5 ms·
This is just an ad for their photo service. Which presumably has terrible search features, if it doesn't use AI to analyse them. That's one of the best features
by IshKebab 2y ago
This is just an ad for their photo service. Which presumably has terrible search features, if it doesn't use AI to analyse them. That's one of the best features in Google Photos!
- zitterbewegung 2y agoIt is a weird advertisement when Ente (the name of the service) will also see your photos.
- philips 2y agoThe service is end to end encrypted with local AI for indexing. I tried it a few months ago however and the upload/encryption was so slow from their desktop app it would have taken weeks to migrate my photos to the service.
- srockets 2y agoApple Photos in iCloud can also be E2E encrypted (though not by default: you have to explicitly enable that), are indexed locally, and Apple's pricing for storage is about half of this service.
- knowriju 2y ago[flagged]
- goodburb 2y agoEnte is client side E2EE at rest, on device AI, open source and audited. E2EE solves all of these issues as long as it's open source and reproducible. Efforts like these should be praised.
- MichaelZuo 2y agoSo then how can it be a paid service?
- captn3m0 2y agoEnte sells cloud storage.
- ignoramous 2y agoYou can self-host Ente. The paid plans are if you choose to backup your photos with them, which is replicated across 3 different providers.
- MichaelZuo 2y agoHow can the paid plans meet the standard described in the parent comment?
- ignoramous 2y agoI don't understand. Why do you think it can't? https://ente.io/architecture https://ente.io/architecture
- jcul 2y agoI think it's a pretty clever advert to be fair. And I really like some of the stuff they are doing. Their TOTP app is great.
- phoronixrly 2y agoTerrible search without AI is a bit of a stretch. Also Google does not have a monopoly on object/face recognition in photos. There are self-hosted solutions that readily provide you with that without feeding a faceless AI with your photos while boiling the ocean.
- ycuser2 2y agoCould you please tell some? I am about to switch to a self-hosted solution.
- phoronixrly 2y agoI am very very happy with immich. See the other commenter's response for many more.
- Koffiepoeder 2y agohttps://github.com/meichthys/foss_photo_libraries https://github.com/meichthys/foss_photo_libraries
- AyyEye 2y agoSyncthing, python face_recognition [1], a static gallery (sigal [2]), and a few lines of bash and its fully automatic. I can even share links with family. [1] https://github.com/ageitgey/face_recognition https://github.com/ageitgey/face_recognition [2] https://github.com/saimn/sigal https://github.com/saimn/sigal
- FireInsight 2y agoImmich is really good. They have AI semantic search, face grouping, etc. Really similar to Google Photos. Only the mobile app is still not that good. https://immich.app/ https://immich.app/
- IshKebab 2y ago> Terrible search without AI is a bit of a stretch. How so? I was looking for a photo of a grave I took some years ago. In Google photos I just searched for "grave" and if found 2 photos, including the one I wanted. Without AI I would have to search all my photos. Maybe I could narrow it down by date and location but it would take a lot longer.
- GeekyBear 2y agoHow do you opt out of Google updating your user/advertising profile based on information they glean from your photos?
- panarky 2y ago"Google Photos doesn't sell your photos, videos, or personal information to anyone and we don't use your photos and videos for advertising." https://safety.google/photos/ https://safety.google/photos/
- throw101010 2y agoCouldn't they argue that they use a description of what is on the photos and not the photos?
- mmh0000 2y agoAnd why should I believe that? There's no reason for them not to lie and go and do whatever they want.
- alwa 2y agoThat phrasing raises my weasel-word hackles… first of all, it’s unclear what it would mean to “use your photos and videos for advertising.” That sounds to me like reprinting your photos to advertise something—which nobody accused them of doing. Perhaps more importantly, it only mentions the photos and videos themselves in relation to the advertising. Analyzing the photos (as per the demo in TFA) isn’t “advertising,” and neither is building a user profile. Then later on, when they use that user profile to allow others to advertise to the user—that’s not “using your photos or videos for advertising” either. Nor is it “selling your personal information to anyone,” since what they’re selling is access to you instead of selling specific personal dossiers. From where I’m sitting, that still seems to leave the door open to Google itself using what it gleans from your photos to build out your profile, use those insights across their whole company, and target ads at you. It also seems to leave the door open to selling “depersonalized” analyses to third parties, not to mention giving free access to whoever it might see fit (research groups, state actors,…), no? There’s also a big difference between “doesn’t” and “will never.” Once an analysis with value exists, it seems counter to the forces of nature and commerce for it not to find its way out eventually. Just as the consumer DNA-sequencing firms pinky-swore everything was private, then gradually started spreading people’s genomes farther and wider.
- vishnumohandas 2y agoHey, one of the folks working on the said photo service here. Ente has reasonably good search[1] powered by on-device machine learning[2]. [1]: https://ente.io/blog/machine-learning https://ente.io/blog/machine-learning [2]: https://ente.io/ml https://ente.io/ml
- makeitdouble 2y agoThanks for the clarification. My family library is around 1Tb, the weakest device is an iPhone SE, and the most used access is through a web browser. Does on-device machine learning (provided you're syncing inter-device) work in that scenario ?
- vishnumohandas 2y agoEmbeddings (and other derived metadata) will sync across all your devices e2ee. So you could use our desktop app[1] to import and index your existing library. Newer photos will get indexed during upload on respective clients. Search is yet to be implemented on web and indexing is turned off by default on devices with < 4gb of RAM. You can opt-in from Settings > General > Advanced > Machine learning. [1]: https://ente.io/download/desktop https://ente.io/download/desktop
- mikae1 2y agoWhy should people not turn to https://permanent.org https://permanent.org, a 501(c)(3) nonprofit that that claims to care about your photos even after you die?
- oarsinsync 2y agoI can’t see any evidence of encryption on their front page. I can see evidence of storing your data in multiple third party clouds (this is advertised as a feature, data redundancy).
- FollowingTheDao 2y agoIf I can interrupt.. Wow, 1TB of photos? This is just astonishing to me. What is the use of so many images? As an ex semi-pro photographer, one of the things I realized is that what makes photographs special to people, even family photographs, is the rarity of them. So I just cannot understand taking and holding on to this many images. I would find just managing the images would take away time and money from my family.
- 23B1 2y ago> This is just an ad for their photo service. Good. The more companies that treat users like humans instead of chattel the better.