9 ms·
Gene behind orange fur in cats
- xeonmc 2y agoTangentially related, but https://old.reddit.com/r/OneOrangeBraincell/ https://old.reddit.com/r/OneOrangeBraincell/ is a subreddit dedicated to specifically orange-furred cats. I was expecting quite something else when I first read the subreddit name.
- aitchnyu 2y agoDo orange cats act/be dumber than the rest or is it Internet legend?
- goodpoint 2y agoIt's an internet legend. There is zero difference in reality but people love anecdata.
- jdck1326 2y agosource?
- williamdclt 2y agoI think the burden of proof is on the "orange cats have statistically-significant behavioural specificity" side
- TheSpiceIsLife 2y agoI mean, they are orange.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- reducesuffering 2y agoThe stereotype is that orange cats are feistier. In my personal anecdotal experience it's true
- immibis 2y agoI thought that was about people, and it turned out there was actually some gene that affects both personality and hair colour.
- waveBidder 2y agowe have 2 orange kittens, and just this morning caught one of them trying to eat pebbles. there's always some weird new hijinks that they're up to.
- n-i-m-a 2y agoMy kitten had iron-deficiency when he was doing that. Maybe worth a quick check/ask and with a little bit of dietary change or a supplement the problem could be addressed.
- saghm 2y agoIn my anecdotal experience, it's 100% true, but this also seems like it might be a bit of confirmation bias.
- UncleSlacky 2y agoWhen I was a child I had a very intelligent (female) orange tabby.
- Miraltar 2y agoReading was instead of had was very confusing to me
- willis936 2y agoYes, but it's because 70% of orange cats are male and male cats tend to be more impulsive. It's a correlation rather than a causation. https://youtu.be/wPVBGE6uUS4 https://youtu.be/wPVBGE6uUS4
- consf 2y agoBut that doesn't necessarily mean they are less intelligent
- cainxinth 2y agoStupid is as stupid does
- shagie 2y agoGenetics says that this is also true for black cats (that most black cats are male). However, less is said about them and there's less meme / awareness about female black cats being less common. I suspect this is that an intact male orange cat is much more noticeably male than an intact male black cat.
- jzb 2y agomost black cats are male Huh, I had not heard that. In my experience it's pretty evenly split -- at least, in my circle of friends and family there's eight black cats, four of each. (Most short-haired, one long-haired black cat that's female.)
- shagie 2y agoCat coat color is an X linked gene, so there's no representation of it on the Y chromosome. Let's denote this as Xo and Xb for the genes. An orange female cat is XoXo, a tortoise shell / calico cat is XoXb and a black female cat is XbXb. Male cats are either XbY or XoY - there are no tortoise shell male cats (there are cats with Klinefelter's syndrome that can be XbXoY but only mentioning this for a full coverage of the topic - and for a real example of this https://disneylandcats.com/cat-profile-francisco/ https://disneylandcats.com/cat-profile-francisco/ and it confuses things since XbXbY and XoXoY cats would be difficult to identify without a genetic test). The thing with all of this is that the genetics for XoXo or XbXb and XoY or XbY are exactly the same percentages. Doing the Punnett squares for cat coats and all the possible pairings and you get simplified Genotype Count Percent of XX or XY XoXo 3 25% XoXb 6 50% XbXb 3 25% XoY 6 50% XbY 6 50% It ends up with 2/3 of the orange cats being male and 2/3 of the black cats being male. This doesn't quite match real world situations since you could have a colony that is dominated by orange cats (or black cats ... or neither).
- hakube 2y agothey're not dumb but they're a menace. They have some interesting quirks but the same could be said about black/tuxedo cats
- empty_space 2y ago[flagged]
- ChrisMarshallNY 2y agoThe cat that owns our family is good-natured, affectionate, well-behaved, and dumb as a bag of hammers.
- BankHottas 2y agoThis is my favorite HN comment of all time
- WXLCKNO 2y agoLmao. I don't often laugh on hn like this.
- consf 2y ago[dead]
- dennis_jeeves2 2y agoMine is wicked, self centered, and doesn't give 2 hoots about anybody except his food.
