5 ms·
3 years ago, VCs in Bay Area tech were thriving. Now, they're 'bleeding cash.'
- toomuchtodo 2y agoSuboptimal asset class having existential crisis.
- blackeyeblitzar 2y agoThe fundamental issue is building a large sustainable company is nearly impossible. You could come up with an amazing product only to have your margins reduced by those that control distribution (like app stores). Or be outright copied by bigger players who give away your product (see microsoft teams and slack). Or maybe a new tech kills what you spent years building (see chegg). And with investors wanting constant growth in a startup’s financial numbers, there isn’t room for long term innovation. The time from founding to going public is very long now. And VCs have a short term focus that is not helpful. Many of these companies are grown to a point only to be dumped on public markets because they know they can’t keep the growth going. All of this adds up to an asset class that has more risk than expected with less return than expected. VCs may have thrived in a world of easy capital and inflated valuations, but the “reality” is more apparent now. What founders need is an alternative source and model of capital entirely. And regulation to rein in megacorps so competition can thrive freely.
- toomuchtodo 2y agoIndeed, this is a call for government sponsored anti trust efforts (pruning and holding back the forest so saplings can take root and grow) and incubators (Solyndra failed, but Tesla paid back their loan in full, with interest, ahead of schedule). But, you'll have people claim "that isn't efficient! the private sector can do better!" while the evidence (here) is that the private sector cannot do better. It just creates a wasteful, capital inefficient ecosystem where everyone performs theater around the concept of venture. Sometimes you're lucky, most times you are not (as it relates to highly speculative investments of this kind).
- xhkkffbf 2y agoVenture driven tech is crazy and wasteful, but it's nothing compared to government. How many electric car chargers did the Biden administration build with billions of dollars? A handful. Look at another post today about the fact that Britain can't build a new rail line for a reasonable price. I would say compared to just these examples, the private sector is doing better.
- kingkawn 2y agoThey haven’t spent the charger building money yet, fella
- 11101010001100 2y agoSo we can say the government is doing a good job helping the private sector look better.
- toomuchtodo 2y ago> I would say compared to just these examples, the private sector is doing better. I'm not going to argue subjective opinion, but simply point out that investors seeking venture exposure should familiarize themselves with the accredited investor test Matt Levine of Bloomberg's Money Stuff suggests: https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2024-10-22/the-sophisticated-investor-test https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2024-10-22/the-so... | https://archive.today/dytZs https://archive.today/dytZs > I have proposed my own solution, which I call the “Certificate of Dumb Investment.” The idea is that anyone can go to the SEC and ask for the certificate, which says: > I want to buy a dumb investment. I understand that the person selling it will almost certainly steal all my money, and that I would almost certainly be better off just buying index funds, but I want to do this dumb thing anyway. I agree that I will never, under any circumstances, complain to anyone when this investment inevitably goes wrong. I understand that violating this agreement is a felony. > And then the SEC will slap you in the face and say “really?” and if you say “yes really” then they give you the certificate and you can buy whatever private investment you want. Who am I to get in the way of unsophisticated money doing unsophisticated things? That's not government waste, that's freedom. If you think you can do better, and prefer venture over a DraftKings account, 0DTE options, or a lottery ticket, go for it. That mental model is sophisticated money opportunity. Tangential: https://longbets.org/362/ https://longbets.org/362/
- stackedinserter 2y agoMaybe the industry has just ran out of ideas and/or there's nothing to improve with products that can be built within a year.
- bediger4000 2y agoThis does happen. A Boeing 787 isn't all that different from a 707 designed in the mid 1950s. Air transport tech maxed out early.
- duxup 2y agoThe VC systems seems to be all or nothing. You race to dominate / found a market so fast that you fail fast... but likely fail. I've seen some VC funded orgs enter into the space where I have some visibility. The pattern of quickly eat up customers (or ... claiming to), and then fail. It always seems like leadership blowing through cash on a sort of "ignorant leadership learns about how the industry works" adventure. All while building up such a hugely resource intensive org with what is now a larger than needed / complex and unproven team ... VC successes always seem to be in "new" spaces where their inefficiency is not noticeable, but also you've no idea the lay of the land in that new space / if someone can walk in with less money and oust you, or if it is profitable at all.
