17 ms·
FTC takes action against Gravy Analytics, Venntel for selling location data
- perihelions 2y agoHere's a few previous threads (about "Venntel" or "Gravy Analytics" specifically), https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25288341 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25288341 ("My Phone Was Spying on Me, So I Tracked Down the Surveillants", 170 comments) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24896456 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24896456 ("CBP Refuses to Tell Congress How It Is Tracking Americans Without a Warrant", 98 comments) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32689862 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32689862 ("[Here's] The Manual for the Mass Surveillance Tool Cops Use to Track Phones", 96 comments) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24709347 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24709347 ("The IRS is being investigated for using location data without a warrant", 80 comments)
- us0r 2y ago"FTC Bans Location Data Company" no not really. https://www.ftc.gov/system/files/ftc_gov/pdf/2123035gravyanalyticsorder.pdf https://www.ftc.gov/system/files/ftc_gov/pdf/2123035gravyana... As I skim that it just feels like a pile of shit that does nothing but create a few jobs to make reports. It doesn't bind the management. They can literally go do the same thing tomorrow. Oh wait... "Gravy Analytics is now part of Unacast!" Why isn't Unacast a party? Where is the monetary fine?
- fallingknife 2y agoYeah government doesn't want to end the surveillance. They want to access it. This action serves that purpose and also makes more work for bureaucrats and lawyers. It's a real win-win from a DC perspective.
- armanhq 2y agoAre we skimming the same thing here? Section II explicitly binds the management and prohibits sale of precise sensitive location data. This is a consent decree - not sure what the FTC banning a company would look like exactly - using your example, Unacast would be bound by the terms of the decree. FTC's shuttering a line of business for these companies and requiring guardrails (which sure, might create jobs for reporting but...those data governance jobs for this type of data specifically should probably exist?), seems like an ok remedy imo. For context: > "II. Prohibitions on the Use, Sale, or Disclosure of Sensitive Location Data IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that Respondents and Respondents’ officers, agents, and employees, whether acting directly or indirectly, must not sell, license, transfer, share, disclose, or otherwise use in any products or services Sensitive Location Data associated with the Sensitive Locations that Respondents have identified within 90 days of the effective date of this Order as part of the Sensitive Locations Data Program established and maintained pursuant to Provision III below."
- ranger_danger 2y agoHow can the FTC make any enforceable rules now that Chevron is gone?
- josefritzishere 2y agoThis is the best question here. The FTC can still make and enforce regulations. But the regulatees can now take those enforecements to federal judges who may modify or vacate the enforcement action, or even the regulation itself. The loss of chevron does not end regulation. It creates a morass of inconsistent and inexpert judicial inturpretations. It was the worst supreme court decision in decades.
- freejazz 2y ago> It was the worst supreme court decision in decades That's saying a lot considering that the presidential immunity decision is going to create the same kind of uncertainty surrounding presidential conduct which is likely not going to be resolved for decades.
- alistairSH 2y agoEven worse than near-blanket immunity for the President? I guess we'll find out in January! But yeah, the inconsistent rulings from the bench will be a total dumpster fire.
- ranger_danger 2y ago
- bpodgursky 2y ago> Despite understanding that precise geolocation data is sensitive information that requires consumers’ consent, Respondents fail to take reasonable steps to confirm consumers consented to Respondents’ collection, use, or sale of this data and consumers do not, in fact, consent to the collection, use, and sale of their location data by Respondents. Is there some actual law that this is based on? I am sympathetic to arguments that this should be a law, and is sketchy and gross, but the legal requirement of active consent for geolocation data seems to be something the agency is just declaring to be true and daring lawsuits to challenge.
- evoke4908 2y ago> seems to be something the agency is just declaring to be true and daring lawsuits to challenge I'm pretty sure that this is exactly how it's supposed to work. Federal agencies like the FTC have (had?) the authority to make rules and reinterpret existing rules with the force of law. In the (present) US government, it really can't work any other way. Without this sort of autonomy, any action by the FTC, EPA, etc would require congressional approval, which would mean that they effectively would never be able to function at all. Law moves far, far too slowly. FTC needs autonomy to go around the law to react to rapidly changing markets and technologies. Notionally their actions should be codified by Congress after the fact, but Congress is incapable of doing anything useful within 20 years.
- colechristensen 2y agoThis puts a bit of a weird spin on it. Especially after recent supreme court decisions, which I support, Congress has to give an agency specific authority within defined boundaries in order to make regulations which have the force of law. Congress doesn't have to get down to the very specifics (like for example emissions standards numbers for cars), but it does have to be specific enough (can't say: EPA, you're responsible for environment stuff, make whatever laws you feel like). For example the origination of the FTC https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Federal_Trade_Commission_Act_of_1914 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Federal_Trade_Commission_Act_o... The legislation charges the FTC with preventing unfair business practices, defines what it means by unfair, and then gives authority to address these things through administrative actions or the courts.
- readthenotes1 2y agoHuh. It was ok the last 4 years but not next year.
- DangitBobby 2y agoSaid in response to literally every law, regulation, or enforcement action ever.
- janalsncm 2y agoA really good book on this topic is Byron Tau’s Means of Control. His contention is that this surveillance data has made NSA warrantless wiretaps old news. Cops don’t need to do the spying themselves, they can simply buy the info. I am of the opinion that at this point, Americans only believe we are less surveilled than people elsewhere. It’s not visible so people forget about it. Yet it is so deeply embedded into the government that it will never be removed.
