5 ms·
You are assuming the court isn't a political thing that is trying to get him regardless of evidence. The court is at least partially political, and Netanyahu w
by bluGill 2y ago
You are assuming the court isn't a political thing that is trying to get him regardless of evidence. The court is at least partially political, and Netanyahu will tell you this is entirely political and he wouldn't get a fair trail.
- bbqfog 2y ago[flagged]
- GordonS 2y ago[flagged]
- qntmfred 2y ago[flagged]
- GordonS 2y agoI honestly don't know what point you are trying to make here?
- qntmfred 2y ago[flagged]
- tsimionescu 2y agoWell, it seems that at least in the case of Palestine, antisemites haven't been able to stop the ICC from addressing the real apartheid, war crimes, and even genocide that Israel is currently conducting in Gaza.
- MrMcCall 2y agoWell, what a person calls a thing and what it is are often two different realities. That's why it is existentially important to understand when a person is a liar, and then never elect them to govt. Yeah, I know, that ship is sailed, but we could place a new framework on whom we choose to run our govts.
- inpdx 2y agoWhen everything Netanyahu doesn't like is antisemitism it begins to lose meaning/legitimacy. Which does great harm to addressing actual antisemitism.
- GordonS 2y agoExactly; it could even be argued that weaponising antisemitism is itself antisemitic behaviour.
- emadabdulrahim 2y agoAntisemitism is a form of bigotry, no more or less special than other forms of bigotry and racism. If you read any significant amount of history you'd know that already, and you wouldn't need to prove that Antisemitism is real. Of course it is. So is anti-[insert religious or ethnic group]
- GordonS 2y ago[flagged]
- limit499karma 2y ago[flagged]
- Hikikomori 2y agoThem turning any criticism of Israels actions into antisemitism is making the word worthless, it's almost a badge of honor at this point. And ironically their genocide is creating real antisemitism.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- defamation 2y ago[flagged]
- newspaper1 2y ago[flagged]
- throwaway_fjmr 2y ago[flagged]
- throwaway_fjmr 2y ago[flagged]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- TrueDuality 2y agoCourts are political entities but this is one that Israel chose to accept and recognize the authority of. It has a history of being very transparent in its decisions and is widely recognized as being neutral and fair in their decision making process. Of course the person charged and found guilty of a crime will argue against the court. Disagreement, even if valid, doesn't change the recognized authority of this court even if the "teeth" are extremely limited.
- seabass-labrax 2y agoIsrael don't recognize the authority of the International Criminal Court. Palestine, however, does, and therefore the ICC consider these allegations within their jurisdiction. A relevant point is that the UK (under the previous Conservative party government) requested the opportunity to dispute the allegations of war crimes based on this complication, but the new British government did not choose to continue with the objection. No other countries have made objections.
- immibis 2y ago[flagged]
- seabass-labrax 2y agoThe government of Germany clearly prefer to side with Israel on any matter related to Palestine (or Lebanon for that matter), but in fairness it has taken this long for the ICC's prosecutor to bring a case. The real tests will begin if, for instance, Netanyahu visits Germany, because that will trigger an obligation for Germany to arrest him. There may of course already be domestic German laws which arms sales to Israel may be breaking, but as far as I'm aware Germany has only had a duty to cooperate with the ICC since the warrant was issued earlier today.
- frm88 2y agoNicaragua had a go at the German government in March 2024 re. arms sales and could not prevail [0]. I just read an article that claims they have already made a new attempt, which could be more successful in the current situation [1 - in German, sorry] [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nicaragua_v._Germany https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nicaragua_v._Germany [1] https://nachrichten.ag/europa/waffenexporte-an-israel-in-gefahr-icc-haftbefehle-sorgen-fuer-umdenken/ https://nachrichten.ag/europa/waffenexporte-an-israel-in-gef...
- vkou 2y ago[flagged]
- LightBug1 2y ago[flagged]
- ars 2y ago[flagged]
- hilbert42 2y agoPerhaps I'm cynical enough to suggest the Court had good reason to overlook the matter—fear of personal retribution.
- ClumsyPilot 2y ago[flagged]
- stanfordkid 2y agoThere is indeed, as you state, political influence being exerted on courts. Most of that influence is in support of Israel and Netanyahu — do you really think there is significant political power and influence upon the ICC from Palestine or Hamas? Look at the amount AIPAC has contributed to pro-Israel politicians. It’s quite frankly absurd such a political organization exists under the guise of representing American Jews yet pretty much lobbies solely for Israeli geopolitical issues. Kennedy even tried to get it to register as a foreign agent. The fact that these warrants were issued despite the influence and leverage of Israel is a hint at how egregious the crimes are.