- spamizbad 2y ago> Or be outright copied by bigger players who give away your product (see microsoft teams and slack). I think that era is over for companies. Budgets for all the tech giants are getting scrutinized and you can't just put together some tiger-team-of-teams to snuff out some startup.
- sc68cal 2y agoAbsolutely, and the VC & Silicon Valley solution of firing of Kahn and gutting the FTC will just make the problems that you have identified worse, not better.
- thefaux 2y agoI suspect an underrated factor in this election was SV antipathy towards Lina Khan.
- blackeyeblitzar 2y agoYes I am skeptical of the proposal to replace her. We need to go much further, not backwards. We need new legislation on competition and anti trust, which can enable people like her to do their job effectively.
- oldpersonintx 2y ago[dead]
- xenospn 2y agoHow are all those web3 crypto wallet investments going?
- spamizbad 2y agoCrypto Lobbyists have done pretty well in the US so I think they're going to be able to offload their bags over the next 4 years, possibly for a profit.
- rvz 2y agoIf you ignored the hype of 2021 and invested at the crash of November 2022, well you would be in extreme profit. Crypto wallets like Phantom providing swapping services are still making money. So when HN was declaring it dead, that was the time to start buying.
- xenospn 2y agoIf you bought BTC. All of those wallet companies are long gone.
- pengaru 2y agoDepends on how many are still hodling BTC which last I checked was at $94k USD.
- escaper 2y ago[flagged]
- pera 2y agoIn retrospective this wasn't a good idea: > Over 40% of the latest YC batch are AI/ML startups > April 6, 2023 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35464933 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35464933
- jjfoooo4 2y agoI wouldn’t yet be comfortable betting against 1 or 2 companies from that class becoming huge.. which is all they need for the bet to pay out
- marcosdumay 2y agoIf YC is real about that "betting on people, not ideas", I would really expect 1 or 2 companies from that class to become huge once they pivot into something completely different. But maybe there is even a good idea there. LLMs have given AI a bad name, but it's a very generic word that could describe a company doing almost anything.
- Kalanos 2y agoWho would have thought that a decade of: a bunch of consultants running copycat investment strategies, flushing money down the drain on crypto + indefensible AI wrappers, throwing cash at kids from Stanford with no real world experience, chasing near term exit multipliers, and ignoring biotech wouldn't pay off big?! https://i.giphy.com/media/v1.Y2lkPTc5MGI3NjExZ2pmN296bjRqM283MTdtenpvdGEyYTU1MXZhY20xdHFmY3Njc3p1YyZlcD12MV9pbnRlcm5hbF9naWZfYnlfaWQmY3Q9Zw/hs0gw1WbgcQw2SSYQj/giphy.gif https://i.giphy.com/media/v1.Y2lkPTc5MGI3NjExZ2pmN296bjRqM28...
- walrus01 2y agoI'm sure it's totally normal and a trustworthy business strategy to have CTO and CEO of something with a $100 million+ budget and rapid burn rate at 23 years old. Nothing to be concerned about whatsoever. In the telecom sector I've seen so-called "CTO" of startup companies that have less hands on experience with network engineering and building internet things than a junior/mid-level NOC staffer. How did they get in these positions? Well crafted business plan documents and pitch decks. Can you imagine that the people who spent all of the VC money on the Juicero put any serious research or due diligence into the entire concept? There's an entire cadre of people out there who are so far removed from the concept of the impostor syndrome that they'll go blithely full speed ahead into a brick wall. Just being cocky and confident and having a good pitch has apparently got them a ton of money to mess about with.
- CalRobert 2y agoYou forgot the part where they did drugs with some vc’s kids at Stanford
- dylan604 2y ago> Just being cocky and confident and having a good pitch has apparently This isn't just in tech. It's just a condition of human nature. I've seen it in every single industry I've worked in. To the point that I now distrust any claims of expertise in anything. So many people have just recreated something they've seen on YouTube and claim it is something new especially to the Olds because it's not like they've seen the original from YouTube. Or something similar to that concept even well before YouTube.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- afavour 2y agoI am well outside of this world so I'm probably just misinformed but when I think back to circa 2010 VC-backed startups felt like they were doing a wide array of interesting, diverse things. Today everything I see just reads like groupthink: crypto is a thing? OK, now _everything_ is crypto. AI is a thing? Hot damn, time to make everything AI-based! Not sure when it happened but the tech world seems to be chasing its own tail. Maybe it's simply because the tech isn't so interesting these days. The release of the iPhone and Android was a cambrian explosion in possibility: the likes of Uber simply can't happen without a GPS enabled smartphone. But that's all old news now, so VCs are leaping on absolutely every tech advancement as the next big thing and then stumbling when it isn't.
