6 ms·
> It's not just the size of Operation Gutt that is striking to the modern eye. It's also the oddity of the tool being used. Today, we control inflation with cha
by eru 2y ago
> It's not just the size of Operation Gutt that is striking to the modern eye. It's also the oddity of the tool being used. Today, we control inflation with changes in interest rates, not changes in the quantity of money. To soften the effect of the global COVID monetary overhang, for instance, central banks in the U.S., Canada, and Europe began to raise rates in 2022 from around 0% to 4-5% in 2024.
It's a bit more interesting than 'the central bank sets interest rates'.
Simplified: the central bank decide on an interest rate that they want to see. By itself that decision doesn't do anything.
What happens next is that they buy and sell government bonds in the open market. The interest rate can be seen as the inverse of the price of bonds.
If the central bank wants to see a lower interest rate, they buy bonds with freshly printed money to drive up their prices, ie drive down the interest rate.
If the central banks wants to increase the prevailing interest rate, they sell government bonds from their inventory and essentially destroy they money they receive in return.
So even when the language of modern central banking talks about interest rates, they still change the quantity of money to implement that.
(This is all simplified, especially with the interest on excess reserves that was popular with the Fed for a while. And there's also repos and reverse repos etc.)
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- neilwilson 2y agoInterest on reserves is very much still in place[0]. Open Market Operations haven't been a thing since shortly after the 2008 Financial Crisis. https://www.federalreserve.gov/monetarypolicy/reserve-balances.htm https://www.federalreserve.gov/monetarypolicy/reserve-balanc...
- hgomersall 2y agoWe don't control inflation with interest rates; we do some economic theatre with interest rates that some people believe controls inflation in a predictable way.
- pjc50 2y agoThe evidence is very strong that we do actually control it, because in many countries you can see in the historical data when central bank targeting was introduced that the inflation rate drops fairly rapidly into the target band. It's not a perfect control system because the cost is "NAIRU": non accelerating rate of unemployment. That is, economic growth and wage growth are constrained to avoid a wage-price spiral. And sometimes you get a shock from outside the system.
- hgomersall 2y agoPlease do show this very strong evidence that the effect is any more than the supply chains sorting themselves out. Even some within the CBs are doubting the causality. Japan had the lowest inflation of any major economy post COVID, and yet persisted with essentially a ZIRP. There's a good argument that in our high reserves world, interest is actually inflationary.
- pjc50 2y agoUK historical investigation: https://www.elibrary.imf.org/display/book/9781557758897/ch07.xml https://www.elibrary.imf.org/display/book/9781557758897/ch07... - written in 2000, but you can see on this graph https://www.macrotrends.net/global-metrics/countries/gbr/united-kingdom/inflation-rate-cpi https://www.macrotrends.net/global-metrics/countries/gbr/uni... how flat it is from 1992 to 2020. That's a very good record for any piece of policy. Inflation control works for controlling business cycle inflation. However, it's not perfect and the COVID+war shock resulted in unavoidable inflation. It's a ""plant"" in the https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Control_theory https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Control_theory sense. (my original comment: "you can see in the historical data when central bank targeting was introduced that the inflation rate drops fairly rapidly into the target band". The US graph is similar https://www.macrotrends.net/global-metrics/countries/usa/united-states/inflation-rate-cpi https://www.macrotrends.net/global-metrics/countries/usa/uni... - although the adoption of inflation targeting wasn't fully formalized, it was definitely used in setting interest rates from the 90s.
- Polygator 2y agoFor an international perspective: buying and selling government bonds is far from an universal mechanism for interest rate control (AFAIK when discussing central banks the US is almost always a special case) For instance the Canadian, UK and European central banks provide systems for interbank short-term loans. It is almost entirely through these systems that they set their target rate. For Canada the BoC doesn't do any open market operations to reach target interest rate (so almost only repos and reverse repos). Their target rate is in fact called the "target overnight rate" and only concerns overnight lending between Canadian financial institutions.
- eru 2y agoFor the interested https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Interbank_lending_market#Monetary_policy_transmission https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Interbank_lending_market#Monet... has more on it. As far as I understand, the central banks intervene in this market by offering to loan or borrow above or below otherwise prevailing market rates. This has the effect of adding money to the system (or removing it). So that's pretty much the same mechanism as what I described. They use an intermediate proxy like the 'target overnight rate' to help them decide how much money to add or remove to the system: exactly as much as needed to bring the market interest rate in line with their intermediate proxy.
- IAmGraydon 2y agoAhh…no. The Fed sets the interest rate directly. What you are talking about is yields on treasury bonds, which are manipulated via bond buying to force money into assets by artificially dropping the yield of those bonds, thus creating a more attractive investment in the stocks, assets, etc.
