3 ms·
Musi fans refuse to update iPhones until Apple unblocks controversial app
- sircastor 2y agoThe headline makes it sound like it’s some kind of consumer boycott collective action. These folks are just trying to avoid the App being offloaded during an update.
- echelon 2y agoThis is why the DOJ needs to strip Apple of its ability to police what you can run on your phone. You should be able to web install anything without a gatekeeper. Without scare tactics or deeply hidden menu toggles. Apple and Google's role here is to provide a hermetic sandbox with permissions layer and do occasional malware scans. That's it.
- FredPret 2y agoThe market will tell Apple what its role is. And the market wants a walled garden. It’s half the reason I buy iPhones. If you want a computer, get a Linux box. The iOS guardrails are a major selling point.
- echelon 2y agoThe free market is not sophisticated enough to remove monopolistic forces. Without government intervention we'd still have Standard Oil. Without Microsoft being forced to invest in Apple in the late 90's to avoid DOJ scrutiny, Apple would have gone bankrupt and we wouldn't even have an iPhone. And before "iPhone is not a monopoly" arguments, there are only two smartphone platforms and both are strong arming marketplace participants in a function essential to navigating the modern world. Google is being told to relinquish Chrome and that's good. But we need both Apple and Google to relinquish control over what can be installed on devices as well. The time for scare-free web installs by default is now. Apple and Google will still keep their trillion dollar market caps, but the rest of the market will be able to innovate with many more degrees of freedom.
- bdcravens 2y agoWithout the threat of forced compliance by the government (courts), Elon Musk wouldn't have bought Twitter.
- aleph_minus_one 2y ago> The free market is not sophisticated enough to remove monopolistic forces. It is (in most cases). The problem is rather that most people don't care: the market delivers, and turns into an oligopoly.
- echelon 2y ago> most people don't care This is why the DOJ function is essential. Most people aren't informed enough to understand how this effects them or even have the awareness that this is happening at all. Ordinary citizens would need hours of lectures and study to understand the dynamics at play and how that impacts everyone in the market negatively. That's why this is a job for the DOJ.
- realusername 2y agoThere's no "market" anymore, it's a duopoly. Apple doesn't need to care about what app makers or even consumers want anymore.
- echelon 2y agoAnd this is why they (and Google) shouldn't have any right to police or even participate in what people want to do with the devices they purchased. Imagine if the car you bought could suddenly stop driving you to Publix or Starbucks because they didn't pay the tax to the manufacturer.
- realusername 2y agoI'm all for it personally, or it's like you had only two supermarket brands in the whole country and you had to pick a single one. The situation on mobile is ridiculous.
- blackeyeblitzar 2y agoThere is no free market in a duopoly with high barriers to entry and lots of anti competitive practices. This absolutely needs regulation. It would not affect you if you want to keep your phone in walled garden mode. But people should have a right to use their devices freely.
- FredPret 2y agoPeople already have a right to buy any of the hundreds of models on sale right now, many of which allow putting your own OS on it. People also have the right to start a new phone brand (if they feel like burning a couple hundred billion). The reason it’s so hard to break into this market is because its mature. The duopoly will only be supplanted by the next tech - smart glasses perhaps. No amount of regulation can change technological realities.
- blackeyeblitzar 2y agoI feel like you are making the case for regulation. If there cannot be competition until the next tech, then society can force the existing players to behave in an appropriate way using regulations.
- FredPret 2y agoWhat I'm saying is regulation slows down all of society to solve yesterday's problems, when we should put as much resources as possible into developing tomorrow's solutions. How much does it bug you that Xerox has (had?) a monopoly on copiers? Or that Windows + Intel dominated the 90's? Or that the train barons had their monopolies in the 1800's? The best solution is to make a monopoly irrelevant by supplanting it. Apple is either going to invent the next big thing, or they will go the way of IBM. Even now their peak quarterly revenue was back in 2022.
