8 ms·
The Influence of Bell Labs
- kranke155 2y agoJust reading the book The Idea Factory, it was incredible amount of innovation. Lasers, early satellites, transistors. And it was all done, apparently, at least in the beginning, because they hired smart people and they let them do what they wanted.
- fuzztester 2y agounix, c and c++ too.
- kranke155 2y agoHaven't gotten to that part of the book.
- Lyngbakr 2y agoThey don't cover it in the book, unfortunately. A serious omission, in my eyes.
- jhbadger 2y agoAnd S, the statistical data language that was the ancestor of S-PLUS and R.
- fuzztester 2y agodid not know about that, thank you.
- ioblomov 2y agoAll true, but monopoly profits sure help.
- l33t7332273 2y agoAs do high corporate tax rates
- rmorey 2y agoI know the author, Jon. Delightful guy
- toast0 2y agoAlmost all of the things I can think of that came from bell labs are things that helped their business. The only thing that I don't know how it helped their business was Hemo the Magnificent and similar films; but I'm sure those helped with PR. Monopoly may have helped them pay for such r&d, but vertical integration is what made it possible for so much r&d to be relevant to the business.
- kranke155 2y agoI think it ended up helping their business because they deliberately made it so later, but it’s not clear how some inventions would help their business in advance. From the book there was quite a few things that sat on the shelf for years until someone figured out a way to use them later.
- Aloha 2y agoThe research done at Bell Labs is the foundation of the information age, however, Bell Labs sowed the seeds that made the post-divestiture AT&T a doomed enterprise from the start - there is a reason they only lasted ~20 years from divestiture 'til they were bought by one of their former children, SBC. AT&T provided for most of its history, the best quality telephone service in the world, at a comparable price to anyone else, anywhere. There were structural issues with the AT&T monopoly however, for example cross subsidization - the true cost of services was often hidden because they would use optional services (like toll calling) to subsidize basic access, and business lines would cross subsidize residential service. The level that AT&T fought foreign connections (aka, bring your own phone), probably hastened their demise, in the end, the very technologies that AT&T introduced would turn long distance from a high margin, to low margin business - the brass at AT&T had to know that, but they still pinned the future of their manufacturing business on that - a manufacturing business that had never had to work in a competitive environment, yet was now expected to - because of this and other factors divestiture was doomed to failure. I'm a believer in utilities being a natural monopoly, but AT&T was an example of effective regulatory capture, it did not, and does not have to be this way, however it was.
- mixdup 2y agoEventually the cable guys were coming for AT&T's lunch, regardless of what happened with their monopoly. It's the rare circumstance where two seemingly unrelated utilities converged into the same business (moving bits, instead of analog video or audio) and we lucked into having two internet facilities in large portions of the country
- Aloha 2y agoLocal Access is a very different issue, and I dont really disagree - but the local copper loop being broadband is an accident and one of technological evolution. When the decisions were made about divesiture, that bit was non obvious.
- phtrivier 2y agoOkay, I'm really in a sad mood, so: tell me there will be places like that, again, somewhere, ever ? We need this. Like, really, we need someone to have created the xerox part of the 21st century, somewhere about 20 years ago. I honestly though Google would be that - but apparently it's easier to fund R&D on "selling copying machines" than "selling ads". Maybe "selling ads" earn _too much_ money ? I don't know. I know, I know, DeepMind and OpenAI and xAI are supposed to fix climate change any time soon, and cure cancer while they invent cold fusion etc, etc... and it's only because I'm a pessimistic myopist that I can only see them writing fake essays and generating spam, bad me. Still. Assuming I'm really grumpy and want to talk about people doing research that affects the physical world in positive way - who's doing that on the scale of PARC or Bell ?
- querez 2y ago> honestly though Google would be that - but apparently it's easier to fund R&D on "selling copying machines" than "selling ads". Maybe "selling ads" earn _too much_ money ? I don't know. I'm pretty sure Google Brain was exactly what you are looking for: People like to think of DeepMind, but honestly, Brain pretty much had Bell Labs/PARCs strategy: they hired a bunch of brilliant people and told them to just "research whatever is you think is cool". And think all the AI innovations that came out of Brain and were given to the world for free: Transformers, Vision Transformers, Diffusion Models, BERT (I'd consider that the first public LLM), Adam, and a gazillion of other cool stuff I can't think of right now.... Essentially, all of the current AI/LLM craze started at Brain.
- phtrivier 2y agoRight. And I'm sure that if I ever get in a better mood, I'll find that the current AI/LLM craze is good for _something_. Right now the world needs GWh batteries made of salt, cheap fusion from trash, telepathy, a cure for cancer and a vaccine for the common cold - but in the meantime, advertisers can generate photos for their ads, which is, _good_, I guess ?
