10 ms·
US newspapers are deleting old crime stories, offering subjects a 'clean slate'
- janice1999 2y ago> One in three U.S. adults has been arrested by age 23. Does that seem crazy to anyone else? I'm in Ireland and can't think of one person in my extended family and friends that has any interaction with the police beyond routine insurance/DUI checkpoints or reporting incidents like car accidents.
- nickfromseattle 2y agoAs a nerdy, middle class, white guy, I and many of my male friends have been arrested between ages 18 - 25. Usually for drinking underage, public intoxication, or small amounts of marijuana.
- tylerflick 2y agoMeh, we’re a rebellious group. Honestly though I would be more interested in what percentage of this ratio are repeat offenders.
- threatofrain 2y ago> Meh, we’re a rebellious group. Definitely not the explanation.
- erehweb 2y agoReally high, and crazy, but apparently legit -see https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC4443707/#:~:text=Brame%2C%20Turner%2C%20Paternoster%2C%20and,nontraffic%20offense%20by%20age%2023 https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC4443707/#:~:text=Br....
- tppiotrowski 2y agoThe fact that it's self reported makes me wonder how close to the actual number it is. Also, how did they choose their sample. Edit: Link to original paper https://d1wqtxts1xzle7.cloudfront.net/32982174/Turner_-_Appendix_A_-_2012c-libre.pdf?1393238502=&response-content-disposition=inline%3B+filename%3DThe_Cumulative_Prevalence_of_Arrest_from.pdf&Expires=1736012643&Signature=hGyXSQ-Wog1w6Pwok~cKdqgTPZCM-1JX2tyKnhf14lLkqmlfKnqhp71y-8kBYVTo4QpyEat5wEctau7jD2K8z6fOAYI5aahQ9efDkyjf9JN2Fj60SX2dkGPcCNgnIsA5ECwYIABI-N6WoVtPdLVaZNs8eoNtObCx9OECQ9TAQY6SMMlEjBI~4cZhTcbXaJWLZP0Gb87l9nD0rV26Pw1LkqW5lvofXyE8ClpA~G2NN-0DFUvNfKh4trN1R7gpiIeAMUHgE7dOYtHUZhghg83060Ml9bYkXqnSe1pcX~wn1g68i65xzzMqIp0urOF0QCOL9Qr3ZsEVuQpdWkLgNtvBkg__&Key-Pair-Id=APKAJLOHF5GGSLRBV4ZA https://d1wqtxts1xzle7.cloudfront.net/32982174/Turner_-_Appe...
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- verteu 2y agoIt's the NLSY, about as good a sample as one could hope for.
- blakesterz 2y agoLooking at the PDF they link to, it doesn't say "has been arrested" it says "has criminal record". Maybe those 2 things are the same, but I'm not so sure.
- sgjohnson 2y agoCriminal records would include all misdemeanors. You can get a misdemeanor without ever being arrested. In some cases trivial things like speeding can be a misdemeanor requiring a court appearance.
- bookofjoe 2y ago25 years ago I got a misdemeanor citation for rollerblading on the sidewalk in downtown Charlottesville, Virginia, which required me to make a court appearance and pay for a VERY expensive lawyer to get the charge thrown out. If instead I'd paid the $25 fine, I'd have had a permanent misdemeanor charge on my record.
- rayiner 2y agoSame thing in Maryland. Speeding is a criminal charge here.
- 1over137 2y agoHaving a record of such a minor infraction doesn’t seem to me a problem, in and of itself. The problem would be if such records were public, available to potential employers, etc. If the records were private to the courts, that’d be something else. Not sure how it is in USA.
- profile53 2y agoIn the USA it is public record which in practice means anyone with money can get the record. This is potentially a large part of the high US recidivism. Once you have been convicted once, most employers will see the record and refuse to hire you forever.
- kQq9oHeAz6wLLS 2y agoThat seems exceptionally high, and I'm assuming the study was mostly (all?) urban subjects, which could skew the results heavily. I can't think of more than 2 people I know that have an arrest history, and I know a LOT of (non-urban dwelling) people.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- verteu 2y agoNo, the sample was the NLSY: https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC4443707/ https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC4443707/
- thrance 2y agoIt's kind of my experience too, we all live in our (socioeconomic) bubbles. You are much more likely to get involved with the police if you were raised by poor parents. Or rather, you are much less likely to get involved with the police if you were raised by (comparatively) rich parents.