- khazhoux 2y agoYour recollection is wrong. At any point in time, it has seemed like VCs and startups were chasing the same idea of the day. The joke in early 2010s was that every startup was "Uber for dogs." Also, to your comment "tech isn't so interesting these days"... we get a new cambrian idea or core technology every 5-10 years, and obviously AI/ML is the current one since Nov 2022.
- afavour 2y ago> we get a new cambrian idea or core technology every 5-10 years, and obviously AI/ML is the current one since Nov 2022. Seems like a backwards way of looking at it. There is _always_ a cambrian explosion every 5-10 years therefore AI is that explosion? Seems like you're asking for false positives. What if we _don't_ have one every 5-10 years?
- samatman 2y agoYou're conflating an observation about the past with a prediction about the future. There's no reason to do that.
- afavour 2y ago> You're conflating an observation about the past with a prediction about the future No I'm not? OP said: > we get a new cambrian idea or core technology every 5-10 years I'm not the one conflating anything here.
- duxup 2y agoIsn't that to some extent what you get with VC ventures? I would expect a lot of volatility, generally. The chart was pretty telling, but it's not like this is unprecedented...
- Centigonal 2y ago3 years ago, the US Federal Funds rate was 0.08%. Now, it's 4.58%.
- AlexandrB 2y agoYup. I even recall, as rates started going up, people in the tech world lamenting that they hadn't gone for big enough risks given the opportunity that ZIRP was.
- marricks 2y agoBut it's not a news story if you realize there's an environmental cause, not to mention a conscious decision of the US government.
- mhog_hn 2y agoRight. Tech startups have projected cashflows relatively far into the future. Applying a discounted cash flow analysis on far out cashflows with a 0.08% versus 4.58% risk free rate leads to significantly different results. It is amazing how impactful the tuning of an interest rate by a central bank, a single float, is.
- randomdata 2y ago> It is amazing how impactful the tuning of an interest rate by a central bank, a single float, is. But not all that amazing when you remember that said tuning always happens in reaction to what is already happening. If money were free again today, it is much more likely that people would funnel it into backing products and services riding the inflationary wave, not go back to tech startups. That's explicitly why the central banks increased rates in the first place, after all – to slow down that behaviour. It is just one of an infinite number of variables, not some magical variable that stands alone. Tech's day in the sun was over either way. People were already moving on.
- kbos87 2y agoMost likely case - - The pool of companies seeking VC funding has exploded as the playbook became democratized - The pool of VC funds has exploded as the playbook became democratized - There is still a thin layer of interesting companies that are deserving of VC investment as there was in 2021, 2016, 2011, back and back, but this is the actual constraint and hasn't grown to keep pace This all strikes me as simple and cyclical.
- umeshunni 2y ago> The pool of VC funds has exploded as the playbook became democratized To combine this with another comment in this thread - there is an abundance of funds from dumb money sources as sovereign wealth funds and others started investing in VC.
- dogleash 2y ago>a perfect storm of economic, regulatory and industry factors has mostly blocked tech startups from “exiting" If that's what you want to call not building a profitable business, ok, you do you. It's fine to fail. The clock was always limited on the strategy of failing at a large enough scale you can still cash out before the other shoe drops.
- rm_-rf_slash 2y agoSomething the article didn’t mention was that the handful of core AI startups (LLM building not just API wrapper) like Anthropic and OpenAI are raising MASSIVE amounts of money, on the scale of billions to tens of billions. Is it possible that these investments are crowding out seed and A rounds for early stage companies on the order of single to double digit millions?
