9 ms·
TSMC's Arizona Plant to Start Making Advanced Chips
- coolvision 2y agoIs it better to invest into TSMC or NVIDIA stocks, in context of AI growth?
- osnium123 2y agoGreat news and arguably these are the most advanced semiconductors being produced in the United States today.
- teruakohatu 2y agoWikipedia lists Intel 3 is roughly the same tech level as TSMC 3nm [1], but without listing transistor density. Intel is producing the Xeon 6 using Intel 3 [2]. So arguably Intel has a more advanced process in the USA than TSMC, which is doing 4nm in the USA next year. Intel's production is probably not very high. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/3_nm_process#cite_note-74 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/3_nm_process#cite_note-74 [2] https://www.intel.com/content/www/us/en/products/details/processors/xeon/xeon6-product-brief.html https://www.intel.com/content/www/us/en/products/details/pro...
- georgeburdell 2y agoTSMC 3nm is a double digit percentage denser. Intel 3 is closer to TSMC 5nm
- soganess 2y agoCitation? (Not intended as a snipe. I honestly just don't know where to look for that kinda info.)
- georgeburdell 2y agoWikichip is my go to (which is down right now for me unfortunately). It’s important to look at the latest data because Intel’s internal nodes real specs have not met the stated expectations recently
- fooker 2y agoIIRC it was the other way around.
- ryao 2y agoThat was before Intel renamed their process nodes. They went from being 1 node more dense to being 1 node less dense with their new naming scheme. You need Intel 4 to match TSMC 5nm.
- silisili 2y agoI'm not refuting the statement, only pointing out that density is not the only factor. Unfortunately, these numbers are arbitrary and companies are guessing what performs about like what based on numerous factors. Often wrongly - Samsung's equivalents were so bad Qualcomm pretty much abandoned them, and for good reason. Anyone who used an Exynos or SD888 understands why. I feel like we should have landed on a better tracking system now, like perf/watt, but here we are.
- Dalewyn 2y ago>these numbers are arbitrary Seeing as Intel 7 is formerly Intel 10nm, there is at least a reasonable argument in that Intel's number is one size(?) smaller than it should be.
- silisili 2y agoIt's equally likely Intel realized it performed as well as Samsung/TSMC "7". Which is the whole issue, we'll never really know.
- osnium123 2y agoIs Intel 3 manufactured in the US or Ireland? https://www.intel.com/content/www/us/en/newsroom/news/new-fab-ireland-high-volume-production-intel-4-technology.html https://www.intel.com/content/www/us/en/newsroom/news/new-fa... Also, it depends on the metrics but TSMC’s N4 is a mainstream foundry logic node. Who is using Intel 4/3 outside of Intel?
- kube-system 2y agoLooks like both according to this quote: > Our Intel 3 is in high volume manufacturing in our Oregon and Ireland factories https://www.tomshardware.com/tech-industry/intel-3-3nm-class-process-technology-is-in-high-volume-production-intel https://www.tomshardware.com/tech-industry/intel-3-3nm-class...
- ryao 2y agoThese are 4nm facilities. Intel’s 18A process is more advanced. Hopefully it will turn out well. If not, that is the end of Intel.
- Dalewyn 2y ago>Intel’s 18A process is more advanced. Can be, not "is". I will believe them when I see it.
- aaronbrethorst 2y ago[flagged]
- clumsysmurf 2y agoMaybe ... But for those living close to the plant, I'm not so sure: "Environmental, and public health groups, including the Sierra Club, are urging President Joe Biden to veto a controversial bill that exempts most semiconductor companies applying for federal CHIPS Act funding from having to complete essential environmental reviews, as required by the National Environmental Policy Act, or NEPA." “Exempting the semiconductor industry from NEPA is completely unwarranted, especially considering the projected significant increase use of PFAS and other toxic chemicals by the industry and their track record of releasing these dangerous chemicals into the air and water surrounding the facilities,” said Tom Fox, Senior Legislative Counsel at the Center for Environmental Health" https://www.sierraclub.org/press-releases/2024/10/environmental-public-health-groups-urge-biden-veto-microchip-bill-threatens https://www.sierraclub.org/press-releases/2024/10/environmen...
- wbl 2y agoNEPA doesn't govern any releases: that's done by the EPA under clean Air and clean water act.
- clumsysmurf 2y agoHaving lived next to the Motorola EPA superfund site, and more recently closer to the TSMC site, I find no consolation in your reply. The lack of transparency and accountability is too great.