- ternnoburn 2y ago[flagged]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- doctorpangloss 2y agoYou can figure this for anything, and prepare to be shocked. The variables are the number of incidents per period, the population during that period, and the expected duration an incident could occur. For example, in San Francisco, there are about 4700 car related injuries and deaths per year; about 800000 people; and the life expectancy is high at 83. This gives you 41 years for a cumulative 25% chance to have been involved in your first car injury. It is crazy. Everyone should be pissed off. Do this for guns, diabetes, etc. Think about the people you know, and how the further you venture into acquaintances, you know someone who has been arrested, injured by a car, injured by a gun, has diabetes, etc. Some will be looking for math flaws. It’s an exponential model for time until first event, “constant hazard.” It’s actuarial. Nothing unorthodox. If you couldn’t calculate the durations until events insurance couldn’t work. The biggest factors are numerator, denominator and eligible period (ie rate of incidence). The biggest factors are NOT other things… The reason you doubt this stuff, that you think it’s crazy, isn’t because the math is wrong. You believe very strongly that people involved in crimes and car crashes and guns have personal agency. The discount for panopticon approved safe driving is a pathetic 5-10%! If agency is all it was, auto insurance would be way cheaper. This is all about the myth about what kinds of agency matter. You cannot be much of a “better” driver. You can’t be a “safer” criminal. Even if you never drove, due to the rate of injuries, it takes 41 years. I didn’t give the figure for causing injuries, just being involved in one, on purpose: we’re primed to assume it’s all about agency. Consider if there were only ONE criminal who commits the same rate of crimes: they’re still going to arrest a ton of people! Or ONE driver who hits everybody: you’re still going to be involved. The math is easy to understand but people absolutely refuse to question their beliefs about agency.
- luckylion 2y ago> For example, in San Francisco, there are about 4700 car related injuries and deaths per year; about 800000 people; 800k permanent residents. > In 2019, prior to the COVID-19 pandemic more than 26 million visitors travelled to San Francisco. That changes your statistics quite a bit.
- brookst 2y ago
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- rqtwteye 2y agoWhen I went to a boxing gym in Maryland there were a lot of young black guys. For them going to prison was totally normal thing. Often they themselves had been to prison or their relatives. Some had scars from gunshots. I can’t even imagine how it is to grow up in that environment.
- ocschwar 2y agoI had a surreal experience riding a Greyhound bus where I was the only passenger who hadn't just gotten out of prison. They were comparing conditions in various prisons the way you and I might compare coffee shops.
- qingcharles 2y agoHaving been locked up, I was regularly the only white guy in a whole building. It's completely normalized for Black youth to go to jail. I hesitate to say it, but it's practically considered a rite of passage. It's really sad. Some of these kids are absolutely smart as fuck and could do anything with their lives if their environment hadn't failed them. When they get to jail, every one of their friends is there already, so it's way easier for them to process and deal with than it is for some random middle-class white dude.
- gjm11 2y agoIt'll vary a lot by demographic. It's not that 1/3 of every group of US adults has ever been arrested, it's that there are some groups where hardly ever have and some groups where a huge fraction have, and it averages out to 1/3. In particular, I bet that if you look at poor black men who live in US cities the figure is very very high. Maybe it's close to 100%.[1] If you look at middle-class white women living in the suburbs, not so much. Also: the fact that the report is about the US and you're in Ireland is very relevant; the US has a lot more arrests than Ireland. (I would guess, though I haven't looked at stats and I don't know whether they exist, that the US also has more racial divergence in the figures than Ireland.) (I shall not get into the highly contentious and political question of why these things are the case.) I'll guess that your extended family and friends are mostly (1) not in the US, (2) white, (3) middle class, and (4) not living in city centres. All of which makes them drastically less likely to end up having difficult interactions with the police. [1] I did some crude arithmetic on the figures at https://www.sentencingproject.org/app/uploads/2022/08/Americans-with-Criminal-Records-Poverty-and-Opportunity-Profile.pdf https://www.sentencingproject.org/app/uploads/2022/08/Americ... and got an estimate that 108% of black men in the US have a criminal record. That seems unlikely to be correct :-) but suggests that the real figure is probably pretty high. (I suspect it does also indicate that the "up to 1/3" is an overestimate.)
- gruez 2y ago>[1] I did some crude arithmetic on the figures at https://www.sentencingproject.org/app/uploads/2022/08/Americ https://www.sentencingproject.org/app/uploads/2022/08/Americ... and got an estimate that 108% of black men in the US have a criminal record. That seems unlikely to be correct :-) How are you calculating the proportion of black men with criminal records? The pdf mentions that black men are 6x more likely to be incarcerated, but that's not the same as having a criminal record.
- gjm11 2y agoYeah, that's one reason why the arithmetic is crude. The PDF says the following things: About 1/3 of US adults have been arrested by age 23. About 1/3 of US adults have a criminal record. Black men in the US are about 6x more likely to be incarcerated than white men in the US. These figures aren't all about the same thing -- different classes of (alleged) offence, and also "adults" versus "men" -- and indeed the black:white ratios may be different for arrests, and criminal records, and incarcerations. It's not obvious to me whether we should expect the black:white ratio to be much higher for incarcerations than for arrests or criminal records. If it is, then that would indeed be one of several possible explanations for how the crude calculation ends up with more than 100% of black men in the US having a criminal record. Anyway, my calculation just pretended that the black:white ratio is the same for arrests / criminal records (take your pick, both are alleged to be up to ~1/3 of US adults) among adults as for incarcerations among men. Probably false, but I was just looking for a ballpark figure.
- ternnoburn 2y ago20% of the world's prisoners are housed in America. Interactions with police and arrests are very common here.
- guerrilla 2y ago4.25% of the world's population live in the US.
- rafram 2y agoRight, so the US incarceration rate is almost five times the global average.
