4 ms·
I doubt the studies accounted for the time and cost savings of having a single location for purchases which would've reacquired multiple stories previously, or
by xnx 2y ago
I doubt the studies accounted for the time and cost savings of having a single location for purchases which would've reacquired multiple stories previously, or the benefits of having access to many items that would not have been available at all without a large store like Walmart.
- vouaobrasil 2y agoBut is having more items always a benefit? I'd argue not. Sometimes, people flourish with fewer choices. And in terms of going to multiple locations: that also can create opportunities, and give people some exercise too. Unlike the myopic view from computer science, saving time is not always a good thing. That's why I avoid many automations that could save me time. Some menial work can actually bring some insight into what I'm doing (like reading over a document manually instead of using Grammarly to correct it for instance...)
- bluGill 2y agoThat depends on the choice. When my recipe calls for coriander substituting cinnamon because that is what is available isn't close enough. I don't need 4 different brands of coriander, but I need one. There are many many other odd things that people want in life and there is no substitute. As for exercise: you get more exercise walking through walmart than driving from small store to small store and parking in front of each - which is what really happens with small stores in small towns. (tourists will walk the street, but locals don't - they park in front of the one store and then are gone - though more likely the locals drive the the big city mall for their shopping and again get their exercise, leaving those local stores for tourists who don't realize this isn't how locals live).
- vouaobrasil 2y agoFair enough but that only means that cities should be modified to be more walkable with more green space and cars should be discouraged as is done in some european cities.
- bluGill 2y agoGreenspace is needed in cities but as parks. Shopping should be live asia: lots of places onethe same busy street.
- digitcatphd 2y agoUsing creative new methods, they find that the costs Walmart imposes in the form of not only lower earnings but also higher unemployment in the wider community outweigh the savings it provides for shoppers. > This consolidation is the root cause
- bluGill 2y agoCreative because they don't account for all the people who now can work better paying more productive jobs.
- freeone3000 2y agoWhat jobs? Rural and suburban communities not linked to an urban area have less and less every year. The cities are growing and towns are dying: there are very few new jobs, much less “more productive” ones. Think on it for a second: if you could work a better job than small grocery store employee, wouldn’t you have already? Why would you wait on walmart to exist?
- bluGill 2y agoIf you can't do better move to those cities - they need you. Rural areas need your land for more farming
- digitcatphd 2y agoIt's very simple actually. For instance, let's assume Walmart automotive takes maybe 2-3 FT employees to operate, where this may normally be fragmented across 2-3 local mechanics employing 3-6 FT employees each. Then of course you have the 2-3 local services which catered to them (E.g. cleaning services, real estate agents, CPAs, ect). Then, multiply this for each Walmart department (Electronics, Groceries, Pharmacy, Auto, Household, ect.) and there's your town.
- bluGill 2y agoWalmart mechanics are no better that any other shop which is why indepndant shops are still around in cities. you picked a bad example, in other places walmart is more efficent. again though you failed to figure what those people do instead - there are still plenty of jobs they are just not retail and probably in a bigger city.
- burnte 2y agoThat doesn't offset the lowering of wages and the shuttering of other local stores that employed more people than the Walmart did. Also each walmart store on average costs state government $1.1m in welfare benefits. https://dataspace.princeton.edu/handle/88435/dsp019s161887r#:~:text=Walmart's%20low%2Dwage%20workers%20cost,with%20Tax%20Day%2C%20April%2015 https://dataspace.princeton.edu/handle/88435/dsp019s161887r#....
- qeternity 2y agoNo, it doesn’t. These people receiving benefits and working at Walmart would almost certainly be entitled to more benefits if they were unemployed.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- bena 2y agoWalmart should be paying a living wage. If you are employed full time, you should not qualify. Walmart does not pay enough, they rely on the government to make up the shortfall.
- sokoloff 2y agoWet streets don’t cause rain (at least not as directly as the correlated observation suggests). If government benefits are set at a level higher than the prevailing market-clearing wage, perhaps the benefit level should be reduced, perhaps the minimum wage should be raised, or perhaps that Walmart should close its doors, which surely would increase rather than decrease government benefit expenditures. Wishing that there were more high-paying jobs than currently are able to be supported in a local economy rarely works.
- snapplebobapple 2y agoyou guys are both missing the actual point in my opinion. Yes you are 100 % right if it's a competitive market, it isn't though. Walmart exercises its considerable market power to push wages, benefits, etc. down. They are wrong to argue for more government intervention with minimum wage increases, etc. though. That just opens a pathway for corruption of government. Instead, the correct solution is break up walmart.