5 ms·
Javier Milei: "My contempt for the state is infinite"
- bediger4000 2y agoDupe: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42267248 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42267248 It's also paywalled, but riffing on the headline: why is your contempt for the state different than mine? "Intellectual Property" must be enforced by the state, no single entity can stop all thefts of "Intellectual Property". I personally find copyright limitations far more of a problem than the Pure Food and Drug Act, or the Voting Rights Acts, or Affordable Care Act. Can I defy the state on issues of "Intellectual Property" and count on your support? If not, why not?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- never_inline 2y agoAverage Haskell programmer.
- CrimsonCape 2y agoThe state is essentially the Java monolith, and a Haskell programmer is never going to convince the maintainers to rewrite the monolith; garbage collection is the best they can do.
- marcosdumay 2y agoNot to detract from the joke, but The Haskell Way is that state should be restricted and made explicit, not destroyed. Milei's discourse is about destroying the State. Even though the Argentinian institutions have been stable enough to stop him and force him into the "restrict and make explicit" mode instead.
- seydor 2y agoArgentina has a population pyramid that actually looks like a pyramid hence why they could elect such a radical change of route. In this decade europe , east asia and even the US might be confronted with the issue of sustaining societies without a lot of capital or investment or workers. I wonder if they will take a page from Argentina (the US already did)
- hackernewds 2y agocountries are not taking a page from Argentina. countries are taking a page from the United States electing someone like Donald Trump. https://www.scienceofrunning.com/2017/05/the-roger-bannister-effect-the-myth-of-the-psychological-breakthrough.html https://www.scienceofrunning.com/2017/05/the-roger-bannister... the Roger Bannister effect
- seydor 2y agoTrump's priority in 2016 was not deregulation, in 2024 it is. Hmm.
- slopeloaf 2y agoThis feels like an oversimplification of their priorities. Many right wing politicians are pro-deregulation. Trump also ran /did act on deregulation (or weakening) of certain agencies in his first term as well. I think it’s moreso during hard economic times. Telling constituents youre going to “axe wasteful government spending” is a very viable strategy for winning elections.
- derektank 2y agoIf Trump were taking notes from Milei, he wouldn't be looking to raise tariffs https://x.com/LibertarianDuty/status/1855530065922023888 https://x.com/LibertarianDuty/status/1855530065922023888
- tim333 2y agoThe first buddy Musk seems much more interested than Trump is.
- djoldman 2y agohttps://archive.ph/lpNox https://archive.ph/lpNox
- wslh 2y agoBeyond the traditional dichotomy of right and left, it's always insightful to contrast real politics and media narratives with reality. Javier Milei is introducing several changes in Argentina, but it will take time to assess their effectiveness. As of now, some key issues remain: - The USD/ARS exchange rate is still tightly controlled by the state, which is neither libertarian nor liberal in practice. - There are no significant incentives for exports. Only imports. - Many Argentinian unicorns and startups are incorporated abroad (e.g., in the US) and show no intention of returning. Moreover, Milei has proposed appointing a highly corrupt judge, Ariel Lijo, to the Supreme Court [1]. On a smaller scale, when my offices in Argentina needed to import three laptops for software engineers, the shipment was blocked due to the mail courier limit of USD 1,000. This cap is now being raised to USD 3,000, but such constraints highlight the ongoing barriers to conducting business. [1] https://es.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ariel_Lijo https://es.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ariel_Lijo
- fifteen1506 2y agoYou don't understand, he's not corrupt, he is misunderstood, otherwise Milei wouldn't be proposing him.
- luzojeda 2y agoMy two cents even tho I'm afraid this thread might become a political battleground: I'm from Argentina and 30 years old, of course he led us to a recession but for the first time in my adult life I can keep prices in my head and I know next month they'll be pretty much the same. Some people who never experienced +10% inflation in a month can't even imagine that and I understand it. I for one like this stability, dunno. Regarding your second paragraph, I work for a US company as well and I've been dealing with the mess that is just getting your hard earned money here. Only few people are aware that we still are mandated to change our dollars for pesos at the rate that the government says. Of course nowadays it's not that bad because that rate is almost the same as the one you get in the famous "cuevas", the black market exchange places. But in 2022-2023 sometimes the difference between those two were almost 100%. So you had to deal with tons and tons of cash, it was a nightmare.