- blackeyeblitzar 2y agoYes but the US is a safer place to live and conduct business than most of the world. And it has a population that’s far more diverse than any other country. Looking at this metric requires context. And it could be that these are great numbers for what you get in return.
- ternnoburn 2y agoThe US is not particularly safe. Various indices put it well below other countries -- in the top half, for sure, but it's hardly a safe place. You'll have to supply evidence that the US is safe, as that's not self evident.
- kevingadd 2y agoPolicing and imprisonment are very aggressive here. Arrests very often don't turn into convictions because the police are rewarded for wielding force any way they choose regardless of whether it's justified - their right to do this is legally protected via qualified immunity.
- lostlogin 2y agoYou may already know of Peelian Policing, but if not: Several countries practice a very different model, described as as ‘policing by consent’. Police try to work with and not against citizens, recognising that they are citizens too. Ireland polices its population this way, USA doesn’t. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peelian_principles https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peelian_principles
- dragonwriter 2y agoThe US is, by comparison to the rest of the developed world (and much of the rest of the world, besides) a very high police interaction regime, owing in no small part to the institutional and cultural aftereffects of the history of slavery and the use of the criminal justice system as a direct substitute for private chattel slavery when it was abolished.
- yuliyp 2y agoI'm trying to figure out where that number comes from. The link to The Sentencing Project claims this, but the link to NCSL instead states "Approximately 77 million Americans, or 1 in every 3 adults, have a criminal record." Like, this feels like it's got to include speeding tickets in the mix to get something that high.
- datavirtue 2y agoSpeeding tickets are not criminal.
- WalterBright 2y agoIn the 1960s, the Air Force decided that they had too many candidates for pilots, and to winnow it down all candidates with a speeding ticket were disqualified. I've often felt this was unwise, as you want fighter pilots to be aggressive.
- datavirtue 2y agoYeah, but you don't want them getting caught.
- anticensor 2y agoSo they looked at traffic infractions record, too; interesting.
- UncleEntity 2y ago> Like, this feels like it's got to include speeding tickets in the mix to get something that high. Speeding is a civil, not criminal, infraction. You can't have the highest prison population in the world for decades and not end up with a bunch of people with criminal records.
- yuliyp 2y agoThe U.S. prison population is around 2M people. I'm not sure how that translates to 77M people with criminal records. (I'm serious about wanting to know more about these statistics and how they're generated. My brief searches trying to find where the data claimed in the linked infographics comes from got me nowhere. EDIT: I found the [National Longitudinal Survey of Youth](https://www.bls.gov/nls/nlsy97.htm https://www.bls.gov/nls/nlsy97.htm) and as far as I could tell from some super quick excel formulas it's about 32% of interview subjects (people born 1980 - 1984) reported being arrested at least once by 2021.
- rychco 2y agoThe prison-industrial complex in the United States encourages this. While less than 10% of prisoners are in “for-profit” prisons, there’s a large industry of private companies beyond this that profit off federal prisons; in addition to providing cheap prison labor or goods made by prison laborers (AKA modern slavery)
- FireBeyond 2y agoMany of those private prisons also have clauses with their contracts that the city/county/whatever is required to pay per bed, regardless of occupancy. "If we're paying for it, might as well use it".
- blackeyeblitzar 2y agoIt’s an obviously incorrect figure. It must include things like traffic tickets. The guardian is a highly activist and biased publication by their own admission, and not truly “journalistic”.
- lostlogin 2y agoIt’s trivial to search and check. The numbers appear to be accurate. However that is misleading, the below link talks about problems with the definition of a ‘criminal record.’ https://www.politifact.com/factchecks/2017/aug/18/andrew-cuomo/yes-one-three-us-adults-have-criminal-record/ https://www.politifact.com/factchecks/2017/aug/18/andrew-cuo...
- Mistletoe 2y agoYes it seems crazy but this map is crazy too. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_incarceration_rate https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_incarcera...
- ocschwar 2y agoThe US isn't one country. When you read things like this, compare the EU to the US, not Ireland to the US. The Southern US is an archipelago of police states that regularly throw black and poor white citizens into jail on flimsy pretexts. New England, meanwhile is another country altogether.
- bongodongobob 2y agoWell arrested doesn't mean thrown in jail. Sometimes you are arrested then just given a citation. Open intoxicant, noise violation, underage drinking, speeding, bonfire in a field, peeing behind the bar, etc. I can see it.
- dougi3 2y agothank god for the wayback machine
- barbazoo 2y ago[flagged]
- qingcharles 2y agoIf the newspaper uses robots.txt to exclude the deleted article's URL then archive.org will also remove it from their archives.
- markx2 2y agohttps://www.judyrecords.com/ https://www.judyrecords.com/ probably has it.
- qingcharles 2y agoAnd this is a potential issue, because you might be able to persuade a newspaper to remove an article, you can get your criminal record expunged, but it's very unlikely you can persuade a court to totally seal a record of the case, especially if it has appellate issues.
- ternnoburn 2y agoI'm ok with this, as long as it's systemic. Otherwise it's just another way for people with means to get a leg up on people without means. If it's, "we delete all crime stories after N years", then fine, especially for low level, non violent stuff. The punishment for crimes should come from the justice system and people should be able to pay their dues and move on.
