7 ms·
California teacher dies from suspected rabid bat bite
- chrisbrandow 2y agoI remember when I briefly lived in WV, we had a bat in our house and after knocking it down with a pillow, I needed to remove it, and i was WAY too much of a scaredy-cat to remotely touch it bare-handed. I came up with an elaborate procedure with an upside down bowl, took it outside and ran away as soon as I freed it. Glad to see my hilariously overweight instincts validated.
- slibhb 2y agoThe problem here wasn't getting bit, it was not getting vaccinated. It took a month for symptoms to appear (which is typical) and at that point it's too late. Growing up, it wasn't too uncommon for a bat to get stuck in the house. Mostly you can just open a door and it will find its way out. If not, it will get tired and you can bring it outside while it's asleep. If you get bit, you need to get vaccinated.
- mingus88 2y agoI occasionally have birds fly into my garage and need help getting out. They will fixate on the large window and need some help finding their way out But, yeah, bats who echolocate don’t really need help, do they? Sad that the woman’s good faith efforts to peacefully move the animal was far more dangerous than she could have known
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> the woman’s good faith efforts to peacefully move the animal was far more dangerous than she could have known The bat and the bite weren’t dangerous, her decision not to seek medical attention after being bitten by a bat was.
- margalabargala 2y agoThe bite was in fact pretty clearly dangerous.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago[flagged]
- kimixa 2y agoAt some point the reduction of what is to "blame" becomes ridiculous. Getting stabbed wasn't dangerous. The blood loss was. The blood loss wasn't dangerous, cerebral hypoxia was.
- Mordisquitos 2y agoTo be fair, we do not know whether she actively decided not to get vaccinated for rabies after her encounter. She may have been ignorant of the need to do so.
- JumpCrisscross 2y agoFair enough, I changed the language to avoid that misreading.
- shaky-carrousel 2y agoI threw a towel to it and moved it outside. It got pretty stuck to the towel so I left it in the garden.
- elzbardico 2y agoMy first instinct would be to shoot it with birdshot. But that would be stupid, as now there will be no way to know if the bat is sick.
- zarzavat 2y agoIf this happens, do not free the bat after trapping it! Instead contact your relevant disease control authority so that the bat can be tested for rabies. Otherwise doctors will have to assume you've been infected and treat you regardless of whether you need it or not. A bite or scratch is not necessarily visible.
- foota 2y agoThe above comment doesn't state this explicitly, but bat bites can go unfelt (e.g., if you're sleeping, for instance) so the recommendation if a bat is found inside the house is to keep the bat for rabies testing and see a doctor.
- jliptzin 2y agoI’ll never understand why the recommendation is for people with no training or experience in handling wild animals whatsoever is to expect them to catch a potentially rabid bat instead of just vaccinating them. Even if someone manages to catch the bat and it tests negative for rabies, then what? What if the test isn’t 100% accurate? Would you trust it? Considering how awful and deadly the virus is, I would not care what the test result is, I’d want the vaccine. I got it about 10 years ago, it was a series of 3 shots and was no big deal. We give rabies shots to dogs and cats constantly, why do humans have to jump through hoops to get it?
- zarzavat 2y agoWhether or not to trap the bat requires some common sense specific to the situation, perhaps you can effectively trap it by closing a door for instance. However if like GP you've already trapped the bat then you should definitely not release it. The post-exposure treatment for rabies involves immunoglobulin[0], which is not always easily available especially in the kinds of places where rabies is most endemic. The vaccine alone, post-exposure, may not be sufficient. An ounce of prevention is worth a pound a cure, get vaccinated beforehand. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rabies_immunoglobulin https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rabies_immunoglobulin
- deleted 2y ago
- plagiarist 2y agoThey recommend going to the ER if there is ever a bat in the room while you have been sleeping because the bites can be undetectable. Any contact at all and it could have nipped you without you realizing. You were right to be wary.
- cedws 2y agoDamn, there was a bat hiding out in my room for ages when I was a kid. Glad to say I never got rabies.
- adamredwoods 2y agoThis happened to our friend's family. They all had to get shots and in the US, doctor's rarely carry the vaccine, so each time a shot is needed, they had to go to the ER, which took hours.