- eru 2y agoI described Open Market Operations, see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Open_market_operation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Open_market_operation > The Fed sets the interest rate directly. So which interest rate does the Fed set directly, and how does that setting have any effect on the economy? (I know they have interest on excess reserves. I already accounted for those in my original comment. I know, they are annoying and misguided. I was mostly talking about the system they used before, ie up until about 2008.)
- IAmGraydon 2y agoThe Fed directly sets the Overnight Rate, also known as the Federal Funds Rate. It's the rate at which banks can borrow from one another overnight to satisfy reserve requirements. This rate indirectly affects the interest rate of all other lending instruments because the higher cost of overnight bank to bank lending is passed on to the customers in the form of higher loan rates, credit card rates, mortgage rates, etc. The Open Market Operations you described (completely different from the Overnight Rate) are a form of stimulus. Because money always seeks higher risk-adjusted returns, the Fed will buy treasuries, which drives down their yield. This makes them an unattractive investment, so the money goes where it can get a better risk-adjusted return. That's usually in the market. So by adjusting treasury note yields, they can stimulate the economy. Furthermore, those treasury bonds are bought with printed money, so this is effectively a way to inject massive amounts (trillions of dollars) of printed money directly into the economy. It's pretty crazy when you think about the power that these policies have.
- eru 2y agoThe Fed can only 'set' the Overnight Rate by being ready to borrow or lend at the Overnight Rate. The Fed still has to stand ready to actually engage in these transactions. As a counterfactual: we can imagine a world where the Fed 'sets' these rates by just announcing the rate but not engaging in any transactions and legislators pass a law that forbids banks from borrowing from one another at any other rates. The interbank lending market would just not clear in that case, and you'd either have a glut of demand or a glut of supply. The Fed sidesteps this by actually borrowing and lending in the interbank lending market. And that's economically equivalent to buying and selling very short term bonds, even if the legal form is different.
- insane_dreamer 2y agoThat's just one mechanism, but not the primary way in which the Fed controls interest rates. The Fed is a large provider of short-term loans ("fed funds") to cover interbank exchanges. It also is the lender of last resort and lends to banks directly ("discount rate"). By changing these rates, the FED can influence the rates the banks charge each other for loans, and down the line to consumers.
- xadhominemx 2y agoYou are correct. Striking how many HN commentors are so often confident and yet wrong...
- mbar84 2y agoWas he really that wrong? Isn't a bond just another debt instrument? It's not obvious to me, that there is any fundamental difference between the operations that both comments describe.
- insane_dreamer 2y agoWhile the effects may be similar, they are fundamentally different mechanisms. Also, this statement is incorrect: > Simplified: the central bank decide on an interest rate that they want to see. By itself that decision doesn't do anything. The Fed does in fact set interest rates and that decision directly impacts rates all down the line to mortgages and local loans. Intervening in the bond market is another tool that the Fed can use.
- eru 2y agoThe Fed still has to make (and receive) loans at these rates, for them to have an effect on the market.
- benj111 2y agoI think you're talking past each other. A central bank doesn't directly set interest rates for your mortgage. It can set rates at which it will lend to other banks, which in turn influences the rates banks will offer to mortgage borrowers, but this isn't necessarily so, see for example 2008. Of course there are more contracts directly tied to the central bank rates, but thats just formalising the thing thats supposed to happen anyway.
- jmyeet 2y ago> Simplified: the central bank decide on an interest rate that they want to see. This is incorrect. Using the US central bank example, the Fed has a target for inflation. It uses interest rates to try and hit that target. If inflation is higher than 3% the Fed will raise rates to cool the economy. The Fed sets interest rates directly because lending money to the Fed is viewed as "risk-free" (as the US government has never defaulted on a debt). So if the Fed offers a risk-free 4%, banks will need to offer more because they are not risk-free. So banks no longer really lend savings out for loans. They borrow money and lend it out at a higher rate (eg mortgage-backed securities). So when you could get a mortgage at 2.5%, it was because the Fed was offering 0%. When the Fed offers 5%, mortgage rates will go up to 7-8%. There is another mechanism that the government could use to control inflation: fiscal policy, specifically taxation. A criticism of monetary policy to control inflation is that it's indiscriminate. People will go out of business and lose their houses. Taxes only target profits. So in 2021-2022, we should've just passed a windfall profits tax of 80%. That would've cooled off inflation real quick and given the governments funds to distribute to those most adversely affected. But that will never happen because the corporations and wealthy who own both parties will never stand for wealth redistribution to the poor. They will however demand wealth be transferred from the government to the rich.
- rpmisms 2y agoThe false equivalence of a profits tax and redistributing wealth to the poor is quite funny.