- 2y ago
- Muromec 2y agoI'm as anarhist as any other wanna be erlang developer, but it's odd to see Trump mentioned in the context of taming Leviathan, when he promises to use military to deport millions of people out of the country under martial law kind of regime. I guess one persons libertarian hero is another persons statist opressor. I would not care less if not the military to use for taming the Leviathan wasn't biggest in the world and literally is in the business of exporting money for the whole world to use.
- rayiner 2y ago[flagged]
- orwin 2y ago> virtually all Africans [...] have a fundamentally paternalistic view of the state Yeah, no, clearly not. Go in Western Sahara, visit touaregs, ask them about states and what they think of them. Go in eastern Africa, talk to them about libertarianism (Kenya, Zambia, Mozambique). In Ethiopia, you'll probably find the highest concentration of libertarians in the world, they call themselves "Horn Anarchists" i think. Maybe what you're saying is true for colonized Africa, or at least for the part of africa that was left in power once Europeans left, but you just have to look at what is happening in south Congo to understand that some states in Africa are so weak they might as well dont exist. And most state have communes that escape them, due to tribal identity (you've heard of native Mexican tribes that oppose and resist Cartels since the 80s? think how it would go for weaker organization like some African states to go after them. Yeah, not well.). Africa is huge man, i'm pretty sure i have a different view of it than you since the only African i know are from anarchist/libertarian orgs, and that's a _very_ limiting lens.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- rayiner 2y agoThat’s a fair point, but what percentage of the population of Africa does that encompass? Where I’m from, the people have been under the boot of empires for 2,000 years. I’m sure there are plenty of individual Asians who are libertarians. But any system that allowed free immigration from Asia would import a population where 99% are going to be statists. To juxtapose my experience with yours: I don’t hang out in libertarian organizations. But I am Asian and know lots of Asians, and I know a fair number of Africans and middle easterners because of my dad’s social circle in international development. I know zero libertarians who aren’t of European or African American descent.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- jjeaff 2y agoThe thing I see as worrying with Milei is that while he is an economist, and seems to be using economic principles to drive his thinking, he has also mixed in an unhealthy dose of culture war nonsense and other politics into his strategy. He claims almost all journalists in Argentina are corrupt and just write lies about him, which I find to be a suspicious claim. He also thinks that Trump is a wonderful and selfless human who is making sacrifices for his country and the same of Elon Musk. So he is obviously a very poor judge of character and it makes me question his own character.
- watwut 2y agoI can understand someone who hates the state and wants to see it destroyed supporting Trump and Musk. They are obvious choices if you want to maximize the damage.
- ks2048 2y agoI wonder if Milei could choose a (country + year) as the ideal model (or closest to it) for how a state should be run, what would he choose?
- drexlspivey 2y agoProbably current singapore or 80s Hong Kong
- aylmao 2y agoThe state holds a lot of power in Singapore, it's very authoritarian. Sounds quite at odds to Milei and his libertarian idology.
- pavlov 2y agoThe anti-state people often like the idea of an authoritarian leader figure who will fix things by their genius and power of will. Some really do want monarchy (see Curtis Yarvin), but others believe that the dissolution of state power needs to go through an authoritarian phase to happen at all. It’s not so different from the old-school communists who claimed that a “dictatorship of the proletariat” is a necessary step towards the true freedom of mankind under proper Communism. Conveniently they were the ones in charge of the “temporary” dictatorship in this picture. Libertarianism and communism are ideological siblings. Both fail time and time again, but to the believers it’s always someone else’s fault and the proper implementation of the ideology simply hasn’t been tried yet.
- dmarcos 2y agoIs not Milei in Argentina the first self-identified libertarian president in history? Where has libertarianism failed?
- brg 2y agoIMHO, Libertarianism fails not by collapse but by success. Any movement in the direction brings economic and social freedom, but in turn creates soft times in which a society's pendulum shift back to larger government is inevitable.
