7 ms·
BYD launches sodium-ion grid-scale BESS product
- msoad 2y agoArticle says BYD sells Sodium-Ion cars too. Are those cars super low range with quicker charging times? If they are much cheaper batteries it makes sense for an urban setting to have such cars.
- hn_throwaway_99 2y agoRelated, it always seemed weird to me that lithium was leading the way (initially, at least) for grid storage. Lithium won the battery race for mobile applications (e.g. cars, laptops, etc.) where energy density is critical. For grid storage, though, battery weight should hardly be a concern at all. It seemed to be like lithium was ahead solely because there was so much industrial knowledge learned from optimizing for energy density first, but that other battery chemistries had to be better for grid storage once we invested the same economies of scale in them, too.
- blackoil 2y agoIt is simply the amount of R&D investment already done and manufacturing pipeline scale that favors Lithium. But if trend continues in couple of years, sodium should have all that market.
- lukan 2y agoAnd then maybe the voices will finally go silent, saying we cannot do battery grid storage in big numbers, because lithium is limited.
- colechristensen 2y agoThere are other issues with older battery chemistries that make them less attractive than lithium. Discharge rate and various issues with charge cycles among them.
- XorNot 2y agoIt's mostly durability AFAIK - lead-acid is heavy, but it's cycle life is actually pretty poor. They're used as car auxillary batteries because they do have very nice properties for that specific application with ICE engines (namely, a nice resistive charging curve - they absorb the sort of noisy power you get from an alternator very well).
- shiroiushi 2y agoNot all lead-acid batteries are like car starter batteries: deep-cycle batteries are the same basic technology but they're actually good at being discharged heavily and recharging over and over. They're not good at supplying tons of current quickly, though, which is what's needed for a starter battery.
- bonzini 2y agoThere's also vanadium flow batteries that seem to be improving and might be good enough to provide a smoother peak capacity. https://www.reddit.com/r/dataisbeautiful/comments/17r9q6s/comment/k8hfmpr/ https://www.reddit.com/r/dataisbeautiful/comments/17r9q6s/co...
- Manuel_D 2y agoLithium became drastically cheaper, but has yet to achieve relevance in term of grid scale storage. The US uses 12 TWh of electricity per day. The world used 60 TWh. Global lithium ion battery production is around 600 GWh. Most lithium storage systems are on the order of megawatt hours or single digit gigawatt hours.
- Unroasted6154 2y agoIt can be very useful for grid stabilization at the scale of seconds to minutes (both with charge and discharge).You don't need that much capacity to do that.
- Filligree 2y agoFor what it's worth, non-portable battery storage these days is mostly lithium iron batteries. Which are, yes, heavier; but are superior to lithium-ion in most other ways.
- CorrectHorseBat 2y agoLithium iron batteries are still lithium ion batteries
- owenversteeg 2y agoI totally agree, but I don't find it weird that lithium led for so long. Sure, in theory, sodium-ion batteries are made of inexpensive materials and are easy to build. You don't need any nickel, copper or cobalt at all and sodium is dirt cheap. But if you look into it, you'll find many thousands of similar examples across countless fields, where something uses advanced materials or parts when there is a simpler and cheaper alternative. If you ever design for manufacturing, you quickly realize that the key is often not simplicity, the key is identifying and using existing high-volume processes. In other words, don't find the cleanest way to solve your problem; instead, kludge together a solution using off-the-shelf solutions already produced at incredible scale. The problem is that low-cost manufacturing is an art form and is far more complex than anyone realizes. Scale is important, sure, but what you really need is scale+time+intense cost competition. In that environment, it is very hard to start on a significantly different chemistry to compete with lithium-ion. (LiFePO4 is similar enough in manufacturing.) IMO the only place you could start this is China, which would leave BYD and CATL as the only two that could pull it off.
- HPsquared 2y agoSoftware engineering is like this too. We reuse existing libraries based on how mature they are, because it's less development time/cost/risk, even though the actual product ends up being very complex under the hood. Very similar principle of finding local maxima.
