6 ms·
As someone that started in computing when affordable computing was all about keyboard, and mices only existed in computers with prices similar to buying a car o
by pjmlp 2y ago
As someone that started in computing when affordable computing was all about keyboard, and mices only existed in computers with prices similar to buying a car or a mortgage, I don't get the hype of keyboard == hacker mentality.
Specially since that on my hacker circle of Demoscene, during the 16 bit days, we were mostly on Atari and Amiga systems, then we had plenty of mouse time, and no one ever stop to wonder we weren't hackers because we had mices.
- lll-o-lll 2y agoEven outside of the “hacker” community, keyboard has always been associated with higher expertise. Average “MS Word” user - Navigate through various menus to find what they want to do. Power Users - Memorized all the “shortcuts”. I think that’s mostly what it is. A keyboard (and a bunch of memorizing), gives mastery over the applications UI.
- anonzzzies 2y agoI still miss Wordperfect for that reason: messing around with Word wysiwyg, even with people who have decades of experience, is just painful to watch or do.
- pjmlp 2y agoSome shortcuts are helpful, until one needs to do anything that affects visual position or drawing. Very few people master shortcuts that require three key chords or more.
- pdntspa 2y agoMaybe it just strokes the egos of those desperate for some validation
- poincaredisk 2y ago>I don't get the hype of keyboard == hacker mentality. This is not about a hype or "looking cool". Mouse and GUIs are faster and more ergonomic for exploratory activities ("how do I do X" for a new task, skimming a document or folder, etc), while keyboard (keyboard shortcuts, command line) is faster for routine, repeatable tasks. Web browsing is full of the latter. I personally strongly prefer the keyboard and find it exhausting to reach for the mouse all the time, but it's a matter of personal preference. I don't think less of someone when I see they heavily use the mouse when programming, though in my opinion they are missing out.
- pasc1878 2y agoBrowsing is mainly of exploration (e.g. reading) then data entry (which does require a keyboard but all on one page no scrolling) and much less repeatable tasks. My hand is usually already on the mouse. Switching apps, scrolling text etc. I started on PC-DOS and mainframes so was originally all keyboard, but having mouse made things much easier for me. Now don't get me started on gestures - I can never remember any. - Which might be some of the reason to use mice I can't remember a lot of keyboard shortcuts let me have discoverable menus etc. Pit Smalltalk did not become mainstream.
- Borg3 2y agoThats interesting. Im using GUI Windows OS, but im very heavy keyboard user, utilizing shortcuts and alt+tab for windows switching. I barely even use start or desktop to start most common apps I use. I wrote myself QuickRun tool that is activated by Win+Q, and I type what I want to run. Usually its just 2-3 first letters of alias name, like bash and autocompletion kicks in. Mouse is used mostly to position windows sometimes. Keyboard is just much faster..
- pbhjpbhj 2y agoDo you use multiple desktops? Windows seems terrible at positioning windows, I can't work out how to tell a window to move to the next desktop, say, or just start on a particular desktop (nevermind start at a particular position). Instead it takes a lot of mouse work just to setup after a boot/reboot. Do you have a solution? I'm stuck with native solutions, otherwise I gather this can be fixed with AHK. I'm interested in what you use either way.
- corank 2y agoFor text editors or IDEs, basically contexts where we expect a lot of typing, I get why sticking to the keyboard is desirable. I don't get how it's better to browse the web without using the mouse. Most of the time on the web I just read, not type.
- christophilus 2y agoFor me, I’m often using the web as a reference while programming. It’s nice to be able to flip over to it (using the keyboard) and use the same familiar key bindings I’m using while in my workflow.
- corank 2y agoThat's indeed a nice use case. In general keeping to the keyboard can be helpful in the context of typing, but if I'm just reading news or blog posts or watching videos I'd go with a mouse.
- opan 2y ago>Most of the time on the web I just read, not type. This is kind of why it works. In vim you spend most of your time in normal mode, reading, moving around, making quick edits. It takes good advantage of the whole keyboard even when you're not writing new text. I use qutebrowser, which has default vim-style bindings for everything and an emphasis on the keyboard. It works very well.
- corank 2y agoI think an important difference between how I use vim and how I use a web browser is that in vim I need to type frequently. Though I may spend most time in normal mode in vim, I still need to switch to insert mode to make edits very frequently. With my normal web browsing it's not the case, so I'm more comfortable with a mouse for that. But I realise that this depends largely on the specific use case for web browsing. Reading blog posts is quite different from reading some documentation where one needs to search and backtrack frequently, for example, although both are done on a web browser. The latter involves the keyboard more frequently so would benefit from a keyboard-centric interface more.
- wkat4242 2y ago> I don't get the hype of keyboard == hacker mentality. It's all about investing a little time to learn something that dramatically speeds up your workflow. A mainstream user has no interest in this even if they work with the computer all day. Hackers as computer enthusiasts do. When you worked on those early computers you either had to be an enthusiast or be forced by an employer to use them :) GUIs are great for infrequent tasks. TUIs for efficiency at frequent ones.
