4 ms·
The Surprising New History of Horse Domestication
- junior44660 2y ago> Such data show us that important cultural developments in the fourth millennium B.C.E.—including the Yamnaya migration and the dissemination of kurgans and Indo-European culture—probably took place many centuries before the first horses were domesticated I can't find the citations to this in the article. The tone of the article seems like this author has a particular schtick with the Yamnaya and / or the Indo Europeans. A lot of academia and journalists do this so not surprised.
- rbetts 2y agoHere's a paper by the author on the topic: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/355443578_The_origins_and_spread_of_domestic_horses_from_the_Western_Eurasian_steppes https://www.researchgate.net/publication/355443578_The_origi...
- cmrdporcupine 2y agoReading the abstract is a lot more pleasant than the article, which rambles. Sounds like the author is supporting a theory that horse-riding spread along with Indo-Iranian languages (Sintashta culture) rather than earlier. Which doesn't seem crazy to me. Horses were definitely livestock for a long time before that, kept for meat and dairy. They were very useful on the steppe because unlike cattle (which were imported from elsewhere), they can dig through snow to forage.
- aga98mtl 2y agoI do not understand how this article undermines the Kurgan Hypothesis. The modern horse enters the picture later according to those discoveries, but it is still within the right time frame and geographic location.
- cmrdporcupine 2y agoI think it's more that there's a more drastic/stricter version of the Kurgan hypothesis that sees Yamnaya migration + Horses + Indo-European language spread as all one packaged good, spreading in a rapid wave from the steppe. Whereas this author is arguing that the horse part happened later. We already know the cultural-linguistic spread was more complicated than Gimbutas' original theory. That's not really controversial.
- motohagiography 2y ago> In very short order, horses went from being a steppe curiosity to the foundation of authority for one of the largest civilizations of East Asia. I've got a pet theory about some western mythological tropes where horses are the economic and technological development that ties them together. the essential idea is that the young heroes mentored by centaurs (achillies and chiron, etc.) and "wisdom originating in the east," come from horse tribes from the steppes influencing proto-greek civilization, where centaurs came to represent those plainspeople in their mythology. as in central and east asia, by the result of being given empires, horsemanship was a channel for both evolutionary and divine assent, where if these other beings in nature favoured the people with the qualitites to ride them, then they were chosen to lead. horses became a force of evolutionary selection for us. it's basically an "ancient aliens" quality theory about horses, which I'm sure archeologists will love as much as they do the tv one, but horses are more than just a thread in our history, they are a force of it. relating to other beings in a complete cultural symbiosis like that seems like a key evolutionary achievement to unlock on the way to becoming starfaring, and if you have any background working with them, they are rare companion beings to us in the real of nature we inhabit. lunacy? perhaps, but experiencing the world with horses isn't just pony rides, it's an encompassing philosophical pursuit.
- marcosdumay 2y ago> relating to other beings in a complete cultural symbiosis like that Well, your theory is interesting. But let's not forget that dogs also exist. Also, most mammals seem to empathize with other mammal species. We are not that different on this.
- motohagiography 2y agosubordinating a predator is very different from getting the trust and willingness of a prey animal though. the other difference is that a horse is taught to overcome its instincts, particularly its flight instinct when we ride them into danger, and effectively we educate them, where a predator takes less finesse to manage.
- 2y ago
- MarkusQ 2y ago[flagged]
- rsynnott 2y ago... Eh? Unless the author is thousands of years old, the Kurgan Hypothesis is hardly likely to be a _political_ issue for them. (This kind of was politicised a bit in the 19th century, with German nationalists in particular being keen on the idea that Proto-Indo-European languages ultimately came from _Germany_, but no-one believes that anymore and none of the competing modern theories have the same sort of political weight to them.)
- cmrdporcupine 2y agoAnd this article doesn't even question that horses were domesticated in the Black Sea and Pontic Steppe, just that it happened later than Anthony postulated. There's no "political" angle here. GP commenter is out of line, and dragging culture wars crap in where it doesn't make any sense.
- cmrdporcupine 2y ago> none of the competing modern theories have the same sort of political weight to them Ho boy, wait until you go read about what Hindu nationalists have to say about this topic...
- rsynnott 2y agoOkay, fair, none of the competing modern theories which have any academic acceptance. Like, I don't think anyone _but_ Hindu nationalists go for the out-of-India thing.
- rd108 2y agoI don't think it's fair to dismiss the OIT hypothesis as a Hindu nationalist thing. I wrote some more about it in a comment on this article, but it actually just seems like the most likely explanation given the evidence. Arguing the archeology, genetics, and (grudgingly, it's barely a science) linguistics is totally fair but I'd like to see more open-minded debate on the data. The Mitanni (1500 BCE) and the Tarim Basin mummies partially Indian DNA are important points to address, but the Sarasvati river dating has to force a dramatic re-think of how Indo-European languages spread.
- alsetmusic 2y agoThe Fall of Civilizations podcast has just released a two-parter on the Mongols. I only just started the first ep, but anyone interested in this article might be interested in that. It’s a great show if you love history.
- s1artibartfast 2y agoNever could stand fall of civilizations. It just seems like an amateur that read through some Wikipedia articles. I much prefer alternative like Dan Carlin hardcore history or the rest of History
- FranzFerdiNaN 2y agoDan Carlin is the prime example of someone reading Wikipedia and a bunch of way too old books. He is an entertainer, not someone that can teach you about history.
- zwirbl 2y agoBut it is good entertainment, and his 'Blueprint for the Apocalypse' series, while not always accurate, does a good job conveying the gruesome reality of WW I warfare
- rd108 2y agoThis strengthens the Out-of-India hypothesis for Indo-European languages. The hardest evidence we have is the paleoarcheology of the Sarasvati river. The peak flow of the Sarasvati was 10,000 BCE - 3000 BCE. Tectonic shifts and climate change caused the river to dwindle from 2600 BCE - 1900 BCE. From ~1900 BCE on the river fully desiccated and no longer reached the Arabian Sea. We see hundreds of urban sites along the dried path of the ancient Sarasvati. For example, Bhirrana in northern India which has its earliest radiocarbon-dated layers at 7500 BCE. There is cultural continuity between the early IVC sites (7000 BCE) and later (3000 - 2000 BCE) sites. Now connect this with the vast corpus of Sanskrit works, particularly archaic Rig Vedic Sanskrit. We know the Sarasvati was described as perennial and large river reaching the sea in those works. Later Sanskrit texts like the Mahabharata, with language features implying hundreds or thousands of years of linguistic evolution, describe the river dwindling and eventually disappearing "underground". This means Rig Vedic Sanskrit was being used in parallel with the extremely large and advanced urban society in the Indus Valley Civilization (IVC), which was larger than Egypt and Mesopotamia combined, at least in 3000 BCE. The drying of the Sarasvati, which is known to have preceded vast migrations from the northwest Indian subcontinent to the northeast Gangetic plain, may have well forced climate-change migrants north into Central Asia, Mesopotamia and the steppes as well in the gradual lead-up to the Sarasvati's full collapse. The current idea that Indo-European language entered India ~1500 BCE is completely incorrect, and oddly there's been no attempt to re-formulate the Indo-European language origins theory to match the data.