- aatd86 2y ago
- linguae 2y agoDuring my teenage and college years in the 2000s, I was inspired by what I’ve read about Bell Labs, and I wanted to work as a computer science researcher in industry. I’ve also been inspired by Xerox PARC’s 1970s and 1980s researchers. I pursued that goal, and I’ve worked for a few industrial research labs before I switched careers to full-time community college teaching a few months ago. One thing I lament is the decline of long-term, unfettered research across the industry. I’ve witnessed more companies switching to research management models where management exerts more control over the research directions of their employees, where research directions can abruptly change due to management decisions, and where there is an increased focus on profitability. I feel this short-term approach will cost society in the long term, since current funding models promote evolutionary work rather than riskier, potentially revolutionary work. As someone who wanted to become a researcher out of curiosity and exploration, I feel alienated in this world where industry researchers are harangued about “delivering value,” and where academic researchers are pressured to raise grant money and to publish. I quit and switched to a full teaching career at a community college. I enjoy teaching, and while I miss the day-to-day lifestyle of research, I still plan to do research during my summer and winter breaks out of curiosity and not for career advancement. It would be great if there were more opportunities for researchers to pursue their interests. Sadly, though, barring a cultural change, the only avenues I see for curiosity-driven researchers are becoming independently wealthy, living like a monk, or finding a job with ample free time. I’m fortunate to have the latter situation where I have 16 weeks per year that I could devote outside my job.
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 2y agoThe truth is that kind of research can only happen with a very rich monopoly. Bell labs came about when AT&T was the monopoly telephone provider in the US. PARC happened when Xerox had a very lucrative monopoly on copy machines.
- linguae 2y agoI have come to realize that over the years, though I still believe that wealthier companies like Apple, NVIDIA, Facebook, and the like could fund curiosity-driven research, even if it’s not at the scale of Bell Labs or Xerox PARC. On a smaller scale, there is The Institute for Advanced Study where curiosity-driven research is encouraged, and there is the MacArthur Fellowship where fellows are granted $150,000 annual stipends for five years for them to pursue their visions with no strings attached. Other than these, though, I’m unaware of any other institutions or grants that truly promote curiosity-driven research. I’ve resigned myself to the situation and have thus switched careers to teaching, where at least I have 4 months of the year “off the clock” instead of the standard 3-4 weeks of PTO most companies give in America.
- rfmoz 2y agoInline with this, the talk from Richard Hamming "You and Your Research" (June 6, 1995) https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=a1zDuOPkMSw https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=a1zDuOPkMSw
- Swizec 2y agoEveryone wants Bell Labs, but not the thing that made it possible — high corporate profit taxes. They were making bucket loads of monopoly money and had to put it somewhere or taxes would it away.
- thrance 2y agoYes, disincentivize dividends and buybacks, reincentivize investments, R&D and others.
- refurb 2y agoThat makes no sense. Dividents and buybacks are both taxed.
- dartos 2y agoI think a lot of people want high corporate profit taxes
- fsckboy 2y agopeople own corporations. If you tax the income of people who own corporations, it's not necessarily necessary to tax corporations; just pass their profits through to the people and tax the people. There are good reasons not to double-tax, first at the corporate level and then again at the personal level.
- callc 2y agoCorporations are apparently people too! They should be taxed like any other flesh and blood human! I really want gov around the world to take back governance to be solely for the benefit of people. None of this greedy corruption lobbyist stuff.
- miohtama 2y agoThis is similar to the perverse incentive of share buybacks. It's just more tax efficient to pump stock value than pay proper dividends.
- leoc 2y agoPasting my comment on the article https://www.construction-physics.com/p/what-would-it-take-to-recreate-bell/comment/79404212 https://www.construction-physics.com/p/what-would-it-take-to... : > RCA Laboratories/the Sarnoff Research Center is surely one of the most important of the American corporate labs with similarities to Bell Labs. (It features prominently in Bob Johnstone's We Were Burning https://www.hachettebookgroup.com/titles/bob-johnstone/we-were-burning/9780465091188 https://www.hachettebookgroup.com/titles/bob-johnstone/we-we... : it has a big role in the history of the Japanese semiconductor industry, in large part because of its roles in the development of the transistor and the LCD and its thirst for patent-licensing money.) >> In Dealers of Lightning, Michael Hiltzik argues that by the 1990s PARC was no longer engaged in such unrestricted research decoupled from product development. > According to Hiltzik and most other sources, the PARC Computer Science Lab's salad days were over as early as 1983, when Bob Taylor was forced to leave, while the work of the other PARC labs focussed on physics and materials science wasn't as notable in the period up to then. Seriously: if this kind of thing interests you at all, go and read We Were Burning.