- dpedu 2y agoIs this fab on par with TSMC's fabs in Taiwan? I am not up to date with the various processes.
- wtallis 2y agoNo. TSMC's 4nm processes are part of the 5nm family. 3nm has been shipping for over a year, and is only fabbed in Taiwan for now and the next few years.
- hackernewds 2y agoAnd purposefully so to keep the "silicon shield" intact for Taiwan. I did read that the yields in the US are just as good
- mdasen 2y agoIt's not on par with the best TSMC has in Taiwan, but most companies are still using 4nm. Yes, 3nm has been shipping for over a year - but only if your company is named Apple. Intel just launched a small portion of its products using 3nm two months ago. I think realistically it'd be more fair to say that 3nm is coming in 2025 and there's a huge distance between 2025 and 2028 (when they'll start doing 3nm and 2nm in the US). Right now, AMD, Nvidia, and Qualcomm aren't doing 3nm. If the world lost 3nm today, it'd basically be Apple's products that would get hit. It'd definitely screw over Apple and it'd mess up the future plans for AMD, Nvidia, and Qualcomm, but it's not like the industry has been using 3nm for over a year. No, only Apple. The big problem is that there's a big difference between "we'll be bringing 3nm to the US in early 2026" and "we'll be bringing 2nm and 3nm to the US in 2028". If they started making 3nm in the US in early 2026, that's going to be less than a year behind most companies using 3nm. Qualcomm and Nvidia will probably start shipping 3nm in February 2025 and AMD will probably start shipping 3nm in late 2025. If TSMC's US fab were 12-18 months behind their Taiwan fabs, it wouldn't really be a problem, except for Apple. Everyone else is waiting 18 months for TSMC's latest gen stuff anyway. The problem isn't that the US fab can't do 3nm today. TSMC's Taiwan fabs aren't doing 3nm at scale unless your name is Apple. The problem is that their US fabs won't be doing 3nm for around 3 years after the industry moves over to 3nm. If the US fab could satisfy 4nm demand and Taiwan disappeared today, it'd mostly hit Apple's product line. The issue is that in 2026 or 2027, every company will be relying on 3nm and if Taiwan disappeared then, it'd hit the whole industry's product lines. But it's possible that Intel's 18A will do amazing and Intel will be able to manufacture at scale and a lot of TSMC's business will move to Intel. Then the US (Intel) would be manufacturing more advanced chips than TSMC in Taiwan. TSMC isn't expected to make the move to High-NA EUV for a few more years so Intel has some time when it could overtake TSMC.
- yieldcrv 2y ago> As more fabs open, the United States is also facing a shortage of engineers and technicians. levels.fyi says principle level engineers are making $86,000 annually in Taiwan, with zero shares. $49,000 being the average for [software] engineers in Taiwan there will be a shortage at that compensation range, which they can solve with higher cash and amplify with shares and a competitively short cliff like Meta and others have, of 3 months or less.
- magic_smoke_ee 2y agoBasically 25% of what American SWEs make. I can only surmise the cost of living is much lower in Taiwan.
- yieldcrv 2y agoyeah of course, but many organizations have a rigid corporate ladder to overcome. this seems like one of them, and their many "cultural differences". they are incentivized to underpay americans, complain that they "can't" find talent, to ensure the relevancy of Taiwan but their arguments are weak and solved with compensation
- j_walter 2y agoThey are not solved with compensation...simply put Taiwanese in both the US or Taiwan will put in more hours and work harder regardless of pay. Will compensation get some US workers to work as hard...yes...but not enough for what is needed to expand the AZ plant and keep it running. The numbers in the OP are Taiwan salaries...AZ salaries are upwards of $140-150K (not including bonuses) for someone with <10 years experience. These are not SWE...these are mechanical, electrical and chemical engineers...not in competition with Google, Apple, Meta, etc.
- mook 2y agoYep, not that many top-tier talent in the US willing to be in the factory for the graveyard shift under high pressure. The lines run 24/7 and if anything is slightly wrong techs need to be already on site to go fix it, because it's crap tons of money for every second of downtime. That leads to a corporate culture where even R&D has similar pressures from your boss (because essentially you're always racing with the competing fabs).
- magic_smoke_ee 2y agoBut not 2 nm node (N2{,P,X}) until about 2028. The delay is still indicative of protectionism. Until the US has a (or preferably more) American company with 2 nm capabilities with the whole process including diffusion and packaging, there's no real native, strategic capability.