- G3rn0ti 2y ago> Today, we control inflation with changes in interest rates, not changes in the quantity of money. That is also not quite correct, I believe. The FED can invest money created out of thin air any time it wants („fiat money“ — „there shall be money“), usually it buys government bonds to help the federal government run its deficit. Sometimes this scheme is called „quantitative easing“ which is a charming euphemism. This is what drove and still drives inflation directly and indirectly (through the effect of our fractional reserve system private banks amplify this about tenfold by lending out 90% of their customers‘ deposits). The interest rates everybody is obsessed about are just the target rates for the interest earned or paid for for money in the account of private banks at the FED. It is just a secondary adjustment. At least during major crisis.
- CraigJPerry 2y ago>> This is what drove and still drives inflation directly and indirectly QE is fascinating. On the one side of QE you have central banks, absolutely baffled by the fact they create all these reserves, we’re talking utterly un-relatable numbers for a human, numbers that belong in the field of astronomy rather than finance. And yet they fail to hit their inflation targets for over a decade. On the other side you have a bunch of folks shouting loudly this amount of QE will cause ungodly amounts of inflation. Now they shouted long enough that inflation eventually did show up but it’s not clear that it relates to QE. The onset of inflation correlates more closely with global energy supply shocks than with changes in QE policy or “printing” money in Covid stimulus. However, energy, despite being an input to almost everything we care about, isn’t really considered in the context of inflation by most macroeconomic models. The models are less than helpful in the face of “externalities”. >> through the effect of our fractional reserve system We don’t have fractional reserve in the USA, the UK, Aus etc and haven’t had for a number of years at this point.
- G3rn0ti 2y ago> The onset of inflation correlates more closely with global energy supply shocks than with changes in QE policy or “printing” money in Covid stimulus. Hmmm. [1] > USA, the UK, Aus etc and haven’t had for a number of years at this point Indeed, the US abolished the 10% reserve requirement in 2020. Crazy. I hope you guys also save in inflation hedges. [1] https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/M2SL https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/M2SL
- CraigJPerry 2y ago> Simplified: the central bank decide on an interest rate that they want to see. By itself that decision doesn't do anything. I get the simplified qualifier and I see what you’re saying but it’s more accurate to say this is not true, it hasn’t really been substantially true since February 1994. > What happens next is that they buy and sell government bonds in the open market Again i feel it’s better to say exactly what happens, not a model or simplification. What happens next is banks move to the new interest rate without any OMO (open market operations) - the announcement effect as it’s called. There’s many reasons for this - not least that it’s futile to fight against the currency issuer. Citation needed to support my statements above: https://www.newyorkfed.org/medialibrary/media/research/epr/02v08n1/0205demi.pdf https://www.newyorkfed.org/medialibrary/media/research/epr/0...
- eru 2y agoYes, expectations and anticipation are very, very important in all markets, and especially financial markets. But they only work, because the Fed can and will back up its announcements with large transactions at the announced prices and rates. > There’s many reasons for this - not least that it’s futile to fight against the currency issuer. You'd hope so, but not all currency issuers are so confident. I remember the Swiss central bank recently giving up on its exchange rate target to the Euro: they let the Swiss Frank appreciate against the Euro in the end, even though they control the printing presses and could always print enough Franks to drive their price down as much as they want to. We saw similar reluctance to do whatever it takes for Japan since the 1990s and the Fed and the ECB during the 2010s, when they all failed comically to push inflation up to their targets, and came up with various excuses. (The failure of the Fed is particularly funny, because one of the guys in charge had earlier written a piece telling the Japanese exactly how to get out of their own trap in the 1990s, but then did not practice his own preaching.)
- jpkoning 2y ago"What happens next is that they buy and sell government bonds in the open market." This describes how central banks operated in the U.S. before 2008 and in Canada before the 1990s. The Federal Reserve and the Bank of Canada both set a target for the overnight interest rate, and then they hit that target by doing open market purchases (or sales) of bonds, effectively adding funds to (or draining funds away from) the overnight lending market. By changing the quantity of funds, they influenced the interest rate. What changed is that both central banks introduced interest payments on balances that banks hold at the central bank. Previously, these balances earned 0%. With this new tool, they could directly set the overnight interest rate by adjusting the rate paid on these reserves, eliminating the need for regular open market operations.
- lbotos 2y agoYou make it sounds like they aren't doing regular open market operations, but as I understand it... they still do? https://www.newyorkfed.org/markets/domestic-market-operations/monetary-policy-implementation/treasury-securities/treasury-securities-operational-details#monthly-details https://www.newyorkfed.org/markets/domestic-market-operation...
- jpkoning 2y agoThe Fed still does purchases and sales, but not for the purpose of driving the overnight interest rates towards its target. The level of the overnight rate is not affected of any purchases or sales that the Fed does.
- eru 2y agoIf the Fed makes or receives a loan at specific interest rates (even if only overnight), that's pretty much economicaly equivalent to buying or selling bonds.