- II2II 2y ago> And the market wants a walled garden. The most you can say is that a segment of the market is willing to accept a walled garden. Some may want it. Some may not care about it. Some may not want it, but feel there are compelling reasons to use iOS and put up with the walled garden. An honest question here: is it actually a walled garden you want or is it an extra layer of security that the walled garden provides? (I can see people wanting the latter, but have a bit of trouble wrapping my head around people wanting a business to control who can offer which software on a device.)
- CharlesW 2y ago> An honest question here: is it actually a walled garden you want or is it an extra layer of security that the walled garden provides? Definitely the latter, with the App Store being is one of many elements of that. It's that old marketing adage: People don't want to buy a drill, they want to buy the ability to make holes. And really, they want to buy the ability to hang a picture of their family on the living room wall, to install a shelf for their daughter's awards, etc.
- ChrisMarshallNY 2y agoMost folks aren’t geeks. Their relationship with technology is very different from most folks that post here. They don’t want tech. They want functionality, and in as approachable and “don’t make me think” fashion as possible. Apple provides that. There are many reasons, and many of the cynics are right. But at the end of the day, Apple has a three trillion-dollar market cap. Can’t argue with the results.
- kevinsync 2y agoA couple barely-coherent thoughts on the topic: I honestly believe that the overwhelming majority people with a phone or computer don't actively want a walled garden, or a non-walled garden, good security, bad security or anything else that we pontificate about. They just want a device that kinda-sorta "works" -- web, email, Amazon, YouTube, Instagram, etc -- even though most websites, software, services we pay for, etc actually are constantly changing, constantly having issues, constantly under-delivering on even the most basic promises -- and on top of that, people want everything to be free too. With the way the world is these days (dancing on the razor's edge of chaos, and I'm not necessarily speaking politically; just that everything cuts corners, moves fast, breaks things, and rarely fixes them once they’re broken) it's better for the average consumer to restrict what they can and can't do for the sake of the entire ecosystem remaining functional. That Apple even attempts to keep their stuff "just working" at all is an anomaly with regards to most of the industry.
- perihelions 2y ago- "The iOS guardrails are a major selling point." It's specious to conflate guardrails against spam and malware with—what this story is about—"guardrails" meant to enforce copyright! One's about the consumer's best interest; the other is not at all.
- 1234letshaveatw 2y agoIt isn't in the consumers best interest for the artist to make money and create more content?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- WesolyKubeczek 2y agoBut Tim Cook has multiple lunches and games of golf with executives of record labels and movie studios that hold copyrights on all kinds of stuff, and you don’t. You, the consumer, are being treated livestock to be eaten, or milked, or sheared. Livestock’s reasoning about freedoms is usually ignored.
- HumblyTossed 2y ago> And the market wants a walled garden. This is just not true. People who want an iPhone, get an iPhone - warts and all.
- sunaookami 2y agoAh yes, the "invisible hand" of the market which is invisible because... it doesn't exist, duh.
- jMyles 2y agoWhile I think most of us agree with the spirit of your argument, we may have different impressions about the degree to which market forces _are even allowed to operate_ in this environment. Consider the combination of: * winner-picking trade policies * regulatory capture * establishment-protecting intellectual property regimes * enormous state interplay with TSMC and Qualcomm (both economic and regulatory, both publicly known and classified) Taken together, this configuration amounts to an insurmountable subsidy of the status quo, such that there are no serious opportunities to explore market appetite for an ecosystem which is more empowering to the user.
- cratermoon 2y agoAh yes, the Free Market Fairy. https://bitworking.org/news/2008/01/the-free-market-fairy/ https://bitworking.org/news/2008/01/the-free-market-fairy/
- HumblyTossed 2y agoMerrick Garland has proven useless. Do you think Matt Gaetz would even understand the issue? Edit: Downvote if you must, but this is the timeline we are stuck in.
- stackedinserter 2y agoOh you'll be lectured on how companies can do whatever they want, whenever they want, in the way they want, and society should just shut up and see how every single consumable bit gets monopolized and turned into extortion machine by 2-3 key players.