- paulpauper 2y agoI think the mythos of the Bell labs and other thinktanks of the Cold War era is overstated to some extent. https://greyenlightenment.com/2024/07/19/the-decline-of-cold-war-era-genius-collectives-and-the-rise-of-human-capital/ https://greyenlightenment.com/2024/07/19/the-decline-of-cold... These organizations employed too many people of relatively mediocre ability relative to output, leading to waste and eventual disbandment. Today's private sector companies in FAMNG+ are making bigger breakthroughs in AI, apps, self-driving cars, etc. with fewer people relative to population and more profits. This is due to more selective hiring and performance metrics. Yeah those people form the 60s were smart, but today's STEM whiz kids are probably lapping them.
- cfraenkel 2y agoOff the top of my head: Shannon, Nyquist, Hamming. Lapping them you say.
- ggm 2y agoI think my reading of your comment is: that's just wrong. And I tend to agree. The current STEM and FAANG activity is second order work in the main. I wouldn't hold AI work up as a paragon, myself. It's diverting from progress across a field. I have hopes of a resurgence of operations research and linear optimisation as goods in themselves: we could be plotting more nuanced courses in dark waters of competing pressure. Decision systems support across many fields would remove subjective, politicised pressures.
- l33t7332273 2y agoDo you think there is room for a resurgence in linear optimization? Linear programming, and even integer linear programming are pretty well solved practically speaking.
- ggm 2y agoI tried using some online systems to help formulate weighted sum decisions over unrankable choices and it's bloody hard work getting people on board. I think how the logic presents could improve. This stuff while old, is not routine for decision makers. They don't seem to grok how to formulate the questions and the choices.
- OldGuyInTheClub 2y agoImpostor syndrome was real at that joint!
- jpmattia 2y ago> and the other co-inventor of the integrated circuit was Fairchild Semiconductor, which as far as I can tell didn’t operate anything like a basic research lab. Kind of a strange statement. Fairchild took the "traitorous eight" from Shockley Semiconductor, which was founded by William Shockley, who famously co-invented the transistor at Bell Labs (and who named the "traitorous eight" as such.) So while Fairchild "didn’t operate anything like a basic research lab", its co-invention of the IC was not unrelated to having a large amount of DNA from Bell Labs.
- inside_story 2y agoNew Jersey back to this when!?
- teleforce 2y agoIf you want to understand and appreciate Bell Labs innovation eco-system from first hand account and perspective of its researcher while at the same time learning to perform research based innovations, please check this book written by one of its celebrated researchers Richard Hamming [1]. [1] The Art of Doing Science and Engineering: https://press.stripe.com/the-art-of-doing-science-and-engineering https://press.stripe.com/the-art-of-doing-science-and-engine...
- dredmorbius 2y agoWhat were the other major R&D labs, corporate or otherwise of this era (roughly: 1880s through 1980s)? I can think of: AT&T, DuPont, Kodak, Xerox PARC, Westinghouse, IBM, GE, the original Edison labs (best as I can tell acquired by Western Union), Microsoft, Rockefeller University, Google Research. Of notable industries and sectors, there's little I can think of in automobile, shipping, aircraft and aviation (though much is conducted through Nasa and military), railroads, steel (or other metals/mining), petroleum, textiles, or fianance. There's also the Manhattan Project and energy labs (which conduct both general energy research and of course much weapons development). (I've asked similar questions before, see e.g., <https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41004023 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41004023>.) I'd like to poke at this question in a number of areas: what developments did occur, what limitations existed, where private-sector or public / government / academic research were more successful, and what conditions lead to both rise and fall of such institutions.
- anthk 2y agoMIT's AI Lab with Lisp, ITS and such. They were far ahead of Unix, Bell Labs and Berkeley.
- dredmorbius 2y agoWhich suggests SAIL (Stanford) and early Internet collaboration (UCLA, UCSB, and others). Various advanced computer facilities: UCSD, University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign. Probably others at Carnegie-Mellon, Georgia Tech, and elsewhere.
- casey2 2y agoPeople always say "oh if you had this or that system we would be so much more innovative", but it's all wishy-washy unprovable statements pulled from 3rd hand sources. If you distill the problem down to it's essentials you are asking "how do I design (human in the loop) AGI", and until you can write a program for it, it will remain an artform, and the success or failure of art depends entirly on it's cultural context. Rather than p(r)aying for the smartest people who have ever been born, design a corporation that can have the average high school dropout work in R&D and you will print money, innovation and goodwill.
