18 ms·
Good cities can't exist without public order
- newsclues 2y agoWe need a solution for judges who let criminals out into the streets to reoffend. I bet if the catch and release criminals were sent to live in the gated communities and high security condo buildings, the judges would be less inclined to let people out to reoffend.
- code_for_monkey 2y agowe need to arrest the white collar criminals that live in the gated communities too
- anovikov 2y agoProblem here is prison capacity. U.S. needs a very large, cheap, ideally profitable imprisonment system to keep all those people in - akin to Soviet gulags. Otherwise catch-and-release is unavoidable unless you just machinegun them - prisons are already overloaded and are extremely expensive to maintain.
- anonym29 2y agoThe "ideally profitable" part you're looking for are called "private prisons", and they come with a host of side effects that are nothing short of horrific. When a corporation becomes incentivized to strip people of their freedom (regardless of whether they do it correctly or incorrectly), bad outcomes occur.
- anovikov 2y agoWhy corporations? They need to be state-run, of course, with all employees being public servants directly. And prisoners need to make government money by building roads, houses, etc. Most of them can never be released anyway, too dangerous when young and too sick/needing too much in the way of medical expenses, when old.
- anonym29 2y agoAt least in the US, pretty much everything that is state-run, including state-run companies (like Fannie and Freddie) are notorious for being massive money pits that do not generate profits. Additionally, what you're proposing is incredibly optimistic from the perspective of how much economic utility prisoners actually have. The median state's average cost of housing a prisoner is about $65,000 a year, with wealthy coastal states like CA, WA, NYC costing over $100,000 per prisoner per year. [1] It's a sad economic reality, but many of the people in these prisons aren't even economically capable of producing output that has a market value even meeting the costs it takes it house them, let alone exceeding it, with the exceptions being largely concentrated in the minimum security prisons where white collar criminals and executives are housed (think Martin Shkreli, Bernie Madoff, etc), though you obviously can't ask people like that to perform the same kind of economically productive work that enticed them to get themselves sent to prison in the first place, if that were even possible (would you invest any of your money in a hedge fund that had a CEO working from prison for fraud?). [1] https://usafacts.org/articles/how-much-do-states-spend-on-prisons/ https://usafacts.org/articles/how-much-do-states-spend-on-pr...
- kerkeslager 2y ago> At least in the US, pretty much everything that is state-run, including state-run companies (like Fannie and Freddie) are notorious for being massive money pits that do not generate profits. Gosh, it's almost like the state is spending tax money to help its citizens! The horror!
- kerkeslager 2y agoAmazing. I think you're being sarcastic, but this is Hacker News, so of course people are engaging with you as if you're being serious because this is considered a perfectly reasonable opinion here.
- master-lincoln 2y agoThis is the internet. Coming across unreasonable opinions is not rare. Because sarcasm is hard to convey in text form I think it's better to assume all comments are made sincerely. What makes you think they are being sarcastic?
- neaden 2y agoAmerica has one of the most punitive judicial systems in the world and sentences people for longer then any peer country. Instead of doubling down on what's not working, why not look and see what is working other places.
- noodlesUK 2y agoI hear the argument that we need "harsher punishment" pretty much every time any kind of social problem gets discussed in media. I don't think that the US lacks harsh punishment at all - compared to peer countries, prison conditions are terrible, the incarcerated population is massive, etc. What I do agree with is that enforcement feels ineffective. Every time a criminal commits an offence, they are spinning a roulette wheel and hoping it doesn't land on "go to prison". Making sentences longer and conditions worse doesn't change the odds that a particular criminal will end up punished, it just means the downside is worse (and increases prison populations). Even when a criminal is caught, they're often bailed and able to abscond. The question should be how to increase the effectiveness of enforcement whilst preserving rights and protections against wrongful punishment. The other side of the equation is looking at the carrot, not just the stick. If life sucks and people turn to criminality because they feel like they don't live in a society that gives a damn, you have to improve society so people have something to live for. I think a lot of this weirdly needs to be "vibes based policy" as it were. People need to believe that justice will be done in order to feel secure, and to feel that if they were to commit a crime that they wouldn't get away with it. Objective reality doesn't control behaviour, peoples' beliefs do.