- kerkeslager 2y ago> "Argentina’s president is idolised by the Trumpian right. They should get to know him better" The subtext here seems to be that if the Trumpian right understood Milei, they would not idolize him. On the contrary, I believe that the Trumpian right understands Milei just fine: they're on board with his ideologies.
- vpribish 2y agoI agree with what you say, but it's funny that I can't tell if we have the same reasoning :) Their supporters don't know or care much about economics but sure like a brash-sounding contrarian strongman leader who appeals to their insecurities. They don't mind a touch of the 'ascism since the leopard surly won't be coming for their sort of face.
- kerkeslager 2y agoThat's about my reasoning, yeah.
- Barrin92 2y agoThat's impossible to square. As the article points out, his drastic spending cuts and embrace of free trade are basically the radical opposite of where the US is going. Protectionism and industrial policy seem to now be consensus. Milei is the closest thing the world has gotten to Milton Friedman style politics in the last few decades and the American right now looks more like what in Britain or Canada you'd call a Red Tory, i.e. paternalistic conservatism. People like Michael Lind who try to give this an intellectual underpinning are explicit critics of libertarianism.
- kerkeslager 2y agoNeither one of them follows an economic ideology: the only ideology either cares about is power. The oligarchies in the respective nations want different things, hence the surface differences you point out.
- avidphantasm 2y agoThere wouldn’t be free markets without the state. So he either doesn’t actually want free markets and wants to run a mafia state like Putin, or he is a complete idiot.
- TriangleEdge 2y agoCitation needed
- foogazi 2y agoPirates ? The free market in the real 3D world we inhabit needs freedom to operate granted by the local people/state
- drexlspivey 2y agoWhy would a state be needed for a free market? The old American west is a recent example of no formal state with a free market.
- Xunjin 2y agoWhen you mean old is when? Also would love you to expand on this too.
- drexlspivey 2y agoRoughly 1830-1890. I am referring to frontier territories before/during the westward expansion. There were mining/cattle towns (eg Deadwood). There was no official federal or state government yet. They operated under a free market obviously (you could trade with anyone, no taxes or levies). Disputes were resolved through arbitration or informal courts. They relied on private lawmen or hired security (Pinkertons)
- dwaltrip 2y agoAw yes, the frontier Wild West, famously known for peace and stability.
- meiraleal 2y agoWhat people don't talk about is that the good things the new administration achieved came with a big price: an expected drop of close to 4% in GDP. With the expectation of recovering it fast next year. So next year is the turning point for Milei, if the recession ends or intensifies. A shrinking economy with smaller inflation but in recession is worse than a growing economy with higher inflation. Also the GDP drop should be bigger but the previous year there was the worst drought in the country's history and it relies heavily on agriculture so the economy was already in a terrible state with a paralyzed and incompetent president at the time. Now the agrobusiness is growing strong (compared to the terrible previous year) but not enough to balance against the recessive economic measures to reduce state spending.
- sam_lowry_ 2y agoThe evil is in the details. The inflation rate pre-Milei distorted economy to the point where any meaningful model based on Austrian or Keynesian or whatever ideas was impossible.
- luzojeda 2y agoAlmost everyone I know and all newspapers I read here, in Argentina, do talk about that. The cost is an inevitable one when you reach 3 digits inflation. Hope we learn our lesson though we didn't in the 2000s when we brought inflation again. To give anyone reading this perspective, Argentina had inflation for almost 80 years, only a brief pause in the 90s and then again since the 2003. What other way is there?
- marcosdumay 2y ago> What other way is there? Remember that inflation is something the government chooses to create. It's not some natural disaster. The other way is to remove the power to create it from the executive leader and give it to some institution that is more stable.
- luzojeda 2y agoOf course but once you have 3 digits inflation, what other way to reduce is there besides cutting the supply of money suddenly in a shock? People won't like it, I didn't like it either but the two other presidents tried various methods such as price controls and that didn't help, on the contrary.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- djaouen 2y agoHe looks and talks like Lucifer imo