6 ms·
Brits are scrolling away from X and aren't that interested in AI
- grues-dinner 2y agoSo the actual breaking news here is "Brits actually fairly normal after all"? Neither X nor AI is particularly relevant to the average person, British or not, unless they're terminally online and/or the kind of person to write unhinged nonsense on LinkedIn. Sure quite a few people might use ChatGPT or whatever sometimes, but they use Excel too and they're probably not especially "interested" in that either.
- ben_w 2y agoThe average person on AI: "Forty-three percent had used one for work" … "The numbers are slightly different for the under-16s. Fifty-four percent said they had used a GenAI tool, with more than half (53 percent) of those saying they had used it for schoolwork."
- jrflowers 2y agoThis makes sense. Since googling something now counts as “using a genai tool” everybody uses and cares about AI
- defnotai 2y agoSome people are being pressured by their management to use AI to increase efficiency in their jobs, with varying degrees of success. I have a friend who works in logistics for GE and they’re getting training on the basics of GenAI and then they have to go out and find ways to integrate it into their workflow. The problem is that management isn’t doing the legwork to understand how to integrate the tooling, they’re just handing that responsibility off to the actual users. Those people wind up complaining that taking time to integrate these tools winds up slowing them down and they struggle to find meaningful applications for the LLMs. It’s like management is saying “here’s a new hammer, we don’t know how to use it but the guy who sold it to us convinced us you can figure out how to use it. So go out and do it and be better and faster at your job, good luck”.
- silisili 2y agoI'm running into this now. Boss is all but mandating everyone use Cursor. I'm not anti-AI. I don't mind asking an LLM to write me some boilerplate. But I don't want to change my tooling, nor have an integrated assistant. My output is fine. I'll hold out as long as I can, but it feels like this may one day just become the reality.
- defnotai 2y agoHype cycles come and go, AI will be no different. The core technology may remain and advance, but the fever will break once reality sets in/and or prices continue to climb.
- scrps 2y agoGonna be fun to see the results of cases like "I didn't defraud the company, gen AI did!" Of which I suspect some will actually be fraud and some not but I don't envy the lawyer who has to explain neuronal computation to a nontechnical person.
- jdietrich 2y ago78% of people aged 16-24 had used a GenAI tool in the last year. That's a remarkable adoption rate IMO. We're talking about this technology as if it's the future, but it has already transformed secondary and post-secondary education beyond all recognition. https://www.ofcom.org.uk/siteassets/resources/documents/research-and-data/online-research/online-nation/2024/online-nation-2024-report.pdf?v=386238 https://www.ofcom.org.uk/siteassets/resources/documents/rese...
- ToucanLoucan 2y ago> 78% of people aged 16-24 had used a GenAI tool in the last year. That's a remarkable adoption rate IMO. We're talking about this technology as if it's the future, but it has already transformed secondary and post-secondary education beyond all recognition. Your wording choice there is excellent as "transforming" can either be extremely positive, or negative, or just different. Given how many students now, judging by various outcries on social media by teaching staff are borderline illiterate in middle school, it does make one wonder what the long term effects of this will be.
- jncfhnb 2y agoStandardized test scores were marginally improving for decades, although they tanked during Covid
- Gigachad 2y agoIt looks like the transformation is going to be that all marked work will be done on paper in class. Anything else is pointless since students just have all their work generated for them.
- tmnvix 2y ago> 78% of people aged 16-24 had used a GenAI tool in the last year. More interesting would be the percentage of people that have used GenAI in the past year with a purpose. I suspect a significant number have just played with it. Likely many didn't make it a habit, let alone ever do anything useful with it. It would be a bit of a stretch to say anyone in this group has 'adopted' AI.
