4 ms·
There is no valid argument for CO2 removal. No matter how you slice it, emissions reductions are more cost effective than removal. If we wreck our economy in th
by nradov 2y ago
There is no valid argument for CO2 removal. No matter how you slice it, emissions reductions are more cost effective than removal. If we wreck our economy in the process of trying to prevent global warning then the net effects will be even worse.
- toss1 2y agoOf course, rapid emissions reductions would be best. However, there are still two very solid arguments for capture, even if it has greater costs. First, even if we somehow make emissions go to zero next Monday and forever after, the CO2 already baked into the atmosphere will still cause massive warming for centuries, and this will cause massive ecological disuption. Only removing the carbon (and/or implementing sun-blocking technologies) will allow a fast enough reset to pre-industrial levels and avoid such damage. Second, it is extremely unlikely that we could make emissions go to zero in anything like the required timeframe. Even if somehow 100% of the people and politicians became convinced and decided to start next Monday, it would be decades before we approached zero emissions. Replacing all the fossil-fuel technology will not be instant. Thus, again, capture and sun-blocking tech has a definite role in rapidly repairing the damage.
- Dylan16807 2y agoThere's a point where reductions get more expensive than removal. We're definitely not at that point, or anywhere near it, but it exists.
- inglor_cz 2y ago"No matter how you slice it, emissions reductions are more cost effective than removal." What about politically effective? You can start removing CO2 from the air without coordinating your effort with all the industrial powers of the world. This is an invalid argument, in a world where China and the US are quickly becoming sworn enemies unlikely to agree on anything?
- defrost 2y agoCurrently there is no actual means for net reduction via CO2 removal. Human activiy (the extraction and burning of fossil fuels) puts some 11 billion tonnes of CO2 into the atmosphere every year. There's a lot of industrial activity required to move 11 billion tonne (and that in itself creates additional emission issues to circimvent). At this point in time the largest global project to sequester CO2 is adjacent to a SANTOS natural gas extraction project. * It's not yet working as planned. * Were it to work as planned the total CO2 sequestered would be a tiny portion of the amount required to be removed. * It's a "cheat" obfuscated by mirrors in any case - the CO2 planned to be sequestered is a small proportion of the CO2 released by the natural gas extraction project its part of.
- kragen 2y agoRight, although we do know how to scrub CO₂ from fossil-fuel power-plant flue gases, it eats up a substantial percentage of the energy produced by the power plant, as I explained in more detail in https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42424292 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42424292. This makes the power plant economically uncompetitive with other plants in the same area burning the same fuel and using the same design, so it is only profitable in the presence of fairly stiff cap-and-trade pricing. But, as I explained in https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42423291 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42423291, the price of renewable energy (in particular solar photovoltaic) is in free fall, which is suddenly making vast amounts of very cheap energy available. The biggest cost of even existing direct-air-capture technologies is energy, so cheaper energy makes them viable in cases where they weren't viable before. Probably those prices will continue to fall further. In short, we shouldn't be surprised that carbon capture hasn't taken off yet; we're still on the fossil side of the renewable energy transition.
- kragen 2y agoUnfortunately it seems that robomartin is continuing to make many of the same incorrect claims in https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42519616 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42519616 as well as adding some new ones.