- swatcoder 2y agoBecause they've taken credit for so many modern unicorns, people forget that VC's don't exist to invest in businesses for what those businesses will achieve. Nobody can guess what an ambitious unknown startup will actually achieve in 3 or 5 or 10 years. They invest in portfolios of ambitious unknown startup for what subsequent investors will think of them some time later. They sell hype. Markets where everybody expects growth and where investors have easy access to money are hot markets for VC's and that's the market we were still in the tail end of 3 years ago. Later investors are optimistic about real business prospects and they have capital they want to leverage so VC's have a ton of wealthy buyers to court with their exciting products. But that's not the market we're in right now, so the VC model doesn't thrive nearly as well. And the stark transition can indeed cause a bleed as old bets turn wrong and start to really hurt. This kind of story can be a helpful reminder as to how venture capital works and the kinds of markets it works well or poorly in, but it's not a big surprise and every experienced VC probably has a strategy for how they'll navigate it.
- rvz 2y agoYes. They invested at the top and now are underwater. Before, they could get away with not making money for decades. That grift does not work anymore. The same is happening with AI and there is going to be hundreds of losers with the data brokers and the AI providers with hosted foundational AI models with Big Tech being the winners.
- majestik 2y agoThe main data point and infographic in this article seem like they might have been misinterpreted to me. The data shows overall VC investment vs profit by year, but not all startups return value in the same year they’re funded. Could it just be that after 2020 VC investments shifted towards startups with longer profit horizons? Could that explain why the author thinks VCs are “bleeding” cash?
- cruffle_duffle 2y agoIn the first half of the 2020’s the entire tech sector was a primary recipient of one of the world’s largest upward transfers of wealth in human history. Hysterical nonsense spewed from trash rags like sfgate are partly to blame. Of course things were going to return to normal. Even if some people in tech had to be drug back kicking and screaming.
- incomingpain 2y agoBay area has gone through some major changes that the bay area doesnt even seem to be dealing with? Foreign direct investment into the area is now hitting a major anti-capital-flight problem. So from VC point of view, there's no growth possible until it corrects. Entire diasporas up and left the area, probably in the area of 500,000-750,000 people. Severely impacting the bay area's viability going forward. Quite identical to white flight from detroit. San fran specifically is quite unlikely to ever recover from this. They'd have to 180 on so much that it's impossible politically. I do expect it'll be probably around late 2026 when VC bleed enough to exit the bay area. Or at least greatly reduce in size. The very people who left were the people needed to fix it. The city of detroit experienced this. Racist policies by coleman young was the reason to leave detroit, different are the causes for the bay area. But the consequences are much the same. History just repeating. It's interesting how willful blindness to the consequences of policies and refusal to undo mistakes have major human and social consequences.
- pengaru 2y agoWhen housing prices crash in Detroit and SF, which market do you buy in? Exactly. Grouping SF with Detroit is utterly ridiculous.
- incomingpain 2y ago>When housing prices crash in Detroit and SF, which market do you buy in? Today, I wouldnt buy either with someone else's money. In the detroit area, I bought my old place for $30,000. Did my own home renos. sold $190,000 a few years later. In the same era when detroit was selling 4 bed 2 baths, with no neighbours for $5000... Obviously i didnt buy any of those money pits. I went for the mansion. >Exactly. Grouping SF with Detroit is utterly ridiculous. I'm not sure how 'exactly' was a response here. The automotive and manufacturing industry in detroit made real estate ridiculously expensive in the 1940s and 50s. Detroit immediately before it's collapse had ridiculous housing prices exactly the same as San Fran. With much the same problems as the bay area. Much worse than the bay area average. Detroit had homeless ghettos of mostly unemployable southerners; while rich business owners left the city en masse. What do you think just happened to san fran? Got any homeless ghettos in san fran?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- Ekaros 2y agoWeren't they always bleeding cash? It is just that they found bigger fools. I really hope market has wizened up and just let these companies burn.
- binary132 2y agoI think most people don’t understand that our perspective on the past 10 years has been very colored by constant availability of extremely cheap business lending. The prevailing mindset in technology has been that one is to spend basically unlimited funds to ”purchase” audience by offering products at a lower rate than the competition. Once the audience is obtained the product is basically irrelevant. That has always seemed like a race to the bottom to me and it’s not a sustainable model for the economy. Post-Covid, and given that the best engineers now command remote availability, and that debt is no longer approximately free, the future of the urban tech hub is in question.