6 ms·
The word "copyright" is slowly transforming into a more generic meaning where a big company silences a little company/individual that it doesn't like. This case
by ryandrake 2y ago
The word "copyright" is slowly transforming into a more generic meaning where a big company silences a little company/individual that it doesn't like. This case doesn't seem to have anything to do with actual copyright. Did the company specify exactly what content they believed was copied?
If you have a kid under 20, ask them what "copyright" means. They'll probably describe it to you in terms of corporate bullying rather than anything that has to do with intellectual property or copying.
- pinkmuffinere 2y agoI disagree with you argument — _we_ don’t know what the copyrighted portion was, but that doesn’t mean no such portion exists. Likewise, asking-kids-under-20 is not a method I’d generally endorse for legal issues. Per the article, it is unclear what was copyrighted. It’s possible that YouTube knows but is not making it public, or maybe even YouTube doesn’t know. I definitely feel that YouTube’s handling of copyright issues is annoying, I feel like the creator should be told what YouTube knows. But that’s not an issue with copyright itself.
- nadermx 2y agoYes, but copyright has fair use exception. And in theory when you send a DMCA, you are suppose to consider fair use[0], so this seems more like abuse. [0] https://www.arl.org/blog/9th-circuit-holds-fair-use-must-be-considered-before-dmca-takedown-notices-are-sent/ https://www.arl.org/blog/9th-circuit-holds-fair-use-must-be-...
- mig39 2y agoThis is the UK? DMCA doesn't apply there?
- nadermx 2y agoPretty sure when you submit a DMCA you submit to US jurisdiction, and since YouTube's copyright strike are their version of "DMCA", and they are a US company, I'd venture to say it's probably still US law they are under for this as they even site fair use[0] [0] https://support.google.com/youtube/answer/13823830 https://support.google.com/youtube/answer/13823830
- db48x 2y agoYoutube doesn’t know, because the DMCA doesn’t require the complainant to be very specific. The right course of action is to deny the complaint and make a counter complaint to youtube. This forces Youtube to reinstate the video, and forces the original complainant to take their complaint to an actual court. A copyright bully will simply never do that. They’re relying on people to give up at the first step, without making a counter complaint.
- Animats 2y agoDoes YouTube do put-back if you file a counter-complaint? YouTube says they do.[1] [1] https://support.google.com/youtube/answer/2807684?hl=en https://support.google.com/youtube/answer/2807684?hl=en
- LocalH 2y agoThey have to do so by law, under an actual DMCA complaint. Not so much under Content ID.
- FireBeyond 2y agoYouTube's system has nothing to do with DMCA. You can also use this mechanism, but their "Content Protection" system has no legal requirements.
- xenadu02 2y agoThis is more of a YouTube thing. They are very trigger-happy on copyright and implement a "strike" system that will quickly get you demonetized. It's fairly easy to file a strike against anyone and the target has little recourse other than taking down the video even if it has nothing to do with copyright. It's not DMCA so you don't even have the right to counter-file. And of course since it's Google there's no one you can call or email to get real help unless you're a super popular channel with an assigned rep.
- dehrmann 2y agoYoutube needs a better mechanism for punishing false claims.
- chgs 2y agoWhy?
- Retric 2y agoFor the overall good of society, and quite possibly to avoid lawsuits.
- Guvante 2y agoBecause it is considered one of the biggest problems on the platform. Creators are frustrated that unless they are big enough to get YouTube to notice them they at minimum have to dox themselves to remove a bad DMCA claim. Honestly in a world with Content ID they don't necessarily need the current system to remain as is to make the big publishers happy, who already get preemptive blocking of content without lifting a finger.
- ysavir 2y ago> Creators are frustrated that unless they are big enough to get YouTube to notice them they at minimum have to dox themselves to remove a bad DMCA claim. Unfortunately, creators have very little leverage over YouTube, nor any realistic ability to move to a different platform. The can be frustrated all they want, but until YouTube has a reason to fear creators leaving the platform en masse, there's little pressure on them to change.
- Karellen 2y ago> When you look at how “IP” is used by firms, a very precise – albeit colloquial – meaning emerges: > “IP is any law that I can invoke that allows me to control the conduct of my competitors, critics, and customers.” > That is, in a world of uncertainty, where other people’s unpredictability can erode your profits, mire you in scandal, or even tank your business, “IP” is a means of forcing other people to arrange their affairs to suit your needs, even if that undermines their own needs. -- Cory Doctorow, IP (Locus, Sep 2020), https://locusmag.com/2020/09/cory-doctorow-ip/ https://locusmag.com/2020/09/cory-doctorow-ip/
- ronsor 2y agoDoctorow also referred to DMCA section 1201 violations (the infamous "anti-circumvention" law) as "felony contempt of business model"
- fgeorges 2y agoOk so the rich and powerful do sketchy things What’s gen pops response? …crickets… Adam Smith is said to have written division of labor taken to extremes will turn humans dumber than the lowest animal Hard to see how he was wrong. Low skilled individuals exist in a state of helplessness. Like turtles in their back. Can’t solve a problem; need a committee to form a problem solving committee.
- freejazz 2y agoIt has nothing to do with copyright law. It's not an act of law, it's an act of YouTube.
- Guvante 2y agoWhile that is true of some YouTube take downs I believe this article is referring to a DMCA takedown request which while using a YouTube specific form is based off Copyright law.
- whycome 2y agoI’ve seen videos where the wording says “no copyright intended” — it’s a peek at how they understand the concept.
- firecall 2y ago> If you have a kid under 20, ask them what "copyright" means. They'll probably describe it to you in terms of corporate bullying rather than anything that has to do with intellectual property or copying. Instead of the original intention which was to grant the right to copy. Copyright should be energising capitalism, not killing it. But yet here are!
- dragonwriter 2y ago> Instead of the original intention which was to grant the right to copy. No, it was to restrict the right to copy which without any special law everyone had to make it into limited, private, exploitable property.
- tremon 2y agoNot granting the right to copy, controlling it was the entire point. The ability to produce copies of existing works never needed protection because it's a natural right that follows from the human ability to create. And that ability never needed limiting because creating a copy involved a large part of the same painstaking work that the original required. Copyright was only introduced after the invention of the printing press. The whole point of copyright was to limit the persons/entities allowed to produce copies of a work, because suddenly the ability to copy became a lot cheaper than the ability to create.
- firecall 2y agoIndeed, I knew that LOL I mangled my comment and never made my broader point! Which was that originally Copyright would expire at some point in our lifetimes :-) As I understand it, no one originally thought things should be uncopyable forever more!
- lmm 2y ago“This doing of something about disputes, this doing of it reasonably, is the business of the law. And the people who have the doing of it in charge, whether they be judges or sheriffs or clerks or jailers or lawyers, are officials of the law. What these officials do about disputes is, to my mind, the law itself.” Are the kids wrong?
- TeMPOraL 2y ago> They'll probably describe it to you in terms of corporate bullying rather than anything that has to do with intellectual property or copying. Unless they dream of becoming a content creator or a vlogger, in which case they'll describe it as a Law of God, protecting the tiny Content Creators from the evil sinners who Steal and Plagiarize, and that occasionally gets abused by the corporate lords we all sharecrop for.
- aembleton 2y agoIn this particular case, it seems to be a small company/individual filing a claim against another individual. Tom Evans audio is a very small outfit.
- aleph_minus_one 2y ago> The word "copyright" is slowly transforming into a more generic meaning where a big company silences a little company/individual that it doesn't like. This has basically always been the case and is what copyright is, by design, for.