- ToucanLoucan 2y ago> Forty-three percent had used one for work That's honestly pretty low considering the sheer number of products that now have AI integration. I honestly think a lot of the hype around AI taking over jobs is because the people who are spreading it are more likely working in some pretty dull coding environments where copilot can shine, because you just plain don't write a ton of interesting or otherwise off-the-beaten-path code, and that's what copilot excels at. And then those people have spare time at work to evangelize about this great technology. And before anybody starts with me, yes I have tried it. It's fine. A lot of what I work on isn't standardized or boilerplate enough to where copilot can really help me, and the situations where it can, I found the time I spent describing what I wanted, getting the answer back, copying it into my IDE and then customizing it as required was frankly just better spent writing it myself. Maybe it made me SLIGHTLY faster? But nothing approaching what I would suggest the term "coding AI" implies, and frankly, I enjoy writing the easier code on occasion because it's a nice break from the harder stuff that copilot can't touch. Like if you're a freelancer who jumps between gigs of refactoring ancient websites into something vaguely web 2.0, you would probably get a lot of mileage from copilot where you're just describing something as written (or hell, giving it the existing code) and asking for it to be rewritten. But if you're doing something novel, something that hasn't been posted on StackOverflow a thousand times, you will run into it's limitations quite quickly and, if you're like me anyway, resign it to the bin because fundamentally asking it to make something, finding out it can't, and then making it myself is FAR more annoying than just assuming it can't and moving on.
- 1oooqooq 2y agoeveryone who had to fill in pages of text for no particular reason they believe in, will use any means no matter how bad. this included teens doing homework, and everyone else filling job applications. same mindset. ai? sure. google search and adapting any template on the very first page? sure!
- weego 2y agoGetting Claude to extract numbers from the image of a spreadsheet someone inexplicably sent you instead of the actual spreadsheet is not the same as "being interested in AI"
- KTibow 2y agoFrom my experience most people who use anything other than ChatGPT/c.ai are somewhat interested in AI
- detourdog 2y agoI’m interested in ai but still haven’t used it. When I finally focus on it I will try kagi’s ai. I already subscribe to search.
- ben_w 2y ago> I’m interested in ai but still haven’t used it There's several free options, so what's stopping you?
- detourdog 2y agoHard to say. Here are a few things keeping Me from looking into it. I might feel so entrenched in my process that I can’t figure out where to start. The current crop of offerings only interest me from a self hosted point of view. I’m interested in an ai that is aligned with closely to my own world view. If there is a bias built in I would rather be generated by me. When this ai wave first started the story was it was so complex the origin of the answers was considered in unauditable. Which I took as deceptive or the pushers didn’t understand what they were doing. When I stated my interest it goes back to the ‘80s and I was playing with OpenCYC about 15 years ago. I keep saying I will take a look but other projects keep grabbing my interest.
- ben_w 2y agoI understand where you're coming from. Good news on a few of those points, but not all of them. > I might feel so entrenched in my process that I can’t figure out where to start. This is the easy one. You can just tell them that, in those words, with what you're up to, and they suggest stuff back in English. (And if you're not a native English speaker, use your native language and many will respond in that language instead of in English). > The current crop of offerings only interest me from a self hosted point of view. My experience with current self-hosted ones is… they're not worth bothering with. (But also, my machine is limited in the model size it can use locally, so this may not impact you so much). > I’m interested in an ai that is aligned with closely to my own world view. If there is a bias built in I would rather be generated by me. Good news here, but for what I consider to be bad reasons. They're often wildly sycophantic, so they'll often display whatever bias they "think" you have. > When this ai wave first started the story was it was so complex the origin of the answers was considered in unauditable. Which I took as deceptive or the pushers didn’t understand what they were doing. It's getting slightly better, but unfortunately the problem is mostly the "don't understand", there's too many different teams for me to feel it's deceptive. If you really need auditable results, I'd stay away from them too — they're definitely not in the vein of AI that CYC ever was.
- bdangubic 2y agothis might also be a demographic issue - I live in an afluent area and genai is woven already into everyday so much that it is already difficult to imagine life without it. just couple of example - my 11-year old kid does most if not all of her studying/research/… through genai. her class has a google doc where they share prompts they found useful for learning xyz… my kid asked me something last week and I said “no clue, google it” and her response was “google it??? thats funny dad…” my homeowners association used genai to go through years of transaction to create a budget etc…
- rsynnott 2y ago> my homeowners association used genai to go through years of transaction to create a budget etc… … Yikes. Hope they checked it afterwards. These things are quite bad at financial stuff; they’re good at producing something which looks superficially reasonable, but when you look closer, well, it’s all nonsense.