- coliveira 2y ago> especially for low level, non violent stuff This is codeword for financial, white collar crimes. So, it is definitely a policy serving the rich.
- cynicalkane 2y agoIt's generally the disadvantaged and poor who get hit for low-level, non-violent stuff.
- blackeyeblitzar 2y agoAre they the ones also committing more of them statistically - is that why (or are you saying they are targeted)? And if so why is that the case - there are plenty of people who are disadvantaged and poor and don’t commit crimes. Look at various immigrant minority groups for example.
- ternnoburn 2y ago[flagged]
- worik 2y ago> It's generally the disadvantaged and poor who get hit for low-level, non-violent stuff. In my country (New Zealand) judges let off young people who look like them, regularly. "This young man [not but almost always a man] has a great future and he should not be burdened...." That is if they are an aspiring accountant, laywer, sports star, etcetera If they are a young bricklayer, welder, etcetera it is tough luck It is absolutely disgusting. No wonder so many people want to burn the whole thing down
- reader9274 2y agoAh yes, rewrite history to not offend, what got us here in the first place
- systemstops 2y agoAs AI tools become more powerful and are used by the public to analyse the news, I suspect we'll see a lot more deletions of news articles to prevent "harmful" narratives from forming.
- nicce 2y agoWould it better to punish the publishers and users of such AI tools instead? A better solution.
- frereubu 2y agoThis isn't about not offending people.
- mmooss 2y agoWhat are you referring to and how did that 'get us here'?
- tokai 2y agoI know Library of Congress has a newspaper database. But does anyone know if newspapers are covered by mandatory deposit in the US? Many European countries archive all national newspapers, printed or digital, so they won't be lost for posterity if deleted by their publisher. To me it seems unreasonable to require publishers to keep an immutable record. Shouldn't be forced by law to keep up your blog posts. National Libraries and legal deposit were literally made to solve this issue.
- SoftTalker 2y agoThe local newspaper here recently shut down. They had close to 100 years of archives, went to the dump. They tried to give them to the library, to the local university, to anyone. No takers.
- tokai 2y agoAgain I don't know the scope of US mandatory deposit. But in the countries such as the UK, the Scandinavian countries, or Germany tall issues of such a newspaper would already be in the archive of the national library, in two copies.
- ghaff 2y agoBasically, as I understand it, there is none. If you want to collect copyright infringement damages, you have to register for copyright, pay, and deposit a copy. Otherwise you have a copyright on creation and don't need to deposit anything. The vast majority of created works are not deposited anywhere.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- Schiendelman 2y agoWhat newspaper was this?
- veny20 2y agoThis is Orwellian gaslighting. These papers should no longer be viewed as authoritive keepers of the public record. Any institution that engages in this kind of memory-holing forfeits all credibility. They can no longer be trusted whatsoever.
- CuriouslyC 2y agoImagine someone who got pardoned by the state for a minor crime (so a clean criminal record) but who still had a newspaper article about them. That would be a raw deal.
- blackeyeblitzar 2y agoNot a raw deal, just the truth. Why should information be deleted? That IS Orwellian.
- CuriouslyC 2y agoBecause people are prejudiced, and the newspaper article doesn't include an addendum that it should be taken with little to no value, so the impact it could have on someone's life due to people's stupidity is unwarranted. If we lived in a perfect universe where people were thoughtful and wise I wouldn't care.
- veny20 2y agoIf it was reported in a newspaper, then it was deemed to be newsworthy, and that record should be preserved for posterity, for myriad reasons.
- evujumenuk 2y agoI understand this is the general policy in a few places, like Germany. The general idea seems to be that it is more beneficial to a society if criminals are given a viable avenue to lead non-criminal lives again, with the alternative being people going "ah fuck it, I guess I'm a criminal now". I'm surprised at this concept spreading in the US, since the system would generally benefit from having perpetual perpetrators percolating through the prison slavery system.
- baybal2 2y ago[dead]
- llamaimperative 2y agoIt’s almost like there are multiple competing interests at play in a country of 340 million people…
- dingnuts 2y agotake your tinfoil hat off. the US isn't one system conspiratorially doing one thing or another. it is a myriad of competing individuals and groups. journalists have different incentives than private prison operators and tend to be more progressive for whatever reason. they often are activists. it should not be surprising that journalists might take a softer view and than prison industrialists in a country with free thought and expression
- cj 2y agoThe article isn’t strictly talking about prisoners. In the example in the article, a kid vandalized a tombstone in a graveyard, and can’t find a job years later.
- dylan604 2y agoThe negative knee jerk reaction to things has become comical. It's to the point where schools will not allow the parents of a student that has a record to come on school campus. They don't even care what the offense was for; they only look that there's not a clean slate.
- xrd 2y agoA flip side to this is that you can go here to see archives of newspapers: https://news.google.com/newspapers https://news.google.com/newspapers After reviewing lots of southern papers during the 1960s, shockingly (!) entire months are gone. I was really hoping to read their editorials saying what they thought MLK really was at that time, and then see what they wrote today. I figured this would be more fun than paying attention to Trump on inauguration day, which weirdly falls on the same day as MLK day. Let's be frank, there probably isn't ad revenue for old crime stories that aren't sensationalized. So, the newspapers owners are not doing this out of the kindness of their hearts, or their thoughts on the criminal justice system. How about instead, they agree moving forward to not publish crime stories about poor people at all? That I could get excited about.
