5 ms·
The future of pay for musicians will be live performances, not recorded music. Recorded music will just be marketing for the live performances. The smart music
by WalterBright 2y ago
The future of pay for musicians will be live performances, not recorded music. Recorded music will just be marketing for the live performances.
The smart musicians, like Taylor Swift, figured that out. Her latest tour brought in what, 2 billion dollars?
- vouaobrasil 2y agoOnly for the most successful ones. But I guess that is the future we are headed to: a cutthroat industry where there are a few successful musicians that give us the illusion that music is still created by people, and the rest of them out of a job anyway because of AI.
- WalterBright 2y agoThere's also the wedding band business, and people hire live musicians for parties all the time. It's a supply and demand thing. There are so many musicians, the idea that they all can make a living doing it is simply not realistic. Only a very few will, regardless of whether they make a few pennies off of streaming or not. Having the government pay them through taxes is a terrible idea. I know many people who are musicians. It's always a side gig. I know artists, too. No money to be made there, either. Maybe a few pennies at the local arts&crafts fair.
- adamc 2y agoI've known several musicians over the years. Things are steadily getting worse.
- WalterBright 2y agoThere are also more and more musicians (because the cost of making professional quality music has declined drastically). The Law of Supply & Demand again is in play. More musicians => less pay for each.
- hughesjj 2y agoMusicians are more likely to stick around these days because you can get a small piece of the pie instead of just immediately dying off if no label or radio station will pick you up. The underground is dying though due to a plethora of other forms of entertainment. Shows were a great spot to get some social interaction, but people just don't go out as much anymore and are more likely to do discord and videogames instead of hitting up a basement, bar, cafe, or warehouse.
- defrost 2y ago> Only for the most successful ones. Which would include the family of working musicians | fencing contractors over the road from me in rural Western Australia. The husband and wife lead performers are in their early forties and have been playing music live for 20 years .. they sell recordings but their main music income is hotel venues and music festivals - they tour almost half the weekends of the year, mostly local, sometime by plane to the other side of the country. When not touring they're building fences by contract (ATM mostly around solar setups for Telstra and mobile repeater towers in the rural telecomm domain) They're not a super band, the live performances pay for themselves and turn a profit, all up they're making something like $200K (AUD) per annum from both jobs. They're not especially well known by name outside of blues hotel gigging.
- idle_zealot 2y agoThis has always been the case with artists, and copyright utterly failed to change this dynamic. It functions primarily as another mechanism for a few incredibly wealthy private individuals to wield state power to attack artists. If you want to help artists then I almost cannot think of anything more counterproductive than treating their cultural output like a physical good subject to market forces and capture.
- WalterBright 2y ago> treating their cultural output like a physical good subject to market forces and capture Like it or not, that's always going to be the case. The Law of Supply & Demand cannot be repealed. It's in play even when the government fixes prices and payouts.
- thatcat 2y agodata based products aren't subject to the supply law, obviously, since the supply is infinite and would therefore have a zero price if it were not for copyright laws.
- WalterBright 2y agoI know that very well, as the D Language Foundation gives away D compilers for free, source code and all.
- idle_zealot 2y agoExactly! Imagine if FOSS weren't a social norm in the space of programming tooling. You'd probably see something like what's gone on in the music industry, with Microsoft, Apple, and Google buying up exclusive rights to nearly every language and toolchain, then selling subscriptions to be allowed to use them (subject to T&C), and they'd be able to do this only because they could wield legally-granted power punish anyone distributing their purchased toolchains. The world would be significantly worse.
- prmoustache 2y agoWhy are you talking about the future? It has always been like that. I am pretty sure it was already like that in the trobadors days, antic Greece or Olmec civilization. Artists have almost always been poor unless they found wealthy or state sponsors.
- vouaobrasil 2y agoPerhaps we should work on changing that.
- prmoustache 2y agoThere have been people advocacing for universal basic/guaranteed income since the dawn of times and people against that. The subject is broader than musicians only.
- duxup 2y agoThe prices for big name concerts are absurd, but I'm not sure there's much profit for anyone else. Are people spending crazy money on Taylor Swift at their local mega stadium, also hitting up local music venues? Seems unlikely.
- hsbauauvhabzb 2y agoI think Taylor swift is an edge case on the demographic and genre of her music. Metal, hip hop, country etc I’m sure would all see cross-overs.
- duxup 2y agoIt would be very interesting to see someone study music fandoms and where their dollars go / what they do.
- WalterBright 2y agoLet's face it. There will never be more than a handful of musicians making pots of money. And those won't be making it on CD sales or streaming.
- bdangubic 2y agothey still make CDs???! :)
- WalterBright 2y agoOddly, the price of CDs seems to be rising. I'd expect them to be falling.