- newsclues 2y agoI’m not American but I’m pretty sure you have the same social justice (or lack there of) that enables certain types of criminals to avoid repercussions and continually reoffend.
- archagon 2y agoYeah, like our incoming president.
- anonym29 2y agoDemocracy is what gave us these judges. Are you proposing limitations on the ability of the public to elect the officials they want to elect?
- jltsiren 2y agoJudges can be elected officials, political appointees, or career civil servants. America prefers the first two options, but the third option with less political judges is also worth considering.
- Thorrez 2y agoAre there sentencing guidelines for judges? Do those guidelines recommend letting the criminals back out, or are the judges going against the guidelines?
- kerkeslager 2y agoIf you want prison to be used to keep criminals off the streets, then you have to be willing to put criminals in prison for life for even the most minor offenses, because that's the extent you have to go to for this strategy to work. I mean can you give any non-absurd answer how you think this works? Someone knocks over a liquor store with a box cutter: is there some magic number of years in prison that they can be released where they won't reoffend? Every piece of evidence I've seen indicates that the opposite happens: people in prison are traumatized further exacerbating mental illness, connected with other criminals, and then released with a criminal record that makes it even harder for them to obtain legal employment, making crime even more attractive. This effect is generational: children separated from their parents by prison time are more likely to end up in prison themselves. Your "solution" doesn't solve crime, it causes crime. Not only does your "solution" not work, it's ethically repulsive. The vast majority of crimes are crimes of desperation, and you are so self-absorbed that you're only concerned with solving your own problem--crime--and totally unconcerned with the suffering which causes people to commit crime in the first place. Your only solution is to cause even more suffering by locking people up and throwing away the key. The causes of crime are economic, and crime will continue until that problem is addressed. It's not hard to see that if you have any care at all for your fellow humans.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- Cheer2171 2y agoEnding an article halfway if you aren't a subscriber is a huge "fuck you" to the reader and lands this domain on my blocklist.
- noodlesUK 2y agoYeah, this paywall is both hard and niche. The normal tricks don't work, and I'm not going to pay ~100USD per year for a single random substack...
- gjsman-1000 2y agoI think you would be shocked at how effective stupid techniques like this, and other marketing strategies, actually are.
- anonym29 2y agoI believe parent comment was referring to tools to bypass paywalls when they referred to the "normal tricks", like archive.org, archive.is, 12ft.io, manually setting a googlebot or other search engine indexer UA, clearing cookies, modifying the HTML of the page locally to remove hidden attributes or scroll locks, etc
- noodlesUK 2y agoYes, this is exactly what I was referring to.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- maybelsyrup 2y agoThere are many ways to decide to not read this writer, and they're all good!
- nati0628 2y agoWealth inequality causes social disorder. All those other non American cities exist in places with more robust social safety nets and have fewer billionaires/less overt corporate control of the government. This is a fundamental truth of human society.
- anonym29 2y agoI grew up poor and that didn't magically compel me to initiate acts of violence or disrespect the property rights of other people. It gave me the motivation to work my ass off to get myself to where I am today. Individuals making a conscious and deliberate choice to commit violence or property crime is the cause of social disorder. Nobody's a robot without free will.
- bpodgursky 2y agoHave you ever been to a large East Asian city? You should look into the income inequality in those cities — and the amount SF spends on social safety nets — and you may be surprised.
- kerkeslager 2y agoHow much money does SF spend on giving the homeless homes? Not shelters, homes. How much money does SF spend on making sure people can get medical care without going into debt? When I went to the SF General emergency room after after a bike accident, I walked out with a just under $2500 bill, which would have been financially crippling for someone of less financial means. SF spends a massive amount of money on social safety nets that don't fundamentally address problems, because they don't have the political will to implement cheaper solutions that actually solve the fundamental problems. Put another way, SF spends a lot of money on feel-good programs, and very little on actual social safety nets.
- bpodgursky 2y ago> When I went to the SF General emergency room after after a bike accident I walked out with a just under $2500 bill, which would have been financially crippling for someone of less financial means. It would not cripple anyone. They would simply not pay, and nothing would happen. That's just what happens to 95% of medical bills not paid by insurance.