- ucosty 2y agoWe're talking about a web browser, right? What workflow?
- kstenerud 2y agoIt's an elitism thing. Notice the terminology "investing time to dramatically speed up workflow". This is the mantra that the keyboard-only adherents have latched onto, and extend to EVERYTHING, including things that are perfectly serviced via mouse control, or don't even need speeding up. Arguing with them is like arguing with audiophiles.
- anonzzzies 2y agoNot sure why arguing is needed? You like a mouse, I think it sucks. If we meet up, we can trivially measure what is faster. What is there to argue?
- codingdave 2y agoOr we can not measure which is faster and just respect that everyone has their own preferences.
- anonzzzies 2y agoAlso fine :)) Just no need to argue about it.
- tsukurimashou 2y agoits a productivity thing, would you rather type text with a physical keyboard or would you rather use a virtual keyboard and mouse? you can miss more easily with a mouse and have to adjust the position of the cursor to line up on two axis before any action
- kstenerud 2y agoThat's a false dichotomy. I'd rather have a physical keyboard and a physical mouse (or touchpad). The "line up the two axis" thing is immaterial, and has no practical impact on actual productivity.
- dartos 2y agoMinimal impact and no impact different. “Line up the two axes” was kind of a silly way to put it, but the position you aim your cursor varies quite often, but where you type on a keyboard doesn’t. You can develop muscle memory for the latter. It’s why hotkeys are so widely used.
- pjmlp 2y agoWhy bringing virtual keyboard into the picture, we aren't talking about tablets and phones.
- codingdave 2y agoThat is a really biased way to spin things. Of course virtual keyboards are the worst of both worlds. And lining up a mouse on multiple axes is just an odd way to look at it -- on a keyboard you need to line up your fingertip on three axes for every keystroke, if you are wanting to go to that level of detail.
- dartos 2y agoI don’t think it’s very biased. When using a mouse you need to completely move your hand to another device, and aim that device at an arbitrary position. With a keyboard the positions you move your fingers are fixed and because of that, you can develop muscle memory and type very quickly without thinking about where to move your fingers. It’s called “touch typing.” There’s no such thing for using a mouse since the target position of the mouse movement can vary wildly from website to website and can vary based on the position of a given window.
- goodpoint 2y agoKeyboard is not only faster, but requires less attention.
- pjmlp 2y agoDepends on the typing skills between chair and monitor.
- shiomiru 2y agoFor best ergonomics, both should be well supported. If I'm programming and want to look up something in the docs, then it's annoying to switch to the mouse and then back, but I pretty much have to with traditional browser UI. (Or tab through a million links to find the right button to click, use cursor keys to scroll, etc.) Similarly, if I'm just scrolling around with the mouse, then I should be able to do everything that I can with the keyboard (apart from text input). The context menu is good for discoverability, but being context-dependent makes it impossible to rely on muscle memory.
- vunderba 2y agoI think you're projecting a bit. I'm sure there are a few weird KEYBOARD VS MOUSE people that occupy the same bizarre neurotic domain space as TABS VS SPACES, but most people just have their own personal preference and leave it at that. Personally, it's not about what's faster - it's about switching. If my hands are already resting lightly on the keyboard, then the keyboard is faster - and vice versa. To decrease the amount of switching I have to do, I use an extension called Vimium that quickly highlights all links with key bindings. For example "g i" automatically puts the first <input> level field into focus. https://github.com/philc/vimium https://github.com/philc/vimium
- antasvara 2y agoAs a younger person, I've never really been alive for a computer that had no mouse. So for people of my generation, it's really only the tech savvy ones that would use key commands for anything but the most rudimentary stuff (think copy, paste, save, and print). Thats not to say that keyboard == hacker mentality, but that a keyboard-first tool like this wouldn't really target the average consumer at this point.
- sourcepluck 2y ago> I don't get the hype of keyboard == hacker mentality There's no (or extremely little...) hype, it's just the sort of thing which starts to appear prominent in a world where conversations are driven more and more by the titles on videos and articles, rather than the other way around. I claim that the following are all pretty factual, all at once: 1. meese can be faster and more convenient, in certain cases 2. keyboards can be faster and more convenient, in certain cases 3. what people (even the computer-savvy) are used to matters much more than what is "objectively" best or fastest or whatever 4. "hacker" is a polysemic term - playful creative norm-bending, technical mastery of some domain, making Ataris and Amigas do funny stuff it seems they shouldn't have been able to, getting access to a gaming console you weren't supposed to, solving a problem in a surprising manner, reverse engineering some game, etc 5. emacs is an empowering, wonderful text editor 6. so is (hyper/super/ultra/n/eo/) vi(m) 7. nyxt is about much more than keyboard shortcuts (Lisp, freedom, etc)
- airstrike 2y agoI think it goes like this https://i.imgflip.com/9d2ec7.jpg https://i.imgflip.com/9d2ec7.jpg