- amelius 2y agoYes, an AppStore and a ContentFilter are two orthogonal concepts. Unlike what Apple wants us to believe ...
- drcongo 2y agoYou should start your own mobile phone manufacturing company. I'm sure everyone who agrees with you will be flocking to buy your phone.
- echelon 2y ago"You should be born in 1840 and try to build a petroleum company. Then enjoy watching it being dismantled by John D. Rockefeller." The gradient ascent to build a smartphone right now is a mile high. It's impossible to compete with Apple and Google, and you know this. This is exactly why we need the Department of Justice (and the equivalent in every other country) to start bringing those barriers to competition down. This can start by forcing both companies to allow nag-free, scare-free web installs of apps.
- unethical_ban 2y ago$100m in revenue in a year? Wow!
- ToucanLoucan 2y agoOkay so like, I have a lot of gripes with IP law especially copyright law, but if I understand this right: - Musi uses YouTube videos of songs instead of audio files to stream music - I'm gonna assume that they clip YouTube ads and do not require a YouTube premium account, otherwise why would anyone care So like, yeah, your business gets a lot more profitable if you just don't take on the expenses of providing the service you're providing, in this case, using YouTube to host your media, with an in-between app that doesn't support their monetization by itself. A streaming service makes a lot more money if you don't... license the music. And granted the "harmed" parties in this are Alphabet and the Music industry so like, I am certainly not going to be crying myself to sleep over this. But like... come on. This is extremely into the gray area of music piracy, and like, I don't respect those laws either, but if you just automate piracy and put it on the fuggen App Store, yeah I imagine Apple would do something about that? Frankly I'm shocked Google is still okay with it on Android. But yeah, as I said in an older comment, if you want a unicorn, the formula is actually quite straightforward if cynical as fuck: find a way to provide a service real businesses provide, without paying any of the expenses. A taxi company that owns no taxis, a hotel company that owns no hotels, or in this case, a music streamer that doesn't buy or even host the music.
- ksec 2y agoHow could an OS update "off load" an App? I could understand an App no longer being supported such as major version iOS update. But off load feels like to be a new blacklist with new iOS update. At what point will Apple "off load" my contacts, photos or videos?
- fckgw 2y agoIf the device is low on space to perform the OS update, it will temporarily remove any large apps from the device, perform the OS update and then re-download the apps from the app store. If the app was removed from the app store it cannot re-download it.
- MichaelZuo 2y agoThis must be selected/confirmed by the user, or else the update won’t proceed, last time I tried it at least.
- aleph_minus_one 2y agoSimply read the old rantings by Richard Stallman from the 80s and 90s, and you know what might happen.
- amiga-workbench 2y agoHe wasn't wrong, we have already had Amazon remotely deleting books from peoples Kindles.
- orev 2y agoOne of the storage management options is to allow the phone to automatically offload (i.e. delete) unused apps, but not the data, and then automatically download it again when the user launches it. Installing an OS update would need temporary storage space on the phone, which could trigger the offload process if the storage space is low. Then the app wouldn’t be able to be downloaded again if it was removed from the store.
- easeout 2y ago
- amelius 2y agoA benevolent dictator is still a dictator.
- easeout 2y agoYou're right. Now why won't anyone else make computers or phones that I like and want to use due to their nice, consistent user interfaces and stability? Apple's quality has slid in both of these regards, and what really sucks is that no one else comes close anyway.
- chasil 2y agoAndroid may not come close, but you get root if you buy the right hardware, and there is a lot of choice in alternate distributions.
- lynndotpy 2y agoIf you want to maintain security (and you should!), AFAIK your only options are GrapheneOS or CalyxOS on a Google Pixel. While these are fantastic, I think most people would find these as UX downgrades from Google Pixel's stock OS.