- nimbius 2y agopolitical is..sorta true. the point of these international legal bodies was to maintain and enforce a world order dominated by western powers. it was not about promoting justice (albeit sometimes that happened.) the selective application of enforcement and investigation have reduced the ICC to little more than a tool of neocolonial rule. the rome statute itself contains provisions that limit its reach. article 98 precludes extradition, which has been abused by the US to prevent US nationals from being tried. in short the ICC is allowed to go after western geopolitical rivals, however going after an ally whos committing genocide is a bridge too far; they will be shielded. for example: the US pressured its allies to refuse to refer any activities in Afghanistan to the ICC and largely succeeded as its allies form the dominant half of the UN Security council. whats interesting here is the US seems so isolated this time as to have lost the ability to block the referral. perhaps a first in history.
- jll29 2y agoI once had the honor to attend a lecture by a prosecutor of the ICC. Out of all lawyers/attorneys/prosecutors/judges that I met in my life, that one was the one that I would judge to bet he most idealistic and justice motivated (admittedly based on my gut instinct); a very rare breed. It's good that there are such institutions with a good purpose, staffed with good people. Bad faith actors - including war criminals - will of course claim agendas (other than bringing justice), deny jurisdiction etc. but it is a good starting point to have them. The next step is to strive to give these organizations enough "teeth" to execute. The "individual bully" problem needs some addressing, a solution to that remains outstanding.
- loceng 2y agoAnd the only counterweight for a person accused of genocide who is claiming they haven't committed war crimes or genocide, while they call this action "antisemetic" - the only way to determine if they are being genuine in claim it is antisemitism or political-manipulation (demonization) tool is to go to court and see all of the evidence presented. Either 40,000+ people dead or seemingly nearly all Palestinian's civilian infrastructure being destroyed, both warrant being witnessed and investigated by the international community with a fine tooth comb, no? The ICC isn't some amateur city court in some backwaters country, it is the current epitome and evolutionary state from effort and passion of humanity towards holding the line for justice.
- bawolff 2y ago> And the only counterweight for a person accused of genocide The ICC has not accused anyone of genocide. It does have juridsiction over personal criminal responsibility for gdnocide, but so far, nothing on that front has been mentioned. South africa is suing israel at the icj alleging state responsibility for genocide, however that is different from personal responsibility, and different standards of evidence and procedures apply. Its also a totally separate court system.
- loceng 2y agoStraw man argument. I didn't make the claim the ICC accused the ICC of genocide, however Netanyahu is now at minimum now officially wanted for war crimes. ICC and ICJ are different, yes.
- bawolff 2y agoWell when you say "person accused of genocide" in the context of a warrant from a court that has juridsiction over personal responsibility for genocide, its not a leap to assume that is what you meant. However if you didn't mean that, what did you mean by "person accused of genocide"? Who is accusing them? You personally?
- 2y ago
- loceng 2y agoCan't you place that exact same argument on the side of the Palestinians, and add more weight to their claim - where the international community so far has allowed this, due to reason (whether money involved in politicians toeing a line or not), and so the courts decisions and political bias are more likely to favour Netanyahu over the Palestinians? There never seems to be much critical thinking on the quick one-liners that on the surface appear to often be one-liner propaganda talking points used for deflection, to give an easy memorable line for an otherwise ideological mob to learn-train them with to then parrot. (edited tran->train)
- bawolff 2y agoYou can claim anything, but i don't think it means much if you don't back it up with some arguments. Like this is basically only the second time that a sitting head of state of a functioning country has had a warrant issued against them. Its fairly unprecedented. I don't agree with the claims the icc is biased against israel, but the fact they are acting at all certainly shows they aren't biased for them.
- loceng 2y agoThe proof you provide is very shallow, and with no real relevance or weight as an argument point - when it's known that the US and Israel have veto powers, as an example, that most international organizations currently are theatre without teeth - and so that's essentially why it's "fairly unprecedented." Now Netanyahu has done enough blatantly, what's argued by some to be the most video/photographed-recorded genocide in history, the hierarchy and people resource hierarchy of the ICC hasn't fallen to Israeli political pressure (or whatever other tactics Mossad is known to use to try to get their way). Once again, your final point is more neutral - where you could only really honestly say that if in a vacuum, if you're not looking behind the scenes with how much pressure Israel has put publicly and privately on members of the ICC to not file nor then issue charges, etc.
- bawolff 2y ago> when it's known that the US and Israel have veto powers, as an example, They don't have veto powers of the ICC. Neither are even members. However if your point is that both are powerful political actors, i think that speaks to a lack of pro-israel bias since they are going ahead with the charges despite the objections (and down right threats) from both countries which are super powerful actors. > Now Netanyahu has done enough blatantly, what's argued by some to be the most video/photographed-recorded genocide in history, It should be noted that genocide is not one of the charges. The ICC has juridsiction over genocide, but the ICC prosecuter has not accused israel of genocide thus far.