- plagiarist 2y agoIt's a ridiculous combination of needing to go to the ER but something that can be scheduled (especially beyond the initial shot).
- madaxe_again 2y agoI can’t tell you how many times I’ve had bats in the house - hundreds. If it won’t leave of its own volition, all you need is a towel - just lob it into the little blighter’s flight path, and then lob the towel, bat and all out of the window. The bat will be fine, the towel will want laundering, and you will be fine. The only times I’ve had to handle bats have been where they’ve smacked into something and stunned themselves, and one of the cats is eyeing up a convenient snack - like any other wild critter, leather gloves are a good idea if you have them, but you can barehand it if you do a normal restraint hold, which is trivially easy - they can’t bend their necks downwards so just gently gripping their torso and hind limbs keeps both of you safe - like this: https://www.goerie.com/gcdn/presto/2022/04/20/NETN/8ec5edbc-0bbf-4846-8d15-f18e7d1c24a6-small_ft_teeth.jpeg?crop=1999,1125,x0,y142&width=660&height=371&format=pjpg&auto=webp https://www.goerie.com/gcdn/presto/2022/04/20/NETN/8ec5edbc-...
- SoftTalker 2y agoAny wild animal bite needs to be taken seriously. A rabies vaccine series isn't pleasant but it beats the alternative.
- richwater 2y agoThe vaccine is much better than it used to be.
- bb88 2y agoThe alternative is almost certain death for the readers that don't know.
- el_benhameen 2y agoI received a pre-exposure prophylaxis series and it was really no different than any other vaccine series I’ve had.
- _whiteCaps_ 2y agoPost-exposure is the uncomfortable one as you're getting the immune globulin where the bite was. But definitely better than the days when you were getting the rest of the series in the abdomen.
- SoftTalker 2y agoDo you work with animals? I'm curious why you or your doctor felt this was necessary.
- bb88 2y agoThe documented number of people who have survived a full blown rabies infection can be counted on one hand. I only know of 1 person, there may be others.
- darkwizard42 2y agoUnder 20 for sure, Milwaukee Protocol is the usual approach
- ssklash 2y agoI read just recently that they no longer even recommend the Milwaukee Protocol, as it's not been shown to have any significant effect.
- cafard 2y agoBack in the 1980s, a Marine at Quantico made the mistake of picking up a sick raccoon--one heard a lot about rabid raccoons in the area then, but I guess he hadn't. He developed rabies, and survived.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> He developed rabies, and survived Certainly not. I'd have said almost certainly had this been a civilian. But the fact that it was an on-duty Marine gives this a 0% chance of not being reported.
- Mordisquitos 2y agoFurthermore, there is a high chance that a Marine in active service would have already received the rabies vaccine as prophylaxis: https://health.mil/Military-Health-Topics/Health-Readiness/Immunization-Healthcare/Vaccine-Recommendations/Vaccine-Recommendations-by-AOR https://health.mil/Military-Health-Topics/Health-Readiness/I...
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago
- JumpCrisscross 2y agoRabies is approximately 100% fatal [1]. The moment you start showing symptoms it's already too late. If you get bitten by a wild animal, tell your doctor and get a rabies vaccine. It's as stupidly effective at preventing rabies as the rabies virus is at kiling you [2]. [1] https://www.who.int/en/news-room/fact-sheets/detail/rabies https://www.who.int/en/news-room/fact-sheets/detail/rabies [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rabies_vaccine#Before_exposure https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rabies_vaccine#Before_exposure
- jt2190 2y ago> If you get bitten… Nit: If you get exposed to the infected animal’s saliva. [1] This does not need to be a bite. > People can get rabies if they have contact with the saliva or neural tissue of an infected animal… [2] [1] “Canadian child dies from rabies after bat found in bedroom” https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cvgxjnldqvdo https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cvgxjnldqvdo [2] Center for Disease Control “Rabies VIS” https://www.cdc.gov/vaccines/hcp/vis/vis-statements/rabies.html https://www.cdc.gov/vaccines/hcp/vis/vis-statements/rabies.h...