- bdangubic 2y agoI know, right?!
- tzs 2y ago> Neither X nor AI is particularly relevant to the average person, British or not, unless they're terminally online and/or the kind of person to write unhinged nonsense on LinkedIn. According to the article X reached 26 million UK adults in May 2022. That's half of the UK adult population.
- verzali 2y agoDown to 22.1 million now though, I think is the point. But honestly, twitter never forms much of the conversation outside of media types.
- valval 2y agoPeople would of course talk about the information found on the platform, not the platform itself.
- KeplerBoy 2y agoThat's a pretty meaningless figure without the methodology used to come up with it. It might just mean 26 million uk adults have heard of a tweet. Think covfefe, barely anyone read that tweet and yet it reached everyone.
- unsnap_biceps 2y ago> Ofcom measured X's adult reach I wonder if the same trend is happening for younger age groups as well. I was surprised at my two nephews scrolling X yesterday reading memes after dinner. They're 14 and 16 and I guess deeply in the "gamers" culture? They shared some of them with me and I wasn't into the edge-lord stuff, but they insist that it's just ironic usage. Much like every generation, I'm likely just not hip enough to understand the youth.
- moomin 2y agoI’m reminded of “I was a teenage edgelord” https://medium.com/@srhbutts/i-m-sarah-nyberg-and-i-was-a-teenage-edgelord-b8a460b27e10 https://medium.com/@srhbutts/i-m-sarah-nyberg-and-i-was-a-te...
- AlexandrB 2y agoIt's funny reading this nearly 10 year old post in 2024 and noticing that many of these tactics are now universal and some of the people mentioned (Ian Cheong) are still being called Nazis, but by people on the other side of the political divide.
- bitwize 2y agoTurns out that the author of that article was/is a pedophile, was using "but I was just being an edgelord/muh right-wing harassment" as a smokescreen to divert attention from her bad behavior, and (wisely) vanished from online after about 2017 when she couldn't whitewash her image anymore. https://medium.com/@srhbuttstruth/5-reasons-you-shouldn-t-stand-with-sarah-nyberg-797d84b07ce https://medium.com/@srhbuttstruth/5-reasons-you-shouldn-t-st...
- valar_m 2y agoYou believe that an anonymously written article full of baseless speculation that relies on an anonymous Tumblr post as its source is credible? It would benefit you to educate yourself on how to evaluate the reliability of claims you read online. Here's a tip to help you get started: anonymously written online posts that rely on other anonymous posts should be considered with a very high degree of scrutiny.
- ChocolateGod 2y agoDespite being a Brit, X did nothing but keep my feed flooded with both left and right wing comment about the American election recently, with some extreme views on either side. For context I only follow tech accounts.
- philjohn 2y agoYes - it wasn't always like that, but it would be interesting to see the "algorithm" now, wasn't Elon all about opening that stuff up?
- valval 2y agoYes, you can find the blog post and repo through a quick search.
- philjohn 2y agoIt's not been updated in over a year. It was a ruse: https://github.com/twitter/the-algorithm https://github.com/twitter/the-algorithm
- dom96 2y agoThe algorithm repo hasn't been updated in more than a year. Who knows if it was ever even the real algorithm, but it certainly isn't now unless you believe that they haven't updated it in a year.
- nobodywillobsrv 2y agoThis seems like RICU propaganda
- retrac98 2y agoPure opinion, but I feel like the UK has a strong cultural bias towards doing things the way they’ve always been done, which can make us a bit resistant to new technologies and ways of doing things.
- ben_w 2y agoBased on my experience growing up in the UK, then having long visits to the US and moving to Germany… the UK overall is fairly open minded to new tech and social change. Well, so long as the monarchy and the castles remain.
- ethernot 2y agoI don't think we're resistant, just hesitant pragmatists. When something new and shiny turns up, we don't necessarily accept the marketing saying it's going to improve our lives. Best to wait for someone else to get through the early adoption pain and work out all the kinks so we don't have to waste our time on it if it turns out to be a lemon. With this strategy I entirely missed blockchain, crypto and NFTs and am in the process of missing AI.