- irrational 2y agoWhat would happen to people’s perception of crime if only the crime perpetuated by the rich and powerful was reported on?
- xrd 2y agoIt's probably just me, but it feels like reporting on crime is very lopsided and slanted against the powerless.
- slowmovintarget 2y agoThe powerless are usually the victims, not the criminals. Criminals are by definition exerting their power (usually through physical violence) over people who have even less "power." Not everything is about power dynamics, and crime rarely is. Far more often it is about selfishness.
- xrd 2y agoAgain, would love to be proved wrong, but I think physical violence is far and away the majority of crime reported, but the minority (in my own definition) of crimes committed. As an example, I think RealPage and the rent collusion they were doing clearly is illegal. And, has impacted hundreds of thousands, if not millions of people.. But, you'll see a lot more reporting on a shooting in every newspaper, even though in most cases that would directly impact only a few people.
- caymanjim 2y ago[flagged]
- PessimalDecimal 2y agoThat's doubtful. This "panopticon" version of the future is in direct competition with the increasing sophistication of deep fakes and other means of generating content. Instead of everything you've ever done being easily searchable, verified to be you, and there to shame you forever, another view of where we're headed is to where all content from the past is subject to doubts and questions of authenticity. To me, the latter scenario seems likelier to occur.
- DonHopkins 2y agoWhenever I'm openly performing nefarious illegal acts in public, I always wear my Sixfinger, so if anyone takes a photo of me, I can plausibly deny it by pointing out (while not wearing it) that the photo shows six fingers, and obviously must have been AI generated. In support of said nefarious illegal acts, the Sixfinger includes a cap-loaded grenade launcher, gun, fragmentation bomb, ballpoint pen, code signaler, and message missile launcher. It's like a Swiss Army Finger! You can 3d print a cool roach clip attachment too. "How did I ever get along with five???" https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ElVzs0lEULs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ElVzs0lEULs https://www.museumofplay.org/blog/sixfinger-sixfinger-man-alive-how-did-i-ever-get-along-with-five/ https://www.museumofplay.org/blog/sixfinger-sixfinger-man-al... https://www.museumofplay.org/app/uploads/2010/11/Sixfinger-play-set-1965-The-Strong-Rochester-New-York.jpg https://www.museumofplay.org/app/uploads/2010/11/Sixfinger-p...
- bongodongobob 2y agoThat's not how llms work.
- gosub100 2y ago> That stupid shit you said in some obscure forum when you were a teenager What's the first presidential election going to be like when the first candidate who was old enough to have a Facebook or myspace runs for election? Each opponent will do anything they can do disparage the 35+ year olds character with the words he uttered as a teenager. I think one of the unintentional consequences of this newspaper move will be that a great deal of our history will be lost. When I was a kid, the libraries touted how cool it was to peruse old stories in the local paper on microfiche. Now that info is online for $8 per article.
- blackeyeblitzar 2y agoThis is a huge disservice to the public. Lots of offenders are repeat offenders, and the public needs to know who they are. Or maybe someone just wants to look up an old news story they remember. More fundamentally, this type of action is just a manipulation of the public and not journalism, which should be a neutral way of sharing information.
- CSMastermind 2y agoNo just lots but almost all. 63% of violent offenders reoffend but that actually undercounts the amount of crimes that are caused by repeat offenders because there are some people offending 10+ times. A three strikes rule would eliminate nearly half of all violent crime because nearly half of violent crime is committed by people who have already been convicted of 3+ other violent crimes.
- blackeyeblitzar 2y agoIn the Seattle area there’s a huge trend of reoffending criminals performing larger crimes as time goes, because they face no real consequences. This is happening because activist judges, who typically run unopposed and don’t face consequences themselves, are releasing dangerous criminals back into the public. As a recent example, an activist judge released a teen who committed felony robbery back into the public, against prosecutors’ pleas, and he ended up stabbing and disemboweling another teen. https://komonews.com/news/local/everett-lions-park-stabbing-kidnapping-assault-teens-charged-adults-violent-attack-juvenile-court-released-snohomish-county-prosecutors https://komonews.com/news/local/everett-lions-park-stabbing-...
- mmooss 2y ago> there’s a huge trend of reoffending criminals performing larger crimes as time goes Is there evidence of it? In my experience, people take a few incidents as ammunition for their reactionary attacks on 'activists'. But that doesn't mean it is or isn't happening.
- qingcharles 2y ago
- tantalor 2y agoThis article fails to include any context and background that "right to be forgotten" was first legally established in Europe in 2014.
- amadeuspagel 2y agoThere's a lot of research on ban-the-box policies[1]. I assume this applies here as well. [1]: https://scholar.google.com/scholar?q=ban+the+box https://scholar.google.com/scholar?q=ban+the+box
- gruez 2y ago>I assume this applies here as well. That it won't have much effect, and might actually be counterproductive? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ban_the_Box#Impact https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ban_the_Box#Impact
- musicale 2y agoHiring discrimination is hard to control, and background checks are still legal.