- tombert 2y agoI agree with what you're saying, and you're absolutely correct, but purely in the interest of pedantry, there has been at least one case of a person surviving after showing symptoms [1]. Still, the odds are so close to 100% lethal after symptoms that you can very honestly round up to 100%. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rabies#After_onset https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rabies#After_onset
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> there has been at least one case of a person surviving after showing symptoms There appear to be some people with the ability to create antibodies to the rabies virus. Together with the Milwaukee protocol, which may keep the brain from frying itself (or do nothing, we don't know), we have the ability to turn it from a death sentence to--in a hair of cases--just a severely debilitating disease.
- stronglikedan 2y ago
- IAmGraydon 2y agoGo ahead and read up on what a death due to rabies is like. After that, you'll definitely never neglect to treat a wild animal bite seriously. It's the stuff nightmares are made of.
- vundercind 2y agoTL;DR it slowly, and mostly asymptomatically, eats its way up your nerves until it reaches your brain and starts eating that. That's when you start developing significant signs and symptoms, by which point, maybe weeks after exposure and without evident illness in the meantime, you're already dead. There's a treatment protocol—it's grueling and if you live, you'll suffer some amount of permanent disability. And, statistically, you won't live. You're dead. The course after that is a few weeks of effectively rapid-onset severe dementia. Animals don't get violent and unpredictable because the virus is simply angry-making—they get that way because they stop recognizing once-familiar things and can't remember how they got where they are, and so are constantly fucking terrified, plus their throats are closing up so they can't eat or drink (assuming they could remember to, or how to) and are experiencing dehydration and starvation. That's your near future by the time there are signs of the disease. You're about to dehydrate to death over a period of low-tens of days while becoming increasingly confused and frightened by your situation and by your own loved ones. It's absolutely horrifying.
- gav 2y agoYou need to treat any animal bite seriously. I had to convince a coworker to go to the ER to have a cat bite looked at, and she ended up spending a couple of days in the ICU with the doctor being clear that delaying treatment another few days would have been fatal.
- vundercind 2y agohttps://xkcd.com/1775/ https://xkcd.com/1775/ This one covers several things but is basically motivated by spreading the bad news about the seriousness of cat bites, as made clear by the alt text.
- 2y ago
- james_pm 2y agoDo not ever touch bats. Never ever. If you do touch a bat, go to the ER and tell them you touched a bat.
- madaxe_again 2y agoI mean, in Europe, bats carry rabies - something like 1% of them - but there have been a grand total of three rabies cases in the last 50 years from bat bites across the entire continent. As to mice and rats - the chance of getting rabies from them is negligible, anywhere - they usually end up incapacitated and dead through predation extremely rapidly. I’ve been bitten by all of the above. No treatment beyond dousing the wounds with peroxide. The closest a mouse ever came to killing me was when it pushed a rock out of a wall in the hovel in which I lived, which smashed the headboard of the bed a few inches from my skull. I feel like this is all something that has been pushed by the American insurance industry. Again - 43 deaths in 50 years. Negligible. If you really cared about risk management, you would never, ever get in a motor vehicle, and you would have insurance for putting on your pants in the morning. Like so many things, rational risk management is overtaken by fear and emotion.
- slfnflctd 2y agoAt the time I write this comment, the thread has been up for 9 hours and has 130 comments. I can't claim to have read them all, but in my scan of the entire page, yours is the only one I could find focusing on the actual facts instead of the fear-mongering. I'm disappointed in this community. I suppose it's not fair to expect a lot of deep zoology background here, but damn. More information on a balancing perspective can be found here: https://www.merlintuttle.org/rabies-in-perspective/ https://www.merlintuttle.org/rabies-in-perspective/
- apple4ever 2y agoVery good article. While I normally am terrified of rabies, this helps me reduced that fear, and not worry because a bat flew by overhead. I know in the US we only get 2-3 cases per year, and the OP case is the first in 3 years I think? All of our cases are known to be direct contact with bats/animals and the people should've known to get help.