- antirez 2y agoTo think that AI is as irrelevant as blockchain, crypto and NFTs is a tragical error many are committing, sir. Those things were trivial and useless and it was clear since the start, and even if tons of money and marketing were put inside, nothing changed because of the blockchain, at least nothing useful. AI is a completely different story: you likely not even realize you are already a heavy user just as a side effect of everything technological you use, from voice dictation, to medical, to all the images you see around. Soon also: when you are going to watch a movie. Moreover LLMs are already transforming the way people work. These two entities, blockchian and AI, have very little in common if not the hype.
- ChocolateGod 2y agoAI and Crypto both use extraordinary amounts of electricity but at least AI actually does something and has replaced Google for me in at least 50% of searches.
- moomin 2y agoI’m honestly surprised at how small the drop is, because it feels like I no longer know anyone who’s using it. Haven’t heard a conversation with involving something someone read there in forever. Hear about reddit all the time.
- awinter-py 2y agofeels like OSS early adopter folks have been trying to leave for years, legal + media people moved to bsky this month and are starting to close their twitter accounts, younger VC / founder type people are trying to stick it out some of the oss + scifi author crowd has been making it work on mastodon but may come to bsky. (think like charlie stross) celeb + sports accounts are joining bsky now post-election, and in theory a bunch of users that will jump with them; insta/threads may still win this slice though rn on bsky there's an early twitter dynamic of like mark hammill following tech journalists
- TheBlight 2y ago>rn on bsky there's an early twitter dynamic of like mark hammill following tech journalists Lmao
- moomin 2y agoI suspect that bsky will have very Twitter like problems as it scales. Still might check it out before that happens.
- awinter-py 2y agoyeah, there's a theory of social networks that you have to move to new ones as they age I think twitter aged artificially fast after it stopped investing in moderation and also shut off external researchers' access to the firehose (they were helping discover bad actor networks) bsky seems more open to integrations at this point; like w/ subreddits, ownership of communities by those communities makes maintenance cheaper
- rsynnott 2y ago
- Havoc 2y agoBecause it's a dumpster fire of shrill partisan US politics. I'm following only SF/hn flavoured tech crowd on there - the thinking being that it'll be about tech. An intentional attempt to buy into a bubble if you will. That used to work well. Since musk take-over and the current election cycle even that is intolerable. Tech gang no longer tweet about kubernetes etc, instead it's about immigrant, Joe Rogan and whatever has Marc Andreessen's knickers in a twist today.
- cgh 2y agoBluesky awaits your arrival. Unfortunately, there's a lot of the creepy anime avatar crowd there already but luckily the nuclear block exists on that platform.
- toenail 2y agoYou chose who you follow, and you can block any words you like. I see basically zero politics.
- jarjoura 2y agoAndreessen and Co. have always been part of this strange utopian Libertarianism where they believe with all their hearts, that tech sets you free. I say the word strange, because it's optimistic, and forward looking, and not cynical. Peter Thiel used to be the main "villain" while the others kept to themselves. Seems that's not the case anymore, and they are more comfortable speaking their minds. Realistically though, as an outsider, I think X.com has just become their echo chamber and they've all lost the plot.
- Gigachad 2y agoBefore leaving Twitter, my feed was almost entirely American politics, street fight videos, and content farm bots. Yet I only followed Australian artists and Australian furries. I watched someone else scroll Twitter and they had the exact same slop posts on their feed. Now I’ve switched to Bluesky and my feed is immensely better.
- grahamj 2y agoHopefully everyone is getting away from X
- ipaddr 2y agoThere is a bluesky doomscroll waiting for you in the new echo chamber.
- jarjoura 2y agoThis is the right answer, sadly. I had moved over to Mastodon and already people are using it to raise pitchforks. I just don't think our human brains deserve the power that comes with social media.
- grahamj 2y agoThere are only three ways to avoid being in an echo chamber: - Use a system that allows you to choose your sources and choose to follow a diverse set of content - Use a system that does not allow such choice and trust that its algorithm supplies a diverse set of content - Don't use social media I happen to choose the last one, but between the other two I believe user choice is more important. Musk has put his right wing thumb firmly on X's scale so that rules it out imo. Anywhere that respects your choices is only an echo chamber if you make it one.