- jillesvangurp 2y agoThese are cheap vehicles with modest ranges from brands that aren't known outside China (yet). This is a product category that simply doesn't exist in the US. The lack of range doesn't matter because they are intended for people that don't drive very far. You charge them on slow chargers at night mostly. And if you use a fast charger, the charging goes relatively quickly because these aren't large capacity batteries. Typical size in kwh is around 20-30 kwh only. China has a large amount of mega cities. Think tens of millions of people. There are a lot of cars driving around in those cities that rarely leave those cities. 200-300km range is all they need and a typical range for a sodium ion battery equipped car. The primary feature of sodium ion in this market is cost per kwh. It keeps the vehicles affordable. People that need more have access to still cheap BYDs priced priced between 10 and 20K with better ranges. Once you hit 30-40K you are looking at the high end of the market with proper long ranges with proper LFP batteries.
- mytailorisrich 2y agoRange is actually not that important to most people in China or Europe. If you use your car to commute and you can charge when you park then even 100 miles of range is plenty.
- raverbashing 2y agoThe more the western boomers fight about "clean energy" products, the more China will eat our lunch At the same time we saw Northvolt going to Ch 11 due to costs and lack of expertise. A lot of what comes from China might be low quality (especially for internal consumption) but it's cheap and they're specializing > Sodium-ion cells are however much less energy dense, as illustrated by BYD’s new product only packing 2.3MWh per 20-foot container, much less than the 5MWh and more than is now standard in the lithium-ion BESS space. Which really doesn't matter if you're on a stationary application, especially if the cost/longevity is competitive.
- blackoil 2y ago> A lot of what comes from China might be low quality (especially for internal consumption) but it's cheap and they're specializing In the batteries CATL and BYD are leaders in terms of cost, quality and innovation.
- colechristensen 2y agoWho cares? Fossil energy i is turning out to just be significantly more expensive. The weird political aversion to things will be easily defeated by greed. Even with various market manipulations absent or present solar + storage is just really cheap and getting progressively cheaper.
- quasse 2y ago> A lot of what comes from China might be low quality This is also Western boomer mentality and it's alarming that people haven't realized it. I work in manufacturing in NA and America is rapidly falling behind China on the ability to manufacture quality high-tech goods. It's not something that's on the horizon, it's something that's already happened. We still have an edge in semiconductors but even that is eroding (just look at the hollowing out of Intel in the last half decade).
- cromka 2y agoSeriously, as an European who’s lived in the US for many years: older or more traditional US products might be of higher quality than anything from China — think Milwaukee tools or KitchenAid mixers. But anything new tech or electronic? Are you kidding me? China has long managed to change people’s opinion on that. Made in China is OK by now, just like Made in Japan got in the 80s and Made in Korea in 2000s.
- epistasis 2y agoI hope that our tariff situation in the coming years doesn't leave us behind the coming tech curve. Our entire energy future in the US could be held back severely if we are kept from adopting the best technology by politicians trying to prop up oil. The market must be allowed to choose the most efficient technology on its own. (And even the oil companies know that their future is limited, the only question is how long they can delay that future and how much money they can extract from consumers through higher prices than the alternatives.)
- wyager 2y agoI agree with the denotative message of your post (that we should let the energy market do its optimization unimpeded), but I'm guessing we disagree connotatively; most "green" solutions (especially wind, to a lesser degree solar) are only viable at all because of extreme distortions in the energy market induced by subsidies. Tariffs would of course also be distortionary, but it would be difficult for them to compete with the gross distortions that already exist! In the (loosely remembered) words of a friend who designs wind turbine blades and control systems: "we would build these things to be a lot more reliable if we weren't just trying to maximize subsidy revenue". I'm more immediately worried about these demand-side distortions than the hypothetical supply-side ones.