- Optimal_Persona 2y agoEek! The only time I've been bitten by a rodent was close to where this happened - sleeping overnight on the floor at a Merced punk venue my band played at, I was awoken by something nibbling on my hand. Not good, it was a rat.
- YeGoblynQueenne 2y agoThat's punk.
- throwup238 2y agoWhen I got bit by a squirrel and contacted the CDC for a second opinion after my doctor wouldn’t prescribe the shots, they told me that there’s no record of rabies transmission between rodents and humans. They can’t really survive an attack from another rabid animal and would die soon after they became infectious anyway. That applies to anything smaller than a skunk or raccoon, which have thicker hides. Bats are special because of their unique biology which creates a viral reservoir (IIRC the virus originated in bats). Rabies persists in their bodies without making them sick and they transmit it to each other within their colonies.
- danhorner 2y agoI live in Washington and bats occasionally wander into our cabin. As others have pointed out, there is a difference between pre-exposure (Vaccination) and post-exposure protocols. The rabies vaccine is given pre-exposure and can be obtained at travel clinics. It's generally only given to people travelling to high-incidence areas or sometimes to those working with wild animals. I believe this is because it's only effective for a year or two. Although, there was one documented non-fatal incidence of human rabies in an individual who had been vaccinated years prior if memory serves. The rabies post-exposure protocol is much less pleasant. It includes Immunoglobulin against the virus as soon as possible post-exposure. This needs multiple injections just to make up the volume. It's much more expensive and a little unusual, so ER visit. A child-sized dose was 4 simultaneous injections into buttocks and arms. It's followed by vaccination+booster at travel clinic, a couple of weeks apart. If you are able to preserve the bat without touching it, local authorities can examine it. They will need to decapitate it and examine the brain tissue, so the brain needs to be intact and not frozen to get good tissue. ie. Don't put it in the freezer. Having said that, bats are super-adorable and I've been able to move them with heavy gloves by placing a tupperware over them, sealing with a piece of paper, and relocating them outside before anybody gets close to them. We just had one borderline experience (no confirmed contact) where we felt it was better to be safe than sorry. Post-exposure protocol is criticial if there was contact with the bat because the stakes are so high.
- VincentEvans 2y agoWhen I was a kid and needed rabies vaccine for a dog bite (the owner snatched the dog that bit me and took off before anyone had a chance to query her whether the dog was vaccinated) - it was 30 or so shots into my stomach, given over multiple days - and causing a lot of soreness and pain in between. I wonder if it’s still like this, because damn.
- zkms 2y ago>it was 30 or so shots into my stomach, given over multiple days - and causing a lot of soreness and pain in between. I wonder if it’s still like this, because damn it's not like this anymore; it's just four shots in the upper arm (like any other common vaccine) over two weeks.
- dmpayton 2y agoI don't have anything meaningful to add other than how bizarre to see this on HN. Laura Splotch, who was interviewed in the article, is a good friend, neighbor, and former coworker. Weird how things intersect sometimes.
- yegle 2y agoTime to review this post on Reddit: https://old.reddit.com/r/copypasta/comments/7qwtd5/rabies_is_scary/ https://old.reddit.com/r/copypasta/comments/7qwtd5/rabies_is...
- edanm 2y agoThat was terrifying. Very well written.
- chadaustin 2y agoLast Christmas, we got a tree from a local farm in the mountains. We had the tree trimmed and decorated before we discovered a sleeping (hibernating?) bat on the inside. We got it moved outside, but it took about 24 hours before I realized that I should call County Health. By that point, the bat was gone, and county health suggested I receive rabies treatment, but call my doctor. The bat could have bit or scratched without us realizing it. The doctor concurred. Rabies treatment must be done at the ER. They strongly recommended everyone in the house receive treatment if we could not 100% rule out physical contact. (We couldn't.) Me, my wife, my kids, EACH receiving the immunoglobulin and four rounds of vaccines at the ER. We ran the first ER out of the treatment so the kids had to go somewhere else. Also, those are big needles. The treatment ended up billing insurance over $100,000. (Almost all of that is the immunoglobulin.) We also had to return to both ERs, three times each, with the last time being on Christmas morning. There is research that says immunoglobulin is _likely_ not necessary if you have no visible bites, but it's current health policy in the USA, and no doctor wants to be the first to undertreat. Most expensive Christmas tree ever.