- chasil 2y agoThe choice for my next device would actually be /e/os right now, but I will have to find something suitable to replace the Bliss launcher. https://e.foundation/e-os/ https://e.foundation/e-os/
- lynx23 2y agoI don't want root on my Phone, I want a stable and consistent UX. Maybe even efficient and simple. You can give me root if you gift the device to me, I'll accept that. But I am totally done with "our users are our beta testers". Even switched to upgrading iOS only at .3 minor releases. It is so fucking tiiring.
- easeout 2y ago
- nerdjon 2y agoIf I am understanding this correctly, they are basically using what is hosted on Youtube for free (or are they paying Google somehow?), not showing youtube ads and then presenting their ads just when the app launched? How exactly did they think that was going to be able to continue to run and not expect any pushback? If the ads were not there then you could argue it was just a free app, but they seem to be trying to make money off of other people's services. While I am not crying for the money lost to google or the record labels. I still question how Musi thought this would work. Is there some big part of this that I am missing?
- ferbivore 2y agoIt did work, for years. Made them $10m per employee apparently.
- pentamassiv 2y agoIsn't that exactly what Spotify does with podcasts? They also take podcasts that are hosted for free and then put ads in them
- nerdjon 2y agoDoes Spotify automatically pull in podcasts wether or not the people that made it want to be on the platform or not? However I think the part missing (which again I am trying to fully understand what is happening here, their website really glosses over what is happening) is if Spotify was pulling podcasts from a place that served their own ads to instead serve Spotify ads without compensating where they got it from. Which my understanding here, is what Musi is doing.
- pentamassiv 2y agoYes, as far as I know they have their own podcast index and list "all" podcasts. There are some Spotify exclusive "podcasts" that are only available to Spotify users. Sure, as far as I know Spotify doesn't block the authors ads but they add ads to podcasts where there are none. The average user doesn't know that Spotify is responsible for that and might stop listening. Some podcasters intentionally publish the first episodes ad free to grow their listener base
- kspacewalk2 2y agoHow can people defend what this app is doing? Not only are you infringing on copyright, which like... Fine, I get it, and I do it. I don't get all self-righteous about somehow having the "right" to do so, and accept when a method of doing it is taken offline, but I can't be hypocritical and criticize the practice itself. But you piggy-back off someone else's service, block their ads and run your own instead, making $100 million?? They incur all the costs (licencing, hosting), and you collect all the revenue? Please, someone, rationally defend this business model, because nothing other than "grift" comes to mind.
- kome 2y ago> They incur all the costs (licencing, hosting), and you collect all the revenue? So many capitalist activities work in exactly the same way: socializing the costs while privatizing the benefits. If anything, the Musi app is one of the more harmless examples of this.
- kspacewalk2 2y agoCan you give some concrete examples to better illustrate your point?
- kome 2y ago- oil companies pollute like crazy, but we pay for cleanup, health issues, and environmental damage. they pocket the profits. - tons of public research (medicine, tech, etc.) gets privatized. taxpayers fund it, but companies patent the results and rake it in. - 2008 financial crisis: banks made reckless bets, tanked the economy, got bailed out with public money. profits stayed private. - gig economy: workers rely on public benefits (like food stamps or medicaid) because wages suck, but the companies make billions. - resource extraction: companies lease public land super cheap, destroy it, and leave taxpayers to deal with the mess.
- jtbayly 2y ago"But to Apple, it would be unreasonable to expect Apple to investigate every copyright notice it receives when thousands of third parties send notices annually.” Nope. That’s not unreasonable. That’s the work you took on when you decided to be the moderator of what apps can be installed on iPhones.
- sigio 2y agoGood thing there is sideloading on android, (and many many equivalent apps to this that let you view youtube videos/music in the background or without ads )
- theshrike79 2y agoPeople will do the weirdest crap to avoid paying for music =) The current generation is so obsessed with streaming that downloading music locally and "owning" it seems like a completely foreign thing to them. All piracy to them is just finding out the next shady streaming website.