- ChrisMarshallNY 2y agoProbably smart as hell. I have a friend, with a little black cat that has him completely wrapped around her paw.
- fiedzia 2y agoInternet legend. All cats do the same things. Some individuals are smarter, but I doubt it has anything to do with fur color. And I don't recall hearing anything special about orange cats from people who have many cats.
- yabones 2y agoIt's largely folklore, but there is a kernel of truth to it. Orange cats have a pretty "silly" attitude, kind of like golden retriever dogs. Black/tux cats are usually docile and friendly. Female tortiseshell/tabby cats are lunatics. But there's also quite a bit of individual variation. I'd say it varies more from cat to cat than the "breed" would imply.
- EasyMark 2y agoThis describes my black cat exactly; she runs and hides at the door bell, but when it all calms down, she inevitably comes out to see who it is and within half hour is trying to climb in their lap and is begging for attention from the new person. I had an orange cat once and he pretty much thought he was the family dog. I’ve never seen a friendlier cat, didn’t matter if it was another cat, a dog, a person, or a squirrel; anyone who would play he was ready to go.
- nikole9696 2y agoMore anecdata; my orange boy also thought he was the family dog. He was rather dumb as a rock, but sweet as pie. Loved every human or animal he ever met. My current cat is a calico and white and she's...emotional. =)
- moomin 2y agoMy next door neighbour was a ginger crossed with a persian. Let's just say there was a LOT of orange. The cat was very friendly to humans, and an absolute terror to foxes and any cat they didn't consider a neighbour.
- flkiwi 2y agoWe have an almost pure-black void that screams bloody murder at everything--pick her up, screaming; walk in the room, screaming; give her food, screaming--but cuddles more aggressively than any cat I've ever heard of and purrs nonstop (when she isn't screaming). She hisses as a primary communications mechanism. I hear that cat hiss more in a day than every hiss from every other cat I've ever had combined. She also panic poops when the other cat gets within 5 feet. She is pure, hate-filled joy.
- jzb 2y agoWe have a very fluffy orange guy who is... not dumb, exactly, but I'd say he operates on a different plane than the rest of us. He often stares at things that aren't there -- or, at least, that none of us can see -- and he tends to puzzle things out more slowly and differently. For example, he didn't vocalize much at all as a kitten but has picked up sounds from other cats in the household. He didn't purr at all until very recently (he's six). He can jump like a champion, but hasn't figured out he can leap up to a spot with another cat's kibble. (Instead he sits and looks at it longingly while his sibling jumps up there and eats it if it's left unguarded...) However, some of that might be explained by the fact that he was a very, very sickly kitten who almost didn't make it, and he seems to have a mild case of cerebellar hypoplasia.
- dghughes 2y agoMy parents got a mature older orange cat who was baffled by doors. An open door was no issue but a half door open? Baffling! He sat and stared at the impossible to navigate two foot wide gap. He loved BBQ it was obvious his previous owner did a lot of BBQing. My Dad dropped some raw hamburger for him. Dad's Lay-Z-Boy chair wouldn't do down. What he didn't know was the cat was under it. The chair would slam down on his head but that was of no concern of the cat.
- ordu 2y agoThe most dumb cat I had was the siamese cat. She was not orange. She learned how to steal from a pan closed by a lid only when she spent a summer in country with my old cat, who was a street born, and he was really smart. At some point he led me for a mile, insisting that I followed him. I followed because I was curios. It turned out my cat planned an assault on some house (not on humans but on an another male cat there) and wanted me to help. But my siamese was extremely stupid. For example, it is the only cat that could be distracted. If you took a cat on your lap and it didn't feel like sitting on your lap, it would be hard to keep cat there, it would take any chance to run away. But my siamese would allow me to distract her and would forget that she wanted to run away. It could be distracted from food also. Her attention span was seconds, not like most of cats who get an idea and become obsessed with it. She had broken spine near the tail. My theory is cats hide their real brain somewhere in the back of the spine, while the thing in their heads exists to mislead humans.
- consf 2y ago[dead]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- pilif 2y agoTangentially: interesting how we are looking for this for 60 years and then manage to have two separate teams come up with the answer independently and practically at the same time
- bitwize 2y agoIt orange cat genes when it's orange-cat-gene time.