- racl101 2y agoTwitter was cool about a couple of years. I haven't tweeted since like 2012. I'm not in a hurry to jump on Blue Sky.
- jarjoura 2y agoBest Twitter, was when it was just tweets of "eating cereal for breakfast" and the pull-to-refresh-ification of everything.
- Jedd 2y agoSample size was ~7300 people, polling done in May / June 2024. Looks like various breakdowns of cohorts by age - in one section there's 7 groups. A thousand people per group is respectable, but OTOH each responder's answers are being extrapolated to assume the behaviour of ~10,000 people.
- piva00 2y agoIf my rusty skills in sample calculation are correct, 7300 surveys could be enough for a 98% confidence with 1,5% error margin. Someone please correct me if I'm wrong but I think the sample size of 7300 should be enough for UK's population.
- mirekrusin 2y agoDepends where it’s taken - online survey will be biased, ai meet-ups responders - extremely so etc.
- philipwhiuk 2y ago> Wave 6 of the Online Experiences Tracker was conducted among a nationally representative sample of 7,280 UK internet users aged between 13 and 84. Fieldwork was conducted over a ten-day period between 23rd May and 8th June 2024. The data has been weighted to be representative of the UK internet user population on age within gender, and overall, to regional and SEG profiles.
- mirekrusin 2y agoThis always bothered me – internet users 100%, having time and will to take survey 100% – it will always be very biased sample that can't be corrected by weighting by age/gender etc.
- ada1981 2y agoThey weren’t that into democracy either. Didn’t stop the Yanks from mopping the floor with them.
- philipwhiuk 2y agoLosing the US colony was a minor inconvenience. We were busy with France. I get that it's important to you, but US independence barely features in our history lessons.
- markhahn 2y agoonly Brits? the set of people interested in AI seems to be quite specific: techno-optimists, fad-seeking "entrepreneurs", people who can get with low-quality outputs.
- philipwhiuk 2y agoYes because it was a survey of by a British regulatory body, the Office of Communications aka Ofcom.
- EasyMark 2y agoThere’s a lot of that on twitter for sure
- rsynnott 2y agoI mean, really, is anyone all that interested in generative AI, barring VCs?
- muthuh 2y agoHear, hear! :)
- aussieguy1234 2y agoFor anyone looking for a good alternative to Toxic Twitter/X, I can't recommend BlueSky enough. I signed up and it's a breath of fresh air without the artificially promoted toxic posts showing up in my feed.
- MegaDeKay 2y agoIndeed. And I'm finding a lot of people that I used to follow on Twitter are now on BSky as well. My feed is not nearly as sparse as I thought it would be.
- philipwhiuk 2y agoOnly because it's small and still burning VC money. The algorithm will come once they need to pay the bills.
- tomlockwood 2y agoAnd then we'll move to the Next VC one! Huzzah!
- tokioyoyo 2y agoEh, if they burn VC money for another 10 years, who cares? There's another one that will pop up, and we'll continue the ride.
- Gigachad 2y agoBluesky is the most refreshing thing I’ve seen on the internet for a long time. The feed actually shows stuff based on my followers rather than just rage bait and another countries politics.
- 0xDEAFBEAD 2y agoI'm pretty disappointed with the rise of reddit. In my opinion, it has a very serious confirmation bias problem.
- 01jonny01 2y agoThere is a lot of resistance to change in the UK. So many businesses and public sector jobs depend on legacy processes that can be automated away, but are not. There are many reasons for this, the main being older generations tend to take up senior positions and have yet to grasp the full potential of the tech. This particularly applies to private indistry. For the public sector the goverment is so intertwined with them that they are too scared to rock the boat and loose votes or risk strikes so they ignore the elephant in the room. Finally, I would say the British culture is one of skepticism, bordering on cynicism we don't like to see winners win, like the US. There is virtue in being above competition and we secretley sneer at people who want to strive for better, so it doesn't surprise that some people would instantly dismiss the potential of AI if a colleague suggested it to them.