- ryukoposting 2y agoI'm a bit surprised that RCA's research division didn't get a nod here. They came up with color TV, then did basically nothing of note for a good 25 years. They're a big part of the reason why RCA is nothing more than a label slapped on imported slop nowadays.
- sourcepluck 2y agoBell Labs is wonderful to read about, and I've really loved delving into it. Alan Kay's talks in particular. However, it should be seen as a starting point! Alternative hypothetical pasts and futures abound. One issue is that the stuff from the past always looks more legendary seen through the lens of nostalgia; it's much harder to look at the stuff around you and to go through the effort of really imagining the thing existing. So that's my hypothesis - there isn't a smaller volume of interesting stuff going on, but viewing it with hope and curiosity might be a tad harder now, when everyone is so "worldy" (i.e., jaded and pessimistic). Proof: https://worrydream.com/ https://worrydream.com/ (brett victor) and the other people doing dynamicland and realtalk, both discussed straightforwardly here: https://dynamicland.org/2024/FAQ/ https://dynamicland.org/2024/FAQ/ https://solidproject.org/about https://solidproject.org/about -- solid, tim berners-lee and co, also. https://malleable.systems/catalog/ https://malleable.systems/catalog/ -- a great many of the projects here are in the same spirit, to me, as well! https://spritely.institute/ https://spritely.institute/ -- spritely, too https://duskos.org/ https://duskos.org/ -- duskOS, from Virgil Dupras https://100r.co/site/uxn.html https://100r.co/site/uxn.html -- 100 rabbits, uxn, vibrating with new ideas and aesthetics https://qutech.nl/ https://qutech.nl/ -- quantum research institute in the netherlands, they recently established a network link for the first time I believe etc etc. These are off the top of my head, and I'm fairly new to the whole space!
- nmcost 2y agoIt's coincidental that this article has reached the front page today. I just picked up The Idea Factory: Bell Labs and the Great Age of American Innovation by Jon Gartner. (I'll let you know how it is when I finish) One thing to consider is that Bell Labs didn't innovate for altruistic reasons like furthering the human race or scientific understanding. They innovated to further AT&T's monopoly and to increase shareholder value. This doesn't seem that different than what Meta, Google, NVIDIA, etc. are doing. Maybe in 10-20-30 years we will view the research that modern tech companies are doing through the same lens. Although, I do admit that the freedom with which these scientists and engineers were able to conduct research is something special. Maybe that's the real difference here.
- redbeanmochibun 2y agoIsaac Morgan is an unsung hero from those ages, man I miss working for that man
- dredmorbius 2y agoDeets? Share the why, not (just) the what.
- newsclues 2y agoWhat was the influence of the manhattan project on bell labs?
- Hilift 2y ago"Unpacking the reasons for this increase goes beyond the extent of this essay, and it certainly wasn’t just because of AT&T and Bell Labs. But Bell Labs’ achievements, particularly the invention of the transistor in 1947, seem to have prompted the decisions of many companies to start their own R&D labs, and influenced how those labs were structured." 1947 was a magical year. That announcement had profound implications. They effectively invented something that would replace the huge existing base of vacuum tube components with miniaturized transistors. This miniaturization phase significantly influenced Von Nuemann's recommendation for the ballistic missile program. Many of the discrete component systems manufactured during this time remained in service into the 1980's. This is a photo of a D-17B guidance computer that deployed on the Minuteman Missile in 1962, 15 years after creating the transistor, and was typical of military printed circuitry at the time for general purpose computers, disk/drum storage drives, and printers. https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/3/38/Autonetics_D-17.JPG https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/3/38/Autoneti... "The D-17B weighed approximately 62 pounds (28 kg), contained 1,521 transistors, 6,282 diodes, 1,116 capacitors, and 5094 resistors. These components were mounted on double copper-clad, engraved, gold-plated, glass fiber laminate circuit boards. There were 75 of these circuit boards and each one was coated with a flexible polyurethane compound for moisture and vibration protection."
- bastloing 2y agoOnce Facebook and tiktok got invented that was pretty much it for big new discoveries. Everybody now just posting crap and eating Cheetos.
- mathgladiator 2y agoMy dream was to do research, but I didn't see academics as happy people. Instead, I had a great career, and now I mess around on my own programming language. Maybe it will become something, may it will not. Life is a mystery. It has been fun spending a few years building my vision ( https://www.adama-platform.com/ https://www.adama-platform.com/ ), but it's hard to communicate it all. I've come to the conclusion, the real magic that makes Research work is having a place where people can collaborate and work together in a shared culture. At this point, I don't want to hire people into my endeavor, and I can't seem to find a co-founder to do commercialization right.