3 ms·
Makes sense. If we knew the theory of everything and the initial conditions of the universe, then we could just compute the next episode of a series instead of
by amelius 2y ago
Makes sense. If we knew the theory of everything and the initial conditions of the universe, then we could just compute the next episode of a series instead of streaming it.
- api 2y agoNot necessarily. A theory of everything does not imply either the computability of a future state or determinism. Even if our ToE is deterministic the universe may be computationally irreducible, meaning it cannot be computed accurately at lower resolution in all cases. Note that such a universe could contain within it regions that are computationally reducible, just not the whole and not all regions. I would expect a ToE to give us knowable bounds to either determinism or computability. It should tell us what is precisely knowable or predictable and what isn’t. Edit: to understand how a ToE could leave some things unknowable (but tell us what they are) consider the Hubble horizon. Light beyond it will never reach us making sufficiently distant things unknowable. Limits may be great. It means we can at least subjectively consider ourselves as having free will — even with a deterministic theory it may be unknowable determinism. It’s just like how the speed of light might be why we got to evolve before being bum rushed by aliens.
- FrustratedMonky 2y ago"cannot be computed accurately at lower resolution" The Map is not the Territory. Our universe is the lowest resolution. So to compute the next instant in our Universe, would need another entire Universe. We could be the computation occurring.
- api 2y agoThat’s what I meant, but perhaps did not describe well.
- FrustratedMonky 2y agoSorry, I was really just re-stating it, to see if I was grasping the point.
- goatlover 2y agoThe entire universe could be the quantum many worlds (branches in higher dimensional Hilbert space), and you would have to compute the wave function of the universe.
- j7ake 2y agoTry it with a chaotic system like a double pendulum you’ll see the dynamics are not predictive in the long term.
- adrianN 2y agoIs that true? It was my understanding that chaotic systems (with a known initial state) could be predicted to arbitrary precision by throwing enough compute at the problem. Of course knowing the initial state is impossible in the real world, „enough“ compute might not fit in the observable universe, and quantum mechanics contains true randomness…
- philipov 2y agoYes, chaotic systems can be simulated, and that's the only way to find out what happens with them. The thing one can't do is reduce them to a closed-form function of x and compute their value for any point along their domain. The only thing we can do is inductively figure out the next x from the current x.
- mitthrowaway2 2y agoThe issue is more that simulations diverge exponentially with time from any nonzero error in the initial state. With perfect knowledge of the initial conditions and parameters you could simulate the system perfectly, but you'd also need to accumulate zero numerical error along the way. If you don't demand perfection, then in practice you can do pretty well for short times.
- monadINtop 2y agoa theory of everything would have to have quantum mechanics as an emergent theory and quantum mechanics is fundamentally non-deterministic. and even if it was, a theory of everything is almost certainly not going to be practically computable for the same reason that even basic non-relativistic quantum mechanics cannot even solve for a reasonably sized molecule numerically (let alone exactly - just as classical mechanics is unsolvable for more than two bodies)