- telgareith 2y agoThey got the braincell
- atrus 2y agoIf it's affordable and practical for one person/team to do it, it's probably affordable for two or more groups to do it.
- dj_mc_merlin 2y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Multiple_discovery https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Multiple_discovery
- downboots 2y agoinefficiency
- quantadev 2y agoThere's no such thing as a "gene for a trait". Just because some gene perfectly correlates with some trait doesn't mean that's all the gene does. There will be 1000s of things that gene does, and merely one of them just happens to be hair color.
- superb_dev 2y agoThis is covered at the end the article: > No one previously knew Arhgap36 could affect skin or hair coloration—it is involved in many aspects of embryonic development, and major mutations that affect its function throughout the body would probably kill the animal, Barsh says. But because the deletion mutation appears to only affect Arhgap36 function in melanocytes, cats with the mutation are not only healthy, but also cute.
- ourmandave 2y agoit is involved in many aspects of embryonic development Ugh, you don't find this out by not looking at a lot of cute orange (and non-orange) cat embryos under a microscope. =(
- FollowingTheDao 2y agoThat is just them making sht up. Arhgap36 does not just effect the MC1R receptor. It is GTPase activator for the Rho-type GTPases. And there are a lot of them: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rho_family_of_GTPases https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rho_family_of_GTPases These polymorphisms not diminish GTP totally, it just lowers it.
- quantadev 2y agoIt's more clear to just say "There's no such thing as a gene for a trait", especially since the title of the article says the opposite, and is wrong. That's why I corrected it.
- benatkin 2y agoYou’re arguing semantics. It doesn’t make it more clear. The gene has been shown to have a causation or at least an interesting correlation in orange cat probability. That’s enough for it to say behind which is not very specific, likely chosen deliberately for that property.
- NoRagrets 2y agoSomewhat related: https://vgl.ucdavis.edu/species/cat https://vgl.ucdavis.edu/species/cat The Cat genetics lab at UC Davis has been cracking the feline code for many years now.
- astrange 2y agoWhat's the point of a genetics test for a coat pattern? Can't you just look at the cat? (Same question about covid/flu tests - a lot of people act like taking a test is part of a treatment regimen, but it kinda isn't. But those are still useful since you might be an asymptomatic spreader.)
- Etheryte 2y agoThe point is trying to understand how genetics works. Traits we can easily check for are easier to test against than say personality traits which are more subjective.
- astrange 2y agoA $60 customer genetics test doesn't seem like it's for educational purposes. https://vgl.ucdavis.edu/test/charcoal-pattern-bengals https://vgl.ucdavis.edu/test/charcoal-pattern-bengals
- catlikesshrimp 2y agoOne of the most visible features of a cat: its hair. Imagine a startup for cloning your cat, except you can change some features. It can start with hair color. After some rounds it might add size, eye color, hair or no hair, chubbiness. You name it. It may start in any BRICS country, and then expand! Tourist trips to cat cloning resorts. Check our CATLOG!
- pnutjam 2y agoThat's how we get Cheshire cats...
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- Sharlin 2y ago> cats with the mutation are not only healthy, but also cute. The latter of which being the likely reason that the trait has become so widespread in the artificial selection environment of the domestic cat population.
- TheSpiceIsLife 2y agoI understand your use of artificial in this context, However, it’s not like humans are en mass terminating the non-orange siblings, to the best of my knowledge.
- Brybry 2y agoBut we do en masse sterilize cats, including feral cats.
- hansonkd 2y ago> it’s not like humans are en mass terminating the non-orange siblings, Black cats for instance are disproportionately more likely to be euthanized: > According to the National Library of Medicine, of all cats in shelters, black cats have the highest rate of euthanasia at a rate of 74.6%, and the lowest rate of adoption at 10% of any cat. [1] Not to many breeders out there breeding black cats. Many people who feed feral cats want to feed the cute ones, so there is at least some bias towards propagating certain colors of cats. (This is one of the reasons I picked the black cat at the shelter and one of the best decisions I ever made. Such a kind and loving cat) [1] https://www.msj.edu/news/2024/02/the-power-of-black-cats.html#:~:text=According%20to%20the%20National%20Library,at%2010%25%20of%20any%20cat https://www.msj.edu/news/2024/02/the-power-of-black-cats.htm....