- Schiendelman 2y agoThis doesn't work well. It results in additional discrimination. The state of the art is, as I understand it, "Fair Chance employment", where the employer explicitly agrees to hire people with criminal records. We're well on our way to the majority of employers opting in, it's snowballed nicely. And it gives jobseekers a big red flag if the company doesn't have that policy.
- rsanek 2y agothat's not how fair chance works -- it just means the company will consider whether or not the offense(s) are relevant to the job. the employer isn't committing to hire more people with criminal records
- musicale 2y ago> the company will consider whether or not the offense(s) are relevant to the job I doubt many employers would consider armed robbery to be a relevant job skill.
- 2y ago
- steelframe 2y agoI used to work with someone who was arrested for having a beer in his possession when he was 20 years old. The circumstances were pretty colorful, and so it made the local news. He had since worked his way into management at the company we worked for. One day he mentioned that the article about his arrest finally fell off the Google index after more than a decade, and he was relieved about that. One of his reports in the room immediately jumped on Google and used their tool for re-indexing sites to get the article back in the results for his boss, and then he proudly announced how he "solved that problem!" Of all the career-limiting moves I've witnessed in my lifetime, that one was pretty near the top.
- meroes 2y agoOr, keep the info but change our perceptions.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- declan_roberts 2y agoI'm so glad people are finally starting to think of the criminals.
- mmooss 2y agoThis could create an imbalance of power: It could prevent the public from knowing of the past misdeeds of the powerful. It's much different to give someone with no power an opportunity to move forward, compared to removing an essential check on people who have power. Also, it seems likely that powerful people will still have access to this data, in news databases, in the data accumulated in the profiles of marketing and surveillance companies, etc.
- krapp 2y ago>It could prevent the public from knowing of the past misdeeds of the powerful. In a world where books, radio, movies, television and the internet didn't exist, and where people had memories like goldfish, maybe.
- carlosjobim 2y agoWhat's the name of the most powerful drug trafficker in your region?
- krapp 2y agoI don't know, I don't use drugs and I'm not involved in organized crime.
- carlosjobim 2y agoYet, these are some of the most powerful people in your region, and you don't even know their names. But you know the name of the mayor, even though you're not a member of the city council or involved in setting policy.
- krapp 2y agoI seriously doubt a drug dealer is the most powerful person in my region. I live in a small suburb of Austin, Texas, not the setting of a crime drama where the mobs and cartels run everything. I also don't know the name of the mayor, why the hell would I? The mayor is nobody. And if I want to know who the mayor is, I'll check the internet. I don't need a paper for that.
- gojomo 2y agoReminds me of a laugh-out-loud closing paragraph in a 2009 NYT article about the clash between Wikipedia & German lawyers over some infamous murderers' right-to-be-forgotten. https://www.nytimes.com/2009/11/13/us/13wiki.html https://www.nytimes.com/2009/11/13/us/13wiki.html Read the whole thing for maximum effect, but for me it beautifully demonstrates the contrast between the USA/Wikipedia/NYT ethos of "the truth is always printable and your speech is by default 'on the record'" and alternate expectations elsewhere.
- realityking 2y agoWorth noting that both Germany’s highest criminal court and the European Court of Human Rights in the end decided that the people in question don’t have a right to get their names expunged from archives (or Wikipedia). https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Walter_Sedlmayr#Murder https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Walter_Sedlmayr#Murder
- whimsicalism 2y agostill, very limited speech rights compared to the US
- ajdude 2y agoHere's the archive link: https://archive.ph/5978 https://archive.ph/5978 It was well worth the read!
- Animats 2y agoIs this being proposed to get Trump off the hook?
- krapp 2y agoHow could it possibly get Trump off the hook?
- FpUser 2y agoThis whole criminal record piece of shit is a crime on its own. I believe that records of people who served their time or just have been arrested/carded and then let free must be sealed and not accessible to general employers. Some obvious exceptions can apply but generally people should not be penalized for what they've been penalized already.
- MattGaiser 2y agoEmployers would need then to not be liable for the actions of their employees.
- zarzavat 2y agoThey are externalizing that liability on to the rest of society then. It's obviously in everybody's interests that convicted criminals can get jobs outside of crime.
- FpUser 2y agoAre they now? I see no reason why they should as long as it does not fall under special exception list. Like pedos working in kindergarten. But attempt to hire those would raise that special exception flag anyways.
- qingcharles 2y agoEmployers just Google candidates now, not even worth paying for a real background check. It's all out there.
- rangestransform 2y agoThis sort of paternalism by “elites” who are “enlightened” and “know better than the proles” is why there is a global pushback against elitism. If people feel like they need this information to protect themselves or their businesses, however misguided, who are you to tell them otherwise?
- pessimizer 2y ago> If people feel like they need this information to protect themselves or their businesses The "people" you are referring to here are the "elites." Conservatives adopting left-wing rhetoric has confused everybody for some reason. The people who own everything and can keep you from working, attending school, or having a place to live are the elites. > who are you to tell them otherwise? The person who the information is about. It's worth making an argument as to why that person shouldn't have a say, instead of railing against the "elites."