- atty 2y agoThat is what Intel 18A is, no? In some ways it’s worse than N2, and in some ways it’s better. Overall seems comparable to me, and apparently it’s still on track for next year.
- ryao 2y agoWhat American company would even attempt this aside from Intel? IBM still does the relevant research, but quit the business of actually using it. They licensed their 2nm process technology research to Japan’s Rapidus if I recall. I cannot think of anyone else in the US that would be willing to take the risk of trying to start a 2nm foundry service.
- oldpersonintx 2y agoSamsung is going for 2nm in Taylor TX
- chasil 2y agoI've read in the interview below that all attempts to implement IBM's copper interconnects failed, except for TSMC. At least for this particular technology, IBM did not deliver everything needed to do this. "So, when we went to .13u, .13u the people began to change from aluminum to copper. And IBM was the leader for the copper metal. They had the longest history of developing copper technology. They worked for more than ten years on copper. TSMC didn't have any experience in copper at all. So, when we decided we need to adopt copper, okay. So, the copper is one story and low-k material is another one. IBM decided kind of low-k material is a spin-on material called SILK. IBM had a Research Consortium that IBM-- Samsung joined them, I think, ST Micro joined them. Several companies joined the Consortium. "And UMC joined them. But we didn't join them. They all used that spin-on low-K material. But we decided to use CVD - instead of flourine-doped it's a carbon-doped made by Applied Materials. They're called Black Diamond. So, we choose Black Diamond. The reason we chose Black Diamond was very simple, because I suffer at .18 with a spin-on. I wouldn't touch spin-on again. <laughter> But they didn't go through that. So, we were very, very lucky. TSMC became the first company in the world which was able to ship a manufacturing wafers with the copper and low-k, because IBM failed... Later on they found reliability the problem." https://www.computerhistory.org/collections/catalog/102792671 https://www.computerhistory.org/collections/catalog/10279267...
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- anon291 2y agoAwesome!!!!
- surcap526 2y ago[flagged]
- xenospn 2y agoIs it just me, or did this behemoth get built in record time? Extremely impressive.
- sangnoir 2y agoThe CHIPs Act is a great piece of legislation.
- redserk 2y agoCHIPS and the Inflation Reduction Act are two of the most underrated domestic policy bills in recent American history. Conservative-driven contrarian politicking aren't doing the country any favors.
- marxisttemp 2y agoAs much as I dislike Biden from a leftist perspective, I must commend him for the inflation reduction act. Felt funny seeing a president actually, you know, improve the country
- xenospn 2y agoDo you dislike him because he's a leftist or because you're a leftist?
- jazzyjackson 2y ago(username is relevant here)
- KerrAvon 2y agoThis is getting way off topic, but Biden is a centrist. The idea that he’s a lefty socialist is a political cudgel the right wing has swung at every Democratic prez candidate since 1988; it’s getting more traction in recent years as the media has been increasingly purchased by right wing billionaires. They called Obama a socialist even as he was praising Reagan and helping out the bankers who caused the 2008 economic meltdown. Everything I’m saying here is a documented. Biden has been in public service since 1973; look up his Senate voting record. Look up the ownership and political stances thereof for any given traditional media outlet; newspapers, websites, etc. “Biden is a lefty” is a false, lazy canard.
- tester756 2y agoBut this plant cant stand alone, I mean if something bad happens to TSMC on Taiwan, then they will no be able to move fab to the newer nodes, I think.
- iddan 2y agoRome was not built in a day. I think it’s a stepping stone for that
- tester756 2y agoIf there is no plan to make it standalone, even worse, for TSMC it would be illegal to make this plant the leading one, then still US should put more money into Intel
- Hilift 2y agoIt's an awesome contingency. If the island falls, they can destroy/impair the local infrastructure, and reconstitute it in the US. Destroy in this context does not mean mass physical destruction. It is a combination of removal of keys and select components. The message being you can have the island but not the business.
- wbl 2y agoAnd? Advanced nodes aren't really relevant to subtracting where it is from where it isn't. China is ideologically motivated to conquer Taiwan not economically.
- WhereIsTheTruth 2y agoA victory for sovereign Taiwan, protecting the industry they built from the ground up!
- yupyupyups 2y agoDoesn't this remove the incentive for the US to protect Taiwan then? I'm speculating, but if China invades Taiwan, it's cheaper for the US to bomb the fab in Taiwan to not let it get into Chinese hands in case of an invasion. They could additionally offer generous asylums to Taiwaneese researchers and engineers. Then whatever happens to Taiwan happens?