- Cthulhu_ 2y agoBy how much are they going up, and how does that relate to inflation? The production and distribution costs of CDs aren't going to improve much, the volume of them (production and sales) is a fraction of what it was (around the 2000s, pre-Napster).
- uhoh-itsmaciek 2y agoIs it? There's no shortage of posts arguing that for most artists, live performances are not really all they're cracked up to be [1]. [1]: e.g., like this one from David Lowery of Cracker and Camper Van Beethoven: https://thetrichordist.com/2016/02/16/the-reality-of-touring-revenue-from-someone-who-has-done-it-for-32-years/ https://thetrichordist.com/2016/02/16/the-reality-of-touring...
- WalterBright 2y agoOf course. They're in competition with all the other bands.
- uhoh-itsmaciek 2y agoBut the system is set up so that, more and more, they're competing for scraps. Shouldn't we incentivize making good art, rather than just becoming a superstar?
- WalterBright 2y ago> Shouldn't we incentivize making good art, rather than just becoming a superstar? The music I like is good, and the music I don't like is bad. Zero people share my opinions on which is which. Are you sure you aren't just unhappy that other people don't share your taste and prefer superstar music?
- uhoh-itsmaciek 2y agoPretty sure. Tastes vary, but you're arguing that runaway commercial success is a prerequisite for artistic success? Not to mention that those superstars need to come from somewhere. If a career in music is basically like spending all your money on lottery tickets, society ends up poorer: many hard-working young musicians are going to see it for the exploitation machine that it is, and go sell advertising instead.
- 2y ago
- rectang 2y agoBecause tech will siphon off all the money for distribution of music, having lobbied relentlessly to cut the musicians out of the deal.
- WalterBright 2y ago> having lobbied Maybe getting involved in music is not a proper function of government.
- rectang 2y agoEverything you've posted on this page leads up to this. The postings about musicians livelihoods seem haphazard and half-hearted. But this, getting government out of copyright, is a point I sense you cherish deeply.
- WalterBright 2y agoYour inference is right on target. Although I have made a living via copyright in the past, I'd prefer it abolished. I do eat my own pudding, though. The D compiler is given away for free. As evidence, Germany in the 1800s had no copyrights nor patents. Their economy boomed. Look at how free software, of the highest quality, has taken over the internet. I am not aware of any particularly compelling counter-evidence that copyright and patents improve productivity.
- rectang 2y ago> I do eat my own pudding, though. I made my living for a decade off of FOSS I originally authored, and was highly active in FOSS circles for much of that time. Being well acquainted with the economics of open source I am thus inoculated against the laughable notion that FOSS is analogous to music. Selling software != selling documents.
- WalterBright 2y agoP.S. You can tell when a live band is lip syncing: 1. it sounds exactly like the radio edit 2. if they're dancing while singing, they're lip syncing. Nobody can sing and dance simultaneously
- morder 2y agoMusical Theater would like a word with you.
- WalterBright 2y agoHaha, try jogging and talking at the same time.
- bdangubic 2y ago2. I sign a dance all the time with my kid. have also been to tens of concerts where various artist sanged and danced. this comment makes no sense at all…
- WalterBright 2y agoOh, I'm sure you can walk and sing, too. A waltz and sing, probably. But when you're dancing hard enough to sweat? Naaah. Just for fun tomorrow, go out for a jog and try to sing.
- vindex10 2y agoThat's how professional musicians workout. See Beyonce for example: https://www.thethings.com/how-does-beyonce-sing-and-dance-at-the-same-time/ https://www.thethings.com/how-does-beyonce-sing-and-dance-at...
- WalterBright 2y agoThe extreme effort she has to go through to make it work proves my point.
- adamc 2y agoThat it works for the top 0.1% of musicians demonstrates literally nothing about what the effects are for musicians in general. This is like saying that because Stephen King makes good money, writers are fine. It is a willful misunderstanding of reality. The reality is that things have gotten much tougher for working musicians in general.
- WalterBright 2y agoI'm not so sure. I read a biography of the Beatles, and their days in Hamburg. Not something I'd prefer to experience.
- paxys 2y agoThere's no "will be" about it. Live performances are the past, present and future of the music industry. Musicians have basically never made real money from recordings.
- WalterBright 2y agoYou're probably right. Even the Beatles went on tour, despite hating it.
- Supernaut 2y agoThe Beatles gave up live performance in 1966, because they no longer enjoyed it and because they were making huge sums of money from their record sales. In fact, the following year, they released their biggest-ever selling album, Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band.
- eleveriven 2y agoAs live experiences grow in importance, we may see artists innovating even further