- bb88 2y agoIRL I knew someone who was charged with child sexual abuse. He went to prison awaiting trial, but the prosecution dropped the charges before it got there. He was released and went about his life. Meanwhile his mug shot photo in the local paper was the number one google search result for his name. And then it reached syndication for other news sites as well. Ideally those news paper articles should be updated to say the prosecution dropped the charges, but the reality is that at where I live, the arrest makes news but the prosecution dropping charges does not.
- Yeul 2y agoIn the Netherlands media never names suspects. But it's more of a cultural thing people just mind their own business.
- tiku 2y agoTo clarify, we name them partially. The first name and then the first letter of the lastname. So John Doe would be John D.
- hilux 2y ago"Minding their own business" means that thousands of children are abused by Catholic priests and no one does anything to stop it. Of course, this is not limited to the Netherlands, but it's the point of the discussion: how to prevent more abuse, more of whatever crime.
- pyrophane 2y agoI know that there is the saying that goes something like “a grand jury will indict a ham sandwich,” but at least there is an acknowledgment there that being publically accused of a crime can come with a pretty high cost to the accused, and that is worth some process. I served in a grand jury in NY and it was overall a pretty positive experience. Yes, the standard is lower and at times it can feel like a rubber stamp, but we did refuse to indict in two cases where we decided the DA failed to get us to “more likely than not.”
- Ferret7446 2y ago
- ThinkBeat 2y agoThankfully we have the Internet Archive. </s>
- qingcharles 2y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42605801 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42605801
- ThinkBeat 2y agoPresumably this will increase business sand value for the various private companies that sit on silos of such data that you access for a price.
- tzs 2y agoThat actually could help. A big reason that say 50 years ago if you had made a newsworthy mistake when young and then had been clean for decades after that mistake being in newspaper didn't cause you to have trouble getting jobs or housing was that it took effort for people to find that archived newspaper item. Move to a new town far enough away that your youthful mistake didn't make the papers there and build your new life there. If someone in the new town wanted to see if you had been in the news in the old town they had to actually get someone to go to the newspaper archives in the old town and search them. There might not be any indexing of the archives good enough to allow going right to stories that mention you. They might end up having to just manually scan old newspapers (actual physical newspaper or microfiche copies). That's too expensive for people to routinely do it for everyone they hire or rent to. Now the records are digitized and on the internet. They have been indexed by search engines and used to train LLMs.
- ThinkBeat 2y agoTHey dont have to go searching. They have most of it, if not all, already in their systems. A lot of it from far more reliable sources than newspapers. https://www.malwarebytes.com/blog/news/2024/11/data-broker-exposes-600000-sensitive-files-including-background-checks https://www.malwarebytes.com/blog/news/2024/11/data-broker-e... But there are far far worse (in term of all manner of personal details) you can buy
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- ThinkBeat 2y agoIt is a hard job to figure out where the boundaries go on what and whom should be forgotten.
- declan_roberts 2y agoIt's pretty clear which Americans the media wants to forgive and which it wants to punish.
- karaterobot 2y agoI'm sympathetic to amending articles related to people who were accused of crimes they didn't commit, and were later acquitted or had those charges dropped—that's a matter of correcting the record. I disagree with destroying the historical record itself, if the expunged stories were factual accounts of real events. Those things ought to be immutable. Journalists engaged in real journalism have special protections because they have special responsibilities in society, one of which is to truthfully document history as it unfolds. If they just give up those responsibilities, people may eventually start questioning what makes them different than everybody else with a hot take on the internet.
- ironmagma 2y agoI know someone who was (in my opinion, clearly) taken in to the witness protection program. That’s the only time I’ve seen every trace of a person disappear. Yes, there are a few stray dangling references to that person in a few documents I found. But if their life is legitimately threatened by an adversary, I can be sympathetic to having the records expunged.
- vldmrs 2y agoI have a good story related to the topic of discussion :) I am the author of one site - a dictionary of the English language, which, in addition to the definition of a word from several dictionaries, shows the use of words in different contexts. One of the contexts is news - so for example for the word "window" it shows several news headlines containing the word "window". So, about 10 years ago, I received a very rudely written email demanding that I remove a reference to a certain person from the text of a news story. The news story was about a misdemeanor that a certain person had committed. Since the email was very rudely written and since I hadn't broken any law, I just ignored it and forgot about it. Over the course of about six months, this person bombarded me with dire threats and also wrote complaints to my hosting provider. The hosting company forwarded these letters to me and asked me to look into it, but did not demand anything because no law had been broken. One day, after many e-mails with threats of legal action, and about 6 months, I received the first normal message, in which the person asked what he should do to make me delete the information he wanted. Here I need to mention that for all this time this person has parroted me quite a lot with his threats and I had no desire to meet him halfway. I wrote that I would delete the necessary information as soon as I received a request from him, written in the form of a short (!) verse. Another month or so passed, during which this person argued and tried to change my mind (instead of sending a short verse) … As soon as he did, I connected to the database with a smile, deleted the entry he asked for and wrote him an email wishing him good luck. I hope he is doing well now :)
- Something1234 2y agoWhat is a short verse?