- mbgerring 2y agoThe proposed solution for “public order” matters a lot. If your solution sounds like “we should dump even more money into SFPD so that paranoid residents of Walnut Creek will feel safer riding BART to go shopping in Union Square, whether or not more police actually make them safer,” no one is going to support this. Unfortunately, thanks to the paywall, we have no idea what the proposed solution actually is.
- jeffbee 2y agoThe central thesis of the post is false to the degree that I can't be bothered with the rest of it. "general disorder discourage locals from supporting public transit" just clearly does not apply to San Francisco, the main subject of the rest of it. San Francisco has passed every Muni bond measure and tax for the last 50 years. Half a million people ride Muni every day. The people of SF do support transit.
- Tade0 2y ago> Transit, especially if it’s made free or if fare-jumping is easy, allows both criminals and drugged-up disorderly types to reach otherwise peaceful neighborhoods. And since apartment complexes A) are cheaper to live in than single-family houses, and B) usually come with inclusionary zoning requirements that require any new complex to include some poor tenants, they also mean more poor people in the neighborhood. The author identified the symptoms, but fell short of finding the cause. Drug dealers typically live in well-connected areas as they have people come to them, not the other way around. And they can afford to, since it's a risky, but lucrative profession. All those "disorderly types" are not drugged up (at least not enough) - they're on their way to get their fix. If they had enough they would be at home, being all drugged up without a care in the world. It's a difficult problem because those who survived long enough in this line of work learned how to not draw attention to themselves from both the law and their competitors.
- motohagiography 2y ago> "Transit, especially if it’s made free or if fare-jumping is easy, allows both criminals and drugged-up disorderly types to reach otherwise peaceful neighborhoods." This is not just public transit either. I live in a rural area about 20mins drive north of an exurb, and the peace we make out here is very desirable. We try to resist the paving of roads because it just brings more traffic from people who don't live here or contribute to the local economy or culture. The conversations I have with people coming out to the "middle of nowhere," to drag race, trade drugs, loiter, vandalize, dump litter, and have public sex in front of my farmhouse often end with reminding them the reason they like it out here is because nobody here does the stuff they're doing here. If you like it, treat it better. What makes these places desirable (anywhere) is the people who live here, and by observing norms, you can be welcome in them. If you go anywhere with a load of garbage in your head about why people should want to be around you and put up with your indulgent nonsense, don't be surprised when they are unenthusiastic, or make a point of walking out and telling you so. It's like someone bringing a 50W subwoofer on a backcountry canoe trip. It's purpose is to despoil its environment. Terms like NIMBY are thought terminating cliches and epithets that people in cities with no responsibility for their communities use to spoil the environments they envy for others. Instead of advocating for the destruction of peaceful neighbourhoods and environments, why not try making yourself welcome in them instead.
- Kon-Peki 2y agoYeah, well when I lived in the urban center everyone complained after festivals and other events where the suburbanites would descend and treat the city like their trash can. Perhaps the real issue are all the lifeless, boring suburbs creating oppressed people that need an outlet.
- motohagiography 2y agotourism of most kinds isn't really sustainable and it's an economic vice that is unhealthy for everyone involved. a sound tourism strategy anywhere would really focus on sports and arts participation driven travel instead of loafing and circuses. the public order angle is that you have to take responsibility for your own neighbourhoods because if you don't they're just going to go to shit.
- johnea 2y agoI have a hard time believing that anyone actually wants to live in a society of true "anarchy". I'm not even sure what people mean when they talk about it, and I've tried asking several "advocates" of "anarchy" what they mean, and I've never received a satisfactory answer. Just general examples of the wrongs perpetrated by our current society. Not only "good cities", but even HN's beloved "free markets" are completely dependent on a government enforcing rule of law. So, as usual, both the wingnut libertarians, and the wokenut anarchists are out in the weeds. With neither expressing rational policy, and both being completely devoid of acknowledging physical reality. A society based on rule of law is essential for any form of civilization. The fairness of that society will be wholly dependent on how uniformly and fairly that rule is applied and enforced. At present we have very poor uniform enforcement in the US, and that's leading to a LOT of social maladies, but that is not a rational reason for eliminating rule of law, it's a reason to reform it.