- webspinner 2y agoWell, if you follow legal cases as I do, you know that isn't true! We are surveilled just as much as everyone else, save for maybe the UK, but we're even getting pretty close to that!
- dylan604 2y agoThere's the old saying that "we are free only as much as we don't have guns in our face telling us we're not". The reigns placed on our freedom are just unrecognized by the vast majority of people so they feel they have more freedom than what they might appreciate.
- gmfawcett 2y ago> we are free only as much as we don't have guns in our face telling us we're not. Is this actually an old saying?
- whatshisface 2y agoIt's at least thirty minutes old.
- dylan604 2y agoi might have butchered the actual saying, but the gist is there
- revscat 2y ago
- yieldcrv 2y ago> without obtaining verifiable user consent for commercial and government uses. and if they did obtain it, this data should have trackable provenance, should be revokable, and there should be payment and royalties to the user for its use and continued use
- dylan604 2y ago>should be revokable this data will self-destruct in five seconds? unless you plan on making it DRM protected, how else do you make data revokable? it's just text that can at worst be screen scraped into whatever format they want/need. plus, as we all know, DRM encryption keys tend to have a way of being broken or discovered or whatever other method of being rendered useless.
- yieldcrv 2y agonothing to do with DRM we can just copy a regulatory regime seen in other industries: non-compliant offerings are outright illegal and anyone trading in it can be sanctioned outright, while compliant offerings have this feature set. the feature set can have a standardized way of tracking provenance, which the user can look at and revoke its compliance if desired, by signing a cryptographic signature that produces the expected address that approved consent to begin with. the same address's public key would be used for royalty payment. there are many examples of this working in standardized ways in some networks.
- afavour 2y agoNot everything has to be a tech solution. Legislate that companies must delete the data and punish them if they don’t. Much like GDPR.
- lmm 2y agoHow's that working out? I know companies have spent a lot on GDPR compliance and you occasionally hear some headline number of company y fined z amount (which usually then disappears on appeal), but are people actually any less tracked as a result?
- lenerdenator 2y agoHow nice of the FTC to do this. I mean, it won't matter come January 21st, but it's a nice thought.
- abnercoimbre 2y agoAre these Lina Khan’s final days?
- lenerdenator 2y agoIt's when an administration that thinks that any and all regulations are job-killing and burdensome takes power, with a Congress and SCOTUS to match.
- nozzlegear 2y agoYes, her term as chair technically ended in September. Trump is expected to pick someone who aligns more toward his and JD Vance's goals regarding big tech.
- llamaimperative 2y agoRegarding people who were mean to Big Don, no matter what industry or whether they in fact have a right to be mean to Big Don *
- selimthegrim 2y agoVance was praising her
- mikeyouse 2y agoHe was basically the only person in the cabinet who did so.. Elon is not a fan, writing on November 1st that “she’ll be fired soon” so it’s safe to say she’s out.
- nozzlegear 2y agoVance was also calling Trump "America's Hitler" at one point.
- blackeyeblitzar 2y agoI would like to see action against car makers like Honda and Subaru and Ford for selling location data from the car’s GPS
- Cadwhisker 2y agoDon't forget Hyundai, too. https://www.caranddriver.com/news/a61711288/automakers-sold-customer-data-for-small-profits/ https://www.caranddriver.com/news/a61711288/automakers-sold-... Honda sold their users' data for 26 cents per car. Hyundai sold their users' data for 61 cents per car. Whether or not that data is used to affect insurance premiums is hard to ascertain, but I wouldn't be surprised if someone somewhere in the world was affected by it.
- kevin_thibedeau 2y agoWhy should we have piecemeal, extra-legal policies that only favor special interest groups? It's nice that they protect the privacy of church goers, but they can still geofence my neighborhood to estimate my income bracket among other invasions. It's well past time for comprehensive data protection laws rather than a hodgepodge of special treatment policies for whoever the executive wants to curry favor with. We really need a leak of tracking data on Congresspeople going to compromising places to make this happen.
- Ylpertnodi 2y ago>It's well past time for comprehensive data protection laws.... Oh, for horror! That might mean more banners on websites....
- navaed01 2y agoThis did not go far enough. Why is there a class action lawsuit for Cliff bars and not for scummy location data harvesters. I am curious whether they sold only segments or device level data and whether you could identify an individual
- EasyMark 2y agoI have a feeling all these FTC cases like this and the ones against big tech companies will all be dropped in a couple of months with just a little greasing of the wheels from these companies that are under investigation.
- tiahura 2y ago[flagged]
- a-french-anon 2y agoOff the gravy train for them! (Sorry)
- bastloing 2y agoI wish they would take action on collecting data
- welder 2y ago> The companies can retain historic location data if they ensure that it is deidentified or rendered non-sensitive or if consumers consented to the use of their data. They left a loophole, sounds like nothing will change.
- blitzar 2y ago> if consumers consented The consumer has a phone, they obviously consented - hardly passing through the eye of a needle.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- Nifty3929 2y agoI really wish we would stop being distracted by what corporations are doing with our data, and shift the focus to what governments are doing with it. It's true of course that corporations often collect and sell this data to the government, so we should focus instead on the data collection at it's source - on our devices. However the data is collected, and whoever collects it - the government will get and use it for their own purposes. Corporations just want to sell you more stuff. The government wants to control you.
- david38 2y agoThis is false. Corporations want to make money. A big way to do this is to sell your data to governments. Another way is to use your data to help them become a monopoly and/or manipulate you. It’s not “sell more stuff”, it’s “assist governments and extract money by any means, including robbing you”.