- jpgvm 2y agoOil subsidies dwarf solar/wind/hydro/nuclear combined that is without factoring in socialized costs of pollution and accidents.
- cscurmudgeon 2y agoThat means we should subsidize local solar/wind/hydro/nuclear more and not allow foreign subsidized companies to decimate local companies.
- tda 2y agoAt least in Europe, offshore wind farms (which are more expensive than on shore) don't need any subsidies to be profitable. The turning point was around 2018
- phtrivier 2y agoAs usual, wake me up when it's in the battery of a car that I can afford _and_ use to visit my mom 500km away. (Don't tell me your EV can do that : either it can't, for real - that's 500km of highway, of course - , or I can't afford it.) Still, it will almost certainly not be a car built in my subcontinent, and that's infuriating. It almost seems like the right way to address energy transition was to buy cheap fossils to increase living standards, then let governement heavily subsidy R&D while the rest of the world plunged into post-Reaganism. R&D works ! Who would have guessed ? It only ensured the domination of so many empires and only got a man on the moon. Such puny matters. Thanks God the US and EU are never going to subsidy R&D ever again. That would be communism ! Better to spend money on ensuring our 1945 baby boom retirees have enough money to buy cheap Chinese stuff. Shareholder over engineer, always, all the time ! But pay "young" people to do, what, fundamental Chemistry ? Experimental Electronics ? Naaah. We have a board meeting tomorrow, we need results by 10:00. All your "research" stuff will never pay out the 12% yearly interest that our shareholders asked. And old people depend on that for pension funds. The kids understood that, and they stopped looking for engineering or research jobs. They're all consultants now. The smart ones will realize they have a bullshit job and leave to work on an organic farm. The less smart ones will burn down. Anyway, we replaced pour R&D department with a new wing of the legal team that's finding more loopholes in the tax code, to ensure we never ever ever give a cent to anyone else than the pension funds. They're on the verge of finding a solution to that pesky "salary" problem, it's not the moment to bother them with your "ion" sci-fi stuff. It's not like developing countries will do that, right ? Right ?
- bberrry 2y agoYou can't spend 20 minutes charging on the occasional 5 hour trip?
- thebruce87m 2y agoAgreed. And depending on other circumstances the EV might save time overall vs an ICE. I only use a public charger around 3 or 4 times a year, and I've had to "wait" exactly 0 minutes since I ate and used the bathroom during the charging time. I save at least 5+ mins a week refuelling compared to my Diesel. That's half a day a year. The automated pre-heating saves me time defrosting in the winter. Probably another hour or more saved every year. All for around 1/4 of the running cost.
- LikeBeans 2y agoI just watched a YouTube video of a battery powered train in the UK [1]. If longevity and number of cycles is much higher than lithium ion coupled with a safer profile then I think this would be an ideal application for sodium ion. Really cool. Edit: I'm talking about for both onboard batteries (for the safety profile) and the BESS container mentioned in the video. Not to mention trains wouldn't have to compete with the lithium ion battery supply that is taken over by EV cars and trucks. [1] https://youtu.be/sARTvQj5jIg https://youtu.be/sARTvQj5jIg
- butterknife 2y agoThere is also class 777 electric-battery hybrid.
- elAhmo 2y agoAren’t trains the perfect use case for a direct connection to the electric grid?
- reacharavindh 2y agoI'm very much rooting for this. A lot of train tracks are not electrified simply because it is not economical to do so. I know that most of Denmark(outside of greater Copenhagen, and Aarhus) is still operating Diesel trains. Such battery backed "electric" trains may be just the thing to turn those Diesel trains into cleaner ones without needing a huge capital investment of electrifying vast track networks that are not used justifiably as much.
- AstralStorm 2y agoNew battery powered trains unfortunately are even more expensive of a capital investment. Especially when it comes to maintenance over classic electric trains. What I always found weird is that a power rail system isn't used. One could do it even without a third rail...
- fartfeatures 2y ago
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]