- tumsfestival 2y agoWhat the hell, my favorite cats are the black ones. Even my cat is black and I chose her from her litter specifically because of her color. Is this all because of stupid superstition?
- 2y ago
- yapyap 2y agodoes this also make them stupid?
- lenerdenator 2y agoKitteh is not stupid. Kitteh just doesn't care.
- waterpowder 2y agoThe (orange) cat has your pipe https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NAh9oLs67Cw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NAh9oLs67Cw
- RobRivera 2y agoThis has opened my 3rd eye, engaged a critical reassessment of how I choose to engage in this world, and left me asking myself how I can leave my mark on this world commensurate to the truth the pipe strip has enlightened my world
- runeks 2y agoI didn't even know we were looking for that gene
- dkarbayev 2y agoSounds like a solid candidate for Ig Nobel Prize award.
- lenerdenator 2y agoWhen you consider that most of human discovery eventually relates back to wanting to take care of cats, I'd say it's more Nobel worthy.
- FollowingTheDao 2y agoHa! Oh my, this is exactly what I am studying. MC1R is a G-Protein Coupled receptor (GOPCR) and the ARHGAP36 gene/enzyme is a GTPase activator for the Rho-type GTPases by converting them to an inactive GDP-bound state. Meaning it breaks down GTP (Guanosine Triphosphate is responsible for providing energy to the receptor.) If there is too little or too much GTP it will effect the sensitivity of the MC1 Receptor and will change the color of the hair accordingly. BTW, humans have these same genes so the same will apply to humans. I am studying these GPCRs and how they play a role in Mood and Chronic Illness like Long COVID and ME/CFS. Too little GTP and all of the 850+ G-Protein Coupled receptor will be effected. These include Serotonin, Dopamine, and Epinepherine Receptors. You can see the whole list of them here: https://www.guidetopharmacology.org/GRAC/ReceptorFamiliesForward?type=GPCR https://www.guidetopharmacology.org/GRAC/ReceptorFamiliesFor... I has an enzyme deficiency (PNP) that makes me have way too much GTP and it has me disabled but getting better after this discovery I made about Receptor Energy. I too much GTP also leads to grey hair. Also, GLP1 is a GPCR! This might have been the most serendipitous or God given thing for me to read today because I have been pretty suicidal and thinking I was wrong about my idea, but this literally is another piece I can put in my paper that proves that if the serotonin receptor does not have enough GTP, it does not matter how much serotonin you have, you will not get cellular activation via cAMP. Adding here that cats had more Arghap36 RNA in orange regions. More Arghap36 means less GTP. Less GTP means less energy for the MC1R receptor which means less black/brown pigment is produced.
- adinb 2y agoI volunteer as tribute! I’m a 2003 PwME who is second generation, and my son is diagnosed 3rd generation. And we have lateral transmission to my wife, somehow. My Dx. was by Dr. Nancy Klimas 2009 and had an extensive work up by the Mayo in 2010. Seriously, if there is anything I can do to assist your research, please let me know. (I’ll put contact in my profile)
- FollowingTheDao 2y agoYes! Please post your contact info!
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- fsckboy 2y agohumans share the vast majority of our genes with other mammals; are a cat's genes for fur the same genes humans have for body hair? does this orange gene for cats bear any resemblance to ginger genes in humans?
- aithrowawaycomm 2y agoNo, cats are a bit different from other mammals: In most mammals, including humans, red hair is caused by mutations in one cell surface protein, Mc1r, that determines whether skin cells called melanocytes produce a dark pigment or a lighter red-yellow pigment in skin or hair. Mutations that make Mc1r less active cause melanocytes to get “stuck” producing the light pigment. But the gene encoding Mc1r didn’t seem explain where cats’ orange fur came from. It isn’t located on the X chromosome in cats or any other species—and most orange cats don’t have Mc1r mutations. “It’s been a genetic mystery, a conundrum,” says Greg Barsh, a geneticist at Stanford University.
- relistan 2y agoIf you read the article this is explained, including how both mechanisms work.