- unsupp0rted 2y agoI had the same treatment in South Korea a few years ago, including immunoglobulin. It cost about $4,000 or so
- PartiallyTyped 2y agoUS absurdities aside, I find it ridiculous that people need to pay for something that will save their life.
- southernplaces7 2y agoReally? That's your only criteria for thinking it's absurd? People need food to live, water too, and also clothing. Is it absolutely insane that all of these cost money? I'm not defending the insane billing system of the U.S, because it truly is designed to be or at least accidentally off the wall with absurdities, but it's not ridiculous to charge people reasonably for many complex, expensive things that also require hiring specialist assistance. Somewhere down the line, somebody in any case needs to pay for it via money and time.
- LiquidPolymer 2y agoI've been rabies vaccinated for 32 years. I get my titer checked every 2 years. I finally got a booster a few weeks ago. I do work with wild animals including bats. Whenever I read a story like this, I wonder if more people should be vaccinated for rabies. When I spoke to the Oregon state veterinarian a few years ago he told me about a terrible case of rabies infection that happened with a child. The general scenario is - domestic cat catches rabid bat - cat becomes rabid - child in the household is bitten. As mentioned, by the time symptoms are detected it is too late. The doctor also told me a man who got bit by a rabid dog in Mexico and died in Oregon. It took some sleuthing to figure out how/when the infection occurred since the Mexico trip had been months before. Rabies is a terrible way to die.
- harimau777 2y agoSomething that never made sense to me: Why don't we just vaccinate everyone for rabies?
- kylehotchkiss 2y agoWe have treatment regimens post exposure, and these are available worldwide: https://www.nyc.gov/assets/doh/downloads/pdf/vet/what-to-expect-rabies-pep.pdf https://www.nyc.gov/assets/doh/downloads/pdf/vet/what-to-exp... The amount of people getting rabies doesn't warrant the vaccine. It's not widely transmitted person to person. I guess we could vaccinate all the animals. Then we get the same antibiotic resistance questions other diseases have.
- fragmede 2y agobecause it's not life long protection and the threat level isn't that high. compare it to the Chickenpox vaccine regime, which needs to be taken once for life long protection. that makes sense to give to everybody. rabies protection only lasts a few years. the chances you'll get exposed to rabies naturally are relatively low, compared to chicken pox. (low doesn't mean zero, and if you're a rural inhabitant, it'll be higher). finally, these things aren't free, so that gets factored into things as well.
- apple4ever 2y agoI thought that too, but we only have a limited supply of it, its not without its own risks, and we get 2-3 cases per year of it - mostly due to vaccinating those exposed, and the 2-3 that happen, such as this case, should've known but didn't.
- aaron695 2y ago[dead]
- m3kw9 2y agoDo people still eat bats on TikTok?
- farmeroy 2y agoThis terrifies me
- anothername12 2y agoI've been through the rabies protocol after a bite from random homeless dog I tried to help. In the US with insurance it's about $5K out of pocket, and 3 or 4 (can't remember exactly) visits to the ER. the first visit they inject some gelatinous stuff all over the site of the bite site plus the vaccine. And no, they don't inject in your abdominal area anymore. The case will be referred to the city and if possible, the animal will be tested for it. I'm not sure if they have to kill the animal to test. They'll let you know if it was positive though. It's extremely rare to get rabies, but also it's extremely lethal.
- southernplaces7 2y agoWith the fairly broad scope of publicity campaigns and pop-sci information about how bats are notorious hosts of rabies, it's surprising that this woman didn't go get checked out right after releasing the bat. I'd assume she'd have noticed being bitten since she was awake and carrying it before releasing it, and that would have been a huge red flag for visiting a doctor, but even if she wasn't sure about a bite, like I said, the publicity around bats and the danger of rabies is huge. Even little kids often know about the connection between the two. Strange. She had nearly a month to save herself and simply nope.
- ngcc_hk 2y agoSorry to sidetrack but is this a local newspaper? I found it odd to see international news so update in this newspaper.