5 ms·
NASA believes it understands why Ingenuity crashed on Mars
- gfdjghd 2y ago[flagged]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- chtitux 2y agoGetting the device speed right seems way more difficult without a Global Positioning System. Hopefully it will eventually be deployed [0] [0] https://techport.nasa.gov/projects/146938 https://techport.nasa.gov/projects/146938
- anothertroll123 2y agoDoubtful and unnecessary
- mannyv 2y agoThey need to drop beacons on all the surfaces to make navigation easier.
- tonyarkles 2y agoYou know… something I’d never really considered before now is that Mars has an absolutely pristine RF environment that would be pretty much impossible to find anywhere on Earth. I’m not sure how the overall noise floor would look with the lack of a global magnetic field but I would guess that you could set up a really great positioning system using small low-power beacons since you could use any frequency you want instead of trying to compete with, say, all the 2.4 and 5GHz noise on Earth.
- throwup238 2y agoIt’s been studied somewhat, at least with satellites: > Assuming a dish antenna with 1-m diameter, for a downward-looking antenna the total noise temperature is about the same as the Earth’s for all frequency bands of interest, with ±15 percent deviations. For an upward-looking antenna, the noise temperature is less than half that of Earth. [1] [1] https://ipnpr.jpl.nasa.gov/2000-2009/progress_report/42-149/149C.pdf https://ipnpr.jpl.nasa.gov/2000-2009/progress_report/42-149/...
- PittleyDunkin 2y ago> In short, the helicopter's on-board navigation sensors were unable to discern enough features in the relatively smooth surface of Mars to determine its position, so when it touched down, it did so moving horizontally. I'm a little surprised there isn't something more accurate than a camera for this.
- tonyarkles 2y agoThat’s actually a pretty hard problem when you don’t have a GPS constellation to assist you. Accelerometers, gyros, and magnetometers are used on Earth but all of them need calibration and drift compensation. We don’t really have much available for sensors that can directly detect position or velocity, it’s all estimated by double integrating acceleration data (which has noise and bias). On Earth most UAVs use GPS as a coarse position sensor and can use that to correct for accelerometer error but if you don’t have that constellation a camera is probably your best bet.
- bri3d 2y agoThe latest UAVs also use ToF LIDAR and SLAM for GPS-rejected navigation / inertial dead reckoning correction. I'm not sure that would work well on Mars either, though, as the environment might be too featureless for that approach also. I think the best approach would probably be to equip the "base station" / lander with an RF beacon. Ideally, you could drop some RF beacons throughout the environment as you went, but even a single beacon with some directional receivers on the drone should work pretty well (here, the featureless environment becomes a benefit as you have to contend much less with radio reflections).
- tonyarkles 2y agoSLAM is likely exactly what they were doing on Mars (it falls apart if there’s no image features to register against on the ground) and ToF lidar works great for vertical position and velocity but doesn’t help much for horizontal position or velocity if there isn’t much terrain variability for the lidar to reflect off of nearby. 100% agree on the RF beacons. You might not even need the directional antennas. Using things like RSSI might be enough to augment the local sensors. Alternatively having a digitally-controlled phased array could probably result in quite excellent positioning.
- pnw 2y agoOn the bright side, the mission goal was five flights and Ingenuity completed 72 flights in three years!
- bpodgursky 2y agoIt was genuinely impressive and I don't mean to downplay that, but NASA always massively lowballs "mission goals". In practice, probes either fail completely, or wildly outperform.
- cogman10 2y agoI assume it's because the things that make stuff fail early are also the things that if addressed will make a project live for 75 years. For example, solar panels for the rovers are overbuilt because you can't clean them if a chance dust storm is a bit too dusty. But that overbuilding also means that as long as the panels stay reasonably free of dust, the rover will last a long time.
- amelius 2y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bathtub_curve https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bathtub_curve
- UltraSane 2y agoThe two most recent rovers are nuclear powered.
- verandaguy 2y agoTo be fair, this means that solar panels are unlikely to be the source of any issues.
- UltraSane 2y agoYou are technically correct, which is the best kind of correct.
- quotemstr 2y agoJust like an early optical mouse on a featureless plastic table
- nomel 2y agoIt would be funny if it was just a lack of normalize(image) before passing it through the correlator.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- gclawes 2y agoI wonder if Marslink will have positioning capabilities for craft like this
- padjo 2y agoWas reading about the Wright brothers recently. It still blows my mind how rapidly we went from the invention of powered flight to powered flight on another plant
- lesuorac 2y agoExponential growth is wacky stuff. Although the thing that bothers me is that basing stuff on AI isn't really standing on the shoulders of giants. One big thing that held back human flight was that the published tables for lift were wrong so everybody that was using them couldn't fly even when they "should've" been able to (according to the wrong data). The Wright brothers had a good idea to re-compute the table and came up with different answers and were able to build a working plane.