- BurningFrog 2y agoI'd feel better about a "right to comment": So instead of deleting the record of my arrest, I could add some kind of comment explaining that I was not convicted in the end.
- cvalka 2y agoThe right of rebuttal!
- bdangubic 2y agorebuttals are never read by anyone. there are numerous examples of this like in our modern age a completely bogus story will “go viral” and will be shared / read by millions and millions while a retraction will go completely unnoticed. even more serious, bogus scientific studies like the one that started the whole “vaccines cause autism” while fully disputed cannot be undone with a retraction/rebuttal
- BurningFrog 2y agoIn my imagined system, the rebuttal/comment is displayed right next to the original story.
- bdangubic 2y agoit won’t be read as it came after the original story and is no longer “interesting.” imagine if say Diddy got exonerated of all charges against him and leaves jail tonight. subsequently imagine every story written since his arrests gets a disclaimer “the accused was cleared of all charges” - that gon help Diddy in any way? perhaps Diddy is a bad example but it don’t matter where you put the rebuttal - it will be completely ignored
- recursivecaveat 2y agoUnfortunately so much information is spread through half-remembered tweets of quotes from screenshots of tumblr posts, a lot of people will never see the original story to begin with. Sometimes I feel like I have to pull people's teeth to get straight talk and links out of people making serious accusations instead of indirect references.
- supercurry 2y ago[dead]
- maginx 2y agoI also think search engines sometimes remove results based on subject requests - at least I've seen such notices in Google search results, that some hits were removed due to 'right to be forgotten' policies. Unpopular opinion (it seems): I think it is OK to some extent. Not for serious crimes (violence, murder etc.) but there's an awful lot of 'lesser crimes' reported with full names where I think subjects might deserve a clean slate or where people have some right to privacy. In the extreme case, everything court-related and all infractions could be public and subject to auto-generated news, and forever searchable: traffic fines, civil cases, neighbor complaints (either way) etc. All parts of an immutable record for everyone to look up by name. I personally think that is a violation of privacy, so it has to be balanced. Maybe the best balance is not to write the names to begin with. In Denmark where I'm from, court cases are almost always public and the subject names are read aloud as well; however the names are not listed on the court lists or in the publicly accessible version of the verdicts. In order for the media to learn the name, a journalist has to physically go and see the trial. This already prevents automation and ensures prioritization by the media. Furthermore, most news media have a policy of only writing the subject's name after a guilty verdict has been found and even then only if the verdict was of some severity (unless it is a public person). I just checked on media outlet and their policy was to only write the name in case of a custodial sentence of at least 24 months. If it weren't for such policies, even relatively small cases would be reported with full name and be searchable forever.
- bko 2y agoI wish newspapers were more concerned about being an objective system of record rather than trying to push social goals by helping rewrite history. They should post follow-ups for those wrongly convicted or after the fact caveats but completely memory holeing news stories strikes me as deeply disturbing
- scarab92 2y agoI would like them to refrain from naming people until/unless they are actually convicted. Heck, I would probably go a step further and update defamation laws to make publishing allegations (legal or otherwise) considered equivalent to making allegations. Far too many lives have been ruined by media “just reporting on allegations”
- bko 2y agoOr they should just report newsworthy public items in an unbiased way and let people decide
- scarab92 2y agoDeciding on the accuracy of claims is difficult. We have complicated and lengthy judicial processes that attempt this, and they still make frequent mistakes. Saying it’s okay to defame people with an “allegedly” disclaimer and relying on the public to somehow do what even our courts cannot, is willfully ignorant. Publishing an allegation should be legally equivalent to making an allegation.
- bko 2y agoIs it accurate that this person is being tried for a crime? Did the prosecutor state which crime they were convicted of? Then report on that. That's not defamation. Stop trying to have newspapers make editorial judgements. Just report the facts.
- DoctorOW 2y agoI work in a local TV newsroom for my job and the idea that the public has about journalism has been deliberately warped. A great example of criticism of bias is that it's widely reported that Luigi Mangione's motive was unknown until they uncovered and verified the manifesto. "Clearly the corporate media is in the pockets of the insurance industry. You can't think of one reason someone would hate the CEO of United?" Of course reporters can relate to your experience with health insurance, they're workers too. However, if you think about it, it's more biased to try to relate to that group (even though almost all the viewers are in it) than it is to ignore your opinion and only say what's in the black and white. 99% of accusations of media bias in my experience are just someone whose experiences don't match those of that particular story.
- fossislife 2y agoIMO it would be much better to redact names instead of deleting the entire stories. Newspapers in other countries like Germany never write the full names, anyway.
- baxtr 2y agoYou often find them on X though.
- EasyMark 2y agoI don't usually call thing "dumb" but this seems like a bad idea and overly forgiving. This is coming from someone who has hire nonviolent offenders in the past because I think it's a good thing to give people a second chance. You don't fix things by hiding the past.
- wsintra2022 2y agoIsn’t that Wilson’s job in 1984 if I recall correctly, been a while since reading it.
- wrboyce 2y agoWinston, but yes he is a records editor at minitrue.
- floatrock 2y agoHave any monetized this feature yet?
- scottiescottie 2y agoHitler was an artist.