- ksec 2y agoI just want to add the term "ADVANCED" in terms of foundry node now has an official meaning anything sub 7nm. With specific rules in place in terms of export especially to China. This was a reference from ASML presentation not so long ago. It is also important to point out, the achievement here is how fast TSMC manage to set things up and running even without the home ground advantage. Intel couldn't even replicate this time frame if it was their Intel 7nm Fab. And of course the greatest record was that with enough planning and permission done before hand TSMC manage to have the fab built and running within 18 months in Taiwan. ( Arguably closer to 12 months ) This also means unless a miracle happen or US Gov being unfair with certain things the chances of Intel catching up with its current team, management, board members and investors, against TSMC in terms of capacity, price, and lead time as a foundry is close to zero. ( I am sorry but I lost all faith and hope now Pat Gelsinger is out. ) Once TSMC 2nm hits the ground later this year, TSMC US will also start their 3nm work if they haven't started now.
- necovek 2y agoIf you believe you can consistently predict future like that, it should clearly guide your investment in stocks. However, just like how quickly and suddenly Intel lost the lead, things may turn around for TSMC too: at some point, their research hits a dead end and somebody overtakes them too.
- ksec 2y ago>If you believe you can consistently predict future like that, it should clearly guide your investment in stocks. Perhaps I should have written with Disclosures. For the record I did invest in AMD when it was below $3 and TSMC at below $400TWD. None of these are investment advices so take it what you will. ( You get much better return with Tesla and Nvidia in the same period of time but then investment isn't always about best returns. ) And I was waiting to invest into Intel, unfortunately Pat is gone. To my words I said this in April 2023 [1] "I am just worried if Stock price continue to fall, Pat may be forced out again by those stupid Board. And if Pat is out, I won’t invest in Intel at all." As you will read in my reply below, I have a very negative view on Intel's board for a very very long time. >However, just like how quickly and suddenly Intel lost the lead It wasn't quick or even sudden. I wrote about it in 2014 and got a death threat from Intel Fan boys then. I have been questioning about Intel's management on GPU, Fab capacity allocation, CapEX, dividends etc for a very long time. For another point, TSMC never wanted to be the most advance manufacturing Fab. Them having leading node is purely accidental and Intel's slip up. They have been doing Intel -1 node for most of their history and are doing just fine. Providing Pure Play Foundry Services with Industry wide support on Tools at a reasonable / acceptable price for Fabless players. And right now, they are firing on all cylinders. Again. None of these are investment advices and personal opinion only. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35722974 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35722974
- icf80 2y agothey are making "dies", they have to export them to china/taiwan to make the finals chips... as far as I understand it.
- ThinkBeat 2y agoThis proves that with sufficient political and military pressure and the ability to give away nearly unlimited amounts of money you can get production moved to the US in a way that works, (Any deals the US has with Taiwan, will always have a military backdrop, they just recently took deliver of some nice new military hardware). Stuff you will never see in Ukraine. )
- elzbardico 2y agoWhat really baffles me is how Taiwans leadership can’t see the US endgame with the CHIPs act and the Chinese sanctions. The US government wants to steal TSMC by using subterfuge, sheer force and malice, while making Taiwan paying for it by refusing the revenue of selling advanced chips to China. Not even TSMC should feel safe even if they successfully relocate themselves to the US. Buccaneering has a long tradition in Anglo-Saxon countries and as TikTok shows the US has no qualms in preaching free commerce, stable legal rules and all that bullshit to everyone else, while doing the most egregious mercantilist stuff without even an once of shame.
- cdot2 2y agoYou're mad that the US is acting in it's own best interest?
- michaelcampbell 2y agoIt's the HN (reddit, etc) zeitgeist, sadly.
- clayhacks 2y agoIt’s the hypocrisy that bothers me personally. They force other countries to have maximally free trade with the world bank/IMF, then abandon those ideals the moment they aren’t convenient for the US. I think it’s reasonable for the US to act in their interest, but it should also be reasonable for every other nation to do the same, even if it means not having the same property laws as the US wants
- cdot2 2y ago"They force other countries to have maximally free trade with the world bank/IMF" The US has the influence to force other countries to act in the US's best interest as well. It's pragmatic.
- elzbardico 2y agoNo. I am really intrigued as why the Taiwanese people can't see what their comprador elite is doing.
- m3kw9 2y agoJust remember they will never have something outside Taiwan having more advanced process to keep the silicone shield viable