numtel 2y agoIt was the same algorithm as Iron finance on Polygon the year before which imploded in the exact same way but on a more expedited timeframe because it didn't limit the apy at 20%. The terra/luna collapse was simple to see coming as it happened exactly when the terra (stablecoin) market cap met the luna one.
- electriclove 2y agoWhat is the SEC going to do with the $4.55B settlement?
- Osiris 2y agoGive it to all the people that lost money in the scam? Isn't that generally what those settlements are for?
- StressedDev 2y agoIf it's a fine, it probably goes to the United States Treasury or the SEC's budget. I also wouldn't be surprised if the settlement was not fully paid.
- seanhunter 2y agoHere’s how the SEC themselves talk about their thought process around settlements https://www.sec.gov/newsroom/speeches-statements/clayton-statement-regarding-offers-settlement https://www.sec.gov/newsroom/speeches-statements/clayton-sta... It’s basically usually some mix of fine and restitution, with the bulk going to restitution in these sorts of cases but with more fine in cases where the defendant should have known better (eg settlements with big banks) but the actual nominal loss to investors is lower than the regulator believes the firm should have to pay up.
- AnarchismIsCool 2y agoDoes this mean he has to participate in the Squid Game?